General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTrump must be held accountable for the crash in DC.
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/trump-aviation-safety-tsa-coast-guard_n_67912023e4b039fc12780c73The aviation security committee, which was mandated by Congress after the 1988 PanAm 103 bombing over Lockerbie, Scotland, will technically continue to exist but it wont have any members to carry out the work of examining safety issues at airlines and airports. Before Tuesday, the group included representatives of all the key groups in the industry including the airlines and major unions as well as members of a group associated with the victims of the PanAm 103 bombing. The vast majority of the groups recommendations were adopted over the years.
It wasnt immediately clear how many other committees were effectively eliminated Tuesday or whether other departments will take similar actions. A similar safety group advises the Federal Railroad Administration on new rules and safety issues in that industry.
I naively thought, oh theyre not going to do anything in the new administration, to put security at risk aviation security at risk. But Im not so sure, said Stephanie Bernstein, whose husband was killed in the bombing and served on the committee.
The future of the committee remains unclear because DHS officials didnt respond Tuesday to questions about the move. The memo that announced the terminations said that future committee activities will be focused on advancing our critical mission to protect the homeland and support DHSs strategic priorities but the group has no members.
How many federal employees who were responsible for safety, resigned after Trumps mass email threat to them?
On Tuesday, the US office of personnel management (OPM) sent nearly all of its 3 million employees an email offering them deferred resignations and warning that, if they choose to stay, they may be laid off or reassigned.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jan/29/trump-federal-workers-resignation-offer-reaction
The SOB owns this disaster. We need to hang this on him, directly.
kerry-is-my-prez
(9,523 posts)Hassler
(3,951 posts)Was money stolen from Air Traffic controllers?
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)along with all federal employees. How many did? There was already a shortage.
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)ATC, from what I have heard, is 30% understaffed. My source also said that it takes about 3 full years to train a controller.......
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)I didn't realize it took three years to train. Wow! And it's a terribly stressful job from what I understand.
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,695 posts)but there is a high burnout rate among ATC's, it's got to be a very high stress job, one I certainly wouldn't want.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)fishing bodies and those who survived out of the freezing water, while republicans disparage and threaten them as public servants.
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)My source says it is way, way, beyond stressful currently. They are only supposed to work so many hours, so many days, have MANDATORY breaks during their shifts, etc. All of which has gone out the window to keep up with the huge amount of passenger aircraft and freight aircraft flying in the air...due to the shortage.
Apparently, the Air Traffic Controllers/Towers for the Military are totally separate/independent from the U.S. Government ATC.......Different navigation systems, Different landing "systems" and "procedures", Different radio channels, different controllers, etc etc
You would think that the military aircraft would be under the control U.S. ATC, at least coordinated, especially when operating in densely congested air space here in U.S.???? in order to avoid nightmares like last night......
We live near Buckley air base in Aurora. They have two F something or others, fully armed on standby at all time after 9/11.
Every week or two, they are "scrambled" due to some airline deviating from normal..... We live about 5-10 miles from the base. When they take off, most of the time they come right over our house, at maybe less than 1000??? feet, with a really high noise level, appearing to be going wherever they please. If they have their "after-burners" on, the noise is deafening, rattling windows. My source says they are supposed to adhere to certain flight paths when taking off, etc, but they seem to sometimes ignore that, making things crazy for the Civilian ATC.....
(I gotta tell you MCE, that if true, it is utterly disgusting to me that Trump is blaming the crash on the "Diversity employment" factor this morning according to NBC).....
At any rate, the complete FAA/NTSB final report on the cause of the crash will be issued two? years from now, long forgotten, except by families and friends of the deceased.........Any information re: the crash, prior to that, is just speculation.........
cloudbase
(5,861 posts)ATC was in contact with the helicopter and was told to pass behind the AA aircraft.
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)Amazing that a You Tuber tells the true and most likely cause of the Crash. None of the major Media, with all its money and resources have explained the crash with anywhere near this amount of detail
.
Could be that the Media doesnt want to say anything that would conflict with Trumps "Presidential Orders"/agenda, esp his recent appointments that will have MAJOR effects on lowering air traffic safety
(95+% of all media in the U.S. is owned/operated by Uber Rich Republicans ????) His recent appointments in several positions affecting Air Traffic Safety, have gone to individuals totally and completely un-qualified for the positions
..Noem, Duffy, ETC
..
I knew much of this from knowing an incredibly experienced ATC, who was an ATC for the Military for 8 years, before becoming a U.S. Federal ATC for the last 9+ years. He has talked for years about the Civilian and Military air traffic controllers both being somewhat in the dark about what the other was doing due to dramatically different communication and navigation systems......
