Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

surfered

(4,520 posts)
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 09:59 PM Nov 18

Marjorie Taylor Greene demands America gets a divorce.

An outraged Greene (R-GA) on Monday urged a national split from Democratic states whose lawmakers, and voters, have expressed criticism of President-elect Donald Trump.

One minor problem Ms Greene fails to understand is that the blue states financially support the red states. Absent some sort of alimony, they’ll be impoverished and without Social Security or Medicare.

Not sure she’s thought this through.

64 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Marjorie Taylor Greene demands America gets a divorce. (Original Post) surfered Nov 18 OP
"not sure she's thought this through" mnmoderatedem Nov 18 #1
There's only 18 blue states. Which has all the revenue and success. jimfields33 Nov 18 #17
Your math is wrong Katcat Nov 19 #33
Thank you! I fixed and appreciate it. jimfields33 Nov 19 #36
Plus Guam, PR and DC. Oopsie Daisy Nov 19 #52
Pretty sure that's a capability she just doesn't have. dchill Nov 19 #35
Can she even think??? nt NEOH Nov 19 #64
Allow me to posit that the Honorable Marge would suggest BOSSHOG Nov 18 #2
Just because she had adulterous tantric sex with multiple people leading to divorce... TheBlackAdder Nov 18 #28
...she has divorce on the brain? Naw. That would require a brain. allegorical oracle Nov 19 #61
She's the Capitol Hill bomber peregrinus Nov 18 #3
Oh, I am too obamanut2012 Nov 19 #57
This isn't the first time MTG has said this. keep_left Nov 18 #4
The thing is, it's far better to get a divorce... regnaD kciN Nov 18 #14
Please proceed nini Nov 18 #5
The grand divorce may be inevitable. Intractable Nov 18 #7
There's no geographical dividing line. yardwork Nov 18 #12
I'm fond of saying that the Mason-Dixon line now runs through all cities, towns, even houses. Intractable Nov 18 #15
You & others need to acquaint yourselves with what happened when India split with Pakistan Hekate Nov 19 #32
Seems to me the Indians and Pakistanis are still at each others throats whenever they get the chance. Intractable Nov 19 #43
They lived together on the Indian subcontinent for centuries, not always well, but even so Hekate Nov 19 #47
Stop telling me what I should do. It is quite rude. Intractable Nov 19 #49
Right. I don't think this works in about any permutation TheKentuckian Nov 18 #24
I'd move to a blue state Katcat Nov 19 #34
Again you strike in with common sense yardwork jfz9580m Nov 19 #38
Excellent Hekate Nov 19 #48
I would very much like to not be a part of their hate. usedtobedemgurl Nov 19 #60
"Marjorie Taylor Greene demands America gets a divorce." J_William_Ryan Nov 18 #6
OMG.. Tribetime Nov 18 #8
Perhaps worth considering if we have a way to guarantee those red states won't invade, loot & pillage the blue states 0rganism Nov 18 #9
There's a silly movie called "Bushwick" that deals with this. Intractable Nov 18 #16
Bye. Lilithschyld Nov 18 #10
Blow it out your ass, Marjo. Talitha Nov 18 #11
I'm fine with that...! regnaD kciN Nov 18 #13
As a Californian, I would be happy Abolishinist Nov 18 #20
Not to be confused with the New California Republic sakabatou Nov 18 #23
We are trying to avoid the nuclear war that set the context for the NCR. N/t SomewhereInTheMiddle Nov 19 #46
I know. sakabatou Nov 19 #62
Is MTG (GEICO Cavewoman) EVEN Capable of Cognitive Thought? MrWowWow Nov 18 #18
Sounds good to me, she knows what happens when we are "irretrievably broken". Abolishinist Nov 18 #19
And don't forget all the US Government property in those red states...courthouses... brush Nov 18 #21
Didn't she take an oath to protect and preserve the country? sakabatou Nov 18 #22
A bit of wiggle room, the oath was in plain English. Abolishinist Nov 18 #27
Madge is not known for keeping her obligations. Eyeball_Kid Nov 18 #29
Why? Did America have an affair with its gym coach? Efilroft Sul Nov 18 #25
Madge is Putin's wet dream. n/t Eyeball_Kid Nov 18 #26
She sometimes looks like the lights are on, but there's never anybody home struggle4progress Nov 18 #30
Breaking up the US is one of Putin's goals. Trust_Reality Nov 19 #31
Imagine the cost increases as well to the red states for goods and food that use the California ports. cstanleytech Nov 19 #37
I don't care... kevinore Nov 19 #39
The Greene Thing Is a GD Stupid MF.. Put her charge Cha Nov 19 #40
Where do I sign? ribrepin Nov 19 #41
Also there aren't any pure red or blue states. duncang Nov 19 #42
You want to go down that route MTG, you bastard? tornado34jh Nov 19 #44
That means we would have a hard border... roamer65 Nov 19 #45
honestly RJ_MacReady Nov 19 #50
So, call her bluff. Let constituents of each "Red State"... SKKY Nov 19 #51
Oh yes, yes please Afrocat Nov 19 #53
Sounds good to me, Marge! Oopsie Daisy Nov 19 #54
I have an idea. The Madcap Nov 19 #55
Looks like somebody isn't getting enough attention. GoCubsGo Nov 19 #56
She's no brain scientist. Swede Nov 19 #58
She wants us to do what the Red State Governors due to Blue state cities. Jit423 Nov 19 #59
I'd rather just divorce her from Congress. Nothing of value would be lost there. Initech Nov 19 #63
 

