Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Pototan

(1,848 posts)
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 01:09 AM 15 hrs ago

Can I tell you a story?

It was 1973 or 1974. It was at a little party at the home of a close friend of mine outside of Boston. Maybe 6 or 8 people. His girlfriend's mother was there. I was 21 years old at the time. The woman was about 50 years old or so. She was German with a pretty noticeable accent. At the time, I was in college and one of my studies was History and we were into WWII Germany. I remember I was reading the "Rise and Fall of the Third Riech" (which was about 1,500 pages).

Anyway, I started up a conversation with my friend's future mother-in-law and we started talking about her days as a youth in Nazi Germany. the conversation lasted about 3 or 4 hours. I was mesmerized. As a 12-year-old, she actually heard Hitler speak in person. He had visited her rural area by plane on one of his campaign stops back in 1932. "How was it that the Germans could elect such a man?" Her answer was quite astounding. The Germans had just lost WWI and were humiliated by the surrender agreement at Versailles. There were many WWI veterans in Germany, including her father and uncles. The depression was crippling. There was barely enough to eat. and here was this man, telling all of them exactly what they wanted to hear. "It's not your fault". "You were stabbed in the back by international jews."

The woman, whose last name was Schmidt, said that everyone in her family was a Nazi. That SS troopers were the equivalent of sports stars of that day's American sport. She and her family would listen to Hitler on the radio during the 30's and marveled at the improvement in the economy. Then the war and the aftermath. She claimed not to be aware of the concentration camps and Holocaust until after the war. I didn't really believe her about that part. She married an American soldier during the American occupation of Germany after the war. Her daughter, who later became my friend's wife, told me her mother hardly ever talked about those years. I think she opened up to me because of the drinking and I showed such an interest in what she had to say.

In the end, I thought, that was an amazing conversation. I know that couldn't happen in America.

I am remembering that conversation today, because for the first time in over 50 years, I'm afraid it can happen in America.

16 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

askyagerz

(788 posts)
1. Being half German
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 01:40 AM
14 hrs ago

And a boy fascinated by history I really took the time to understand how an entire country could fall for propaganda.
I've watched as rural America has fallen for the same antics from right wing media the last 30 years. I really think it lifted up by plain ole jealousy.
Since they see the Dems overall as snooty college educated elites they can blame their problems on someone else.
They don't understand government or history so that vacuum can easily be filled.
The one thing that has always irked me about the Democratic party is they think everyone passed their constitution with flying colors and should just understand what they are talking about.
Dems have to do a better job at gov education. A lot of prominent Dems might roll their eyes but Ross perot had it right with all the graphs and such. I still remember his talks and I was 10

Figarosmom

(1,853 posts)
2. When trump says Hitler did some
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 02:32 AM
13 hrs ago

Good things he is talking about the economy which was fueled by slave labor. He's likely also repeating what his parents said.

Jimvanhise

(361 posts)
3. THE POST WAR GERMAN GOVERNMENT TRIED TO COVER UP
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 03:08 AM
13 hrs ago

After the war, the new German government tried to hide the facts of the Jewish holocaust because they thought it would harm them on the new world stage. The Nuremburg Trials were literally the tip of the iceberg. It wasn't until the 1960s that concentration camp survivors started getting their stories told. As the war was ending, German officers tried to destroy all records of what they had done but the allies found out and retrieved them and created a huge warehouse of those records in Berlin. A German policeman began investigating the concentration camp stories and he went to the American command in Berlin who took him to a warehouse and explained, "The Germans wrote down everything they did, no matter how horrible, because they wanted to impress their superiors." That's when they started hunting down the worst of the Nazis even though many had fled to South America. A German language movie was made about this several years ago.

CTyankee

(64,756 posts)
14. "Judgement at Nuremburg" was a wonderful film about this time in history. I saw it again last year and was even more
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 11:53 AM
4 hrs ago

impressed with how devastating it was to the German crowd who said "We didn't know about these things," which were the growing encroachments of a Nazi party intent on wiping out Jews and other "unacceptable" people, i.e. mentally challenged individuals, for instance. FIND THIS MOVIE AND SEE IT! Probably one of the finest moments Hollywood has ever had...

EverHopeful

(352 posts)
4. Recently heard on a Thom Hartmann clip posted here on DU
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 03:17 AM
13 hrs ago

that Reagan eliminated federal funds for civics education. The time-line fits and has become another item on my long list of "I blame Reagan" accusations.

