Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
64 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Is Trump evidence there is no God? (Original Post) edhopper 12 hrs ago OP
Well, if there is a just and good god, Donnie is compelling evidence that god moves in strange and mysterious ways. unblock 12 hrs ago #1
Yes RandySF 12 hrs ago #2
No. TwilightZone 12 hrs ago #3
Yes, Dahmer is edhopper 12 hrs ago #6
He's not proof of anything, without making other assumptions. TwilightZone 11 hrs ago #20
Two points edhopper 11 hrs ago #22
You can't prove a negative. Think. Again. 12 hrs ago #4
Russell's teapot underpants 12 hrs ago #8
Yes, proving something doesn't exist is very hard to do... Think. Again. 12 hrs ago #13
I say edhopper 11 hrs ago #23
Sure you can FreeState 8 hrs ago #51
Thanks, and yes, my response was to the discussion of whether gods exist, not to how many of them mathematically exist. Think. Again. 8 hrs ago #53
I suppose you could make a case that god NH Ethylene 12 hrs ago #5
Indications certainly lean in that direction. magicarpet 12 hrs ago #7
He's proof there is. How many times have how many people said GOOD GOD! about him underpants 12 hrs ago #9
No DET 12 hrs ago #10
Trump can't be the Antichrist. Mariana 11 hrs ago #19
And the antichrist MorbidButterflyTat 8 hrs ago #55
Trump has certainly fooled a lot of Christians. Mariana 6 hrs ago #60
I went down a rabbit hole looking for God and his response to the question "why do we have to have evil"? mahina 12 hrs ago #11
Define "God," please. H2O Man 12 hrs ago #12
G.O.D.... lame54 12 hrs ago #14
That raises the question H2O Man 8 hrs ago #52
The creator of all things ... Jmb 4 Harris-Walz 9 hrs ago #46
That sounds a bit H2O Man 8 hrs ago #50
It just means He ran out of locusts. jls4561 12 hrs ago #15
Not if he loses. NT anamnua 12 hrs ago #16
No, but ... apeshot 12 hrs ago #17
you mean Little people edhopper 11 hrs ago #24
Which god? Mariana 12 hrs ago #18
see edhopper 11 hrs ago #25
Personally, the flying spaghetti monster has been run down too far... Moostache 11 hrs ago #30
Could be that God exists and has a mean sense of humor. Ocelot II 11 hrs ago #21
Might just be that God is testing us. calimary 11 hrs ago #26
Was the Holocaust a test too? How about African slavery? Stalin's purges? Black Plague? Native American genocide? Sky Jewels 11 hrs ago #34
Don't know about God, but he's evidence that humans are very easily conned. polichick 11 hrs ago #27
NO BlueKota 11 hrs ago #28
Those who hold that philosophy that everyone has good (and bad) points.... lastlib 11 hrs ago #32
I will give you that there is nothing about Trump BlueKota 6 hrs ago #64
So God gave humans, including kids, the free will to be wiped out in the Holocaust, wars, famines, plagues, etc.? Sky Jewels 11 hrs ago #33
The people of all ages who are wiped out by BlueKota 6 hrs ago #63
TRump is the symptom...our society is the patient and social media is the contagion... Moostache 11 hrs ago #29
If not, it proved god is an asshole..... lastlib 11 hrs ago #31
That has been well established. God is a fucking murderous dickhead. Sky Jewels 11 hrs ago #35
It has long been clear that supernatural beings don't actually exist. Sky Jewels 11 hrs ago #36
Trump and God - insecure sadistic assholes who demand constant worship and praise dalton99a 10 hrs ago #37
That version of God was invented by people like Trump... polichick 10 hrs ago #38
No. In Christian theology, God created humanity with a completely free will. lees1975 10 hrs ago #39
Free will christian bullshit edhopper 10 hrs ago #40
The logic does not track here MerrilyMerrily 9 hrs ago #42
The logic is edhopper 9 hrs ago #45
Trump violated their free will. That is, from a Christian theological perspective, equal to murder. lees1975 9 hrs ago #49
Only if you are a monotheist Hekate 10 hrs ago #41
No he is not! God exists because there is belief in his existence. Jmb 4 Harris-Walz 9 hrs ago #43
I fail to see how the beasts were wicked biophile 8 hrs ago #54
How do you know yours is the one, true God? Because he hates the same people you do. keithbvadu2 9 hrs ago #44
He is evident that some of the most evil people lead long lives Dem4life1234 9 hrs ago #47
tRUMP is evidence of EVIL. bluestarone 9 hrs ago #48
I think MorbidButterflyTat 7 hrs ago #56
If anything, Trump would be evidence of Satan. SupportSanity 6 hrs ago #57
It is heartbreaking to me that luck is usually on his side helpisontheway 6 hrs ago #58
You are giving him far too much credit. Intractable 6 hrs ago #59
Ask me after the election. Jack Valentino 6 hrs ago #61
Man is the only animal to have discovered The ONE TRUE God.....several of them. Mark Twain Ping Tung 6 hrs ago #62

unblock

(54,028 posts)
1. Well, if there is a just and good god, Donnie is compelling evidence that god moves in strange and mysterious ways.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:08 PM
12 hrs ago

Like, *extremely* strange and mysterious ways....

