General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWoman who held "Trump is a c*nt" sign has passed on, but not before leaving another message
Her name was Doctor Janey Godley. She was from Scotland. You may remember her. RIP!
This is the image that made her famous.
Solly Mack
(93,239 posts)Rest in truth.
teran
(57 posts)Can recommend The C Bomb on BBC radio. She had one hell of a life and left it making us laugh.
RIP
MadameButterfly
(2,049 posts)right up until the end
dalton99a
(85,022 posts)Janey Godley dies three years after cancer diagnosis
Dennis Donovan
(27,780 posts)Clouds Passing
(2,894 posts)Ill miss your brazen humor!
Hope22
(3,150 posts)We have lost a fighter and she is so needed here. Rest in peace dear person! You are missed.💗💗🙏🏼💐
littlemissmartypants
(26,006 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)especially coming from women themselves. It's as sadly self-hating as Black people calling themselves the "N-word".
Tweedy
(1,231 posts)not another woman.
Rest in peace brave soul!
whathehell
(29,887 posts)of who it is targeting...
Those who would call Trump a "cunt" say NOTHING about him, and EVERYTHING about their own contempt for women's bodies.
Orrex
(64,366 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)dchill
(40,821 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)and no, I'm not talking about MY departure.
dchill
(40,821 posts)Dr. Godley was from Scotland, where the word "cunt" is commonly used as an insult - it's also an insult to any vagina. It's a crude word, and it is used in this incidence to describe an even cruder individual. You should choose your battles, and not take on the Scottish people. They know what they're doing.
jfz9580m
(15,584 posts)Like how the gay community turned queer into a prideful word.
Repurposing a misogynistic slur to attack the creeps.
duhneece
(4,271 posts)All while understanding this wonderful womans insult to Trump.
And her sense of humor as she faced dying.
May I have some of that before I die.
jfz9580m
(15,584 posts)Amen to that..It is how my much loved mom coped with cancer and I with the series of unfortunate events that have dogged me ;-/..
I dont think one can survive modern life wo a sense of humor:
duhneece
(4,271 posts)I hope to say, I got you last as I touch them and exhale for the last time.
I saw it in a cartoon years ago and it stuck.
jfz9580m
(15,584 posts)muriel_volestrangler
(102,701 posts)It is the most extreme insult, but we also see don't lesser ones, like "prick" or "dick" as saying anything about men.
Violet_Crumble
(36,143 posts)In the UK the word is used as a non-sexist insult. Where I live, the word can be an insult (Donald Trump is a dumb c***), used by bogans as a form of greeting friends (Hey, ya c***!) or to describe something not very nice that someone's done (That was a c***y move!).
I think Trump is a massive c***. Feel free to tell me about this supposed contempt I have for my own body.
whathehell
(29,887 posts)but it's being quoted here on a US site where the word is NOT used lightly. If the word was used here in the same way you describe its use elsewhere, it would be deleted as a TOS violation; Persistent attempts would get the poster banned. Cultural sensitivity -- It's a thing.
Tweedy
(1,231 posts)We will have to agree to disagree.
Have a lovely weekend!
TexLaProgressive
(12,342 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)a women's genitals as the lowest, most disgusting thing around.
Ask yourself this: If a white person calls another white person the 'n-word', who are they insulting, that white person or black people, generally?
I'd say the latter, and it's the same with women and the C word.
Envirogal
(178 posts)I look at context and its actually very funny how she used it against the target of her ire.
whathehell
(29,887 posts)but I'd find her ire at Trump amusing as well had she not, with all the gender neutral insults available, chosen a gender slur instead.
moonshinegnomie
(2,926 posts)It is applied to both men and women
Differnt country different meaning for the same word.
Just like biscuit means differnt things
Emrys
(8,071 posts)H2O Man
(75,848 posts)opinion, but can see why others think otherwise. And I don't think black people using the "n" word are expressing self-hatred. One of the guys I last trained, a Golden Gloves super heavyweight champion, used the word in a few situations. He laughed and said, "We stole that word from racists whites. They can only say it in private. So we're showing we can say it in public. And that pisses them off to the extent some try to argue about it publicly."
