General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forumsa woman whose anger needs to be paid attention to
Last edited Mon Nov 11, 2024, 05:54 PM - Edit history (2)
I changed the title of this woman's op because it offended many, but just because it offends some doe snot mean the problem it outlines is not real
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)the target of MAGA as ALL women are.
I have had the worst week of my life--including directly saving lives in my ER of those who declared that my body now belongs to THEM with their MAGA hats and who now think they have license to disrespect me every hour of the day.
So now, I get to see THIS? Thanks, DonCoquixote, very much. NOT. And don't you dare patronize me further by telling me to "just watch the video and that I will undoubtedly agree with her." Well, I might on many issues, but the subject title alone is enough to make me want to throw something through my screen.
DONQUIXOTE, PLEASE STOP!!!
wryter2000
(47,431 posts)White women continue to vote for Trump. Not a huge majority, but a majority.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Defending it is incomprehensible, wryter2000 and not merely insensitive.
wryter2000
(47,431 posts)I guess you can take offense that someone posted it here but not that the woman made the video.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)this call-out of a group on DU isitself indefensible.
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)2:26 seconds it takes a very different turn.
What I do agree with in the video - Blue Bracelets and Womens' Marches are worthless. Didn't do a damn thing the last time.
If that group is going to lead the Resistance - they need to do something else.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)Or anyone else.
I put that patronizing squarely on the OP - who chose to focus on taking a pot shot at Liberal and Progressive Women.
But in all black spaces (Sunday dinner at my house yesterday) - the women - including myself -
Were vocal at our anger about ONE selfish self-serving community who thinks I'm going to come to their defense when Trump comes for them.
Black women are not here for that. Uh uh no way. Not gonna do it.
And I'd only support a woman's march if it is going to be as brutal and chaotic as January 6th.
ETA - Angela Davis wouldn't play nice if she was a young woman today. She simply wouldn't. And neither would Shirley Chisholm or Harriet.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)and promulgating divisive misogynistic blame on this forum. SHAME ON YOU!
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)You won't let a black woman have an opinion that differs from yours.
Shame on you.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)So now you are determined to divide based on gender AND race TOO as the OP clearly did for those who are ALL under attack? Really? ALL women. ALL. Regardless of race, ethnicity, or status (while some don't realize that- who were ignorant enough to throw away their vote or chance to do so).
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)You are accusing me of being a mysoginist who hates white women and wants to divide us. "Shame on you is really demeaning."
I've given you so many chances over the years. No more.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)the point you were trying to make. I am sorry for that misunderstanding. I see now that your were not trying to attack others as some on this thread clearly are.
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)But - I won't trust a blue bracelet. I could see Magats using one of their women to lure us - so the men can harm us.
I no longer believe that people are generally good. I just don't.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)LizBeth
(10,821 posts)never confused.
Odious justice
(199 posts)everyone can read the OP.
LisaL
(46,601 posts)As far as I can tell, Harris did better with white women as a group than Biden did. So clearly white women as a group is not the reason that Harris lost the election.
Biden received higher percentage of white women votes than kamala. period.
LauraInLA
(1,304 posts)LisaL
(46,601 posts)NT
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)ariadne0614
(1,869 posts)I didnt feel at all maligned. I only felt my heart expanding to meet her where she is.
LisaL
(46,601 posts)Youtube has given her this space. OP for whatever reason decided to post it here.
I am not sure what your race is, but if it is white, don't bother to meet her where she is, she clearly says you are not welcome.
ariadne0614
(1,869 posts)Im half Norwegian and half Mexican, and I dont expect her to make me feel welcome.
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)It offends me that she makes accusations and refuses to hear (read) comments from those she accuses.
There were plenty of white women who supported Harris - yet she shut them down. Why bring that here when all of the white women who post here supported Harris.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)expecting, hoping White Women in general would vote better in this election.
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)Sheesh!
I don't approve of videos that insult me and then cut off communication.
Please tell me why Black women were betrayed more than white women who voted for Harris.
Yes, racists voted for Trump, but all white women aren't racists.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)but Black Women have a an extra layer of experience starting from nasty to deadly with either certain White citizens, LOEs, or government institutions blanketly or individual officials within.
As I said I'm guessing the Black Woman in that vid felt that more White Women would vote for Kamala. Didn't happen! 😑😔🤬
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)but as to the topic of this thread, White women were told to shut up.
I worked in Social services as a case manager for a welfare to work type program, I know what difficulties the Black community endures.
This is a separate issue - and I don't appreciate being told to shut up.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)expression of betrayal pain on a blanket level.
She may remain inconsolable, she may change her mind later.
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)I think we all feel that pain.
Discrimination against minorities is a separate issue.
Why would that woman alienate women who supported Harris?
Personally, I supported Harris because she was the best candidate with the best platform ... gender and color were not a factor.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)alright, maaaaybe I didn't say "betrayed" somewhere. So, yeah, that too.
And distraught over all, still in partial disbelief.
Or maybe unconsciously I thought non college white women would still go more for drumphf. Idk.
Yes, I know somewell educateed women , and men support fascists
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)I was just trying to make a point.
I felt that the woman in the video wasn't understanding that, and in her fury at the situation lashed out at women who are her allies....even though they may happen to be white.
I also think that it was poor judgement to post that particular video here at DU.
As an aside: I don't personally go for the blue bracelet thing, nor did I go for the pussy hat thing. Such demonstrations may help a person to feel better, but are not very effective in changing minds or policy.
I do think that I will get more involved in my local League of Women Voters though. Where I live, they trend Blue.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)blue bracelets, highly unlikely for me.
If I'd had been a fast knitter (oh, I am so not!😄 ) might have made hat.
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)When I'd bet that most of us are feeling pain.
How did the OP think that would help, except to rub salt in our very fresh wounds?
soandso
(1,155 posts)wnylib
(24,375 posts)that the election was solely about the issues of Black people or of Black women.
It is divisive because she is race blaming. And that is unacceptable on DU. Does not matter thst she is not directly addressing DU. It is posted on DU.
Black women, White women, Latina women, Native women, Asian women are all experiencing the devastating risk of their health and lives, with some of us dying and others horribly traumatized by nearly dying before being treated.
Aside from women's issues, all Americans, male and female, will suffer from President Felon's fascist regime. All Americans now risk losing health insurance and health care, daily life-saving meds, housing due to higher costs of everything. Immigrants risk detainment in prison camps. People who worked hard to win the election face retaliation with investigations, charges, possible imprisonment.
Staying together to look after each other is our best hope. There is no place for such division among us.
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)is finding out what caused the division. There is a hole that the gop has exploited, and we need to patch it. Yes, I know many women of a light skin did vote for harris, and I appreciate them. But I am sure these same women will se that their friend voted the other way, and did not have the guts to own what they did. I want us to stay together, but as in any relationship, we need to honestly see where we are, and how we got here.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)I'd be shocked.
I try to pick my white friends carefully since I was young.
wnylib
(24,375 posts)how we got here. She has assumed that all White women are responsible for the outcome because she has lumped all White women into one group.
And yet, we know that Latino support for Trump, especially among Latino men, increased in this election. We also know that there was voter suppression in the form of removing eligible voters from the rolls. There were bomb threats at some locations. Yes, those sites reopened after being checked, but how many people remained at those polls to vote after the site was cleared? How many people heard of the threat and stayed away?
Why did Harris get less support among Black voters than Biden did? Did White women cause that?
I can understand anger over the White women who voted for Trump. Black people are not the only ones who are angry about the outcome. Extending anger to include White women who voted for Harris is divisive and does not an answer the question of how we got here. It does not even ask the question.
Would she now reject unity in resisting the the racist, misogynistic government that is looming over all of us and reject unity in helping the people who will be most harmed by it?