jimfields33

(19,382 posts)
17. There's only 18 blue states. Which has all the revenue and success.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:46 PM
Nov 18

Last edited Tue Nov 19, 2024, 12:35 AM - Edit history (1)

I guess the other 32 states will just have to suffer under her deluded mind.

BOSSHOG

(40,786 posts)
2. Allow me to posit that the Honorable Marge would suggest
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:06 PM
Nov 18

That your post is an in-dick-table offense.

keep_left

(2,628 posts)
4. This isn't the first time MTG has said this.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:17 PM
Nov 18

She also loves eliminationist rhetoric, like "we need a second Civil War". She's a real piece of work...and a real piece of shit!

regnaD kciN

(26,696 posts)
14. The thing is, it's far better to get a divorce...
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:38 PM
Nov 18

...than to have to live the rest of your life in the dungeon as your spouse's prisoner. Which is what I'm pretty sure TSF wants.

Intractable

(782 posts)
7. The grand divorce may be inevitable.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:26 PM
Nov 18

Very complicate to pull off, but we may be left with no choice.

A house divided cannot stand. -- Lincoln

Only a fool fights in a burning house. -- Kang, Star Trek, The Day of the Dove

We're on fire. -- Me

The time has come, the wise one said, when we must all decide.
We cannot carry on this way, and so we must divide.
The road before us goes both way, so which one do you choose.
But all will not go well if you refuse. -- The Alan Parsons Project, Upper Me

yardwork

(65,120 posts)
12. There's no geographical dividing line.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:35 PM
Nov 18

Many states aren't really red or blue, they're a mixed bag. There's no state or region of the country where there's unanimous agreement that they're all Republican or all Democratic.

The Democrats in Alabama are just as important as the ones in Massachusetts. There are just fewer of them. Likewise, Republicans in Massachusetts are just as bad as the ones in Alabama; they're just outnumbered.

Intractable

(782 posts)
15. I'm fond of saying that the Mason-Dixon line now runs through all cities, towns, even houses.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:39 PM
Nov 18

Like everyone else, I have no idea how this will work out. I just know a lot of people are going to suffer until we discover the end game.

Hekate

(95,873 posts)
32. You & others need to acquaint yourselves with what happened when India split with Pakistan
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 12:26 AM
Nov 19

It was terrible. Muslim Indians were driven from places they had lived for centuries, neighbor murdered neighbor, people lost everything in the move.

I am against secession or any other split-up of the USA. It’s a fantasy, and trying to make it reality would lead to the bloodbath Steve Bannon lusts for.

Intractable

(782 posts)
43. Seems to me the Indians and Pakistanis are still at each others throats whenever they get the chance.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 02:12 AM
Nov 19

You know, religion? It's the great unifier. You got Hindus and Muslims.

So, can't live with them, can't live without them?

Of course, it would be for the best if the country stays unified. What if the bloodbath occurs anyway?

Hekate

(95,873 posts)
47. They lived together on the Indian subcontinent for centuries, not always well, but even so
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 03:03 AM
Nov 19

As I said, you should acquaint yourself with even a little of the history of the separation in the 20th century. You can take it from there.

Religion? What are we to do with Evangelicals and White Christian nationalists? Trad Catholics?

The people who really crave to have the US come apart are: Putin, White Christian Nationalists, Steve Bannon (a Leninist) , Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy (egomaniacs) . Bannon and his cohort want to burn the country down, burn down the federal government, and dance in the rubble.

You are in bad company.





Intractable

(782 posts)
49. Stop telling me what I should do. It is quite rude.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 05:53 AM
Nov 19

I didn't say I wanted it to come apart. I suggested it may be inevitable.

> You are in bad company.

Your condescension notwithstanding, I am in your company. But now, no more.

 

TheKentuckian

(26,314 posts)
24. Right. I don't think this works in about any permutation
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 11:32 PM
Nov 18

and seems like a receipe for at least two civil wars rather than just one.