I'd also point to Dave Chappelle. Some like him, some don't. He is one of, if not thee, most influential comedians in his era. He makes all kinds of jokes.
However, they are two words that I do not use.
True Dough
(21,045 posts)Hence the handy asterisk as a substitute for the "u" in the thread title.
But I respect this lady's right of expression, and I most certainly concur with her choice of target!
LizBeth
(10,924 posts)That it is not doing them any good and it cannot be owned by those subjected. We clearly see with woman, that we are not "owning" the sexist slurs.
whathehell
(29,887 posts)and I believe they're doing the right thing.
In terms of its effectiveness, I frankly think the whole practice of "reclaiming", or "owning" an insult as a way to 'defuse' it is exaggerated. It's worked in one or two instances, but is not, imo, a reliable strategy.
I'd guess that part of its appeal, lies in its being easy..It takes far less work than actually constructing an actual ARGUMENT against the use of demeaning terms. Instead of engaging in that kind of sometimes rigorous effort, one just opts to take an insult and "wear it"..I believe it fails more often than it succeeds.
H2O Man
(75,848 posts)your opinion. You make a strong case for your position, which is exactly what I like the most on DU. So thank you for this. And I intend my responses here in a respectful manner, in the spirit of an interesting, important conversation.
Now, I am very old. So old, that I likely have said that a dozen times but can't remember. Two branches of the extended family are black, and came from NYC. Rap music started there -- and likely other places -- in the early 1970s. From NYC, it caught on. Even back then adults from these communities warned the younger generation. And hip-hop caught on in the 2000s, and older people warned the youth. That's not a new or limted thing. Elvis and the Beatles upset the older generation, and they warned us.
Of no importance, perhaps, my family came from the Old Sod. They were not greeted with open arms by the WASPs. In my youth, some of the old hatred lingered and found expression. I'm not comparing it, for even if there are similarities, there are obvious significant differences. I am concerned about the levels of hatred -- sexism and racism in particular -- that is rising again in this country. I think this cycle started when Senator Obama was running for president. So I do pay attention to the things you have said here.
whathehell
(29,887 posts)I really do, and I certainly won't argue with you about black people's use of the N word, especially among themselves. It may have been a bad analogy. I just don't think that, in general, attempts to "reclaim" an insult for the purpose of defusing it, works as well as some imagine..Thanks for sharing you're experience with me (are you a boxer? ) and also the fact of your refusing to use insults based on condition of birth.
H2O Man
(75,848 posts)The respect is mutual!
I tend to focus my concerns on the world my generation -- including me -- are handing down to my grandchildren's generation. And I don't feel good about all of the toxins that saturate the social fabric these days. I think that Democrats need to study examples such as Martin Luther King, Jr's approach ...... because we can not and will not "out-hate" the maga cult. And I remember long, long ago, in an English class in college, the teacher saying that a good writer does not need to curse to fully express themselves.
I used to speak at colleges and universities. I loved being challenged by students. These days, the old bag of bones & lard I inhabit prevents my doing that. But I continue to study people, individuals and groups. I try to remain hopeful.
On edit: I boxed when I was young. I was pretty good. It was my friend Rubin Carter who convinced me to quit boxing, and get into college. I'll note that when he was young, he favored Malcolm X. Years later, he came to understand that King was correct.
DoBotherMe
(2,350 posts)The Brits use the word against male jerks.
Tarc
(10,580 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)Perhaps you need to re-read the DU terms of service regarding slurs based on Race, Religion, and Gender.
Have a nice one.
.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)If it is, in fact, "not going anywhere" it's because it's a quote originating in another country and culture
with the intent of somehow
"memorializing" a dead woman, and those would be the ONLY reasons.
Used in another context, it would be gone faster than you can say "Misogyny is the last acceptable bigotry of the Left".
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)Its very un Democratic.
Tarc
(10,580 posts)By all means, "dear", alert that. I'd wear that ding with pride if you somehow hit the lottery for a likeminded jury.
whathehell
(29,887 posts)to put it in quotes, dont you? That, or replacing the "u" in the word with a symbol, as the OP did, is the ONLY way this flies here, and we know that.