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)and I AM a Latino man, although I have ceased to find any comfort or even identity as they have willingly infested themselves with the GOP parasite. I can admit this poster does lack subtlety, but questions remain. I do not to be here 2028 and find ourselves in the same spot again, where the work we all do is undermined by people who will tell us they hate trump, but then they go into the booth.
Yes, there DOES need to be an examination of vote tampering, should have been since 2008.
Yes, there DOES and I mean DOES need to be an investigation of this election where Black districts in Georgia were threated with BOMBS! We can bet the FBI won't get on that because they are too busy wondering when Trump will fire them.
But we do need a plan of consistent, persistent action to make sure we are not in this again. Can it mean that you have some unpleasant conversations with friends and family? I know from experience that it does.
and yes, I do appreciate the many women , white and black, and yellow and all shades beyond and between that did vote for Harris , that worked to get her on. All I am saying is that whatever we are doing, the GOP has found a crack in the ramparts, which we need to fix, and note, I do say we, because whatever acrimony was caused by a tiktok video, we will need to. To quote Ben Franklin, "we must all hang together, or we will all hang separetely." All I want is to work stop the Gallows from being prepped.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Of course women over all will suffer. Along with every other vunerable group of people, and those in intersecting groups you've mentioned!
Imho, her pain is important to hear, even while being uncomfortable.
She may change in time.
wnylib
(24,375 posts)at an entire demographic. I am directing my feeling of betrayal at Trump voters. I am not directing it at Harris voters who fall into the demographic.
Now more than ever we need to be united in resisting the coming racist, misogynistic government and in helping each other get through it. Creating division at this time aids them in dividing and conquering.
mchill
(1,088 posts)Wrong crowd to be directing her malice toward. This is helping nothing.
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)Blue bracelets. Yes, it's that simple.
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)To draw us close so they can grab black women and lynch us?
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Considering the worst racists' track records, and what drumphf turned over; your fear is not unfounded. Unfortunately!
Patton French
(1,132 posts)So there's that.
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)They don't realize the isolation that many of us find us in. And, quite frankly, I missed the part where blue bracelets only represented support for black people. A first step for many of us in Red counties, is just to begin to make eye contact. Maybe we'll be ready to organize by the next election.
Patton French
(1,132 posts)I see it as odd to attack white women who for voted for Kamala and are now doing things like wearing blue bracelets. People doing that seem genuine to me.
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)I think the problem is that people are taking out their frustrations on their own allies, because we're truly confused by what happened. None of it makes sense. Frankly, where I live, no one seems to cross race or culture lines. So no one's opinions are going to affect me. When the Democratic party can figure out how to bridge that gap in Florida, they will be closer to winning elections.
Red Mountain
(1,880 posts)skin tone, not so much.
Blue bracelet tattoos, anyone?
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)At least 80% of them will identify with the Democratic party. For Latina Americans, the percentage is much lower, and because of all the fear that exists in the world, they will be less inclined to be as friendly as they once were.
And white women? Forget it. I wouldn't venture there unless there was a clear way to identify them.
1WorldHope
(899 posts)Really?
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)Which is HUGE.
As a bi-cultured American, I understand both cultures, but I have no feeling of sisterhood or comradery from either.
1WorldHope
(899 posts)My point is that white women need to SDSFU when a black woman is telling them how hurt or angry she/they are. All women are discriminated against, but black women have suffered far more and far longer than we (white woman here) have suffered.
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)own purposes.
Look, I fully understand that it's impossible to say words of sympathy to black Americans because we can never understand what they've been through and we will always fall short. Though this is what causes hindrances to developing strong relationships, the reality is that unless we're neighbors and can have opportunities to build bonds of trust, there isn't much more we can do, besides quietly listen.
Listening is one thing. We can do that. Unless they come out and tell us what action would actually be effective, what else can we do but listen? On the other hand, if they're claiming that the blue bracelets are ineffective, which I would agree, I would also claim that they're harmless. Or, as I pointed out, it might help Dem women identify each other and make efforts to get to know each other.
1WorldHope
(899 posts)I guess if we (white women) would have shown up in the polls like our lives depended on it, that would have been a good action and a good 1st step to bridging our cultures. I respect her anger and I don't blame her one bit. I know that I am angry as hell and find myself trusting everyone a little less.
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)more white women would have voted against drumphf in particular bc of increasingly threats against choice.
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)We're all frustrated. Kamala Harris was a great candidate. She would have made a phenomenal president.
happy feet
(1,093 posts)Not sure if you were commenting to me exactly, but, I didn't want to leave you without a "hi" back at you.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)column it must feel dispiriting at times.
I have friends, and acquaintences in TX, and FL that are surrounded by drumphers.
IzzaNuDay
(601 posts)So it rings hollow to me.
Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)The other day someone from a Latina Facebook site I belong to tried to befriend me. Her name was Anglo, and she had gone to school in a private religious high school in Texas. And her facebook page was sparse.
Do you think I friended her? Or declined her?
wryter2000
(47,431 posts)The bracelets are supposed to indicate supporting Harris.
Not taking a stand on them one way or another.
Fullduplexxx
(8,254 posts)Donald Trump has won the majority of white women voters for the third straight time.
Even after destroying abortion rights, even after a judge went to painstaking lengths to clarify that Trump raped E. Jean Carroll, and even as the Harris campaign targeted the imaginary silent majority of women hiding their political views from their husbands, 52 percent of white American women showed us who they are: Trump supporters.
LisaL
(46,601 posts)So this one group (white women) is the group we have actually improved with, unlike many other groups.
happy feet
(1,093 posts)Biden won higher percentage of white women votes than Harris
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Meowmee
(5,467 posts)From an idiot trying to get likes etc on yt. Dont watch it. 🤗
wryter2000
(47,431 posts)I'm leaning toward taking it off.
Elmotime
(10 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)What next? I shudder to think what misogyny will be allowed on DU next?
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)Elmotime
(10 posts)And would ask "is it elmotime?" kinda became a family phrase.
SoFlaBro
(3,347 posts)LisaL
(46,601 posts)NT
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)and I really blamed Latino men who I have previously screamed , but I am not going to patronize black women who have fought like hell, only to go WTF?
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)LizBeth
(10,821 posts)the women specifically who betrayed women. Which I could post it. I am so so so fuckin angry. Why is that betrayal more profound for her? Because I am thinking cause they are such a fuckin embarassment in ,y very own social circle (Stopped hanging or talking to any rwer yrs ago) we are even MORE betrayed, I suggest. Why should white women feel the loss less. Makes NO sense.
Funny how they have not posted videos blaming white men, lol, and men of other groups who also voted for him.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Meowmee
(5,467 posts)They want to attack white women also? it could be a combination of both. But its not a reason to excuse all of the men is it? Its so much easier to attack women in a misogynistic society.
I also just think this is a trollish post in my opinion I didnt watch the video
I dont waste my time on this type of thing and I put a lot of people on mute here after the reading what they said. I already started doing a lot of that here when I was attacked myself. I saw things like this posted here for a long time now, the karen stuff, the wipip stuff- it shouldnt be here imo.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Meowmee
(5,467 posts)So far, I only see people posting this type of thing about women
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)Each voter is an individual, not a group. This type of thinking is dangerous.
karynnj
(59,935 posts)All the things the woman in the video should fear.
karynnj
(59,935 posts)Last edited Mon Nov 11, 2024, 04:48 PM - Edit history (1)
There are few states whiter than Vermont AND few states that had a lower percent vote for Trump.
Not to mention, groups I identify with were strongly Harris.
