Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

questionseverything

(10,135 posts)
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 07:52 PM 7 hrs ago

Did you know most of Europe hand counts their paper ballots?

Last edited Wed Nov 20, 2024, 08:43 PM - Edit history (1)

Germany has specifically banned anything except hand counted paper ballots because it’s in their constitution that citizens have the right to oversee every part of the government

Xxxxxxxxxxxxx

From the replies, there are a couple questions I want to address

First off , they don’t have as many races

My answer, we are only talking about counting one race, the president

Second off,
They don’t have as many people

My answer, we vote in small precincts, mine usually has about 1200 voters, no one is suggesting we count the whole state together

Third question/point,
Humans make mistakes

My answer, maybe we need some honor roll 4th graders that can stack ballots in stacks of fifty, seriously sort and stack isn’t that hard

11 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

Fiendish Thingy

(18,506 posts)
1. Did you know most of Europe's ballots have but a single race?
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 07:59 PM
7 hrs ago

Voters vote for their member of Parliament, or whatever the legislative body is called, and that’s it.

Same here in Canada for both federal and provincial races- just one race, one single vote, per ballot.

The exception is for municipal elections, those have more than one race (multiple city council positions, mayor, etc)

Provincial (BC) and municipal ballots are tabulated by machine.

JT45242

(2,886 posts)
2. We have more than 4 times as many people as any country that actually votes in europe
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 08:01 PM
7 hrs ago

Scantron type machines of paper ballots are super accurate.

It's why high stakes testing has used them since they were invented by Iowa professor who founded the ACT test and worked on the Iowa Test of Basic skills.

The upload process would be the vulnerable part from my perspective.

Germany is roughly 20-25 percent the population of the US...and roughly 4 percent the land mass. The scale of both makes a huge difference. The disparities in population density in the US are unlike any country in Europe as they don't have anything that compares to the densities of NY, Chicago etc and the wide open area of rural America all participating in the same election.

Scantrons sheets are fine. We should randomly back check 3-5% like high stakes testing SAT, ACT, AP, etc.

No one should be completely paperless with no hard copy backup.

Yes Russia is like 1/3 the population of the US in Europe but they don't really get to vote.

eppur_se_muova

(37,388 posts)
7. When vote counts are done heirarchically, the process time should be O(log n), not O(n).
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 08:54 PM
6 hrs ago

Small batches are counted, then the totals sent for a second totaling. Those results are then sent for a third total, if need be. The time required to count depends on the number counted in each small batch, and the number of levels in the heirarchy. Increasing the number of votes several fold should add one step to the heirarchy, increasing the time by a fraction (maybe a large fraction, like 1/3 if there were three levels to begin with) but much, much less than a doubling.

Elections can be fast or accurate, but the latter is more important. The large number of ballots is not an insuperable obstacle.

dsc

(52,631 posts)
3. because other than France those countries don't elect
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 08:02 PM
7 hrs ago

a nationwide leader. They have a bunch of district races and their districts are vastly smaller than ours. A congressional seat in the US has over 700k people. A german one as about 280k.

Igel

(36,082 posts)
4. And their ballots are quite different.
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 08:02 PM
7 hrs ago

Often one or two races with multiple parties running for each race.

You want to hand count them, each ballot gets counted for just a couple of races (sometimes you get 2 votes on a given race). You vote for a party and the party makes the decision as to who your vote actually got appointed. It takes days.

Now, consider a typical ballot that I've seen in TX with 80-90 races/issues covering multiple pages, with multiple races or issues on each page.

Emile

(29,777 posts)
5. I remember myself and two other union
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 08:11 PM
7 hrs ago

brothers counting Ballots in our local election. We counted three times and had the exact count 2 out of 3. Humans make mistakes.

snot

(10,702 posts)
8. The thing is,
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:02 PM
6 hrs ago

it's a lot harder to cheat on a massive scale with physical ballots -- tends to require more physical effort, more conspirators, etc.

Even if it took a month to count paper ballots by hand, I'd consider it worth the wait.

questionseverything

(10,135 posts)
9. Counting one race precinct by precinct should take a few hours not days
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:13 PM
6 hrs ago

The exception might be the states that count all the absentee ballots for a county together, that could be a huge number but let’s say you take 20,000 ab ballots, break them up into ten groups of 2000 ballots and get ten teams of honor roll fourth graders then we are still talking a few hours

LiberalFighter

(53,465 posts)
10. In my county there are multiple precincts at each polling place.
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:24 PM
6 hrs ago

I had fifteen elections or issues to vote on.

Back in the eighties and before we had machines we voted on that had levers to pull.

questionseverything

(10,135 posts)
11. We are only talking about hand counting the presidential race for this discussion
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:31 PM
6 hrs ago

How many people get run through your polling place with multiple precincts?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Did you know most of Euro...