Neither the tens of millions of Republicans in California nor the tens of millions of Democrats in Texas are too likely to go quietly into the night.

We also have way too many nukes, we have a responsibility to humanity to defeat the nutjobs in some fashion that doesn't increase chaos to the point that some portion of that arsenal gets out of pocket.

jfz9580m

(15,584 posts)
38. Again you strike in with common sense yardwork
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 12:48 AM
Nov 19

Thanks !

Greene is an idiot. So is Balaji Srinivasan who wants the same “divorce” and is a California tech bro of the Vivek Ramaswamy type shilling some sort of fake school (these guys do fit a sort of type):

https://www.wired.com/story/network-school-balaji-srinivasan/

(As an aside I find these tech bro-creeps fascinating. Their worldviews are so lousy and so many of them want to “rule the world”. We have to sound the alarm about these creeps especially with Musk and Ramaswamy etc out to destroy the govt now. Indeed arguably red parts of blue ca are cradles for some of the worst of these ideas in the last few decades. I posted about that here ( the links in the post not my meandering ) and DUer Hekate said it is worthwhile to keep spreading the word :
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=19736813).

People want to reduce life to such reductive patterns. It is not true of course that there are no patterns or that data doesn’t tell you stuff.

That argument reminds me of the guy (and sorry but it’s usually a guy ) who says all nutrition science is bullshit using the anecdote that his grandfather ate steak everyday, drank a six pack, never exercised and lived to be a 100.

Sure, but most people who live like that will lead significantly shorter and unhealthier lives than those who do take care of their health.

But it is similarly reductive to attach salience to a few broad patterns here and there and to eschew more complete models that are rigorous and tested.

Hard to do in discussions as complex as ones related to the state of our connected world, its communication systems, technology’s effects and so on :-/.

But these ideas about the blue-red divorce are as common with the jerks of Si Valley as they are on more legitimately frustrated parts of the left. The former arguments make me wary. The latter are frustration I understand.

The former are as simplistic and crass as: wealth good, me wealthy, me good and genius, all else unfit and stupid, me make the world and they should all die . I have a hope that the public at large will first weary of these tech bros and take steps to reign in their shitty tools where they are quite legitimately destructive to democracy and the planet as a whole.

usedtobedemgurl

(1,464 posts)
60. I would very much like to not be a part of their hate.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 08:05 AM
Nov 19

I have suggested, here, we may end up at that crossroads. Here is why I think it will never work. I believe the bloodlust in their hearts is so much they will come into the new territory and try to slaughter us all. It would be too much for them to resist. I know we would have military and guns, but it would still be nasty.

J_William_Ryan

(2,374 posts)
6. "Marjorie Taylor Greene demands America gets a divorce."
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:22 PM
Nov 18

Conservatives hate America.

They want to see it destroyed.

0rganism

(24,846 posts)
9. Perhaps worth considering if we have a way to guarantee those red states won't invade, loot & pillage the blue states
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:29 PM
Nov 18

Also, there's the question of tippy purple places like Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania.

And the matter of a bunch of federal resources which would need to be redistributed.

All of which leads me to believe neither she nor those people she's talking to have really thought this through, if they're even capable of thinking at all.

Intractable

(782 posts)
16. There's a silly movie called "Bushwick" that deals with this.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:45 PM
Nov 18

I saw it on Amazon years ago. It's currently only on Apple TV.

Essentially, Kentucky invades New York City because they think they can conquer New York because its citizens have very few guns.

Well, they were wrong. Apparently everyone in NY (including the Rabbis) are packing.

As silly as it is, they got the great Dave Bautista to star in it.

regnaD kciN

(26,696 posts)
13. I'm fine with that...!
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:36 PM
Nov 18

We up here in Washington would be delighted to join with our fellows in Oregon to form the Republic of Cascadia. The first action of which should be to create a mutual support treaty with the California Republic.

MrWowWow

(431 posts)
18. Is MTG (GEICO Cavewoman) EVEN Capable of Cognitive Thought?
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:47 PM
Nov 18

Last edited Mon Nov 18, 2024, 11:20 PM - Edit history (1)

Or is she just a reichwing meat puppet?

Abolishinist

(2,135 posts)
19. Sounds good to me, she knows what happens when we are "irretrievably broken".
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 10:55 PM
Nov 18

Greene married Perry Greene in 1995 while in college. They have three children. Perry Greene announced in September 2022 that he was filing for divorce and that their marriage was "irretrievably broken". On December 22, 2022, the divorce was finalized.

Her now ex-husband pulled the trigger on the marriage after media reports revealed that the neophyte politician had repeatedly cheated with other men, including polyamorous tantric sex guru Craig Ivey and the manager of the local gym she frequented.

brush

(58,598 posts)
21. And don't forget all the US Government property in those red states...courthouses...
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 11:06 PM
Nov 18

post offices, military bases etc that they don't just get to keep for free.

