Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

jmowreader

(51,606 posts)
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 08:15 PM Dec 5

Strange conjecture: Brian Thompson's murder may have been a contract killing

The New York City Police Department, after careful analysis of the surveillance footage, believes the assassin used a B&T Station Six pistol to kill Brian Thompson.

https://www.capitolarmory.com/bt-station-six-9mm-suppressed-pistol-bt410111.html

https://abcnews.go.com/US/police-piece-unitedhealthcare-ceo-shooting-suspects-escape-route/story?id=116475329

What to know about this gun: It is modeled after the "Welrod" pistol issued to British secret agents in World War II. It is magazine fed but you have to cycle the action by hand after every shot. If you buy one, which you probably aren't planning on because they're over $2000 apiece, you have to undergo a federal investigation which takes up to two months due to the silencer it comes with.

So...who would buy such a thing? People with a very serious love of the history of covert operations, people who love unusual firearms...and people who murder people for hire. I can go to Cabela's any day of the week and walk out the door in less than an hour with an automatic pistol from any of the famous brands to include the notoriously-overpriced Heckler & Koch for a third of what the B&T Station Six costs, and have a better pistol for anything except whacking people in the middle of Manhattan.

ABC is reporting that the killer stayed in the HI New York City hostel. They have surveillance footage of him checking in. It's on the corner of 104th St. and Amsterdam Avenue.

So, let's follow this guy's footsteps for a bit. He would have left the hostel and walked over to Central Park West, where he would have boarded either the B or D train. He rode to the 7th Avenue station, which is on 53d Street. One block up and one block east is where he killed Thompson. Go back to the station - remember, the pictures they have shown of him make it clear he's just an ordinary-looking guy and in New York people walk around at all hours - then he jumped back on the B train, rode to the 86th Street Station, jumped over the Central Park perimeter wall, grabbed the bike he had cached in there and was seen riding it near 84th Street just before 7 am.

Even if they find this guy - and he's definitely an out-of-towner; HI New York requires an out-of-NYC ID to check in - it's going to be hell solving this because they also have to find whoever hired him.

31 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Strange conjecture: Brian Thompson's murder may have been a contract killing (Original Post) jmowreader Dec 5 OP
Why is that considered choie Dec 5 #1
because some are acting like he is a folk hero Skittles Dec 5 #2
Ah. choie Dec 5 #11
So the guy who paid him is the folk hero? intheflow Dec 6 #22
I don't think of the shooter as a hero.... BUT.... Happy Hoosier Dec 6 #23
I doubt he was a professional assassin Meowmee Dec 5 #3
Definitely NOT a pro. Happy Hoosier Dec 6 #24
This has been one of my theories. yardwork Dec 5 #4
I doubt he would use his own ID to check in to the hostel Sanity Claws Dec 5 #5
Apparently he used a fake New Jersey ID, from what I read. Oneironaut Dec 5 #7
Not strange. No one knows the actual reason. Only conjecture and speculation. Solly Mack Dec 5 #6
Cui bono? RockRaven Dec 5 #8
He had the bike at the killing scene...he rode away on it Prairie Gates Dec 5 #9
He doesn't appear to be well off. LisaL Dec 5 #10
His backpack is not cheap FreeState Dec 6 #19
There is zero proof he isn't well off obamanut2012 Dec 6 #26
Suppressors take as little as a week to obtain these days NickB79 Dec 5 #12
Maybe so ... Straw Man Dec 6 #18
It wasn't a Station Six 9 pistol. NutmegYankee Dec 5 #13
were they jams? Or was he cycling the bolt action pistol above? Look again. WarGamer Dec 5 #14
See picture: NutmegYankee Dec 5 #15
a random youtuber said he was racking the gun each time, unnecessarily. nt ecstatic Dec 6 #17
If a stock pistol is used, the silencer can cause the slide to not properly close. NutmegYankee Dec 6 #20
Subsonic Rounds? Elmotime Dec 6 #25
Possibly. Straw Man Dec 7 #30
I think y'all are all overthinking it. The only thing unique about that attack was that the killer limited ecstatic Dec 5 #16
His estranged wife had really nice things to say about him. They lived in the same city allegorical oracle Dec 6 #21
Cigna did it! Omnipresent Dec 6 #27
Except the station he exited was an F train local, the sole line that uses that one Aviation Pro Dec 6 #28
I read today snowybirdie Dec 6 #29
I'm not an expert... Dulcinea Dec 7 #31

Skittles

(160,327 posts)
2. because some are acting like he is a folk hero
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 08:21 PM
Dec 5

being paid to do it doesn't really fit that fuzzy version of revenge

intheflow

(29,054 posts)
22. So the guy who paid him is the folk hero?
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 09:27 AM
Dec 6

What about that guy's revenge motivation?

I don't really think of either of them as heroes in any sense, but I'd be lying if I said I haven't been expecting something like this to happen for some time now.

Happy Hoosier

(8,558 posts)
23. I don't think of the shooter as a hero.... BUT....
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 09:42 AM
Dec 6

the victim was definitely a villian.

At best, I finder the shooter's actions understandable (acknowledging that I am making assumptions about motive here).

But the victim was a willing participant in the process of extracting wealth from suffering people and enriching himself to the tune of 8 figures a year.

Meowmee

(6,125 posts)
3. I doubt he was a professional assassin
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 08:22 PM
Dec 5

Because he failed the first time or there was some malfunction with the shooting. And he unmasked himself… imo a pro would never do that. Also, I don’t think they usually write things on bullets. I don’t know. Maybe I’m not in the loop with all of this stuff.