As to juries, they don't reflect "likemindedness" as much as you might think..A better representation of the "popularity" of an OP is seen by comparing the number of 'recs' it has in proportion to the number of 'views' it's received. When you check the "info" box on the OP you'll it has 188 recs. That seems like a lot until you see that over 4,350 DUers have viewed it, which amounts to LESS than 5 percent, making for a most miniscule number of "endorsements".
Response to whathehell (Reply #88)
Post removed
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)Nah..I didn't think so. As Katha Politt said "Misogyny IS the last acceptable bigotry of the Left.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)whathehell
(29,887 posts)The question is why you would be sensitive to one but not the other.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)Im sensitive to gender slurs. Im also intelligent enough to understand things like context. Hope that clears it up.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)Maybe allow for cultural differences and stop assuming everyone everywhere should conform to American norms. Its super arrogant.
whathehell
(29,887 posts)I've been to the UK several times and when I am IN the UK, I DO allow for the "difference in cultural norms", but we are not IN the UK now, are we?..We're on an American political board, so you might want to turn it around a bit and consider the "arrogance" of those in OTHER countries refusing to recognize OUR cultural norms when in our space.
Cultural sensitivity -- It goes both ways.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)I know its horrific that this dead woman used a slur common to her country but try to press on.
Response to BannonsLiver (Reply #46)
Post removed
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)Are you kidding? I love a good sanctimony party!
whathehell
(29,887 posts)I guess these toothless little "insults" will have to suffice.
Unfortuntely, those of us who CAN argue on the merits tend to be bored with such tripe, and so choose to enjoy their day rather than indulge it. Buh bye now.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)Is being a contrarian for the sake of being a contrarian some kind of principled stand?
whathehell
(29,887 posts)but I'm afraid I can't help anyone
who fails to understand rational discourse.
Bye.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)😬
JI7
(90,950 posts)We can't see it based on how things are in the US.
Nasruddin
(876 posts)Really common cuss word across Britain
Offensive but not as outre as in USA
You'll just have to deal with that as you will
Self Esteem
(1,797 posts)Violet_Crumble
(36,143 posts)I'm not sure about Canada or other English speaking countries, but I suspect the US is the odd one out. It's not a gender based slur here, though I'd never use it against another woman as an insult.
The argument I'm seeing is this is a US forum and we need to respect US culture. I'm sensitive to Americans who are offended by the word by saying c***. I'll make one exception this time only and give a nod to the Scottish lady who sadly passed away by saying that Trump is a cunt, a real cunty McCunt. Apologies to anyone offended but Asterisks would spoil that line.
orangecrush
(22,153 posts)Safe passage, Ma'am.
iluvtennis
(20,958 posts)Fla Dem
(25,912 posts)republianmushroom
(18,258 posts)riversedge
(73,490 posts)demmiblue
(37,885 posts)Link to tweet
LizBeth
(10,924 posts)For Du to embrace this on one side and not another is a little bit sick. So tired of vile toward women. Per law we are already in states killing women and girls not providing medical care. This feeds into the misogyny.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)That people here dont understand cultural differences or demand that all cultures conform to American norms isnt her problem.
LizBeth
(10,924 posts)Culture difference or not, it is a reality. Democrats are good about holding two positions at the same time and call out the harm. Like, Jason Kelce smashing the phone of a mouth throwing out gay slurs, then using the gay slur himself for retaliation. He was wrong with using the gay slur back at him, BECAUSE we know the harm.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)LizBeth
(10,924 posts)Shame on me. Use any slur for any reason on gays or blacks and get called out, not going to hear a single person say it is sanctimonious. ONLY with women can we use a bigoted slur and if a woman dares to have an issue she is sanctimonious.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)LizBeth
(10,924 posts)BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)Its about a woman in Scotland who called Trump the C word. Whataboutisms arent going to change that.
LizBeth
(10,924 posts)I cannot tell you the number of times on DU listening to someone use the B or C word and defending it when using it on Republican women cause we do not like them, while outraged, I tell you, when used on ours. So, you have an issue with Elon calling Harris the C word on twitter?