TwilightZone

(27,362 posts)
3. No.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:09 PM
12 hrs ago

Is Jeffrey Dahmer evidence that there isn't a just and good God?

If evil or however one chooses to define someone like Trump is the sole determining factor, there have been innumerable examples prior to Trump, many of them arguably much worse than he is.

The question also presumes that whatever god might exist has an active interest in humanity and tilts the scales in one direction or another.

TwilightZone

(27,362 posts)
20. He's not proof of anything, without making other assumptions.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:45 PM
11 hrs ago

He's only proof of something if other things are assumed to be true, such as a god having active influence on humanity.

There could be a just and good god that simply doesn't have the ability or the inclination to interfere with free will.

edhopper

(34,563 posts)
22. Two points
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:58 PM
11 hrs ago

The Free Will argument is negated by Dahmer's victims not having the free will not to be brutally murdered.

And as Epicurius would say, if he has neither the ability or inclination to stop evil, why call him God?

underpants

(185,979 posts)
8. Russell's teapot
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:16 PM
12 hrs ago

Russell's teapot is an analogy, formulated by the philosopher Bertrand Russell (1872–1970), to illustrate that the philosophic burden of proof lies upon a person making empirically unfalsifiable claims, as opposed to shifting the burden of disproof to others.

Russell specifically applied his analogy in the context of religion.[1] He wrote that if he were to assert, without offering proof, that a teapot, too small to be seen by telescopes, orbits the Sun somewhere in space between the Earth and Mars, he could not expect anyone to believe him solely because his assertion could not be proven wrong.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot

Think. Again.

(16,783 posts)
13. Yes, proving something doesn't exist is very hard to do...
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:35 PM
12 hrs ago

...as we're reminded everytime we discover things that we previously believed didn't exist.

The only thing I don't get is why it's so hard for people to admit they simply don't know, for sure, if a thing exists or not, but that's probably just the Agnostic in me.

edhopper

(34,563 posts)
23. I say
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:02 PM
11 hrs ago

I see no evidence for the exist of a God (rather than know or not know)
If I said the same thing about Bigfoot or the Loch Ness Monster or fairies, people would not tell me I should not be closed minded and I can't "know it" That it is 50/50.

FreeState

(10,675 posts)
51. Sure you can
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 07:00 PM
8 hrs ago

In formal logic and mathematics, proving negatives is possible within defined systems. For example, proving “there is no solution to this equation” or “no integer exists between 1 and 2” is straightforward within those frameworks. The difficulty comes when attempting to prove negatives in empirical contexts, like “ghosts do not exist.” In such cases, it’s hard to prove a universal absence since evidence could potentially appear somewhere unknown.

I prefer to say you cant prove an unfalsifiable claim.

Think. Again.

(16,783 posts)
53. Thanks, and yes, my response was to the discussion of whether gods exist, not to how many of them mathematically exist.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 07:05 PM
8 hrs ago

magicarpet

(16,062 posts)
7. Indications certainly lean in that direction.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:14 PM
12 hrs ago

Definitely not as omnipotent as we were led to believe.

Maybe God is off on distant galaxy playing a few rounds of golf and his attentions have been temporarily diverted ? But will be back to address the trDUMP issues in due time.

underpants

(185,979 posts)
9. He's proof there is. How many times have how many people said GOOD GOD! about him
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:18 PM
12 hrs ago

or something he does or says?

Mariana

(14,936 posts)
19. Trump can't be the Antichrist.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:45 PM
11 hrs ago

The Antichrist is supposed to be loved and worshiped by the whole world. Trump isn't. Trump can't even get the majority of votes in his own country.

MorbidButterflyTat

(2,583 posts)
55. And the antichrist
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 07:32 PM
8 hrs ago

will fool even the chosen (from my long ago bible study).

That lump of blubber doesn't fool anyone except the willful idiots.

Mariana

(14,936 posts)
60. Trump has certainly fooled a lot of Christians.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 09:18 PM
6 hrs ago

The majority of Christian voters cast their ballots for him in 2016 and in 2020. It remains to be seen if he'll get the majority of them this time.

mahina

(18,786 posts)
11. I went down a rabbit hole looking for God and his response to the question "why do we have to have evil"?
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:34 PM
12 hrs ago

This was as close as I got.

