General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsVanity Fair: Pete Hegseth Scandal Is Rattling Trumpworld: "People Are Upset About the Distraction"
GOP sources say there are doubts within the Trump transition as to whether the defense secretary nominee will be able to hang on following revelations of a 2017 sexual assault claim.
By Gabriel Sherman
November 19, 2024
For now, Donald Trump is reportedly standing by Pete Hegseth, his embattled pick for defense secretary, but some Trump transition officials are beginning to doubt whether the Fox News host can survive the controversy. According to two Republicans close to Trump, the transition team is quietly preparing a list of alternative defense secretary candidates should Trump abandon Hegseth. Its becoming a real possibility, one of the sources says. The second source tells me that transition members are frustrated that Hegseth failed to disclose he had paid a financial settlement to a woman who alleged he raped her at a Republican womens event in 2017. People are upset about the distraction. The general feeling is Pete hasnt been honest, the second source says. (Hegseth, through his attorney Timothy Parlatore, strenuously denies his accusers allegation.)
Hegseth, a thrice-married, 44-year-old Army veteran turned conservative media personality, faces a difficult confirmation battle. He has a long back catalogue of extreme statements: Hes expressed opposition to women serving in combat roles and labeled the political left domestic enemies. On Thursday, I reported that Trumps incoming chief of staff, Susie Wiles, was made aware of an allegation that Hegseth committed sexual misconduct with a woman at a Republican womens event in Monterey, California, about seven years ago (The Monterey Police Department confirmed it had investigated the alleged sexual assault and that the woman had reported suffering contusions to right thigh. No charges were filed).
Over the next several days, journalists uncovered other troubling information about Hegseth. The Washington Post and The New York Times reported that a friend of the alleged victim sent the transition team a memo that detailed what she said transpired at the Hyatt Regency in Monterey. Hegseths lawyer told Breitbart News that the alleged victims settlement contained confidentiality agreements that were breached when the allegation became public.
Meanwhile, Mother Jones has reported that Hegseth has ties to a controversial group of Christian nationalists called the TheoBros. The groups unofficial leader, an Idaho pastor named Doug Wilson, said in an interview last month that he believes women should not have the right to vote; Hegseth has previously said he studied Wilsons book My Life for Yours. Judd Legum, who writes the Popular Information substack, reported Monday that Hegseth published a column in college claiming that having sex with an unconcious woman is not rape because the woman experiences no duress. (Hegseths attorney did not immediately respond to a request for comment regarding the column or his alleged ties to the TheoBros.)
/snip
Prairie Gates
(3,032 posts)Here are the four possible scenarios that could possibly be supported by the facts:
1) Hegseth gets drunk and hooks up with random woman at the convention for Republican women. She is his minder, and has consensual sex with him. He does not know that she is married and has two small children who are staying in the same hotel. It was h3er job to bring him back to his room, and she opts for a little sexy time. So, uber Christian Hegseth just has sex with a stranger in a hotel.
2) All of scenario 1), but Hegseth knows that she is married and has two small children staying at the hotel. The uber Christian has sex with a married woman, randomly, as a one-night stand hook-up. Very Christlike, this.
3) The woman is herself drunk, and takes Hegseth back to his room (this is actually not supported by the facts revealed in the WP article, which doesn't mention that she was drinking). She is completely inebriated, Hegseth "has sex" with her (unconsensual - you know the word). She realizes it the next days and goes to the emergency room for a rape kit.
4) Hegseth roofies the woman and rapes her.
Each of these is a possible scenario explaining what happened at the Hyatt Regency. But what is plausible?
Is it plausible that this woman decided to have a one-time hook-up with her drunk famous charge with her husband and small children staying at the same hotel?
Is it plausible that she is incapacitated for several hours and has to stumble back to her room from booze alone? Or from no booze, since it doesn't report any.
Is it plausible that she would have a memory deficit and only flashes on to the "sex"/rape the following day?
Is it plausible that upon remembering the "sex"/rape, she would immdiately go to a hospital emergency room and ask for a rape kit if she engaged in consensual sex with this guy?
Is it plausible that semen would be found in the rape kit, and she would be sure it wasn't from her husband (they were in a room with their two young kids)
Is it plausible that Hegseth would admit that he had sex with her and pay her a settlement if he wasn't absolutely sure that the semen found in the rape kit would be his?
The plausibility test certainly leans more towards scenarios 3 and 4. I would say that her decision to immediately go to an emergency room and seek a rape kit leans it way, way, way toward scenario 4.
I'll just add this: if we are in a scenario 4 situation, it's not the sort of thing that somebody does just once. Wait for the additional reports to start coming out over the next several weeks, I'd say, if they're not already spilling into Ronan Farrow's inbox.
Raven123
(6,037 posts)Distraction should be the least of their concern
Solly Mack
(92,750 posts)OK.