Vermont residents
Jews
Jewish women
My large family, stemming from the 9 kids my parents had - I think 100 percent Harris
College educated
I assume this woman would be among the first to react with rage if someone not from her ethnic group would criticize ALL black woman for something a majority of them did. Incidentally, I think she would be entirely correct. You are responsible for what you yourself do or fail to do.
What influence do I, as a senior VT white woman have on other white women, living elsewhere that I have never met.
happy feet
(1,093 posts)Crunchy Frog
(26,974 posts)is to blame, regardless of demographic characteristics. I'm not including people who were victims of voter suppression.
Groups don't vote, people do. Or maybe I should just start hating everybody in Florida and Texas.
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)She States:
Dear White Women? Really? I'm looking at Dearborn Michigan and not giving a fuck. Yep - a lot of white women need their white knights to beat and suppress them - but a lot voted up and down ballot for Democratics.
What the ProPalestine groups did? They fucked themselves over. Hard.
As she said - "Good luck to you".
As I say - - it was a self-inflicted wound.
HowlingWulf
(576 posts)Deleted
jalan48
(14,386 posts)JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)Where they want us to all come together and focus on their issues again.
I'm too busy trying to figure the right time to sell my house.
Takket
(22,514 posts)into an Israeli settlement.
JustAnotherGen
(33,542 posts)Ask me to not worry about the forced sterilization of the young people in my family. That's what the Nazi's did. I would not put it past the Maggot's Administration.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)jalan48
(14,386 posts)Baitball Blogger
(48,024 posts)Since I live in a predominately white community I like the idea of wearing blue bracelets, because it makes me feel solidarity with Democratic principles. And it would also help me find a kindred spirit in a sea of conservatives.
So, I disagree, atleast with reference to wearing blue bracelets.
LisaL
(46,601 posts)White women isn't the reason Harris lost the election.
FBaggins
(27,698 posts)While support from Black women was actually down three points from Hillary
pinkstarburst
(1,547 posts)happy feet
(1,093 posts)What is the source of your numbers? I,m curious because I saw the opposite (posted on DU)
LauraInLA
(1,304 posts)FBaggins
(27,698 posts)The arrogance to think that she speaks for all people with the same gender and skin color- or that she can paint whole swaths of the base (also based on skin color and gender).
The irony of pointing fingers at anyone saying essentially dont blame me - I did my part when her entire premise is that none of this is her fault because she did hers
And while were at it
who the heck taught her that this was how speaking respectfully looks?
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)her feeling of extra betrayal since more white women didn't vote against drumph.
FBaggins
(27,698 posts)Its one thing to feel betrayed by people who actually voted for the other candidate. Its an entirely different and illogical (though still emotionally understandable) thing to blame everyone in a group for what the overwhelming majority of that group did (as with white men)
But to blame everyone in a group (explicitly including those who voted the same way she did) for something almost half of that group opposed? Thats just not rational. (And there remains a huge split between married/single white women and those with/without college degrees - and those in her chat are likely to be almost exclusively educated single women)
She doesnt make me feel in the least bit uncomfortable (and my race/gender group voted against my preferences)
it makes me feel sorry for her.
The good news for her though is that it doesnt matter. Shes preaching to her own YouTube choir. Shes likely to make more money this way than with a more rational response.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)SHAME ON YOU!
pinkstarburst
(1,547 posts)Is that we need to stop with the blaming and alienating subgroups in posts like this, blaming suburban white women, blaming Hispanics, blaming Arab-Americans, blaming working class voters... only to turn around in 2 years, in 4 years, and beg them to vote for us. It's all over social media and it's not a good look for the party.
If we want those votes, we have to figure out WHY we are not reaching those voters and adjust strategy. Screaming YOU SUCK is not a strategy.
SickOfTheOnePct
(7,339 posts)And to do that, some folks on the Democratic side need to stop with the "the election was stolen".
We lost, big, and while we need time to mourn that loss, at some point (sooner rather than later, I hope), we need to dive into why, and then look at how to do better next time.
Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)That the democrats arent giving them. Why would they want an incompetent white man with enough flaws to fill a New York garbage barge versus an accomplished woman. I think we know the answer.
SoFlaBro
(3,347 posts)Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)There are certain rails you dont touch.
SoFlaBro
(3,347 posts)Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)If you offend certain groups you will be suspended and many people have felt the lash.
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)you state my point better than I, or the lady in the video did.
We cannot act like ostriches.
TheKentuckian
(26,181 posts)Preposterous, three times is an enemy action.
The excuses ran long dry 1/6/21.
It is all out here.
People will do what they do and most likely unless they can be hoodwinked out of it, stupid low life motherfuckers are going to do stupid low life shit.
Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)It is okay to ask why black men, Muslims, Hispanics and any other group votes against its interests. But we must say not all white women because they see it as personal meaning I am not them. So in the future please leave white women out and it will all be good.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)regardless of race and ethnicity and WILL. Your attempt to divide on this is atrocious and has NO place on DU.
Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)Perhaps you are seeing something that is not there. If we cant discuss why people vote against their interests, we cannot solve the problems we face.
I feel in your anger you are trying to shut down something you dont agree with.
Lets figure out why rather than you cant discuss this because I feel uncomfortable.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Or not.
Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)The big picture is that the majority of white women, not you voted for a rapist, a thief, an adulterer, a misogynist and any other commandment he could break.
I want to know how we can reach them because if they joined us we would have control of our bodies, get childcare, maternity care, and no one should be grabbing our you know whats. If discussing this is off the table . We need to figure this out and if we silence voices , we will keep going in this circle of hell.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)did vote for Trump" as you are desirous of seeing on DU. To that point, I'd suggest you cautiously and with sensitivity post a thread of your own, but more inclusive of all of the individual groups we need to reach--pointing each out for a separate discussion. But, again, if it stinks of misogyny and blaming ALL the very people most hurt by this debacle, it will not go over well--nor should it.
Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)For chump have already been crucified and vilified. I am trying to find what we can do to reach these people and you keep trying to shut me down . If more women had joined us maybe we wouldnt be in trouble. I dont need to start another discussion. You have yet to give me an idea about reaching these folks.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Your attempts to wave us all away and dismiss us is noted as the overt misogyny espoused. I tried to meet you halfway but apparently, as in most things, only men can hold a valid opinion--even on DU. Don't bother to engage again. I'm done with you.
happy feet
(1,093 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)If you think it is fine to treat women of DU as they have on this thread, gawd help us. It is not just MAGA.
happy feet
(1,093 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Mossfern
(3,172 posts)The woman in the video demanded that white women not comment on her video. She didn't demand that white women who voted for Trump not comment - but ANY white woman.
This is just wrong. This is throwing out the baby with the bath water. This is 'punishing' women who supported/ funded/worked for Harris merely because they are white.
This is a very important issue to acknowledge.
This is racism. Not what we need right now.
Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)Shes angry and lashing out, her problem not mine. I want someone to tell me what can we do to get the majority of white women to vote for democrats.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)her mind. Pain can cause people to blanketly lash out.
The fact that white women still voted ?52% for drumphf [GAHHH!!!!!] is a Betrayal!
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)why was this posted on DU where the white women supported Harris.
Did the OP assume that we don't understand the pain, not only hers, not only black women, but all women.
This is not the place to post such a video especially since the person in the video basically told us to shut up, that she doesn't want to hear from us.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)friends, and community to have dealt/deal with.
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)why do you say "All women AND Black women?
One would assume that Black women are covered in "All women" Why single them out?
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Mysoginy for those Black Women who feel it, and racism added!
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)Laso you know there is even greater with Latino women. But the greatest deprivation is with Native American women;. You know that right? So while we do not live the same element as black women, they dont with Latino women and none of us has it as harsh as Native American. Is this how we really want to have this conversation? I think we can be educated and listen, and always listen because there is always more to see and understand, but it is a woman issue.