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)And yes, I do have a problem with Elmo calling her that. The difference is I can process nuance and recognize Dr Godley calling Trump that is not the same.
LizBeth
(10,924 posts)women. I think she misinterpreted the ramifications, but then we shouldnt have an issue with Elon, if we decide it is not hate speech, right?
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)I do have a problem with him call her that. The difference is I can process nuance and can understand Dr Godley calling Trump the C word is not the same.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)LizBeth
(10,924 posts)dying because the can no longer get certain medical procedure for the indifference or just flat out hate toward them. The C word fuels that, nothing is in a vacuum BUT Bannons, I enjoy your posts, we see this different, neither will relent so I am done with this conversation. I take it personally and is so sad for me, I do not need to hash it out with people I enjoy.
BannonsLiver
(18,280 posts)Have a good evening.
moonshinegnomie
(2,926 posts)Basically your trying to assign us culture to a statement in a foreign country
The rest of the world doesnt have to subscribe to American sensitivity
whathehell
(29,887 posts)and has the guts to say so!
LizBeth
(10,924 posts)words with black or gays, but a woman? ..... sure. I have always had a problem with the hypocrisy and calling it out. I won't shut up, even alone. So thank you.
whathehell
(29,887 posts)about the hypocrisy and double standards applied to women, even by supposed "progressives"
It's why I think The Nation's feminist writer, Katha Pollitt nails it in claiming that "Misogyny is the last acceptable bigotry of the Left".
LizBeth, I am so glad to find another kindred spirit here!
I feel exactly the same -- I won't shut up either, even if alone. Would enjoy talking to you by pm sometime, if that's okay.
LizBeth
(10,924 posts)In the process of buying a condo and elections, lol.... oh but you betcha. Anytime you want so send a message, feel free. !!!
malaise
(279,102 posts)😀
Faux pas
(15,450 posts)she got her last laugh, for sure
Traildogbob
(10,226 posts)She will rest in total peace, knowing no trump, wife or spawn, will ever be in heaven.
He could actually start a mass religious rebound by
People thinking the best way to never deal with them again, is an eternity after life, where they will never be. Make me wanna commit just thinking eternity in hell with trumps is one of two options.
Fire and brimstone preachers need to make THAT the fear they yell every Sunday, for donations.
DrivingOnThe Left
(77 posts)keithbvadu2
(40,620 posts)The Scots have some good insults for Trump
Deuxcents
(20,249 posts)Eliot Rosewater
(32,538 posts)In the adult world around the world that word is not about Women it is about assholes. Sigh
Yes Donald Trump is a Cunt Cunt Cunt🤬🤬🤬
I have never in my life used that word in relation to a Woman and never would, it is no different than words like shagging, fanny etc. that have an entirely different meaning here and the rest of the world.
LizBeth
(10,924 posts)others that all the time.
This is a sad thread, .... I should have never stepped in.
Eliot Rosewater
(32,538 posts)LizBeth
(10,924 posts)It is used toward men because it is the most vile thing you can say about a woman, painting him as a nasty women, hence the insult. But of course we do this only with women, but not other protected groups.
JanMichael
(25,340 posts)I blame the internet.
JanMichael
(25,340 posts)Because I know people in Scotland hated Drumph well before 2016.
muriel_volestrangler
(102,701 posts)Harker
(15,247 posts)I've thought of her often.
keithbvadu2
(40,620 posts)Back when Hillary was running....
surfered
(3,890 posts)IcyPeas
(22,808 posts)CentralMass
(15,629 posts)"As a broader derogatory term, it is comparable to prick and means "a fool, a dolt, an unpleasant person of either sex". This sense is common in New Zealand, British, and Australian English, where it is usually applied to men or as referring specifically to "a despicable, contemptible or foolish" man."
https://tinyurl.com/mry3wspc
Emrys
(8,071 posts)LizBeth
(10,924 posts)Because as we feminize what is perceived as weak with the p word, the same with the c word meaning a prick. But, the real insult is behaving like a female. Weak or nasty, the insult is calling a man woman, and no greater insult than that, hence calling a man a woman one way or another. That simple.
DENVERPOPS
(10,216 posts)And.....I Miss Molly Ivans.......