Happy Hoosier

(8,558 posts)
24. Definitely NOT a pro.
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 09:43 AM
Dec 6

For one thing, he's a KID. I'm thinking a parent or other loved one denied care. But we'll see.

yardwork

(64,765 posts)
4. This has been one of my theories.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 08:25 PM
Dec 5

I've wondered from the beginning if he was a hired assassin.

I don't know anything about guns, so that's interesting.

To me, the motive is not necessarily clear. It could be retaliation for health insurance denials, or it could be made to look that way.

Prairie Gates

(3,570 posts)
9. He had the bike at the killing scene...he rode away on it
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 08:45 PM
Dec 5

Up through so-called 6 1/2 Avenue and into Central Park. He is then seen on camera coming out of Central Park between 70th and 80th on the bike and then again on 85th street. When he leaves Central Park, the backpack is gone. Police are still searching the park for the backpack.

One other thing to note: between the hostel he stayed in and the B D train station at 103rd street are the (at one time notorious) Frederick Douglass houses, a sprawling housing project that he would have pretty much had to walk through either on 104th street or 103rd street to get to the subway. It used to be quite an interesting walk at 5am to be trapsing through the FDH on 103rd street, which pretty much bisects the grounds. Not sure if it's the same these days, but I'd certainly feel better about making that walk armed!

LisaL

(46,766 posts)
10. He doesn't appear to be well off.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 08:49 PM
Dec 5

Apparently he came by bus and stayed in hostel sharing room with other people. I don't think it's a contract killing, or he doesn't get a lot of contracts.

FreeState

(10,701 posts)
19. His backpack is not cheap
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 01:59 AM
Dec 6

It’s the 2019 version of this:

https://www.peakdesign.com/products/everyday-backpack?Size=20L&Color=Ash

Sure it could be a gift, second hand or stollen but it wasn’t cheap new and very identifiable.

NickB79

(19,663 posts)
12. Suppressors take as little as a week to obtain these days
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 09:45 PM
Dec 5

Source: I was just pricing one for a .22 rifle two weeks ago. The ATF has recently upgraded their review process and months long waits have largely gone away.

Straw Man

(6,789 posts)
18. Maybe so ...
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 01:41 AM
Dec 6
Suppressors take as little as a week to obtain these days

... but there is the thorny issue of the background check and sign-off by the ranking law enforcement officer -- county sheriff or city chief of police -- in your home location. If he had a clean record, that would be possible, but the paper trail would certainly lead law enforcement to him eventually. How many people do you think buy those pistols?

The speculation about the $2000 WWII replica pistol is just that: speculation. What you saw on those videos was him clearing jams, not racking the manual action of an archaic firearm. The evidence is the complete cartridges found on the ground. That's what happens when you clear a jam: a live cartridge almost invariably gets ejected, whether it was the initial cause of the jam or just collateral ejecta from clearing the jam of a spent casing. The bottom line is that you don't eject live cartridges when you cycle a manual action.

What you saw was a garden variety semi-auto pistol with a silencer that was either homemade or sourced on the black market. The jams were probably caused by the silencer, which causes back-pressure that can affect the often-finicky functioning of a semi-auto pistol. The pistol can be tuned to compensate for that, but his clearly wasn't. Pro? No.

NutmegYankee

(16,336 posts)
13. It wasn't a Station Six 9 pistol.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 09:51 PM
Dec 5

It was a glock or similar with floating barrel attached to a threaded on silencer. The frequent jams are common in that configuration unless the main recoil spring is replaced with a much harder spring.

A professional wouldn't have had that many jams - he would've tested and refined the weapon.

NutmegYankee

(16,336 posts)
20. If a stock pistol is used, the silencer can cause the slide to not properly close.
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 02:23 AM
Dec 6

He may have had to pull the slide back to reset for the next shot, ejecting an unfired cartridge each time.

Elmotime

(17 posts)
25. Subsonic Rounds?
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 09:47 AM
Dec 6

If you are trying to minimize noise, subsonic rounds lack the crack of most ammunition. A suppressor + lower powered subsonic ammo often lack the power to properly cycle the gun causing the need to manually rack the slide between shots.

Straw Man

(6,789 posts)
30. Possibly.
Sat Dec 7, 2024, 03:04 AM
Dec 7
A suppressor + lower powered subsonic ammo often lack the power to properly cycle the gun causing the need to manually rack the slide between shots.

That power deficiency can be overcome by using a weaker recoil spring. Proper functioning of a semi-auto pistol is dependent on a balance between the power of the cartridge and the strength of the spring. Springs can be changed easily. The fact that he didn't tune his pistol to his silencer suggests that he wasn't a pro at all.

ecstatic

(34,519 posts)
16. I think y'all are all overthinking it. The only thing unique about that attack was that the killer limited
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 10:28 PM
Dec 5

the carnage to the person he was targeting (unlike other terrorists who kill everyone in the vicinity).

I don't think he personally knows anyone killed by UHC. He's just a homegrown domestic terrorist / serial killer, for lack of a better word, and his target appears to be heartless CEOs. He probably did not expect to still be alive right now, but now that he's escaped, he might move on to the next person on his list.

There are a lot of other wild theories I can think of, but I think the simplest explanation is usually the right one.

allegorical oracle

(3,397 posts)
21. His estranged wife had really nice things to say about him. They lived in the same city
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 08:34 AM
Dec 6

but in different homes.

Aviation Pro

(13,570 posts)
28. Except the station he exited was an F train local, the sole line that uses that one
Fri Dec 6, 2024, 09:54 AM
Dec 6

It's part of the tranche of photos.

Dulcinea

(7,603 posts)
31. I'm not an expert...
Sat Dec 7, 2024, 05:20 AM
Dec 7

...but maybe the shooter is ex-military, maybe Special Forces? Someone with knowledge of guerrilla warfare?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Strange conjecture: Brian...