General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhat is the greatest Christmas movie?
None of the others compare. 😉
| 18 votes, 23 passes | Time left: Time expired | |
| Die Hard | |
18 (100%) |
|
| 23 DU members did not wish to select any of the options provided. | |
| Show usernames
Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll |
|
edbermac
(16,399 posts)Lots of cheery and mirthful gunplay.
But if one prefers another type of stimulation

betsuni
(28,705 posts)What was the point.
thebigidea
(13,558 posts)DFW
(59,730 posts)Jedi Guy
(3,417 posts)The Jim Carrey version of How the Grinch Stole Christmas is a close second, though.
Die Hard isn't a Christmas movie, anyway. The fact that it's set during the Christmas season is totally irrelevant to the plot. Set it during Easter or the Fourth of July and absolutely nothing changes.
SocialDemocrat61
(6,814 posts)Jedi Guy
(3,417 posts)It could take place on Labor Day or Valentine's Day and precisely nothing about the plot changes. It's the same exact movie with, at best, slightly different decorations in the background shots. Its message, if it can be said to have a message apart from "thieves bad", has zero to do with Christmas.
Ergo, not a Christmas movie regardless of what the writer says. I don't consider Gremlins a Christmas movie either, for the same reasons. Both are movies that happen to take place during the Christmas season and that's about it.
Just my opinion. That and $2.50 will buy you a coffee. 😁
SocialDemocrat61
(6,814 posts)The original novel was set during Christmas and was the main element that was retained for the movie. Plus the films themes are about family, redemption, forgiveness and reconciliation. That sounds very Christmas to me. Theres a reason his wifes name is Holly.
https://gazette.com/premium/7-reasons-why-die-hard-is-a-christmas-movie/article_f2aec69b-6715-5c46-9c96-68c3df078156.html#:~:text=The%20results%20of%20the%20poll,that%20is%20a%20ridiculous%20statement.
Jedi Guy
(3,417 posts)So once again, inconsequential to the plot of the film. And I don't regard the wife's name as of consequence, either. As for the party, meh. Could've been a party to celebrate the opening of Nakatomi Plaza and, once again, nothing changes but the background decor.
We shall, it appears, have to agree to disagree on this one.
SocialDemocrat61
(6,814 posts)Its a Wonderful Life and Home Alone. Are those not Christmas movies either?
SarcasticSatyr
(1,360 posts)JMHO
Cosmocat
(15,347 posts)I like a lot of the others, but this one hits home for me.
Johonny
(25,444 posts)SNL nailed the the real liberal ending.
Raine
(31,094 posts)Dulcinea
(9,665 posts)No matter how many times I see it, I always sniffle at the end. "No man is a failure who has friends."
Shermann
(9,007 posts)I hadn't seen so much as a single scene and didn't know the first thing about it. All in all, I really enjoyed it. I loved the way the story followed George over several decades with a focus on Christmastime. It really established the characters in a slow burn plot. There were corny elements, but it has aged relatively well. The sugary sweet ending was a bit much, but it was apropos to wrap things up in a bow. It is a bit derivative of "A Christmas Carol" but adds enough to the story to get a pass.
mdmc
(29,377 posts)Merry Christmas!
Shermann
(9,007 posts)Fortunately, George saved her from that fate.
Nowadays MAGA would use the term "childless cat lady" instead. The more things change, the more they stay the same!
dem4decades
(13,677 posts)Not a Bruce Willis fan
Auggie
(32,880 posts)leftyladyfrommo
(19,955 posts)Vegan4life
(37 posts)Kate Hepburn, Peter O'Toole, Anthony Hopkins. Perfection.
The Third Doctor
(449 posts)AZSkiffyGeek
(12,744 posts)I love that movie so much...
PJMcK
(24,739 posts)It's a porn movie.
hatrack
(64,246 posts)woodsprite
(12,541 posts)He falls one floor a day until Christmas.
SocialDemocrat61
(6,814 posts)
Blue Full Moon
(3,156 posts)Sympthsical
(10,849 posts)I shouldn't have laughed as hard as I did at that this early in the morning.
GoneOffShore
(17,978 posts)Die Hard is just an action movie.
ratchiweenie
(8,160 posts)LSparkle
(12,120 posts)And must play Vince Guaraldis Charlie Brown Christmas album, along with Stan Frebergs Green Christmas ...
Ligyron
(8,004 posts)Merry Christmas DU!
electric_blue68
(25,922 posts)mnhtnbb
(33,117 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(6,814 posts)Just not his best 😉
GoneOffShore
(17,978 posts)The movie does give off a slightly creepy stalker vibe at times, but is still fun.
ITAL
(1,262 posts)Not only the best Christmas movie, perhaps my all time favorite of any genre.
Mike 03
(18,690 posts)But there are some classics I haven't seen, so the pool of films I'm selecting from is narrow.
GoCubsGo
(34,664 posts)Mike 03
(18,690 posts)Lethal Weapon accepted as a great Christmas movie? It also takes place during Christmas and even opens with "Jingle Bell Rock" and a scene involving some Christmas lights IIRC.
ms liberty
(10,963 posts)jmowreader
(52,901 posts)It has even more Christmas elements than Die Hard but since Die Hard is a better movie, Lethal Weapon kinda gets lost in the shuffle.
ms liberty
(10,963 posts)4th
(453 posts)
WalkerinSC
(283 posts)The best movie for any holiday.
Srkdqltr
(9,363 posts)Polly Hennessey
(8,568 posts)Nanjeanne
(6,508 posts)Barbara Stanwyck. Anything with Stanwyck!
Or Family Stone.
usonian
(23,535 posts)
Heart-Warming!
Written by Rod Serling.
Jerry2144
(3,177 posts)It has Elves, snow, and a Golden Ring. What more do you need for an Xmas movie?
La Coliniere
(1,754 posts)From 1952. Cary Grant and Betsy Drake are parents who have their own kids, but are talked into taking in a couple troubled foster children. Its charming, predictable and yes, schmaltzy. Reminds me very much of my childhood because my natural parents also took in foster kids. My parents werent Cary Grant or Betsy Drake, but they were very kind folks with very big hearts. And solid Democrats throughout their lives. Merry Christmas yall!
bif
(26,671 posts)Coventina
(29,110 posts)sakabatou
(45,769 posts)maveric
(17,009 posts)JoseBalow
(9,163 posts)Skittles
(169,539 posts)yes INDEED
Morbius
(893 posts)I think everyone should see Rare Exports. It's a Finnish horror comedy from 2010 about what happens when men drill into the tomb of the real Santa Claus. I watched it once, years ago, and the memories still make me smile.
TommieMommy
(2,659 posts)ArnoldLayne
(2,256 posts)Emile
(40,603 posts)krawhitham
(5,055 posts)Polybius
(21,511 posts)Attilatheblond
(8,279 posts)Have fun, do something you haven't done in years.
Meet up with an old friend again.
Give up a little vanity for a greater good.
Listen to kids singing.
Do a favor or two for those who work hard.
Count blessings and voice appreciation.
And remember that one small, empty stocking: the angle's sermon left for the bishop to give, well, no matter what one's faith, those words matter.
Texasgal
(17,235 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(6,814 posts)☺️