Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

speak easy

(11,115 posts)
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 08:49 AM Jan 12

Malibu: No more 'Billionaire Beaches.'

Last edited Sun Jan 12, 2025, 10:48 AM - Edit history (2)

If the city of Malibu can't rezone land west of the Pacific Coast Highway to preclude the rebuilding of ocean front monstrosities, then at least acquire a property or two on each beach to give the public more easy access to public land.

There are no Billionaire Beaches, only public beaches.


Carbon Beach.

46 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Malibu: No more 'Billionaire Beaches.' (Original Post) speak easy Jan 12 OP
I suspect a trump crony will build some monstrosity on the whole thing. Think. Again. Jan 12 #1
These people pre-Date Trump DeepWinter Jan 12 #25
Agreed XanaDUer2 Jan 12 #2
Doonesbury is fighting the home owners today KS Toronado Jan 12 #41
Mark5767 Mark5767 Jan 12 #3
"A. 50-year battle for public beach access in Malibu speak easy Jan 12 #5
Wealthy home owners have put up fake "No Parking" signs to keep visitors out DBoon Jan 12 #23
Great first post! Emile Jan 12 #38
Welcome to DU ! KS Toronado Jan 12 #40
Welcome to DU LetMyPeopleVote Jan 12 #44
South of Pacific Coast Highway, not west NameAlreadyTaken Jan 12 #4
What is to the west of the Pacific Coast Highway? speak easy Jan 12 #6
The Pacific ocean EX500rider Jan 12 #15
Where the ocean front houses were built. speak easy Jan 12 #16
PCH runs east/west in Malibu NameAlreadyTaken Jan 12 #22
The Central. Coast is a large curve, meaning the Pacific Ocean is to our south Hekate Jan 12 #45
Actually Malibu Beach access is pretty easy. MineralMan Jan 12 #7
Not on Carbon Beach. speak easy Jan 12 #8
If you look at that PDF, you'll see two public access points to Carbon Beach. MineralMan Jan 12 #10
"What's behind a 50-year battle for public beach access in Malibu" speak easy Jan 12 #12
Well, I'm pretty sure it's not a high priority at this moment. MineralMan Jan 12 #13
"People wanted to go to Malibu just because it was Malibu" speak easy Jan 12 #14
I've heard that the people in those houses on Carbon beach Farmer-Rick Jan 12 #35
Well, now their luxury beach mansions are just ashes. MineralMan Jan 12 #36
Doonesbury was covering restricted Malibu Beach access 20+ years ago. Rhiagel Jan 12 #9
I've been following that as well. JohnnyRingo Jan 12 #18
That's correct, I've been watching wealthy folks block access to public beaches since 1960. Magoo48 Jan 12 #11
There will never be a better time to buy back property. speak easy Jan 12 #19
This message was self-deleted by its author karynnj Jan 12 #17
Don't allow them to rebuild there. There's not enough space. Should be open beach. Those houses are (were) monstrosities Clouds Passing Jan 12 #20
I'm guessing it has been local (or county) zoning groups that made this mess FakeNoose Jan 12 #32
Those MacMansions were a blight on the coastline. Clouds Passing Jan 12 #39
I used to hate driving through Malibu, looking at those monstrosities niyad Jan 12 #21
I thought that all the beaches in California are open to the public question everything Jan 12 #24
That would be Oregon. WheelWalker Jan 12 #26
Carbon Beach Old Okie Jan 12 #28
I believe Oregon declared all beaches MurrayDelph Jan 12 #42
History of Oregon's public beaches... WheelWalker Jan 12 #43
"I thought that all the beaches in California are open to the public' speak easy Jan 12 #27
The beaches are but homeowners make it difficult to access JI7 Jan 12 #46
Poverty is our greatest enemy. twodogsbarking Jan 12 #29
If it doesn't happen in FL, NC, etc, why should it happen in CA? Renew Deal Jan 12 #30
That is a pretty gross depiction of opulence (picture). Evolve Dammit Jan 12 #31
City can't zone, than no hook up to city utilities, electric, water, sewer. republianmushroom Jan 12 #33
? speak easy Jan 12 #34
Larry Ellison Deep State Witch Jan 12 #37

DeepWinter

(770 posts)
25. These people pre-Date Trump
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:19 AM
Jan 12

LA County and especially the Pacific Pallisadesis some of THE most expensive real estate in the Nation. The ENTIRE nation. There is 0.000000% chance it will be bought up for low income or medium income housing. There is 0.00000% chance it will be set aside for nature. Many are multi-multi-millionaires who have already stated they are going to rebuild, rebuild bigger.

