Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 05:17 AM Mar 2025

Social Security

I've been following debate on how much at risk is Social Security. Some think we are safe and naysayers are fearmongering. Others believe it is hopeless.

The main point right now is that we are even having this debate. I've heard about Republicans wanting to cut or privatize SS for decades. But I never really worried. I assumed that elected officials would have to vote on it and then face their voters in a few years.
Now we are looking for our payment each month uncertain whether it will be there. The very uncertainty is abuse. We don't need this to last until next month; we need it to last for 25 years.

This is only a crisis because Elon Musk, not Congress, are making decisions. Besides the worry that there won't be another election to make anyone accountable.

52 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Social Security (Original Post) MadameButterfly Mar 2025 OP
Retired with health issues and SS retirement is my only income but I am a fighter and will survive..live in my car or wcmagumba Mar 2025 #1
We need fighters like you right now MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #2
I am retired for 10 years, fortunately with no health issues.I elocs Mar 2025 #13
I would hope that after 34 years your mortgage would PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 2025 #17
This message was self-deleted by its author Rebl2 Mar 2025 #31
This person Rebl2 Mar 2025 #32
You are correct. PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 2025 #46
Some locales have very high taxes UpInArms Mar 2025 #52
House and Senate Republicans have this magical thinking that if no_hypocrisy Mar 2025 #3
Good point. The cowards talk about being proud to represent their constituents, but they're sucking up to tRump Timeflyer Mar 2025 #12
I don't believe there will be accountability at the polls in '26. elocs Mar 2025 #14
Yep. Musk will have bamagal62 Mar 2025 #34
Then it's the responsibility of every State Mossfern Mar 2025 #35
i agree with paper ballots MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #40
They are creating the anxiety and fear on purpose. Irish_Dem Mar 2025 #4
Exactly. n/t Mister Ed Mar 2025 #5
We made them billionaires, their money trickled UP from us. All of us. Meadowoak Mar 2025 #7
Exactly. We made them billionaires. Irish_Dem Mar 2025 #10
Actually we spend a lot of money on products MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #20
I have been thinking about making an OP with the point you are making. Irish_Dem Mar 2025 #23
The point is we spend money like everyone else if we have it MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #24
They make more money stealing SS and Medicare funds. Irish_Dem Mar 2025 #28
Not in the long run MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #41
It is imperative they act quickly and it is a short term. Irish_Dem Mar 2025 #43
You got it. And yet, MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #47
Their greed is a severe sickness and they are obsessed with money. Irish_Dem Mar 2025 #48
Bernie made that point quite eloquently in his Kenosha Wisconsin speech MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #49
Yes the billionaires are mentally ill and destroying the planet. Irish_Dem Mar 2025 #50
This message was self-deleted by its author MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #25
mineral man had a post on this subject. AllaN01Bear Mar 2025 #6
is there a way to find that post? MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #51
It's the unknown that's scary. William769 Mar 2025 #8
They think we just have it too easy getting 2000 a month from Social Security. While, they live on their billions. Walleye Mar 2025 #9
No way Rebl2 Mar 2025 #33
The very uncertainty is abuse. 2naSalit Mar 2025 #11
This. K&R. n/t ms liberty Mar 2025 #15
I need SS to last until next month, then the next and the next and the next.......................... elocs Mar 2025 #16
If, not when MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #26
I hear lots of objections that people would riot... mike_c Mar 2025 #18
This needs to be a battle the soldiers aren't willing to fight. MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #27
I agree. The fact that we have to have this conversation, is in itself a problem. yellow dahlia Mar 2025 #19
This "Now we are looking for our payment each month uncertain whether it will be there." Alice B. Mar 2025 #21
The fear is legit if you have read Project 2025 JCMach1 Mar 2025 #22
greenspan fucked up. we need to eliminate the cap. or means test. pansypoo53219 Mar 2025 #29
or just raise the cap as Reagan and Tip ONeill MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #36
Was it up to Greenspan? MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #38
My solution. Remove the cap. Let Elon pay multigraincracker Mar 2025 #30
Put Elon in jaile and take all his money MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #37
Put him in chains and a dark cell. JanMichael Mar 2025 #44
An illegal immigrant stealing our public money. I thought Orange Judas travelingthrulife Mar 2025 #39
I already have over the 40 work credits required in SS. JanMichael Mar 2025 #42
It would be the biggest heist in history MadameButterfly Mar 2025 #45

wcmagumba

(5,660 posts)
1. Retired with health issues and SS retirement is my only income but I am a fighter and will survive..live in my car or
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 05:36 AM
Mar 2025

whatever else I need to do. I can find a source of income somehow. F**k Trump and Musk....