That is what this election was for me. The barrier was woman. We had a black win, twice.... a man. We have not had a woman break the barrier. The loss as great for all women, not only blacks. Harris was as much ours and our dreams and hopes as much with her as any other woman. It was all woman still not able to break the ceiling.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)LizBeth
(10,821 posts)whites/asains, blacks, latinos then native american. I mean I have been educated on hierarchy so all misogyny deferred to native american because they have it the worse? Or do we recognize understand listen and work to resolve.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)TheKentuckian
(26,181 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)And yet, they are the ones on this thread battering down the women posting, mansplaining, telling us we are the ones who are not being understanding of this black woman's pain. The latter is so incredibly patronizing, condescending, misogynistic, and WRONG (in terms of DU women's sympathy first and foremost toward women of color who likewise fought for Harris) that it is just plain sickening. Yet they continue to lecture us when we are all together, as women, with the most at-risk and with the most to lose from this sickening administration. Do not even listen to themselves. No, certainly, not all, or even most DU males are so lacking in self-awareness or even, for the few, fully misogynistic. But, boy is it coming out NOW for the few.
So, no. I am not putting up with the misogynistic attempt to divide on DU--especially the women on racial lines. It is WRONG. And GD it, they need to damn-well STOP.
DooverBeliever
(18 posts)This is the second post I've seen telling white women to stop. These posts are just continuing to dividing us. We got very very strong while we were united around Kamala. Now, "they" (whoever they are) are trying to break this united front apart.
If white women need something to show unity-- let them wear bracelets, jeez. Let's regroup and focus on next steps and not buy into this tactic.
We got this... keep our focus on our goals - we must not chase every stick that is thrown at us.
Ndp5
(66 posts)but not the bracelets thing, which is ridiculous. Special markers for identity groups? Ill wear a blue bracelet around as soon as male (pick a race) Trump voters have to wear a red clown nose everywhere they go.
Groundhawg
(929 posts)stillcool
(32,767 posts)white men, and some black men. When you spout bull, make it a full load.
Groundhawg
(929 posts)stillcool
(32,767 posts)if you're going to regurgitate the official story you should include everyone that's being blamed.
Groundhawg
(929 posts)WhiskeyGrinder
(23,830 posts)KT2000
(20,832 posts)That is about the level of her comprehension in this video.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Im calling foul. If I were you, Id delete that post and never mention it again.
FBaggins
(27,698 posts)I cant think of a third possibility- because that was one big ad-hominem attacking membership in a group.
The glasses do look stupid
but each to her own where fashion (or lack thereof) is concerned.
But single white women were by far the largest block of Democratic voters. Attacking them does seem pretty stupid when so many other demographics have been shifting away from us.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)My experience of the video is of a constituent asking me to hear them. Clearly, this woman is in pain/anger/fear, too. Lets outline her argument (much more calmly) and refute/affirm honestly (without trivializing her looks).
FBaggins
(27,698 posts)She made no argument to outline. And she didnt ask you to hear her. She said she was done listening to you (assuming youre one of the groups she painted with her broad brush). That she had tried too long to educate you and now shes done (or better yet - you can kick rocks if youre part of some groups)
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)You may have heard that statement, but Im not sure its been understood. It is part of her argument.
Respectfully, it looks like our conversation is going nowhere. Lets try again some other time.
LisaL
(46,601 posts)She doesn't want people to be posting comments in there? I hardly think that is entering a space.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Last edited Tue Nov 12, 2024, 08:42 AM - Edit history (1)
of us white women.
FBaggins
(27,698 posts)You could consistently get 100% of the left-handed Irish trans female amputee vote
but it wouldnt be stupid to offend them because there just arent that many of them. It was stupid to offend white working-class men because there are so many of them and they used to be reliably democratic. Single white women are now the largest block of support we have.
There has to be a way to criticize actual Trump voters without pointing fingers at tens of millions of Harris voters.
IzzaNuDay
(601 posts)Just love it!
KT2000
(20,832 posts)is that this video is vapid in its content. My comment about the glasses is also vapid. She condescends to all white women because she has tried to educate us but we don't apparently "get it." She is through with all white women. I don't even know who she is but the video is offensive to a lot of people because it was a direct attack on a select groups of people. I know she is hurting about the election but we still must maintain our critical thinking.
If I as a white woman posted such nonsense about all black women, it would be taken down. Same goes if you replace any "category" of people, whether racial or religious group.
Polybius
(17,800 posts)She acts just like her too.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)KT2000
(20,832 posts)what I was saying - but not everyone.
brush
(57,471 posts)LizBeth
(10,821 posts)Even the ones supporting merely for a longer leash. In their stupidity along with every blue color and working class person who voted for Trump, or the Latino male that could not for for a woman, not simply a black woman, ... or the black man that could not vote for a woman.
The pain after the election, i saw many black women come forward and told us to all to allow them THEIR grief, as if it is not the grief of every woman that has lived their lives and even ruined their lives for those of all sisters... across the board. A woman, still has not been voted in as president.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)shown by 52% of white women
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)She did not lose because she is black. She lost because she is a woman.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Misogyny is too much alive, and well.
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)A man can win. A women obviously cannot. That is ALL women.
Lancero
(3,103 posts)Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)May I suggest one listen and welcome her frustration and pain? You dont have to agree or endorse but if youre a white woman (anyone, actually), listen to learn.
And yes, I think I understand how painful it is to hear. I want to be in relationship with others. When I hear, Respect the boundary it makes me grieve. I dont want to be deprived of this relationship.
So, today Im going hold my tongue. I may not be as smart as I think I am.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)and wave it all away as our "fragility?"
Good gawd. HOW DARE YOU?
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Its a discussion group. Thank you for your feedback. Your experience is important, but I dont think youre the only one who has any legitimacy in what could be an interesting discussion.
Feel free to insult me or make any other outburst as needed. It only adds to your credibility.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Im simply unwilling to enable your entitlement and privilege.
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)about a poster making divisive misogynistic attacks-- that lump the very women under attack into one group to blame... That is just rich, Duncan Grant. I hope many many many here see your post(s). Your mansplaining could be ignored, but calling the women of DU who disagree with being under attack and our very lives being devalued "privileged and entitled" CAN NOT.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Im sure youre the only voice that can be right about any of this. Im disappointed that your anger appears to be more important to you than anything else. Happy to discuss this with you again sometime, but right now? Nope.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)and have the nerve to claim WE-- those who are under attack--our very freedom and in a very real sense, our lives--by the RW of this country as "privileged and entitled." Enough so that you throw out the ad hominem to every woman on this thread and then falsely claim you were called names.
My gawd. What is wrong with YOU?
happy feet
(1,093 posts)Response to happy feet (Reply #140)
hlthe2b This message was self-deleted by its author.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Candace Owens doesnt believe there is racism and Phyllis Schafly enabled the RW to prevent the passage of ERA to nowso nothing under the sun surprises me anymore. There are always thise who will defend
Sad, though
Mossfern
(3,172 posts)No words.
Fullduplexxx
(8,254 posts)berkerly6240
(27 posts).
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Youre seeing what you want to see. Theres no mansplainin. You dont even know my gender. You know nothing about me, only what you project or assume via your belief system. Engage critical thinking skills in 3, 2, 1
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)The term white fragility was coined by the Seattle-based educator and author Robin DiAngelo.
She defines it as a state in which even a minimum amount of racial stress becomes intolerable, triggering a range of defensive moves. These moves include the outward display of emotions such as anger, fear and guilt, and behaviors such as argumentation, silence and leaving the stress-inducing situation.
It just occurred to me that some here must be unaware of White Fragility (2018). If so, it would explain a lot. If not, never mind. I have no interest in arguing about this important book. Especially, if you havent read it.