We are 5 miles from a Military airbase. That airbase has two F somethings that are scrambled every week or every couple of weeks due to commercial jets appearing to be in question of their intentions. They fly about 500-1000 feet over our house, with afterburners on, having an incredible roar and rattling windows in our house......I asked him if their take off's and flights were monitored/directed/coordinated by the Civilian "Denver ATC"....................He just laughed..........
MichMan
(13,980 posts)Typically, FAA investigations take months.
Is that the cause of the crash? Understaffing?
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)At any rate, usually the "complete" FAA/NTSB final report on the cause of the crash will be issued two? years from now, the crash probably long forgotten, except by families and friends of the deceased.........Any information re: the crash, prior to that, is just speculation.........
(I gotta tell you, that if true, it is utterly disgusting to me that Trump is reportedly, partly blaming the crash on the "Diversity Employment" factor this morning according to NBC).....
HereForTheParty
(530 posts)That's what we need to know.
Jmb 4 Harris-Walz
(1,068 posts)Silent Type
(7,929 posts)Most, if not all, trump voters will believe him.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)He's the one who just requested all federal employees resign asap. Trump is the one who negated the need for federal government workers.
Do Trumpers KNOW that the FAA and the Coast Guard etc. are "the government?" Gawd, they're idiots.
Nixie
(17,509 posts)military appointee who wants to change the military. The messaging should not let up about this tragedy. Eliminating federal employees has made air travel unsafe. Trump is responsible.
Nine days in and 60 civilian airline passengers died* from a midair collision with a military helicopter?? Im so livid.
Our whole economy revolves around consumer confidence. Trump is creating so much chaos, and now there is a deadly outcome.
*60 passengers onboard, not recovered yet.
Silent Type
(7,929 posts)mzmolly
(51,812 posts)on 911. He should have been held accountable, quickly.
Silent Type
(7,929 posts)into his regime that blaming the MFer will achieve anything among the 5% of voters that really matter. Sure, great for us, but what are we going to do call for a Congressional investigation of trumps role.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)He looked like a martyr then. He wasnt in charge. He was playing the victim.
What are we supposed to do, not criticize him for the next four years? Count on the Republican Congress and Senate to do a fair investigation?
Trump just requested mass resignations from the very people who can help prevent situations like this. He owns it.
and they rattled the sabers for those 8 months leading up to 9/11 too. Me and my Mom lived in total fear each and every month wondering when something was going to blow up. After breakfast or dinner, I'd say "Well, Mom, let's go see if something blew up." Then I'd roll her to the TV room to transfer her to her lift chair & turn on the news. And then something did happen. True story.
Well, Mom's gone now, but here we are again, but this time only 8 days after a Republican took office.
Think. Again.
(20,995 posts)Silent Type
(7,929 posts)Think. Again.
(20,995 posts)And yet again, are we doing enough now?
SocialDemocrat61
(3,378 posts)for the withdrawal from Afghanistan less than 6 months into his term.
Blue_Roses
(13,604 posts)and stupid, callous thing to say, especially, since this is an ongoing investigation. And to bring politics into this with all these grieving families right now, is just plain inhumane. But, like usual Trump form, he'll find someone to take the blame
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)I gotta tell you, that if true, it is utterly disgusting to me that Trump is already blaming the crash on the "Diversity employment" factor this morning according to NBC.....
RainCaster
(11,893 posts)He deserves the blame. It's happened while he is in charge and changing how the govt works. How's this working so far?
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)eom
Hassin Bin Sober
(26,837 posts)newdeal2
(1,468 posts)Replacing qualified folks with his TV stooges like Pete and our new secretary of transportation.
Initech
(103,192 posts)And they will only make things worse. A plane crash happens on the same day they fire 100 people from the FAA? Just the stupidity... argh!
DJ Synikus Makisimus
(859 posts)mzmolly
(51,812 posts)now.
Granted, it's too soon to know what specifically occurred. But Trump suggesting that federal workers (including FAA employees) are disposable, while demanding a mass resignation a couple days ago, should wake a few people up.
DJ Synikus Makisimus
(859 posts)Disaffected
(5,291 posts)Sounds like an accusation the Repubs would make...
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)in this situation, given Trump just asked for the resignations of every federal employee (including air traffic controllers) a few days ago.
Or, do you think we should let that slide?