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
2. We need fighters like you right now
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 05:43 AM
Mar 2025

but you shouldn't have to. I'm looking forward to your deserved retirement.

 

elocs

(24,486 posts)
13. I am retired for 10 years, fortunately with no health issues.I
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 08:11 AM
Mar 2025

I will live in my car if need be. But losing my home of 34 years will be heartbreaking, the place where my daughter grew up, a memory palace.
As it seems to be going to turn out, Social Security is not secure and its trust fund in untrustworthy. I am going to be robbed by the richest person in the world.

Response to PoindexterOglethorpe (Reply #17)

Rebl2

(17,416 posts)
32. This person
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 11:42 AM
Mar 2025

didn’t say their mortgage wasn’t paid off. They said they lived in their house for 34 years. Maybe they would hate to have to sell it to survive because they no longer received SS. Also, what’s it to you if their house wasn’t paid off yet. You don’t know that person’s circumstances.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(28,459 posts)
46. You are correct.
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 08:59 PM
Mar 2025

But I'm constantly amazed and horrified at how many people apparently spend every single penny of income, don't set aside as much as a dime, and then are bamboozled by their lack of money.

I'm here to tell you that it is possible to refrain from spending every possible penny. Keep in mind that there is probably someone down the street from you who takes in several thousand dollars a year less, and they are surviving. If they can, you can also. And cut back a bit so you can save something.,

I learned this lesson decades ago. I'd borrowed the money needed to buy my car, a VW bug (convertible, hooray!) and the payback from my checking account every two weeks was a bit more than the minimum needed. I only learned that when I went to borrow some money to do Christmas shopping, and learned I already had the sum I wanted to spend. Ever since then I understood the value of credit unions, and every time I had a job that offered one, I signed up.

$25.00/pay check isn't a lot of money, wasn't a lot more back in 1969 when I signed up to have that amount taken from every paycheck. But it added up. It still does.

UpInArms

(54,097 posts)
52. Some locales have very high taxes
Tue Mar 11, 2025, 08:23 AM
Mar 2025

Which can make it difficult to maintain if an income stream is lost

no_hypocrisy

(54,316 posts)
3. House and Senate Republicans have this magical thinking that if
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 05:58 AM
Mar 2025

they let Elon Musk decimate Social Security, THEY won't be held accountable.

Fools.

Congress has to pass a budget. And they have to vote on Musk's cuts. And be held accountable at the polls in 2026.

Timeflyer

(3,688 posts)
12. Good point. The cowards talk about being proud to represent their constituents, but they're sucking up to tRump
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 08:10 AM
Mar 2025

hoping we'll forget by their next election.

 

elocs

(24,486 posts)
14. I don't believe there will be accountability at the polls in '26.
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 08:17 AM
Mar 2025

Because I don't believe there will be elections, at least not free, fair, and legitimate elections.
Why would Trump allow Musk to do all he has done if he would get crucified in the '26 midterms by losing both the House and the Senate by huge impeachment and conviction margins?

Mossfern

(4,628 posts)
35. Then it's the responsibility of every State
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 12:07 PM
Mar 2025

and every County to have paper ballots! It may take some time to get final election results, but it's worth it.
Where I live, there are paper printouts of the vote, but even then, if it's going though a machine I wouldn't trust it.
We do have paper ballots that are read by the voting machines.

Hopefully this will help make elections Muskproof.

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
40. i agree with paper ballots
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 04:00 PM
Mar 2025

at least until Trump/Musk are gone and maybe forever. We just can't protect machines if we can't even protect our tax returns and social security. At least we'll know if the checks don't come. if the votes aren't counted, we'll never know.

Irish_Dem

(79,899 posts)
4. They are creating the anxiety and fear on purpose.
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 06:01 AM
Mar 2025

This is typical in a fascist regime to make people more docile and compliant.

