Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

milestogo

(18,274 posts)
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:31 PM Dec 5

So is vigilantism now the preferred way of making a statement or enacting change?

Because it seems to me to be a very flawed process. The shooter will have his day in court and will have his rights- but the dead man will not.

44 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
So is vigilantism now the preferred way of making a statement or enacting change? (Original Post) milestogo Dec 5 OP
One person does this, you assume it's widespread? leftstreet Dec 5 #1
It seems to be popular here on DU. milestogo Dec 5 #2
It's hugely "popular" across most social media right now leftstreet Dec 5 #7
Are you saying you're seeing lots of DUers going out and shooting people? Do tell. Otherwise, if you're Scrivener7 Dec 5 #23
From my perspective it is shockingly popular here at DU Redleg Dec 5 #24
American judges have made it clear that the law does not apply to rich white males. Irish_Dem Dec 5 #3
Preferred? No. Understandable? Yes, IMO. Happy Hoosier Dec 5 #4
Who said that? BannonsLiver Dec 5 #5
Boo-fucking-hoo. Coventina Dec 5 #6
I would like to say no sarisataka Dec 5 #8
Is jailing those that can't pay their medical debt the preferred method of collection? tenderfoot Dec 5 #9
Who said that? BTW, this will change nothing with that corporation. themaguffin Dec 5 #10
one isolated event equals preferred way? prodigitalson Dec 5 #11
Understanding and empathizing with somebody's motives is not the same as endorsing their actions. Voltaire2 Dec 5 #12
I think a number of us are feeling some empathy. yardwork Dec 5 #35
the 'system' is broken. It isn't working for a lot of people. Voltaire2 Dec 5 #36
That is becoming more and more apparent. yardwork Dec 5 #40
People are getting fed up with the bullshit. BlueTsunami2018 Dec 5 #13
Violence is the last resort of the incompetent. Isaac Asimov Ping Tung Dec 5 #14
This message was self-deleted by its author onecaliberal Dec 5 #31
Asimov was a serial sexual harasser so I'm not sure everyone holds him in the same regard as you do. BannonsLiver Dec 5 #32
Did he go to trial? Ping Tung Dec 5 #38
""Violence is the language of the unheard." - MLK, Jr. intheflow Dec 5 #42
Probably a last resort for a few that feel powerless to change things any other way. nt 2 Meow Momma Dec 5 #15
I agree. But, his act Will save no lives. The CEO will be replaced by another moneymaker. Ping Tung Dec 5 #39
Appears so. Maybe the government ought to get it's act together and enact a viable healthcare system Silent Type Dec 5 #16
People kill people that they're made at all the time... Think. Again. Dec 5 #17
Don't mistake enjoying a little Schadenfreude for support for vigilantism LearnedHand Dec 5 #18
First of all, you're 100% correct Blue_Tires Dec 5 #19
I've watched some westerns set in 19th century America milestogo Dec 5 #20
I'm not disagreeing with you Blue_Tires Dec 5 #22
No one here is advocating for vigilantism LearnedHand Dec 5 #30
Its time to acknowledge we are in a fight and stop this moral high ground crap Asa13 Dec 5 #21
Nothing else seems to work. alarimer Dec 5 #25
I've not read anyone condoning murder. CrispyQ Dec 5 #26
Lesson from history: The attempted murder of Henry Clay Frick DBoon Dec 5 #27
The dead man made deliberate decisions that killed a lot of people on the daily. onecaliberal Dec 5 #28
Broad-brush straw man argument. Basso8vb Dec 5 #29
Rich Man, Poor Man Deep State Witch Dec 5 #33
Not the "preferred" way, but it appears to be electorally beneficial to Retrumplicans maxrandb Dec 5 #34
Being happy someone is dead Trenzalore Dec 5 #37
The dead man made life choices also. Conjuay Dec 5 #41
It's ok to be indiffferent to vigilantism (or even pleased) if you think the person was bad Bonx Dec 5 #43
ANOTHER thread about this? nt GenThePerservering Dec 5 #44

Scrivener7

(53,199 posts)
23. Are you saying you're seeing lots of DUers going out and shooting people? Do tell. Otherwise, if you're
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 02:50 PM
Dec 5

just equating talking about the killing and actually killing, you're being ridiculous.

Redleg

(6,248 posts)
24. From my perspective it is shockingly popular here at DU
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 02:54 PM
Dec 5

I think I can understand the sentiment behind it, but damn if it doesn't give me the chills. Believe me, when I hear assholes like Steve Bannon or Kash Patel running their fucking mouths I do briefly regret having sold my .270 deer rifle. Then the anger subsides and I realize how stupid it is to do such a thing, even if I feel they have it coming and I know the legal system won't bring them to justice.