Just cause she just got divorced recently (her infidelity), it's on this silly woman's mind. I wouldn't mind never hearing from her again though.

Eyeball_Kid

(7,594 posts)
29. Madge is not known for keeping her obligations.
Mon Nov 18, 2024, 11:55 PM
Nov 18

She's made a career of violating her various "oaths". It's who she is. She hasn't been long in Trump's inner circle because she hasn't been killing pets or raping kids. If you want to be the diamond in Donny's eye, you've got to compete with his anti-social legacy. The worse you are, the higher you rate with Donny.

So what will happen if Gaetz and Noem and the rapist from Fox (Hegseth?) all somehow get legitimately rejected? What's Trump's plan "B"? And who will be the "hard act to follow" the first reject? Will Trump go legit with other picks? And if so, who on earth will accept his nomination?

Trust_Reality

(1,949 posts)
31. Breaking up the US is one of Putin's goals.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 12:25 AM
Nov 19

She sure looks like one of Putin's many operatives in the US.

cstanleytech

(27,294 posts)
37. Imagine the cost increases as well to the red states for goods and food that use the California ports.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 12:36 AM
Nov 19

kevinore

(58 posts)
39. I don't care...
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 12:59 AM
Nov 19

...let them go their own way. Just keep the nukes and other WMDs away from them.

Cha

(306,529 posts)
40. The Greene Thing Is a GD Stupid MF.. Put her charge
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 01:03 AM
Nov 19

of the DIVORSE, Ya Sick Fuck.

"Criticize" the MF".. Yeah Fuck you too, Assface!

duncang

(3,766 posts)
42. Also there aren't any pure red or blue states.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 01:07 AM
Nov 19

Even Texas was closer in 2020 than most people think. This time there was back sliding though. 42% voted for VP Harris. What happens to them/me? Will there be purity checks?

tornado34jh

(1,342 posts)
44. You want to go down that route MTG, you bastard?
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 02:18 AM
Nov 19

All right then, pull all funding for red states, pull the military out of those states, revoke aid to these states including Social Security and Medicare, and see how they fare. Oh by the way, if a major disaster like a tornado, hurricane, or whatever comes, they are on their own. To give examples of how ungrateful they are, when Texas had that big freeze in 2021, guess who was president? That's right, Biden was! When Hurricane Ian in 2022 and Hurricane Helene hit earlier this year, both really deadly hurricanes, who was president? Yep Biden. How about the deadly tornado in December 2021 that hit Kentucky? I mean, I could list several more. But last I checked, did Biden/Harris step up in the face in these disasters? I'm pretty sure they did. A friend of mine in California, a state who they much malign, even went on a two-week trip to North Carolina in the aftermath of Hurricane Helene. This really shows how ungrateful they are. If it were me, I would have said, "All right, you are on your own, don't come crying to us when things get bad you ungrateful fools."

roamer65

(37,282 posts)
45. That means we would have a hard border...
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 02:28 AM
Nov 19

to stop southern red state MAGAts from northward climate migration.

👍👍

 

RJ_MacReady

(448 posts)
50. honestly
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 05:56 AM
Nov 19

I just have no common identity with ruby red states. I no longer like my rights and freedoms being subject to the whims of low population states eith outsized say.

SKKY

(12,350 posts)
51. So, call her bluff. Let constituents of each "Red State"...
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 06:20 AM
Nov 19

...decide. She'll be made a fool of.

Oopsie Daisy

(4,958 posts)
54. Sounds good to me, Marge!
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 07:00 AM
Nov 19

Boiled down to its essence, we have Makers and Takers. Who will support the "taker" Red States? Will they have their own currency, postage, infrastructure, military?

The Madcap

(824 posts)
55. I have an idea.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 07:46 AM
Nov 19

The ultimate fight club. Let all these lunatics gather in the Arizona desert with their choice of weapon and have a battle royale. Last magat standing wins a new truck.

Would take care of the crazies and would be a lasting memorial to our idiocy as a nation.

I'm sure MTG would participate. Hunger Games 2025.

GoCubsGo

(33,367 posts)
56. Looks like somebody isn't getting enough attention.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 07:55 AM
Nov 19

Either that, or that clown trying to distract us from something else... Like the fact that her own Dear Leader and his minions want to loot those programs, and line their own pockets with our money. Social Security and Medicare are the last big chunks of money the GOP hasn't been able to steal from us, and they've been salivating over it for decades.

Jit423

(709 posts)
59. She wants us to do what the Red State Governors due to Blue state cities.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 08:01 AM
Nov 19

Shall we divey of the tax revenues also?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Marjorie Taylor Greene de...