Marigold
(193 posts)I know I am probably going to get heat for this. I am ashamed that the majority of white women voted for Trump. I think I understand the pain this woman is sharing. African Americans time and time again have been betrayed by white people who claim to be in solidarity. Every time they put themselves out there and think that we have their backs, we let them down. Perhaps that is why you see such apathy sometimes in their voting patterns.
I think her anger is directed specifically to white women this time because we were all supposed to be voting for our rights. Women. Now our rights were being infringed upon too. African Americans have been suffering this for centuries. They thought they had a new ally in white women. They did, but not enough. It will be harder for them to trust us the next time if there is one.
I in no way mean to diminish the work and effort that many white women put in to this election. I did too, and am just as horrified. But I am also horrified that many white women who weren't uneducated MAGAT's voted for this abomination with excuses and justifications. Black women came out in droves expecting our support and we abandoned them.
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)Look, I know many white women did fight for harris, but many did not, and they were not the stereotype. If you get a tumor, you get it checked to make sure it does not become a cancer.
and if you think OI am leaving my fellow brown males out of this, read other stuff I wrote. I am actually at a point where I would rather NOT have many in my political foxhole, and if you think that does not make me cry, you are wrong. People sold their country out all because they have a promise they too can be rich, even though everybody knows that between Trump and Musk, we will be poor. if I seem to express this op, it is to show that damage is being done. Yes, many afams are MAD, and they have every right to be mad, and going "there there it was nto me4" is not helping. AGAIN, I am furious with many of my fellow brown males who should have known better, and when the op slam them, I understand why, and I do not get defensive or guilt trippy, nor do I think this post slams all brown males, the way some in this very op seem to say she is slamming all women.
If you are not willing to figure out how to remove this tumor, then spares us the virtue signaling.
I
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)Glass ceiling broke for women. White women voting for Trump either because of support of patriarchy or racism is a conversation to be had. Harris represents all women and I think that is what is being pointed out. It mattered to all us women looking for the glass ceiling to be broken and seeing once again, so much of our society is dictated by yes racism and misogyny. We are part of and live that misogyny. Our daughters are dying from it and losing their rights.
happy feet
(1,093 posts)Especially for listening through empathy and trying to understand vs reflexively taking it personal and being defensive (the victim)
GrapesOfWrath
(534 posts)Agree completely
OneGrassRoot
(23,423 posts)electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)52% is shamefully horrific!
Or 56%? Not being flippant just very tired now
GenThePerservering
(2,630 posts)in already winning - we're squabbling.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)No one who cared about decreasing the factional blaming and divisiveness would post this, see the righteous anger it incited, and not delete the thread. But not even a comment to try to explain their motive in posting it? I can only assume the intent was to divide.
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)It was posted so that we would stop acting like ostriches and figure out what happened, and that we could try to understand the anger that is out there, not shame it, but ask why it is there, and WHAT can we DO? Not fixing the problem will divide us more than ever, and I know we do not want to be in this same place come 2028, bemuse THAT will hurt all of us, especially women
LisaL
(46,601 posts)WTF does it matter anymore? And if we are going to be able to vote, posting such a divisive OP isn't going to accomplish your supposedly desired outcome.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)This is not what I would have expected. The misogynistic divisiveness and total disregard for the pain the women on DU--who are already shouldering far more than our share of the threats to come--are feeling is breathtaking. You owe the women of DU an apology and a deletion of this highly divisive thread
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)so that we can ignore what happened?
and to any who use this to hate all women, fuck off. That I officially will do to soften the blow, to officially tell those folks fuck off.
but black women have to deal with misogyny and yes, racism. To delete this thread is in effect to tell black women "I know you are mad, but our feeling matter more than yours, here's a blue bracelet. Please remember to vote for us again."
We owe all women, especially black women, a lot more than that.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)privileged," fragile, and a few other accusations I will let lie. Talk about piling on to the very people who have worked hardest together to avoid this debacle and among those most at threat.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Youre not even being honest now, are you?
Fragility. Defensiveness. Trivializing the video. Thats what I said about you, not the women of DU.
Is your subjective experience and anger the only thing that can be true in this discussion? I dont think so.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)You are just bullying now. Proud of yourself?
Lest anyone doubt what this poster is all about, please start with post # 63 where he attacked all the women on the thread.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)My recommendation for readers of this thread is to view the video with the intention to learn, not react. The video has legitimacy. Also of interest are the longer comments near the end of this thread. They are thoughtful responses worth your consideration.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)open to such nonsense and BROS commentary. It is NOT welcome by the women of DU who do not deserve such bullshit.. And I am not the only one that will call you on it. It is purely contemptible. if that is how you seek to get attention, well shame on you, but it is contemptible.
If you learn how to be respectful I am sure you will be welcome in such discussions here. But right now, I see dozens of women on this thread with similar disdain for such attitudes.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Feel free to call me anything you like.
I think its significant that a video by a black woman has provoked a defensive (fragile) response here. An hours long, rage-filled response, vilifying anyone who calmly asks:
Can we listen to and discuss this video calmly? Can we outline what shes saying for greater understanding? Is there anything I can learn? Can I trust that my emotions arent dominating the discussion? Do other black women feel this way, too? Do I have a responsibility to understand why that is?
There are other observations about that in this thread, too. So, youre certainty not correct in assuming you speak for any majority here. The conduct I see in this thread, trivializing a black woman, mocking her appearance, vilifying her POV disturbs me, greatly. Others may disagree, thats their prerogative but they should block me immediately. Anytime I get a whiff of this again, youll find me here.
I dont think Im off base, advocating for this black womans video or for the things shed like to acknowledge. If that makes me a misogynist, right-wing, manspainer so be it. I dont regret going to the mat with you in defense of this woman, her opinion and her video.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)That is the very definition of misogyny. NOPE. YOU DO NOT. Your contempt toward the women on this thread will not stand. You've used all the euphemisms, but we've got YOUR NUMBER.
To any new to this thread, this poster has felt compelled to accuse those of us who do not appreciate being blamed for the election of Trump and fighting back against the loss of our rights (and perhaps our very lives) as "emotional" "entitled" "privileged" and proceeded to mansplain to multiple women on this thread as to why they are not able to think for themselves. I haven't seen worse lately on some of the BROS sites and I am NOT going to ignore it here. There are at least two dozen women posting on this thread who won't either and many more who have not yet seen it who undoubtedly will be equally appalled. It is time-consuming to do and I can't blame anyone for not wanting to, but if you doubt it, please read the entire thread and note that the OP has changed (edited subject line) which started the entire divisive controversy.
There are multiple feminist groups here who started when we experienced a period where a vocal minority of men decided they would tell the women of DU "what's what" and belittled us constantly. While this was more than a decade and a half in the past, the longer-term posters from 2001 and later remember the unpleasantness. The original administrator, Skinner did work with us to try to corral this behavior. I can only hope it is not returning and spreading among even Democrats/Progressives with the blessing of those now in power. But, DU must remain a respected and respectful space--for all. I can only hope this poster decides to adopt that approach as well. But, as I am sure he will not, I will ignore his further comments- a feature I rarely use but is well-earned in this case.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Youre putting words into other peoples mouths.
Anyone who finds my advocacy for this woman and this video so offensive, should block me immediately. The conduct I see in this thread is divisive, it mocks a black women, trivializes her POV without engaging in any civil discussion of her experience, and is so unpleasant as to attempt to shut down all discussion. As if *she* is victimizing other women.