And yes, cutting SS and Medicare is a real possibility.
Trump is very cruel and he and the billionaires want the SS fund for themselves.

Also it is consistent with their philosophy that the old and sick are useless eaters.
We make no money for the billionaires, so why feed us?

Irish_Dem

(79,899 posts)
10. Exactly. We made them billionaires.
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 07:33 AM
Mar 2025

They did not do it alone.

We provided an educated, responsible workforce.

We paid taxes to provide transportation, local safety and security, police, fire, etc.
A stable country where they were free to make as much money as they wanted.

US taxpayers provided the entire infrastructure for them to get rich.

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
20. Actually we spend a lot of money on products
Sat Mar 8, 2025, 04:03 PM
Mar 2025

for their businesses and stock holdings. SS is good for the economy.

These guys just see the tax breaks and don't understand where their wealth came from in the first place. Proof that having money doesn't make you smart.

Irish_Dem

(79,899 posts)
23. I have been thinking about making an OP with the point you are making.
Sat Mar 8, 2025, 04:44 PM
Mar 2025

The American taxpayer and consumer made the billionaires what they are.
And they hate us and want to destroy us.

And yes, older people may have a bit more leeway in the budget with the kids
out of the house and on their own.

It was not until I retired that I did a few things for myself.

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
24. The point is we spend money like everyone else if we have it
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 11:01 AM
Mar 2025

and if you take away SS we don't have it. What does loss of SS do to Senior buying power? What if we collectively have 50% less money and we are 20% of the population? That would be a 10% reduction in consumer spending. That doesn't count younger people and children affected by having someone in their household drawing SS.

When does anything that big happen to the economy? The repercussions would be huge.
This just isn't good for business.

Irish_Dem

(79,899 posts)
28. They make more money stealing SS and Medicare funds.
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 11:19 AM
Mar 2025

Compared to allowing us to spend it.

They cut out the middleman.

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
41. Not in the long run
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 04:10 PM
Mar 2025

and not for everybody. Because you won't have people paying into SS if the benefits have been stolen. The loss in business income will be long term, the cache they steal can only happen once. And fewer people will prosper from the stolen benefits than a healthy economy.
But thieves think short term--especially if they are old, and Republicans and Oligarchs chronically think short term so they want to cash in. That's why they can't consider climate change, or future generations.

Irish_Dem

(79,899 posts)
43. It is imperative they act quickly and it is a short term.
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 04:27 PM
Mar 2025

I believe the billionaires know that climate change is real and will cause a great deal of damage and change in lifestyle.

They also see the fascist alliance coming to global power.

All of this cuts into their profits so I think they are raking it as fast as they can
before the shit hits the fan.

Irish_Dem

(79,899 posts)
48. Their greed is a severe sickness and they are obsessed with money.
Tue Mar 11, 2025, 07:09 AM
Mar 2025

It is an addiction and it doesn't matter that they cannot take it with them.

They already have more money than they or their heirs can spend in a lifetime.

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
49. Bernie made that point quite eloquently in his Kenosha Wisconsin speech
Tue Mar 11, 2025, 07:54 AM
Mar 2025

which was recently posted on DU.

The fact that it has gone so far as to be an illness cannot be over-emphasized.
It's not one faction's interests against another's.
There are no needs being met here for the billionaires. It is beyond nonsense that the richest man in the world wants to get richer.

Irish_Dem

(79,899 posts)
50. Yes the billionaires are mentally ill and destroying the planet.
Tue Mar 11, 2025, 08:00 AM
Mar 2025

We need to keep saying this.

Response to Irish_Dem (Reply #23)

Walleye

(43,845 posts)
9. They think we just have it too easy getting 2000 a month from Social Security. While, they live on their billions.
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 07:09 AM
Mar 2025

Rebl2

(17,416 posts)
33. No way
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 11:47 AM
Mar 2025

do I get 2000 a month. I didn’t work for many years because of medical issues, so I get less than 800 a month.

