Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

RidinWithHarris

(790 posts)
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 03:51 PM Oct 2024

Most of us agree polling is probably broken. But broken by how much?

First off, let's assume we're factoring all "red-wave" fly-by-night fake polling OUT of the discussion.

Let's just talk about established pollsters (as long as you aren't choosing the tinfoil hat option given below) who we'll credit with trying to do their best given low response rates and trying to model a difficult-to-model changing electorate, difficult-to-predict motivation to turn out, and difficult-to-predict ground game effectiveness.


19 votes, 1 pass | Time left: Unlimited
Some degree of Trump support is being hidden
0 (0%)
About 1% of Harris support is being hidden
0 (0%)
About 2% of Harris support is being hidden
1 (5%)
About 3% of Harris support is being hidden
5 (26%)
About 4% of Harris support is being hidden
2 (11%)
5%-10% of Harris support is being hidden
10 (53%)
More than 10% of Harris support is being hidden
1 (5%)
My tinfoil hat is on -- it's ALL RIGGED!!1!11!!
0 (0%)
Show usernames
Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll
21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Most of us agree polling is probably broken. But broken by how much? (Original Post) RidinWithHarris Oct 2024 OP
I hope you see the irony by running a poll lapfog_1 Oct 2024 #1
Absolutely. The kind of irony I love 😄 RidinWithHarris Oct 2024 #2
LOL! LymphocyteLover Oct 2024 #10
Trump said it: Election is rigged LiberaBlueDem Oct 2024 #3
Shes gonna win by around ten is my guess ColinC Oct 2024 #4
In what country? iemanja Oct 2024 #12
America is a place that makes drastic reversals after major mistakes. ColinC Oct 2024 #13
Quite possibly, but that doesn't equal ten points iemanja Oct 2024 #14
No we are screwed if it is anything less than a landslide in my opinion ColinC Oct 2024 #15
It would be amazing if you were right iemanja Oct 2024 #16
Agreed! ColinC Oct 2024 #17
"Election is rigged." J_William_Ryan Oct 2024 #5
3%? Elessar Zappa Oct 2024 #6
Why I chose hidden (by a lot) GemDigger Oct 2024 #7
What matters, however, is not your reluctance to participate in polls... RidinWithHarris Oct 2024 #8
*bump* RidinWithHarris Oct 2024 #9
We won't know until after the election iemanja Oct 2024 #11
Most of us like to try to figure out where event are likely to take us RidinWithHarris Oct 2024 #19
Agree Baggies Oct 2024 #21
The average of polls according to 538 has her leading 48.1 to 46.6%. Self Esteem Oct 2024 #18
I'm slightly more optimistic than that, but not by a whole lot RidinWithHarris Oct 2024 #20

LiberaBlueDem

(1,167 posts)
3. Trump said it: Election is rigged
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 03:56 PM
Oct 2024


Believe him. It is rigged in his favor. Only way we win is by massive turn out. And we are, women lead the way!

ColinC

(11,098 posts)
13. America is a place that makes drastic reversals after major mistakes.
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 06:48 PM
Oct 2024

It'll sometimes take some time, but we see our mistakes and tend to correct them after a while.

iemanja

(57,387 posts)
14. Quite possibly, but that doesn't equal ten points
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 06:50 PM
Oct 2024

We live in an intensely, pathologically divided nation. It is the nature of America at this point in history. That doesn't leave room for a 10 point victory. 3% would be amazing. I don't know why people have to pretend it will be a blow out. All we need is a win.

ColinC

(11,098 posts)
15. No we are screwed if it is anything less than a landslide in my opinion
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 07:03 PM
Oct 2024

We need a landslide as a bare minimum for survival of our country, and quite possibly our species.

I can revisit the numbers with you and tell you why I think this 10 points is possible and even likely, but it will be easier just to wait and let you see it for yourself.

GemDigger

(4,379 posts)
7. Why I chose hidden (by a lot)
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 05:14 PM
Oct 2024

I have talked to several of my friends about phone polls and many of us are not even answering the phone or responding to them in other ways. I hope there are lots more of us out there holding out because it would be one hellova surprise.

RidinWithHarris

(790 posts)
8. What matters, however, is not your reluctance to participate in polls...
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 05:26 PM
Oct 2024

…but if Trump supporters are equally reluctant or not. If there is no particular partisan bias in willingness to participate in polling, the effect is a wash.

Good modeling can also compensate to a degree for a partisan bias in poll participation.

RidinWithHarris

(790 posts)
19. Most of us like to try to figure out where event are likely to take us
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 07:06 PM
Oct 2024

You don't have to be capable of perfect prediction to want that. For most people speculation is an automatic brain function. The only choice part about that speculation is if you engage others in a conversation about it or not. I choose to engage.

Baggies

(666 posts)
21. Agree
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 07:17 PM
Oct 2024

And given the TOS here, it’s not worth the potential blowback to discuss what’s happening on the ground, and that’s a shame it can’t be mentioned. But too many itchy fingers.

 

Self Esteem

(2,248 posts)
18. The average of polls according to 538 has her leading 48.1 to 46.6%.
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 07:06 PM
Oct 2024

That's a 1.5 margin. My guess is she wins 51-47 - maybe that 47 rounded to 48. So, 3-4 point margin of victory in the popular vote.

That would put the polls, on average, 2.5 off at best. I think that's reasonable and within the MOE of most polls.

Very little chance Kamala wins by more than that.

RidinWithHarris

(790 posts)
20. I'm slightly more optimistic than that, but not by a whole lot
Sun Oct 27, 2024, 07:14 PM
Oct 2024

My reason for a little more optimism isn't in the accuracy of the polling itself, but the turnout motivation that can only be roughly estimated based on previous elections.

As for MOE, that's actually less important the more polls you have to average together, and/or have a running track record of. MOE captures the completely random part of polling error, related to the luck-of-the-draw of who randomly pick to poll, nothing more and nothing less.

The more you aggregate, the more the MOEs tend to cancel each other out. Average together 10 polls each with an MOE of 3% and the average will have an MOE of only around 1%.

MOE doesn't capture modeling errors or participation bias at all.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Most of us agree polling ...