I could go on. Theres plenty here to think about, rather than lash out about but this thread is no longer an environment for self-reflection, empathy, the exchange of ideas or anything potentially positive. Again, Im happy to defend the video if for no other reason than its good to hear anothers experience.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)That is your go-to. And you are NOT even self-aware enough to recognize it. It is shameful on a liberal/progressive site--especially now. Women everywhere have lost their rights and humanity and in some cases, their very lives. But according to YOU, they are not even able to speak without YOUR permission and reframing to YOUR liking. Your comments are dripping with contempt for women and you seemingly can't (won't) even recognize it.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)If you feel the need to respond to me again, please see post #150 and #207. Rinse. Repeat. Thank you.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)The Guardian: Will the American project survive the anger of white men?
The Guardian - (archived: https://archive.ph/87407 ) Will the American project survive the anger of white men?
Carol Anderson
Tue 12 Nov 2024 06.00 EST
A friend recently asked: Do you think the United States will survive the anger of white men? As blunt as the question is, the core element is not so far-fetched. In fact, the majority of white men (and women) who voted in the presidential election in 2024 have rallied around a man who has called for the termination of the constitution, vowed to be a dictator, and threatened to deploy the US military against Americans. They support a man who is a convicted felon, an adjudicated rapist, a proven liar, who has been fined nearly half a billion dollars for fraud, who incited an insurrection that injured 140 police officers, and who mismanaged the Covid-19 pandemic causing hundreds of thousands to die needlessly.
The fact that Donald Trumps candidacy was even viable, given that horrific track record, was because of the support of white men. White men, whose anger was on full display at Madison Square Garden as they spewed racist, misogynistic venom. White men who attacked poll workers and also voters of Kamala Harris. White men who chafed at the thought that their wives and girlfriends would not vote for the man who thought it was a beautiful thing that reproductive rights had been destroyed. And, as the New York Times reported, the downwardly mobile, frustrated white men without a degree, [who] have been surpassed in income by college-educated women.
And lets be clear. Trump has laid out an agenda that will provide the wages of whiteness to his male supporters but very little else. The racist hate that undergirds Maga can only provide threadbare comfort. The planned enormous tariffs, the rollback on workplace, food and environmental safety regulations, the dismantling of labor protections, the planned deportation of tens of millions of undocumented people and naturalized citizens, the assault on reproductive rights and alignment with dictators all of this will destroy the economy, explode the deficit and leave the United States severely isolated and weakened.
This is nothing new. White male anger, especially at the nations inclusion of African Americans, has repeatedly privileged white supremacy over the viability of the United States. During the war of independence, when the nation was fighting to become the United States, South Carolinas government fumed at Congresss request to arm the enslaved and give them their freedom in exchange for fending off a British force that was more than 10 times the size of what those in Charleston could muster. Government officials flat out refused and barked that they werent sure that the US was a nation worth fighting for and would rather take their chances with the king of England. In short, enslaving those of African descent was infinitely more important than the United States.
/snip
Jeff (Gutenberg Parenthesis) Jarvis
@jeffjarvis.bsky.social
Will the American project survive the anger of white men?
November 12, 2024 at 6:46 AM
https://bsky.app/profile/jeffjarvis.bsky.social/post/3laqr3sxpjk2a
Hat/tip to DUer Dennis Donnovan--a real treasure on DU and anything BUT a misogynist. Thank you for being you, Dennis.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Pitiful. But now it is just pitiful and
And that is why relying on misogynistic comments does not serve you well. You might learn from those who are not, both men and women.
How do you like the Femisplaining? Back at ya
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Can't stand when a woman doesn't let you mansplain, can you?
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Do you never tire of such pitful tactics?
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)No. Your desire for attention is ridiculous now. Enjoy your life. But if I catch you repeating your indefensible behavior toward other DU women again, I will not hesitate to defend them as well.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Pithy, but yeah, rather true.
I'd probably add '(And, oh), Please remember to vote for us again.'
Since Black Women have been the biggest Democratic voters demographic. Then us big but still minority of white women.
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)bit we need to change the reality that brought it into being.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)No one here deserves the attacks that will come from those who are unaware of the original issue. Thank you.
kerry-is-my-prez
(9,197 posts)Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)They cannot hear you nor understand.
2 Meow Momma
(6,775 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)Texasgal
(17,154 posts)You thought posting an extremely divisive thread about what WOMEN did wrong with this election was the way to go?
REALLY?
Meowmee
(5,467 posts)And several others on ignore. I suggest you do the same- theres no point wasting time and energy on this. Ty to those who let me know with your responses to ignore you 😀
Quiet Em
(919 posts)I'm just going to assume every man I don't know is unsafe until proven otherwise. Sure, there are lots of ahole white women, but they don't post the same danger to me.
Nimble_Idea
(2,428 posts)coming to all 50 states. They really have no idea what about to drop on em. no fcuking(sp) clue.
appmanga
(919 posts)...but I understand because, in part, I share her disappointment and anger.
While polls say a majority of white women supported Trump, that doesn't mean (and I think it's unlikely) those white women are in this forum. And while, like her, I'm also done, I never had that much confidence this country would elect a woman, much less a black one. What galls me is the continued dismissal in so many quarters this simply couldn't be about misogyny, racism, and bigotry. There are people who continue to lament how this result simply doesn't make sense considering who her opponent was and how one of the most effective presidents in my lifetime had the incredible and consequential deeds of his administration totally ignored. At first, it was about his age, although Trump is just a couple years younger and no more lucid or coherent than Biden. He's certainly not as ethical. But once Biden dropped out, "inflation" and "the economy" became the proxies, and that has worked for the talking heads and punditry mostly because it's more palatable then the truth it seems like only black people don't mind publicly speaking.
I'm just as tired of hearing how Democrats don't know how to talk to the working class when Joe Biden walked a picket time with them. I'm tired of hearing about "elites", which is another euphemism for having critical thinking skills. And I'm tired of hearing that shit from Democrats. If being a Democrat meant being the same kind of person who could be swayed by someone's sexuality or the color of their skin, that I would have to embrace hatred and fear to win elections, I would have never joined this party.
It was a mistake to not answer the ads about transgender prisoners. Harris was going to have a tough climb, but those ads killed her chances because they hit hard and hit home with a lot of people, especially men, but also a lot of women, particularly single mothers who constantly question themselves as to how good a parent can they be when they can't truly be the man AND woman of the house. Not only did those ads flip votes, they got people to stay home.
So I understand what this woman is saying. I don't agree with her blanket indictment, but I know how she feels. I know how Eddie Glaude feels. And I say if you continue to misdiagnose the patient, which is this party, you won't cure him, and he will eventually die from the wrong prescription.
So like her, I'm out. Not because of frustration or anger at other Americans; I'm out because the damage that's going to be done will not be fixed in my lifetime, and I can't give anymore time trying to enlighten or protect those who just don't get it. We know the dangers to come, and people didn't buy what we were selling. They wanted "fuck around and find out" and now they have it. I wish them luck. I wish us all luck.
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)He was a man. The race along with 2016 was the first woman could not win. That is the loss. That is what is grieved by all of us collectively.
IzzaNuDay
(601 posts)Last edited Mon Nov 11, 2024, 07:19 PM - Edit history (1)
I can tell folks are up in their feelings about listening to this video. But its not me. This woman was in pain, and sharing her pain.
Have you even thought of all the cr@p black women have endured, been stereotyped, even by this dotard? For freaking centuries! They deal with stereotyping from the time they are conceived to the time they die. Think about it.
Black women went all out for Kamala because they didnt have short memories. Like the pandemic shutdown, separating families, etc. And more recently the Dobbs decision because its well documented that Black women typically have the worst outcomes for maternal care. They voted en masse because they saw the dotard as an existential threat to their lives
This all reminds me of a story from a consultant that Black archetype tends to embrace truth before peace conflict needs to be addressed, while the Anglo archetype embraces peace before truth - minimize conflict.