These multi-millionaires will buy more expensive and better lawyers than the city to fight city land grabs. (Municipal lawyer are on the low end of experience and pay scale) They will Lawfare the city for as long as it takes. They're already well connected to city officials and will make backroom deals, as they've done in the past.

I'm super interested in how this will play out. But it won't be for the little guy. There are Billions of dollars of real estate on the line. Money will take care of money. As it always has. Count on it.


Edit - Just googled up CA costal property. Approx only 58% is private, the other 42% is public. That's actually a lot more public than I was expecting.

Mark5767

(1 post)
3. Mark5767
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 09:15 AM
Jan 12

I’m so tired of billionaires. They have turned this country into an oligarchy, they have no respect for those who work themselves to death to stay 30 days ahead of homelessness. If people making in excess of 10mm a year paid their fair share, which would have far less impact in their quality of life-QOL than it does the majority of Americans. They got their man though, and now the money table gets leaned to the right even farther. Of course they’ll rebuild. Of course Malibu isn’t public property. That’s an illusion created by the ordinances that aren’t enforced. Billionaires destroy everything they touch these days and care not a whit about those whose money got them there. What really blows me away is that they are so stupid and arrogant they think we’ll just keep showing deference and allowing them to create a “New Rich Order” with Donny as their fake billionaire leader. Tax them at 70% like many other countries. Are the Stones and Sir Paul hurting? I believe they pay huge taxes to remain subjects.

speak easy

(11,115 posts)
5. "A. 50-year battle for public beach access in Malibu
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 09:30 AM
Jan 12
Although Californians have legally had access to all beaches in the state since 1976,  locals are still fighting for their rights to access Carbon Beach, also known as Billionaire’s Beach, in Malibu.

https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/malibu-public-beach-access/3203933/

DBoon

(23,389 posts)
23. Wealthy home owners have put up fake "No Parking" signs to keep visitors out
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:11 AM
Jan 12
https://www.cbsnews.com/losangeles/news/malibu-residents-post-fake-no-parking-signs-to-ward-off-tourists/

MALIBU (CBS) — Residents of Malibu who don't want beach visitors parking in front of their high priced homes are reportedly taking matters into their own hands.

Locals in the exclusive community and highly trafficked tourist hot spot have been posting fake no parking signs along Pacific Coast Highway. The signs are illegal, but often look so legitimate they earn violators parking citations.

Hekate

(95,948 posts)
45. The Central. Coast is a large curve, meaning the Pacific Ocean is to our south
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:13 PM
Jan 12

As you drive North or South on 101, the sun can blind you at certain times of the day.

Strange, but true.

MineralMan

(148,372 posts)
7. Actually Malibu Beach access is pretty easy.
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 09:54 AM
Jan 12

There are beach access points all along that waterfront area. Or there were, anyhow. Now, access points are moot until the rebuilding happens. Here's a map that shows all access points in Malibu, along with directions to get to the access paths. It's a PDF file at the link.

https://documents.coastal.ca.gov/assets/access/MalibuGuide2010.pdf

MineralMan

(148,372 posts)
10. If you look at that PDF, you'll see two public access points to Carbon Beach.
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 10:16 AM
Jan 12

They're right there.

Now, I think that houses should not be built on the beach. That is allowed, though, but access up to the mean high tide line is guaranteed in California, with a few very specific exceptions. You can't go to beaches that are on military bases, or on beaches that are in front of nuclear power plants, for example.

speak easy

(11,115 posts)
12. "What's behind a 50-year battle for public beach access in Malibu"
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 10:26 AM
Jan 12
Although Californians have legally had access to all beaches in the state since 1976, locals are still fighting for their rights to access Carbon Beach, also known as Billionaire’s Beach, in Malibu.

https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/malibu-public-beach-access/3203933/

August 2023. Buying up a pair of properties on the beach would put the issue to bed once and for all.