Disaffected
(5,291 posts)The point is the two circumstances may (or may not) be totally unrelated. It is much too early to determine or even speculate what the cause of the crash might be.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)Last edited Thu Jan 30, 2025, 12:57 AM - Edit history (1)
It's still important to point out that Trump considers federal employees disposable and told them to resign or be fired, when we already have a shortage in these critical positions.
So, I don't care about a direct relationship frankly. But, I'd venture to guess there is one.
Disaffected
(5,291 posts)If the two are shown after investigation to be unrelated I trust you will issue a retraction of the accusation(?).
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)once Trump starts telling the truth, how about that?
BannonsLiver
(18,525 posts)The whole my honorable friend bit.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)kerry-is-my-prez
(9,523 posts)mzmolly
(51,812 posts)And they would do it quickly. And they would do it on every social media platform. And they would have their talking points down - all of them.
BattleRow
(1,315 posts)MichMan
(13,980 posts)LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)It looks like the airline was approaching the runway correctly. Therefore, it appears to be the military craft's fault. Was their an ATC issue? I have no idea? But why did the helicopter fly into it? The helicopter was flying parallel to the Potomac. ATC asks the helicopter if they can see the plane
Audio between PAT25 and DCA tower asking if they have the CRJ in sight. Affirms and requests visual separation.
Link to tweet
(This is why I still have twitter)
Disaffected
(5,291 posts)Yes, If. That's the point - we don't know one way or the other now so claims that Trump is responsible are at this point without basis.
questionseverything
(10,388 posts)mzmolly
(51,812 posts)Or, did you miss that?
LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)Did any cuts he made in the past 10 days involving ATC or the military etc? Were hours cut resulting in decreased staff? Was there a decrease in supplies, support staff? etc etc...
I'm sure his statements resulted in decreased morale. However, that will not be made public because, then they will just blame ATC for all of this.
It appears that the helicopter didn't see the airplane until it was too late.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)The helicopter might have been warned, with sufficient air traffic control.
Trump doesn't deserve the benefit of the doubt, here. Fox News will cover for him.
LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)The coast guard isn't responsible for the flights.
ATC has been around much longer than TSA. TSA are the people who operate X-ray machines and make you take your shoes off and check your bags etc.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)You also skipped right over the resign now, or be fired later threats to federal workers.
Im sure Trump will have plenty of apologists that share your sentiments. I plan to encourage dem leaders to hold him accountable regardless.
happybird
(5,311 posts)This was a tragic accident and not political. They will be pulling bodies out of the freezing Potomac all night. Have some respect.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)I have respect for the people that died on Trumps watch. Criticizing his leadership does not disrespect those who perished. Criticizing his desire to gut the federal government, which prevents tragedies like these - is important to point out. May the deaths of those who perished not be in vain.
It is respectful to not start pointing fingers and trying to lay blame -with no evidence and scant facts about the accident- when the victims and possible survivors haven't even been recovered from the wreckage and water. At the time of the OP, it was not known if there were any survivors.
Furthermore, those of us in and around DC can be especially touchy about respecting the families and victims of plane crashes in the icy Potomac. We've seen the herculean and heartbreaking rescue efforts of this very situation before, live as it happened, and it was traumatic af.
Blaming the current administration for the accident because of a hiring freeze implemented last week is definitely jumping the gun. It sounds like Trump Derangement Syndrome, tbh. The whole "blame them first because they'll just blame us."
I get it, but: time and place, man. Time and place.
What he has done is, indeed, horrible. I hate him and would like nothing more than to blame him and effin Elon for everything that goes wrong. There's a scary amount of things we'll being going through over the next few years that will be directly and obviously their fault. But, air traffic controllers take their job VERY seriously. The same number of people were likely working last night as there were a few weeks ago, during the prior administration. Changes in such a hugely important, controlled and regulated industry don't happen overnight. Or over few weeks, even. Especially when it involves security around DC, in any capacity.
Accident are terrible but they do happen. Wait for the facts, the actual details of went wrong in a tragedy like this one, before laying blame. Let the families of the passengers know if their loved one is even alive before pointing fingers at politicians. That's what is respectful.
Just my 2 cents.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)that prevent situations like this. He's also blaming "DEI" - today.
Read through the points made in this thread, and tell me he has no blame.
It's time Democrats held Trump accountable for his failures, without waiting for the obvious to present itself. We must start controlling the narrative, or that asshat will continue to do so. He needs to be on defense vs. offense - for once.
happybird
(5,311 posts)around DCA for years.
https://www.cnn.com/2025/01/30/us/dca-plane-helicopter-crash-invs/index.html
The time and place to get him will certainly arise, and probably sooner rather than later. This is not the time and place, imho. We need to be better than them. How is this any different than how gross it felt when trump and his nasty posse of bootlickers blamed Gov. Newsom for the still ongoing wildfires?