If this video makes you mad, then I dare you to forward this to any white woman or Arab American you know who voted for the dotard. Dont be shooting the messenger. And I dont care if you block me because youll be proving the point the consultant said.
And a postscript from same
https://youtube.com/shorts/FKki5Z75uKk?si=QtMvijHIiRScyGkr
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)I would post that postscript as it's own op
Zeitghost
(4,550 posts)Please remove it.
IzzaNuDay
(601 posts)You're proving the point from the consultant.
Zeitghost
(4,550 posts)n/t
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)While suggesting any one of us would be cowardly harshly addressing any Trump voter, let alone women. I mean there is tons of insult in that one.... That is no challenge like you think it might be. That tells me you really do not understand much of any of this besides telling women to sit down, shut up.
IzzaNuDay
(601 posts)It was not a question of STFU, it was listen to her pain, and learn from it.
As I said before in #125, the consultant said Blacks tend to embrace "truth before peace", vs the "peace before truth" acceptable in some white communities.
Regarding branding "all white women" -- Black women have been portrayed with stereotypes from all over the political spectrum: as gangsters (Clinton), welfare queens(Reagan), angry, criminals, (too many to mention) -- and we all know when one non-White person commits a heinous crime, it seems the media has no compunction showing the accused's face their entire population is branded with that stereotype.
So LizBeth, I guess it would have been just better if Black women just STFU and go away, eh?
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)" proven the consultant's point" because I disagree with you and your assumptions. I am well aware what the discussion is having been a part of it for at least three decades now. I addressed what YOU said. Nowhere in my comments will you seeing me disagree with the woman in the video.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)WHY? No woman on this site voted for anyone or fought for anyone than Kamala Harris and Walz. Unless they are trolling, no one.
What is to be gained by dividing? ]WHAT? A much as I feel for the pain of black women, who more than others as a demographic voted significantly more for Harris. But that video tells ALL OTHER WOMEN--including those who voted and fought for Harris that she does not want to hear from us. Because in the end, her video isn't about the pain we all share as Harris-supporting women, but the desire to divide based solely on racial lines. DIVIDE. Well, we have conquered OURSELVES by doing that.
Abolishinist
(1,961 posts)Last edited Sat Nov 16, 2024, 08:30 PM - Edit history (1)
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)though I did change the title to be softer, the truth is still there
kerry-is-my-prez
(9,197 posts)I dont blame black women for being angry but some are going over the top with hatred towards anyone white - even people who voted for Harris.
Heres something off the internet. I really worry that these statements do nothing but harm to unity:
Women of whiteness wonder why Black women dont trust or feel safe with them as a collective. But when we tell yall why, yall dont listen.
And when its time for yall to show up in substantive ways, yall cant seem to get it together.
And when its time to root down and do work in your own communities, yall would rather individualize and differentiate yourselves and then call yourselves doing the work.
And when Black women say we dont want any part of your performative nonsense, yall fold your arms and say youre gonna keep on keeping on.
And when the feces hit the fan and Black women are the only ones who consistently show up with any level of moral clarity once again, yall will start the cycle of Im sorry and this white woman and empty gestures all over again.
The answer is right in front of you.
We dont trust yall because yall aint trustworthy. We dont have solidarity because yall aint solid.
We cant even get past this recycled conversation from eight years ago because yall didnt learn and wont listen.
How are yall different than the 52% when you act just like them? Voting for a democrat dont make your racism any less violent. Thats a hard truth but Im trading in hard truths today.
hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)reactions of most of the women on this thread--which in some cases was met by some really disgusting misogyny.
kerry-is-my-prez
(9,197 posts)Seem to feel this way about white female Harris supporters who were willing to risk a lot to show their support to black women. They meant well - although if they were specifically doing that to show their support for black women, they should have consulted with some black women. I dont know, maybe they did. Im on a site for female voters for Harris and there were black women on there that said go ahead - get the bracelets. Personally, I wouldnt wear one if its going to offend someone (unless its a Trump supporter or Republican). I wanted to figure out something to wear to show my resistance and to say eff you to people in my red area. I doubt anyone would know about these blue bracelets in SW Florida anyways. Im considering wearing a Harris button. I need to do something against those bastards for my own mental health. Women wore red lipstick WW2 to say they were a member of the resistance.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Last edited Tue Nov 12, 2024, 09:13 PM - Edit history (1)
generalized way. Is it comfortable to be on the receiving end. No. But so be it.
Blue_Tires
(55,778 posts)Polybius
(17,800 posts)She doesn't give a shit about the white women who voted for Harris. She's basically telling them to go away.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Pain can lash out all over.
It's uncomfortable to be on the receiveing end.
I'm almost sure; excepting for Black Women Socially Conservative on Choice that they may have expected more white women to have voted for Kamala because of the Choice issue!
In time she might be open again to converse w white women. Or not.
Polybius
(17,800 posts)But right now she's saying a big FU to white women who are messaging her saying that they voted for Harris. They aren't to blame, they did their part.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)LizBeth
(10,821 posts)devastation of the results of this election and the rejection of another outstanding successful competitant woman being discarded by society? Aren't we all equally sick to our stomach? I watched the video the first day it came out. I heard her, .... but in my heart and not in the posts respectfully, Harris was our hope too.
I mean, this woman doesnt have to ever want to talk to a white person, I get that and I may be as mad if I were black. Thankfully I have a blast with black community and they like to play with me and let me play. She gets to feel what she does. I don't talk to rwers. Nope. The only one is I still talk to father, but not a single other one. I dont want to hear them. So I can even respect that part of her video.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Hillary, then Kamala were my hopes, too.
And she as a Black Person/Woman has the additionnal scourge of racism to deal with. Bc of that she will more likely get inferior health care, than white women whose needs aren't always understood, or met either by white male health professionals.
We (assuming you are white, and not another POC woman) do not.
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)Care than men in many ways, all women. It is a woman issue. Black women get even worse care. Native women get the worst care. Yes you are right. But ALL women get less care than men
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)hlthe2b
(106,330 posts)that? ALL women are going to suffer.
soandso
(1,155 posts)Using the election as a safe pretext to express her hate for white women. If it was really about the election she'd attack Republicans.
No individual Democratic white woman has any control over how the country votes, period. The video is bullshit and people shouldn't take the bait.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)Are you willing to defend white supremacy here, in front of everyone? I took a screenshot, so dont delete the post.
(I'm so looking forward to this. Until tomorrow, expert on passive aggressive racist tirades
)
soandso
(1,155 posts)Maybe you would like to explain how white Democratic women are responsible for how the country voted, especially Republicans. But maybe not and you have a different intent, eh? If that Youtube were a post it would be recognized for the trolling it is and you're defending it. Curious.
In addition to your demonstrated misogyny on this thread, you're threatening me? Do screen shot away and keep up your mansplaining. It's not like you're transparent or anything, lol.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)governmental, corporate, smaller businesses, educational, and individual people who act on it, and benefit from it ie white people. Majority against minority.
So a Black person isn't a racist bc they're not part of the structure, but could be a individually a bigot.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)You said, the video in the OP, TabithaSpeaksPolitics, is a passive aggressive racist tirade. Take it up with Tabitha; post that remark in her comments.
Dear White Women, This White Woman Gets It
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)When they asked white women not to? Either you think so little of the women in du to think any of us would be so uncaring or you are simply taunting or worse.
Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)one should feel no shame or trepidation in saying it to her face (so to speak). Thats why.
LizBeth
(10,821 posts)DU and your post was truly only about taunting or worse.
FBaggins
(27,698 posts)That even thinking its possible is white supremacy.