I think many of us are running a bit hot here, blowing off steam that has been building for a few years now. Perhaps some of us have been screwed by health insurance companies. I get the anger, I get the desire for justice.

Irish_Dem

(59,719 posts)
3. American judges have made it clear that the law does not apply to rich white males.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:39 PM
Dec 5

American politicians enact laws which make the
murder, death, torture, injury, pain, suffering, theft,
financial ruin of American citizens perfectly legal.

So in this kind of environment people yearn for
some sort of justice, and unfortunately street
justice is what they are left with.

I may not agree with it, but I understand it.

Happy Hoosier

(8,558 posts)
4. Preferred? No. Understandable? Yes, IMO.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:40 PM
Dec 5

The dead man's crimes were all legal. Which is why the vigilanteism is understandable... some people can only take so much before they break.

sarisataka

(21,284 posts)
8. I would like to say no
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:44 PM
Dec 5

but the best I can say is maybe not the preferred way.

Yet

But the day is young...

 

tenderfoot

(8,879 posts)
9. Is jailing those that can't pay their medical debt the preferred method of collection?
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:45 PM
Dec 5

Asking for a friend.

Voltaire2

(14,878 posts)
12. Understanding and empathizing with somebody's motives is not the same as endorsing their actions.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:49 PM
Dec 5

My assumption, for now, is that the shooter was a victim of UHC. I view this as similar to an abused spouse killing their abuser. Sure, it's wrong, but it is also quite understandable.

yardwork

(64,765 posts)
35. I think a number of us are feeling some empathy.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:44 PM
Dec 5

I've surprised myself by finding a certain common ground with Trump voters. A lot of them appear to have voted for Trump out of frustration, rage, and despair. A number of DUers are expressing frustration, rage and despair and it's causing them to express a lack of.... grief.... for this victim. Some even view the shooter as a folk hero. These impulses - voting for Trump to burn it all down and supporting a vigilante killer - stem from the same kind of emotional thinking.

I'm not in favor of vigilante justice or assassinations, but they are age-old human impulses when people are pushed beyond their limits.

Maybe we can use this incident to reflect. The world is really screwed up and solutions seem sparse. Is it any wonder that people are acting out.

Voltaire2

(14,878 posts)
36. the 'system' is broken. It isn't working for a lot of people.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:48 PM
Dec 5

Centrist political parties running as defenders of the system are holding a losing hand.

yardwork

(64,765 posts)
40. That is becoming more and more apparent.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 04:02 PM
Dec 5

The problem is that the people voters support to make radical change will be lousy governors.

BlueTsunami2018

(4,071 posts)
13. People are getting fed up with the bullshit.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:49 PM
Dec 5

If things get to the point where we have to fight for what we need, it’s not going to be a bloodless affair. There’s no place for shrinking violets in a revolution.

Ping Tung

(1,431 posts)
14. Violence is the last resort of the incompetent. Isaac Asimov
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:51 PM
Dec 5

If it was murder the shooter will be tried. If guilty he will be punished. If not guilty his fanclub can buy him a beer and slap him on the back.

Response to Ping Tung (Reply #14)

BannonsLiver

(18,217 posts)
32. Asimov was a serial sexual harasser so I'm not sure everyone holds him in the same regard as you do.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:26 PM
Dec 5

Ping Tung

(1,431 posts)
38. Did he go to trial?
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:53 PM
Dec 5

I have no "regard" for Asimov. But I agree with his statement on violence.

If the shooter here is captured he will go to trial and a jury or judge will cause him to face the consequences of his murder if he's found guilty.

If he's sentenced to death I'll still agree with Asimov's statement about incompetence as concerns the judge or jury..

Ping Tung

(1,431 posts)
39. I agree. But, his act Will save no lives. The CEO will be replaced by another moneymaker.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:59 PM
Dec 5

The best way to change a rotten system is by enforcing the laws or changing them to be more humane.

Silent Type

(7,334 posts)
16. Appears so. Maybe the government ought to get it's act together and enact a viable healthcare system
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:54 PM
Dec 5

that doesn't depend on private insurers. Hell, even original Medicare at inception used private insurers to administer the program in the 60 years since every major "advancement" included private insurers, even the ACA/Obamacare.

Then there is this:

Gallop Poll 2023

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- A 57% majority of U.S. adults believe that the federal government should ensure all Americans have healthcare coverage. Yet nearly as many, 53%, prefer that the U.S. healthcare system be based on private insurance rather than run by the government. These findings are in line with recent attitudes about the government’s involvement in the healthcare system, which have been relatively steady since 2015.

https://news.gallup.com/poll/468401/majority-say-gov-ensure-healthcare.aspx

Think. Again.

(19,091 posts)
17. People kill people that they're made at all the time...
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 01:59 PM
Dec 5

What make you think it's vigilantism or that it's new?