MineralMan

(148,372 posts)
13. Well, I'm pretty sure it's not a high priority at this moment.
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 10:33 AM
Jan 12

There is an opportunity here, though, and I'm sure it will be looked at. Yes, the battle for the beaches has gone on for many decades. It will, no doubt, continue. I grew up in Southern California. As a teenager, I spent a good deal of time on Malibu beaches. Someone was always yelling at us to get off their beach. We just gave them the finger and kept walking. I mean, that's why we were there, wasn't it?

If we had just wanted to swim or sunbathe, there were hundreds of beaches available, all up and down the coast. People wanted to go to Malibu just because it was Malibu and you might see someone famous. It wasn't about the beach, itself.

Now, I live in Minnesota. Here, it's access to lakes. Wealthy people don't want you to have access. The state mandates access. I have done a lot of fishing on lakes around the Twin Cities. I can't count the number of times some moron in a big-ass house came out and yelled at me to "Get off my lake!" I'm a lot older now, but my reaction remains the same. I just give them the finger and keep right on fishing.

Farmer-Rick

(11,617 posts)
35. I've heard that the people in those houses on Carbon beach
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 12:04 PM
Jan 12

Would build gates walls and fences across the public access points. Yeah, if they got reported they would take them down, very slowly. Then they would turn around and put them right back up. Then they got a free beach, until the government took some major action. If you're rich it's no worse than landscaping costs.

Some of the residents have resorted to posting fake signs of all kinds. Your link shows what are real signs and what are fake signs. The filthy-rich want it all, every nice thing, every bit of comfort, all the beauty and wealth out there.

MineralMan

(148,372 posts)
36. Well, now their luxury beach mansions are just ashes.
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 12:10 PM
Jan 12

But, so are other people's homes nearby that aren't nearly as luxurious. On the other hand, there are zero affordable houses in the Palisades. It's a rich person's city on the coast.

JohnnyRingo

(19,570 posts)
18. I've been following that as well.
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 10:47 AM
Jan 12

I don't care how old it is, I have to read Trudeau's work.

David Geffen in the crosshairs of Old Surfer Dude. haha
One of the things I thought so beautiful about the Golden State was the public beach law.

Magoo48

(5,803 posts)
11. That's correct, I've been watching wealthy folks block access to public beaches since 1960.
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 10:16 AM
Jan 12

In 1960, I was 12 yeas old and just beginning to surf off beaches between Long Beach and our southern border. Battling with private and government municipalities for access to and conservation of beaches is ongoing. The military and other government entities lock the beaches away and rich folks, well, they behave like privileged rich folks.

Response to speak easy (Original post)

Clouds Passing

(3,449 posts)
20. Don't allow them to rebuild there. There's not enough space. Should be open beach. Those houses are (were) monstrosities
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 10:55 AM
Jan 12

.

FakeNoose

(36,451 posts)
32. I'm guessing it has been local (or county) zoning groups that made this mess
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:50 AM
Jan 12

If Uncle Sam and the State of California are going to share the cost of rebuilding the burned properties, then they need to set the regulations for how the replacement structures will be built. They'll need to make sure there is ample parking and access to the public.

If the billionaires don't like it, tough shit. Let them move out to an island somewhere. The local zoning authorities have really messed it up good.

niyad

(121,845 posts)
21. I used to hate driving through Malibu, looking at those monstrosities
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:03 AM
Jan 12

littering the beach. I often wondered what would happen in the event of a tsunami.

Old Okie

(211 posts)
28. Carbon Beach
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:32 AM
Jan 12

Well; at least it is aptly named now! Few years ago I visited a Private beach club right on Santa Monica Beach; It was for the wealrhy to enjoy the beach; no riff raff allowed.

JI7

(91,236 posts)
46. The beaches are but homeowners make it difficult to access
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:30 PM
Jan 12

that's why I think it's better not to have private residential places there.

twodogsbarking

(12,498 posts)
29. Poverty is our greatest enemy.
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:40 AM
Jan 12

It kills eduction.
It kills proper medical care.
It kills nutrition.
It kills humans.
There is too great a divide between the "haves" and the "have-nots".
It shouldn't be this way, anywhere, in any country.
WTF.

Renew Deal

(83,441 posts)
30. If it doesn't happen in FL, NC, etc, why should it happen in CA?
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 11:47 AM
Jan 12

How many wealthy democratic donors would that impact?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Malibu: No more 'Billiona...