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)As a result, many air controllers at the airport work up to 10 hours a day and six days a week. Those levels probably have not been helped by Donald Trumps federal hiring freeze, his gutting of the Aviation Security Advisory Committee, and the FAA chiefs resignation at Elon Musks behest. As much as Trump and the right might try to blame DEI or something else ludicrous, perhaps they should look in the mirror.
Cha
(306,639 posts)"respect" Does that Fuck Face have?
Oh and mzmolly is Showing RESPECT by calling out the LIAR.
Cha
(306,639 posts)Thank You,!
"The Federal Aviation Administrations leader stepped down on Jan. 20, months after Elon Musk demanded that he quit."
https://www.thedailybeast.com/faa-chief-michael-whitaker-quit-on-jan-20-after-elon-musk-told-him-to-resign/
LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)mzmolly
(51,812 posts)mzmolly
(51,812 posts)kerry-is-my-prez
(9,523 posts)Flurry of White House Actions Reaching into Aviation
Regs are on halt, ASAC dismantled, and key agency positions vacant
-snip-
While it is unclear at this point how long this process will take, it harkens back to the early days of the first Trump Administration when regulations halted, including key safety actions such as airworthiness directives, for several weeks.
-snip-
In addition, the White House has put a hiring freeze in place, prohibiting the replacement of open government positions or the creation of new ones while the administration evaluates reductions in the workforce. The White House plans to release a memorandum with further guidance within 90 days. This has drawn criticism from lawmakers as the FAA has been ramping up controller hiring.
"The bipartisan FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 directs the Administration to hire the maximum number of air traffic controllers. Thats what the law says, so the Administration must rescind this ridiculous executive order, said Rick Larsen (D-Washington), the ranking member on the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee. Hiring air traffic controllers is the number one safety issue according to the entire aviation industry. Instead of working to improve aviation safety and lower costs for hardworking American families, the Administration is choosing to spread bogus DEI [diversity, equity, and inclusion] claims to justify this decision."
Among the other early White House actions has been the dismantling of the long-standing Aviation Security Advisory Committee (ASAC) that was under TSAs purview. The government/industry advisory group was established in 1989 after the terrorist attack on Pan Am Flight 103 and became a permanent structure in 2014.
LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)And DOGE Musk is designing a new AF-1!
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)with a 30% shortage of ATC, you all should have been around when Ronald Reagan, overnight, FIRED over 50% of ATC when he was in office.
Several commercial airline pilots I knew back then, told me that they were way beyond frightened while flying after that...............
and that fear lasted for YEARS due to the difficulty in training replacements............
Incidentally they also stated that Air Traffic Controllers had to space planes farther apart for safety under the situation, and it resulted in serious delays for their passengers. They also pointed out, that they were ORDERED not to say to the passengers, that the delay was due to Air Traffic Controllers......
BTW, both pilots had tens of thousands of hours flying commercial passenger jets, both were die hard Republicans, and also voted for Reagan for a second term........imagine that....LOL
BTW, this 30% shortage in ATC began back in Trump's first term. And interestingly ATC during the Covid period were EVEN BUSIER than normal, even though many passenger flights were cancelled.....this was due to the huge increase in Air Freight flights of PPE going on around he country and supplies coming in from other countries on freight aircraft.......
ElementaryPenguin
(7,854 posts)mzmolly
(51,812 posts)BidenRocks
(1,021 posts)Noem as head of Homeland security runs the Coast Guard.
Chump is at fault just by being president.
questionseverything
(10,388 posts)LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)That was all that was available as I watching everything unfold on Agenda Free TV last night.
There have been quite a few articles written today.
BannonsLiver
(18,525 posts)It should be made clear that Trump wants to gut aviation safety. Theres no reason not to exploit that weakness.
Disaffected
(5,291 posts)Yeah, and apparently endless rationalizations for doing so (just like the Repugs).
Frankly I think Trump and his cronies are going to crash and burn on their own and there is little to be gained by going down with them.
BannonsLiver
(18,525 posts)Talk about obtuse. Oof.
Disaffected
(5,291 posts)Plonk.
BannonsLiver
(18,525 posts)lame54
(37,381 posts)mzmolly
(51,812 posts)H2O Man
(76,071 posts)LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)Maybe congress will hold his feet to the fire and realize how foolish he is.
