Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

wiseowljedi

(73 posts)
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:05 AM Monday

Democrats need to learn how to do the Haka

If you have not seen the video yet you need to see it:

Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke a member of New Zealand's Parliament responds to a proposed bill to change an 1840 treaty with the country's indigenous tribe the Maori.
There are different ways to deal with oppression and injustice. You can be polite and civilized or you can show your anger and your outrage.
New Zealand has Clarke and we have Jasmine Crockett. We need more young Democrats to get vocal about fighting for democracy and the values that our country must defend. This takes a lot of courage and we can only pray they find it!

23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Democrats need to learn how to do the Haka (Original Post) wiseowljedi Monday OP
Haven't seen the video but totally agree! LearnedHand Monday #1
Just go to YouTube or TikTok and search haka New Zealand wiseowljedi Monday #7
I agree it would be awesome BUT, cultural appropriation concerns will scuttle that idea...... nt kelly1mm Monday #2
We know how to share. cbabe Monday #3
LOL, yep DeepWinter Monday #5
Took the words right out of my mouth BannonsLiver Monday #6
HAH! OldBaldy1701E Monday #9
Here's the thing... meadowlander Monday #13
I was actually referring to here in the US. OldBaldy1701E Monday #15
🌺. Mahalo nui loa for all this information. Hele on. Hekate Monday #21
Did you ever see Lilo & Stich and all the little girls learning hula? Kick out the redhead? Hekate Monday #12
my favorite disney movie. mopinko Monday #16
Disney really pleased me with their character portrayals in Lilo&Stich and Moana ... Hekate Monday #17
yeah. it's also their last hand painted movie. it's so gorgeous. mopinko Monday #20
Yes, I thought so too. Hekate Monday #22
Haka Stuns New Zealand Parliament: Watch Youngest MP Rip Bill On Cam cbabe Monday #4
There are 1 million Maori's in NZ 20%of the total population. wiseowljedi Monday #8
Wow i need a cigarette after that LearnedHand Monday #14
🌺 You go, girl! 🌺 Hekate Monday #18
Indeed. OldBaldy1701E Monday #10
For what? WhiskeyGrinder Monday #11
I too am definitely missing the imperative and possibly the whole point. TheKentuckian Monday #19
Um...no. Iggo Monday #23

LearnedHand

(4,032 posts)
1. Haven't seen the video but totally agree!
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:41 AM
Monday

The haka is a very powerful statement. Do you have a link to that video?

DeepWinter

(465 posts)
5. LOL, yep
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 11:51 AM
Monday

I am so done with cultural appropriation. The history of humanity is trade. Every culture have been trading and appropriating since day 1. Food, spices, tools, raw materials, ideas, art. Welcome to history.

BannonsLiver

(17,970 posts)
6. Took the words right out of my mouth
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 12:03 PM
Monday

Days and weeks of debate about how awful and over privileged it was and how everyone involved should be deeply ashamed.

OldBaldy1701E

(6,338 posts)
9. HAH!
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 02:29 PM
Monday

I once watched someone rail on and on about cultural appropriation... while wearing jeans and sneakers.

Isn't it wild that it only seems to work one way?

The whole point of the 'Great Melting Pot' was the mixing of culture and society. I guess we have decided to ignore that concept these days.

meadowlander

(4,717 posts)
13. Here's the thing...
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 02:45 PM
Monday

White European settlers came to New Zealand, violated the Treaty that allowed them to come there, stole land, killed people, kidnapped kids, forced them to go to schools where they were beaten for speaking te reo and doing the haka, told them for generations that their culture was inferior and forced them to obey "superior" Western cultural norms.

It's only in the past thirty years or so that efforts have been made to save te reo Maori as a language and to recognise the contributions of Maori indigenous knowledge and values to New Zealand society.

So sorry but it's ridiculous to compare white people shaking their hands and asses and repeating words that "sound cool" when a rugby team does it with no concept of what those words actually mean or the cultural context they come from to Maori kids wearing jeans. They didn't sign up for a "Melting Pot" and even today they have barely recovered from one.

The Treaty Bill being proposed by ACT would fundamentally rewrite the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi. Basically it's saying "the British Crown and the Maori chiefs signed an agreement 180 years ago allowing British people to settle legally in New Zealand on the basis that Maori chiefs retained kawanatanga, or governship of their own people and the rights to administer their own "treasures" including their lands, fishing rights, their native language, cultural heritage, etc."

Now ACT wants to rewrite that completely to say the principles of the Treaty are that all people have equal rights under the law when that is explicitly not what the Treaty says. It says that the British Crown will protect Maori and empower them to look after their own interests. ACT have decided that since they are part of a coalition government currently in power that they can rewrite that Treaty unilaterally. But they are not a party to the Treaty. The British Crown is. And their Bill has less than 20% popular support which is why Te Pati Maori tore a draft of it up - to say this is nonsense that you have no right to introduce into Parliament.

That's the cultural context in which they are shouting "ka mate, ka mate" - it is death to our culture and to our rights to agree to this Bill.

So I'll take a generous interpretation of the OP's proposal - that we need more of people standing up and getting in the face of bullshit right-wing proposals but not literally that they do the haka stripped of all of the cultural context that makes it a meaningful gesture in the first place.

"Let's all be a melting pot" is literally the opposite of what they are trying to say which is "you don't get to assimilate us on your terms."

OldBaldy1701E

(6,338 posts)
15. I was actually referring to here in the US.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 06:54 PM
Monday

The comment I was responding to did not mention a specific area, just that the concept of cultural appropriation would interfere with doing anything like this here in the US. I was also talking about events that were here in the US. The person I was referring to was here in the US.

I am well aware of why the. Maori did what they did. I support it. I am glad they did it. I hope that there will be something like it done here, but that is wishful thinking.

Hekate

(94,623 posts)
12. Did you ever see Lilo & Stich and all the little girls learning hula? Kick out the redhead?
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 02:39 PM
Monday

Don’t think so….

Hekate

(94,623 posts)
17. Disney really pleased me with their character portrayals in Lilo&Stich and Moana ...
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:19 PM
Monday

I really like these two stories.

mopinko

(71,798 posts)
20. yeah. it's also their last hand painted movie. it's so gorgeous.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:27 PM
Monday

havent seen the other. came out about the time my kids were too big for disney.
lilo was very not a princess. they did a good job of showing hawaiian culture w/o reducing it to kitch, but also the struggle to keep it.

cbabe

(4,155 posts)
4. Haka Stuns New Zealand Parliament: Watch Youngest MP Rip Bill On Cam
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 11:40 AM
Monday

Bill will destroy Māori constitutional rights as New Zealand turns hard right.

https://m.

OldBaldy1701E

(6,338 posts)
10. Indeed.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 02:31 PM
Monday

Many years ago, I was privileged to film the National Hula Competition in Orlando. I enjoyed it so much. (I also played music there as well.)

I would love to see this happen. Like, every time those rethugs start in with their 'Project', a major Haka should immediately break out.

I would be grabbing my drum, that is for sure!

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Democrats need to learn h...