LearnedHand

(4,221 posts)
18. Don't mistake enjoying a little Schadenfreude for support for vigilantism
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 02:06 PM
Dec 5

The entire nation is engaging in some gallows humor about this man's death. It may be unlovely, but it also tells us we're not alone in wanting to see the end of unregulated vulture capitalism.

Blue_Tires

(56,735 posts)
19. First of all, you're 100% correct
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 02:12 PM
Dec 5

Second of all, it doesn't change the fact a lot of us are extremely pissed off since the election and truly believe now that the only justice any of us are going to get is the justice we create for ourselves. (And I'll stop here before I get this post hidden for rulebreaking)

milestogo

(18,274 posts)
20. I've watched some westerns set in 19th century America
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 02:21 PM
Dec 5

and sometimes the whole town would go after a person who had committed a murder. Usually they got it right, but in those days it just wasn't a very tight system. I can definitely see how people got caught up in vigilantism, because the system of laws just wasn't workable yet.

I'm not saying its workable now. But surely there are more options than stalking someone and gunning them down. Because once it starts, this kind of behavior keeps spreading and never ends.

Blue_Tires

(56,735 posts)
22. I'm not disagreeing with you
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 02:49 PM
Dec 5

I believe in law and we're supposed to be a nation of laws... But when the angry orange idiot gets away with literally everything because he owns the federal judges and the USSC has officially said nothing he does is illegal, we're no longer citizens with a president, we're subjects living under a king. The law is now officially whatever Donnie declares it to be.

And if the leader of the free world (along with his ever-increasing bandwagon of cronies) no longer abides by any laws, why should any of the rest of us?

LearnedHand

(4,221 posts)
30. No one here is advocating for vigilantism
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:15 PM
Dec 5

We're all just nodding our heads in understanding how a person could be driven to it when it comes to dealing with medical insurance.

 

Asa13

(43 posts)
21. Its time to acknowledge we are in a fight and stop this moral high ground crap
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 02:23 PM
Dec 5

The right, Christians, corporations declared war on the American people and it's time to start treating it like the fight it is.

alarimer

(16,644 posts)
25. Nothing else seems to work.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:00 PM
Dec 5

Even the ACA was only nibbling around the edges of what is truly needed.

We do not actually know the motive at this time anyway. It's just that the system lets so many people down (kills them in fact) that it was only a matter of time.

But nothing ever seems to change, no matter the lofty promises made by politicians.

CrispyQ

(38,590 posts)
26. I've not read anyone condoning murder.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:05 PM
Dec 5

As for grave dancing? If you don't want people to dance when you die, then live the kind of life where people don't want to dance when you die.

DBoon

(23,170 posts)
27. Lesson from history: The attempted murder of Henry Clay Frick
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:06 PM
Dec 5
In 1892, during the Homestead strike, anarchist Alexander Berkman attempted to assassinate Frick. On July 23, Berkman, armed with a revolver and a sharpened steel file, entered Frick's office in downtown Pittsburgh
...
Frick was back at work within a week; Berkman was charged and found guilty of attempted murder. Berkman's actions in planning the assassination clearly indicated a premeditated intent to kill, and he was sentenced to 22 years in prison.[5] Negative publicity from the attempted assassination resulted in the collapse of the strike.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Clay_Frick (my bolding)

So, the target survived, Berkman spent a long time in prison, and the strike collapsed.

The violent history of the American labor movement has some lessons for the 21st century. One is that individual acts of terrorism not only fail but also discredit the overall cause.

onecaliberal

(36,331 posts)
28. The dead man made deliberate decisions that killed a lot of people on the daily.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:07 PM
Dec 5

Actions have consequences. I have no fucks to give.

Deep State Witch

(11,364 posts)
33. Rich Man, Poor Man
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:29 PM
Dec 5

I'm enjoying the schadenfreude of a rich health care executive getting offed. That doesn't mean that I condone murder. However, if the victim was a poor, unknown POC who was shot in the back in a bad part of town, would people's reactions be different? Mostly it would be, "too bad, but it's a day ending in Y in (insert area here)." I feel bad for Mr. Thompson's wife and kids, but they will survive without having to start a GoFundMe to cover his funeral expenses.

maxrandb

(16,004 posts)
34. Not the "preferred" way, but it appears to be electorally beneficial to Retrumplicans
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 03:36 PM
Dec 5

Not sure how we put the violence genie back in the bottle, after America proved violence is a winning strategy.

Bonx

(2,235 posts)
43. It's ok to be indiffferent to vigilantism (or even pleased) if you think the person was bad
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 05:17 PM
Dec 5

It's really not. I judge people on this, just like with grocery carts.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»So is vigilantism now the...