All the Rs can see is, "We won. We won. We won"....
Maybe this will knock some sense into their empty heads!
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)eom
LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)He only cares about himself
newdeal2
(1,468 posts)Musk is working on the new Air Force One. Im sure even Trump has seen his SpaceX rockets go boom.
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)There are actually TWO being built.......
They both started production during Trump's first term........
Trump didn't like the exterior paint job, designed by Jacquie Kennedy when they were built.
Sooooo, he ordered a new exterior paint job. Three horizontal bands of color: Red White and Blue. Much like the Russian Flag, but in a different order........
Biden cancelled his exterior paint order. Now Trump will dictate a return to the RWB stripes.......
leighbythesea2
(1,236 posts)Philosophically approached the way the Titan submersible was. No time for regulatory groups to examine. Billionaire techies & their followers seem to like this.
Hekate
(95,916 posts)C Moon
(12,667 posts)Look up while walking under any windows of high-rise buildings. I'm sure that's coming next.
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)CABAL much better defines his group.....Look it up in the dictionary.......
Reagan's CABAL, WBUSH's CABAL, which coincidentally, had a large number of Reagan's CABAL...
Cha
(306,639 posts)Orders!
Unless We STOP IT!
LetMyPeopleVote
(157,239 posts)LeftInTX
(31,967 posts)ultralite001
(1,299 posts)F47 fired the head of TSA...
F47 illegally fired the entire Aviation Security Advisory Committee mandated by Congress...
F47 put a hiring freeze on all air traffic controllers...
The blood is on F47's hands...
Doodley
(10,487 posts)OAITW r.2.0
(29,207 posts)Why would you think he'd be responsible for a plane crash?
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)a qualified group, having studied the U.S. Covid Deaths during the Pandemic states that
there were an ADDITIONAL 500,000+ deaths in the U.S. directly due to Trump's actions/inactions and also due to all the same with Republican Senators and House Members............
Another epidemic/pandemic, avian flu, is on our door step, and Trump has already cancelled our membership in the World Health Organization, and will be eliminating or cancelling the National Disease Control agency..... In addition he appointed RFK jr to office and he is trying to cancel ALL vaccine mandates in the U.S. including kids vaccinations.
I is rumored that, in fact, Kennedy made sure to have HIS grandchildren vaccinated with all the normal childhood vaccinations.
Maybe that is their plan; to vaccinate THEIR kids and Republicans, and encourage their 74+ Million voters to not get vaccinated along with all the dems......."Creative Genocide" ???????????????????????????????????
DET
(1,798 posts)No problem - former realty show personality and Fox News contributor Sean Duffy has been confirmed as the Secretary of Transportation. As evidenced by the news conference on the tragedy tonight, he will um his way through this ordeal.
Dave Bowman
(4,373 posts)OrlandoDem2
(2,409 posts)Budget cuts impacting federal workers at airports will be devastating.
Response to OrlandoDem2 (Reply #64)
Name removed Message auto-removed
AntiFascist
(12,990 posts)BoRaGard
(3,763 posts)what kind of a commander finks out in a crisis? The republicon kind.
spanone
(138,029 posts)➡️ January 20: FAA director fired
➡️ January 21: Air Traffic Controller hiring frozen
➡️ January 22: Aviation Safety Advisory Committee disbanded
➡️ January 28: Buyout/retirement demand sent to existing employees
➡️ January 29: First American mid-air collision in 16 years
C_U_L8R
(45,979 posts)Not just incompetent or negligent, it's was purposeful and criminal. Trump should face the consequences.
NCDem47
(2,611 posts)That's where we're at.
Oneear
(332 posts)Travelers Need to Have Safe Sky Travel, and Congress Needs to have more Air Traffic Controllers Working to Keep Us Safe
DENVERPOPS
(10,580 posts)I gotta tell you, that if true, it is utterly disgusting to me that Trump is blaming the crash cause, on the "Diversity employment" factor this morning according to NBC.....
MINORITY AIR TRAFFIC CONROLLERS ARE TO BLAME !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bernardo de La Paz
(52,133 posts)MichMan
(13,980 posts)Every Democrat need to repeat that ad nauseum
Bettie
(17,608 posts)but he's never held accountable for anything.
Karasu
(473 posts)It's up to us to do so.
Kablooie
(18,823 posts)There is normally one controller for landing and another for takeoffs.
This guy was assigned both.
I haven't heard why this happened though.
mzmolly
(51,812 posts)in addition to the victims of the crash.