 

elocs

(24,486 posts)
16. I need SS to last until next month, then the next and the next and the next..........................
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 08:27 AM
Mar 2025

I imagine that when the checks really stop that we will see an avalanche of confirmation by posters here. I don't believe I've seen one here that could be attributed to Musk's actions.
With 71 million getting SS, there must be many each month who don't receive theirs for one reason or another.

I just heard yesterday that my city's SSA office has closed--a western Wisconsin city of 50,000.

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
26. If, not when
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 11:05 AM
Mar 2025

Let's not assume it's going to really happen.
We must stop it from happening.

mike_c

(36,905 posts)
18. I hear lots of objections that people would riot...
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 01:38 PM
Mar 2025

...if SS is cut, but I also hear that TSF ordered his admin to prepare the way for invoking the Insurrection Act and initiating martial law. That would give him the ability to crush any resistance quickly.

My anxiety level is off the charts. Without SS we'll likely lose our house.

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
27. This needs to be a battle the soldiers aren't willing to fight.
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 11:17 AM
Mar 2025

Riots of course are not the solution but even peaceful demonstrations risk giving Trump an excuse.
We must overwhelmingly win the media battle on SS and other cuts and threatened cuts. People aren't for these things unless they are misinformed. That's why Bernie is making the rounds and Rachel is on every night. Of course we need to do more.

Already our Intelligence experts are upset at being suddenly forced to withdraw help to Ukraine after 10 years of dedicated help.
Rachel questioned whether the armed people letting DOGE into the lates federal agency were really US Marshalls. If not, I wonder if they couldn't get actual marshalls to do the job.

Soldiers have family on SS. They won't like to see their ranks purged by Musk and AI.
They need to understand that anything Trump orders them to do is illegal and against the wishes of the people.
No one signs up to serve the country and then attack it.

yellow dahlia

(4,607 posts)
19. I agree. The fact that we have to have this conversation, is in itself a problem.
Fri Mar 7, 2025, 07:21 PM
Mar 2025

And the fact that many are worried about their financial security, and whether their check will show up is abusive.

The way we are all living right now - waiting for the next hit on our institutions and our sense of stability, also feels abusive.

Alice B.

(697 posts)
21. This "Now we are looking for our payment each month uncertain whether it will be there."
Sat Mar 8, 2025, 04:13 PM
Mar 2025

I'm in a couple Facebook groups where I've noticed the retirees are checking in with each other on this each month.

It's horrible and I bring it up to my useless congresspeople whenever I call or write on the topic of SS.

Useless R Rep's recent reply claims Dems "lied" about SS and Medicaid and Medicare being endangered. *eyeroll*

JCMach1

(29,094 posts)
22. The fear is legit if you have read Project 2025
Sat Mar 8, 2025, 04:19 PM
Mar 2025

And know the agenda and philosophy of the Techno Fascists who are in charge of the government.

Your fears are legitimate people and don't let people gaslight you on the right, or left (or DU for that. Matter) and tell you they are not.

The key question is what do we do with that fear and information.

MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
36. or just raise the cap as Reagan and Tip ONeill
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 12:41 PM
Mar 2025

did back when the parties worked together sometimes. The cap hasn't even been raised to keep up with inflation, of course it can't keep up.

travelingthrulife

(4,463 posts)
39. An illegal immigrant stealing our public money. I thought Orange Judas
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 12:45 PM
Mar 2025

was going to do something about illegal immigrant crooks.

JanMichael

(25,725 posts)
42. I already have over the 40 work credits required in SS.
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 04:26 PM
Mar 2025

If I don't get it I will not say what I will do. paid into it off and on since 1984. It is a promise.

While I have a non federal defined benefit pension lined up SS is the proverbial icing on the retirement cake. I will not give up said icing without a serious fight.

Plus I have several relatives that have no real retirement other than SS so they need it more than we do. IE serious fight.



MadameButterfly

(3,746 posts)
45. It would be the biggest heist in history
Sun Mar 9, 2025, 04:48 PM
Mar 2025

The most money, the most victims. We have to fight the lies about corruption and insolvency. People need to understand there is something to lose. Especially young people who feel the cost of paying in but don't understand how much they'll need it someday.

Long before Trump I met young people who complained that SS wouldn't be there for them when they were old. SS is easy to fix but people don't know it. We have to educate them. And we have to expose Elon's lies.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Social Security