WhiskeyGrinder
(23,830 posts)Because a lot of them get up in their feelings because they're not automatically seen as an ally by marginalized people. It's happening right here in this thread. There's a lot more work to be done besides electoral politics and those doing the work are tired of people acting like one (1) vote every four (4) years makes them a trusted ally in the fight. Others decide whether you're an ally. You don't get to decide for yourself.
notroot
(267 posts)Zeitghost
(4,550 posts)Last edited Tue Nov 12, 2024, 12:15 AM - Edit history (1)
"We're done with you".
Racist garbage is all this is.
The outright anti-Hispanic racism here on DU is getting out of control.
nini
(16,713 posts)Shes venting and calling out lip service from people supposedly being Allies then voting against everyones best interests. If you did not vote for trump youre not the problem but are still acting like a victim if her words stung you for whatever reason. Stop and think for a minute how frustrated she is to say what she did and try to understand before reacting. Were all frustrated. I know the type she is referring to and I bet most of us do. They dont realize their own privilege and when it comes down to it will always put themselves first.
DonCoquixote
(13,710 posts)Look, I am hispanic, and I have gotten into fights with my family, to be point where I became an island. I have posted soem hatred against Latinos who voted for trump, as my journal will show. But the fact is, I love my fellow hispanics enough to tell them if they let themselves take the meds the GOP is offering, it will kill them.
Zeitghost
(4,550 posts)Posts that support statements like the one I quoted from the OP.
LauraInLA
(1,304 posts)Duncan Grant
(8,549 posts)In response to the OP, a black woman was mocked for her appearance and trivialized for her POV. Also of interest, someone in this thread spent hours in a rage-filled repudiation of the black woman in the video, while insisting she speaks for all women of DU.
Has anyone here attended anti-racism workshops or DEI training? Fragility is not a new concept. Its been around since 2018 (see: Robin DiAngelo, White Fragility.) Theres no reason why we cant have civil discussion about the OP.
For anyone who might like additional context regarding white fragility:
The term white fragility was coined by the Seattle-based educator and author Robin DiAngelo.
She defines it as a state in which even a minimum amount of racial stress becomes intolerable, triggering a range of defensive moves. These moves include the outward display of emotions such as anger, fear and guilt, and behaviors such as argumentation, silence and leaving the stress-inducing situation.
Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)Tons of training to bring about change. Instructors didnt like to do diversity training because there was so much pushback. The issue was they werent the problem so why discuss it. Nothing has changed and the teachers had to soften it or discontinue it because they had to eat.
IzzaNuDay
(601 posts)Because it is a space for African Americans to discuss topics. I've been on DU off and on since 2001.This is not the first, nor it will be the last time someone will discuss what is going on in another General Discussion thread.
What was the problem with me starting the topic there?
LauraInLA
(1,304 posts)IzzaNuDay
(601 posts)As I mentioned before, I was not the first nor last to do this.
LauraInLA
(1,304 posts)FHRRK
(968 posts)Want to know what black people could do to have a huge impact? Tell your damn kids to refuse to sign athletic scholorships to Racist states.
FUCK ALABAMA
FUCK CLEMSON
FUCK FLORIDA
FUCK FLORIDA STATE
FUCK EVERY SEC TEAM
FUCK OHIO STATE
FUCK EVERY SOLID RED STATE and refuse to let them use black atheletes from Blue States.
Same thing goes for anyone with a skill that can be used in other States. TAKE IT TO THE BLUE STATES.
So prior to responding with put up or shut up. I left AZ in the 80s a solid red state, to go to California. Due to a professor setting me up via a recommendation locally, I took a job making 10% less in CA. (and had a higher cost of living) but ended up much better off by doing the right thing.
At the time, I was six foot one, 145 pounds, but pushed through and doing fine/great now. I have gotten jack shit from the Govt my entire life. Stimmy checks, made too much, EV credits, made too much, on and on.
So after 45 years of working, getting no hand outs from the Gov. (Something focused at just people like me) There ain't no way that she has any right to say White Dem Woman need to STFU, which means she is saying White Dem Males need to SFTU.
it is her that really need to consider her post.
Response to DonCoquixote (Original post)
Post removed
coffeenap
(3,210 posts)like unenlightened men do when we talk about SA and the lived trauma-informed experience of virtually all women. They will become incensed, feel judged and insulted, and say, "but not all men." And of course, it's not all men, but we can't tell which ones, so we go through life in a defensive mode. This is how I hear the woman speaking. Just as we demand men change other men, she is demanding we change our culture too. Imagine her pain, centuries long, and let's give our feeling of being personally attacked a rest for a minute
LisaL
(46,601 posts)Even if she knows which ones, since women posting on her youtube about blue ribbons didn't vote for Trump. But they are guilty too, as far as she is concerned
This kind of logic doesn't help anybody as far as I am concerned.
coffeenap
(3,210 posts)Keepthesoulalive
(575 posts)That why we need safe spaces to tell our truth. When an opinion is expressed that the larger community cant understand it becomes personal and emotions derail the discussion. They have not endured the constant recalibration black people have to do just to go to the store, yes I would like a bag. Instead of listening they start personalizing instead of empathizing. Sorry a little Jessie Jackson. America is what she is and we had better put our shields back up.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)people in a new, or recently new environment; new to an area, you a store, to a job etc. How should I act, or respond.
usedtobedemgurl
(1,423 posts)She does not hear from me so I shall not outreach to her. I am white and female. I feel as much as racism was a component of this election, misogyny was as well. I feel marginalized and helpless. More so, because of my health. If I protest and am arrested, that may be the end of me.
I am not racist. I am not selfish. If she is too blind to see white democratic women were fighting for her, she is the one who needs to open her ears and listen. Or, better yet, open her mind and think.
I am not selfish. I am too old to have kids any more, but I voted for others to have the right to choose. I am white, but I voted that others may be lifted up. I am ok, for now, financially, but U voted for others to perhaps have a better financial life. (Abortion is an economic issue, so that crosses over to this as well, in addition to a living wage, etc).
If she is so filled with hate, I will let her go it alone. Here is one white lady, who she does not care, who voted for her future to be brighter. When I was a teen, in Canada, I got involved with the ANC. They flew me to Quebec for a conference. I back up the talk that I say, with actions. I will not abandon others who see my friendship and know we are stronger when we have bigger numbers.
I understand her sadness and disappointment. I am sad and disappointed. But I am not attacking people who ate doing no wrong. Who maybe who do not know what to do, so they desperately turn to a bracelet. Instead of looking at their actions, maybe she should be looking at their intentions. Is it to support you or oppress you? Maybe if it is the former, don't lash out. Don't attack those who have goid intentions and want to help. We are not the racists. We do not want to deport you or keep you a second class citizen. I get that if you lash out at the other folks, they could hunt you down and hurt, rape and/or kill you, but attacking your allies is not the answer.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)Instead of looking at their actions, maybe she should be looking at their intentions.".
This first comment makes sense for some, I'm sure.
As for your second ...depending on the kinds of interactions she's had w white women through her life (not on line), add in the devasting result of drumphf winning - her pain is perhaps making her overgeneralize currently. That's what terrible emotional pain can do. She may change later.
rampartd
(316 posts)we need to coalesce and widen our tent, not the divisiveness inspired by the thing.,
Crunchy Frog
(26,974 posts)Is she aware that the comment section of YouTube is a public space? Is she aware that Trump made inroads among blacks, particularly black men? Is she aware of the massive swing among Latinos towards Trump, or that Trump lost ground among whites?
As a white woman, what exactly is it that she expects me to "do"?
And I don't even know what the blue bracelets are that she's talking about.
Things will certainly go much better for all of us with this kind of divisiveness.
electric_blue68
(17,978 posts)likesmountains 52
(4,175 posts)I am a white woman who did everything in my power to get Kamala elected . We obviously need to do better next time, but I'm not going to feel bad about what I wear, or what I did.