?si=KI5nwnQIvPw7xp3g

That movie is worth it.

Jmb 4 Harris-Walz

(619 posts)
46. The creator of all things ...
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 06:10 PM
9 hrs ago

Heaven, earth, light, day, darkness, night, land, seas, seed, grass, trees, fruit, seasons, stars, sea life, land creatures, man, woman, the tree of life, and the tree of knowledge of good and evil.

Too bad God made that last tree, we’d live in a far different world…but would it be better? Impossible to know.

H2O Man

(75,120 posts)
50. That sounds a bit
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 06:55 PM
8 hrs ago

like the definition of Spinoza, Einstein, and Sagan, or the sum total of the loaws of the universe(s). Sagan, of course, in his 1977 classic "The Dragons of Eden" explained that tree etc in the context of the evolution of the human brain. I think that still holds up well.

apeshot

(4 posts)
17. No, but ...
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:40 PM
12 hrs ago

Maybe fat trump is just evidence of God's all-encompassing sense of humour. Midgets, the Platypus, Rush Limbaugh and Texas just weren't enough!

Mariana

(14,936 posts)
18. Which god?
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 03:42 PM
12 hrs ago

Have you read the Bible? It is stuffed with stores about despicable men, whom God put into positions of power over people, and showered with his favor and his blessings. It's not the least bit out of character for that particular god to choose someone like Trump to rule over the US.

Moostache

(10,096 posts)
30. Personally, the flying spaghetti monster has been run down too far...
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:13 PM
11 hrs ago

I am also waiting to get in on the ground floor for Ra worship when the climate completely collapses into chaos and mankind reverts to sacrificing virgins to the storm gods and the sun. Might want to find some back-ups too like Zeus, Jupiter and Ares.

Sky Jewels

(8,644 posts)
34. Was the Holocaust a test too? How about African slavery? Stalin's purges? Black Plague? Native American genocide?
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:37 PM
11 hrs ago

That god, always wiping people off the planet for funsies. What a card! What a sense of humor!

I'm glad psychopathic murderous magical beings don't actually exist.

BlueKota

(3,210 posts)
28. NO
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:07 PM
11 hrs ago

According to a Rabbi, God gave humans free will. It is therefore each individuals own responsibility to choose their own actions. If a person chooses to act like a disgusting piece of vermin(my words not the Rabbi's) that's on him or her not God. God can only give strength to those who seek it to carry on in hard times, and also decides the ultimate destination of one's soul after they die on earth.

There is also the philosophy that everything and everyone has both good points and bad points. Like a fire can warm you when you're cold, but it could also burn your house down. Water can quench your thirst or kill you, if you drown in it. In people we chose which side we want to use the most.

tfg always chooses to show his evil side.

lastlib

(24,606 posts)
32. Those who hold that philosophy that everyone has good (and bad) points....
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:25 PM
11 hrs ago

...never met The Felon.

BlueKota

(3,210 posts)
64. I will give you that there is nothing about Trump
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 09:36 PM
6 hrs ago

or others like him that I would classify as good.

Sky Jewels

(8,644 posts)
33. So God gave humans, including kids, the free will to be wiped out in the Holocaust, wars, famines, plagues, etc.?
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:34 PM
11 hrs ago

What an asshole. I'm glad that monster doesn't actually exist.

BlueKota

(3,210 posts)
63. The people of all ages who are wiped out by
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 09:32 PM
6 hrs ago

war, famine, disease etc are in most cases not the ones doing the choosing . It's the people like Trump, Musk, Hitler, Stalin, Putin, etc who are choosing greed and power, over caring about other people and the earth we live on. They choose to be selfish and evil.

The theory about the duality of being isn't even of Christian-Judeo origin. I believe the concept goes all the way back to the ancient Greeks.

I am not trying to sell anyone on faith in God. I am giving my personal response to the question asked. In my opinion just because evil people do evil things doesn't necessarily equate to proof that God doesn't exist. Also in many Christian religions there is the belief that the evil side of human nature comes from the devil aka satan.

I have my own reasons for believing in God that I will refrain from sharing, because I also respect others right not to believe.

Moostache

(10,096 posts)
29. TRump is the symptom...our society is the patient and social media is the contagion...
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:10 PM
11 hrs ago

In the pre-Twitter/Facebook/Instagram fantasy world we inhabit, his behavior and statements would have been disqualifying back in 2015. As it is, there are entirely too many credulous, uninformed imbeciles that vote and do so based on whatever misinformation catches their fancy.