Friends and loved ones grow weary of my I blame Reagan comments and certainly many others since then have contributed to our current peril but even the outsized voice given to right wing broadcasting can be traced back to his destructive reign.

Also recently read that if enough people are kept miserable enough for long enough, they will choose Authoritarians. That certainly seems to be playing out here and now.

NBachers

(17,973 posts)
6. A few years ago, I met a man at work who said he'd been in Hitler Youth. He wasn't old enough yet to serve when the war
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 04:14 AM
12 hrs ago

ended. He told me about how, in his town, when they heard Hitler had died and Germany had fallen, everyone took their uniforms and Nazi paraphernalia and threw them in the river. He said the river was clogged with all the Nazi cast-off items. I took it to mean that they were afraid they'd be judged guilty when the foreign troops arrived, and wanted to get rid of the proof.

In Miami, in the early '70s I worked on a crew headed by a man named Helmut. He'd been a lieutenant in the German army on the Russian Front. He was taken prisoner, and had frozen so bad he lost all the hair on his body. He owned a BMW motorcycle. He often talked about the war from their perspective, and the lead-up in Germany. Like many Germans from that time, he still held on to the "good things" Hitler had done to restore Germany's faith and confidence in itself. He was an old-school carpenter who'd apprenticed himself at 15. He was probably the best boss I ever had. The entire crew loved him for his staunch advocacy for his workers. He always made sure to have a large population of Black workers on his crews. He said the Black mess staff at the prison camp was the only reason he survived his Russian wartime prison ordeal.

no_hypocrisy

(48,418 posts)
7. Consider this:
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 04:50 AM
11 hrs ago

There's a good chance that Germany would STILL BE NAZI if the Allies hadn't won the War. And Naziism would have spread to other countries, e.g., France, the U.K., the rest of Europe.

Once you're in a dictatorship, you don't get to vote it out.

Jmb 4 Harris-Walz

(671 posts)
8. Such amazing stories
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 05:29 AM
10 hrs ago

Thanks so much for sharing. It must have been incredible to hear directly from someone who was there when it happened Pototan.

llmart

(16,270 posts)
9. What stood out for me from your story...
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 06:00 AM
10 hrs ago

is when you said he visited rural areas during his campaign. I have often asked why trump was going to all these small, sparsely populated rural towns on his campaign trail. After all, he knows he has those people's votes (mostly all white, mostly not college educated). He is following Hitler's playbook.

Yesterday I took a drive out to the rural area for my fall pumpkins, etc. Up until yesterday I had seen very few trump signs if any. The trip was about ten miles. The farther I got away from my town I started to see trump signs everywhere. By the time I got home the rest of my day was very unsettled. This is Michigan and for the first time I had this feeling that Michigan may not be a lock for Kamala.

I still think that a vast number of people do not believe that he would ever do the things he says such as be a "dictator on day 1". They still think "oh, that's just trump being trump." That's what scares me the most. There's a lot of them out there.

Martin Eden

(13,341 posts)
10. Embracing a fascist dictator in 2024 USA is worse because:
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 06:24 AM
9 hrs ago

The German people suffered humiliation in the wake of WW1 and terrible economic hardship during the Depression, whereas the USA has the strongest economy in the world and we are still the pre-eminent nation.

The popularity of Donald Trump stems from ignorance and bigotry, not trauma and desperation.

This is not to ignore the poverty which still afflicts many in this country, but to believe Donald Trump or Republican policies will rescue the poor is delusion.

OneGrassRoot

(23,384 posts)
15. I interviewed a Nazi 20 years ago...
Thu Oct 24, 2024, 12:01 PM
4 hrs ago

lol I'm just going to call him that.

His entree was via Hitler-Jugend - Hitler Youth. He was an excellent athlete and they were among the first recruited. In the case of the young people, who were essentially isolated in summer camp-style environments, I believe them when they say they didn't really know what was going on as far as the heinous things, not until they were conscripted into active duty.

He said you absolutely could not say no to be in Hitler Youth; it was obviously authoritarian enough from the onset that they realized they had to join. But they were treated like young gods.

Then shit got real, fast, especially since it was toward the end of the war by the time he, at 14, was forced into active duty. Holding that swastika patch was surreal, to say the least.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Can I tell you a story?