Trump is a cancerous lung tumor that has metastasized. Social Media is the smoking that led to the aggressive cancer.

Sky Jewels

(8,644 posts)
35. That has been well established. God is a fucking murderous dickhead.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:38 PM
11 hrs ago

I'm glad "He" (HAH!) is just a figment of human imagination.

lees1975

(5,550 posts)
39. No. In Christian theology, God created humanity with a completely free will.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 04:56 PM
10 hrs ago

So Trump's choices are his own. And no, the "devil" didn't make him do it. He's accountable on his own.

edhopper

(34,563 posts)
40. Free will christian bullshit
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 05:09 PM
10 hrs ago

what about the free will of the women he raped or the people he stole from. What about the free will of the women who can't have medical care because of him.
Beyond the philosophical discussion of what is free will. The argument that there is evil because of free will is a non starter.

MerrilyMerrily

(180 posts)
42. The logic does not track here
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 05:43 PM
9 hrs ago

The definition is - a human being has free will to hurt people, or help them. or just leave them alone. If the choice is to hurt someone else, the victim will suffer, or even die. That has nothing to do with whether or not the person who did the harm exercised free will.

edhopper

(34,563 posts)
45. The logic is
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 06:07 PM
9 hrs ago

God allows evil to exist because we have free will to choose evil or good. But this same God, supposedly good an loving, gives one person to choose innumerable suffering to dozens or hundreds or millions. So this God thinks the free will choice of one person can take all choice away from millions of others.
The fate of that person's soul is more important to God, no matter how evil their acts are, than the anguish, suffering and life of millions of others.
This doesn't even touch on if people who are mentally ill have this God given free will.

It is just Christian bullshit to account for why their so called loving God allows the world to be so fucked up. But the logic of it doesn't hold.

lees1975

(5,550 posts)
49. Trump violated their free will. That is, from a Christian theological perspective, equal to murder.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 06:19 PM
9 hrs ago

And he bears responsibility.

In Christian theology, humanity is next to divinity. Jesus elevated respect for humanity to the same level as respect for God, Matthew 22:29, equating the commandment to "Love the Lord your God with all your heart, all your soul and all your mind," with "Love your neighbor as yourself."

Support for Trump, from people claiming to be Christian, is a symptom of the complete breakdown of conservative Evangelicalism in the United States. Violating the free will of another human being is equal to blaspheming God.

Does that work a little better now?

Jmb 4 Harris-Walz

(619 posts)
43. No he is not! God exists because there is belief in his existence.
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 05:48 PM
9 hrs ago

From Genesis 6-9, the Bible teaches that God found his creation of man had become corrupt, evil, and filled with violence, and it grieved him. He determined to destroy the wickedness on earth, both man and beast. Other than those aboard Noah’s Ark, God destroyed every living thing on earth by sending 40 days and 40 nights of rain, the water prevailing for 150 days, flooding and killing all upon earth’s surface.

Trump is allowed to exist because, after the flood, God promised to never again curse the earth by destroying every living thing as he had done with the flood.

However, by the grace of God, Trump will definitively lose the election by a significant margin. Then Jack Smith can go forth with his cases against him and send his evil lying fat a$$ into semi solitary confinement where he’ll never be able to spew his nasty filth upon the U.S. population again!

biophile

(292 posts)
54. I fail to see how the beasts were wicked
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 07:16 PM
8 hrs ago

He destroyed every living thing because people were wicked. But the beasts? How exactly is a cow wicked? A dog? The sheep? I have tried to make sense out of religion but it just….doesn’t. Doesn’t make any sense at all to me. 😏

Dem4life1234

(572 posts)
47. He is evident that some of the most evil people lead long lives
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 06:12 PM
9 hrs ago

While we have lost many gems of human beings at far younger ages.

If he wins, we will know that God hates Amerikkka. So...

MorbidButterflyTat

(2,583 posts)
56. I think
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 07:48 PM
7 hrs ago

it's a weird paradox that some people seem violently opposed to something they violently assert, doesn't exist.

helpisontheway

(5,176 posts)
58. It is heartbreaking to me that luck is usually on his side
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 09:06 PM
6 hrs ago

Every time we think he will pay, he does not. First he is a disgusting traitor and was elected as president. He committed awful crimes almost four years ago and has never spent a night in jail. He is a convicted felon and they allow him to run for president. And now he has a very good chance of being elected again. I’m watching as the polls start improving for him towards the end just like with Hillary.

Ping Tung

(1,165 posts)
62. Man is the only animal to have discovered The ONE TRUE God.....several of them. Mark Twain
Mon Oct 21, 2024, 09:25 PM
6 hrs ago
When it is a question of money, everybody is of the same religion.
Voltaire
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Is Trump evidence there i...