Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ificandream

(11,653 posts)
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 06:57 PM Apr 2025

The whole Bill Maher thing.

I used to be a big, big fan of Bill Maher. My family (wife, son, and me) even decided to get tickets to a rehearsal of his HBO show years ago, and we had a lot of fun. (The rehearsal had stand-ins for the eventual guests, but we did hear him do a test of his monologue for that week.) But I haven't watched Maher in years, especially as he's seemed to become moderate to the point of conservative.

I watched the clip of him explaining his visit to Trump and how he enjoyed it, and I can't help but think Trump was putting on a show, as he loves to do. Trump is a veteran television performer, and he and, I think, Maher know that. Why didn't Maher realize that? Why haven't we seen this side of Trump before? And will we see it again? I wouldn't bet the farm on it.

As for Maher's ho-hum attitude, in one respect, I get it because he's reporting on the performance that he saw. But the real question will be how Maher plays this out as Trump 2.0 continues. Initially, I was quite irritated with Maher, but after hearing his explanation, I realized there was room for it. It'll be interesting to see where he and Trump go with this. We'll then find out who the real actor is.

59 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The whole Bill Maher thing. (Original Post) ificandream Apr 2025 OP
Entirely too much press being given to a dinner between a has-been comedian and a has-been game show host. Scrivener7 Apr 2025 #1
Beautifully said. jrthin Apr 2025 #2
Thank you. :) ificandream Apr 2025 #3
Yep, 2 has beens vapor2 Apr 2025 #10
Yes. Maher stopped being entertaining long ago and Trump never was. PA Democrat Apr 2025 #54
If one thinks Maher is a trumpster, watch the entire show including New Rules. Silent Type Apr 2025 #4
But even then, though, there's still an evil man there. ificandream Apr 2025 #6
So what Maher described and said misanthrope Apr 2025 #15
It is worse Cirsium Apr 2025 #27
It was like when George C. Wallace misanthrope Apr 2025 #34
If Maher is just paying dumb, then he deliberately helped to normalize Trump Martin Eden Apr 2025 #37
Maher is definitely not as smart as he thinks he is SocialDemocrat61 Apr 2025 #44
Same boat misanthrope Apr 2025 #47
Why couldn't Germany get the Hitler who SocialDemocrat61 Apr 2025 #16
Yes Cirsium Apr 2025 #28
Maher is there to NORMALIZE Trump!! Ars Longa Apr 2025 #56
I can imagine that... skypilot Apr 2025 #58
He can't lose face so he'll be semi-defending trump till the end. tman Apr 2025 #5
Time to understand the orange king is a psychopath / sociopath Meowmee Apr 2025 #7
Bill Maher and Trump share an essential trait. harumph Apr 2025 #8
I'm sorry Keith Olbermann didn't act Hassler Apr 2025 #9
Would that be the same Keith Olbermann who made disgusting comments about those fundraising for childhood cancer? Abolishinist Apr 2025 #12
I never knew Olbermann said that. He's the one that's pitiful for saying that Wiz Imp Apr 2025 #25
He never had dinner with the dictator Hassler Apr 2025 #31
Avoiding the question, duly noted. Abolishinist Apr 2025 #32
I'm not defending KO, but why aren't you Hassler Apr 2025 #33
That just sounds like . . . RedArkGuy Apr 2025 #36
Trump is the person who is tearing apart American and trying to bully empathy applegrove Apr 2025 #11
Thanks for posting this! I didn't find much to disagree with either. He has a Abolishinist Apr 2025 #13
How do you know SocialDemocrat61 Apr 2025 #17
Of course he votes Democratic. applegrove Apr 2025 #19
Why? SocialDemocrat61 Apr 2025 #21
He gave a million to Democrats a few cycles back. Really why the attempt to alienate Bill Maher from Democrats. applegrove Apr 2025 #22
So? SocialDemocrat61 Apr 2025 #24
The poster probably had the post deleted for slamming DU on the way in AZProgressive Apr 2025 #38
I foolishly thought Maher might surprise and Hold Dump's feet to the fire Blue Owl Apr 2025 #14
Maher got played into normalizing the orange monster Martin Eden Apr 2025 #18
Maher got played. Straw Man Apr 2025 #20
Hey Bill, you claim to be a comedian. LudwigPastorius Apr 2025 #23
Well, there's Abolishinist Apr 2025 #59
Maher probably has plenty of kompromat Hornedfrog2000 Apr 2025 #26
The media message was "Trump can be a quite nice." All that does is confirm to MAGAs that they are right about Trump. Doodley Apr 2025 #29
We aren't the haters Cirsium Apr 2025 #30
If you're referring to my OP as apologizing for Maher, I really wasn't. ificandream Apr 2025 #48
Why? Cirsium Apr 2025 #49
We already know what's down the road - multiple gigantic piles of shit . . . hatrack Apr 2025 #57
Now THIS is funny misanthrope Apr 2025 #35
This k & r Emile Apr 2025 #39
It's good to see... BH liberal Apr 2025 #40
I was charmed by Bill Cosby. So, was my daughter. RoeVWade Apr 2025 #41
Bottom line: Maher was a useful idiot for Trump Martin Eden Apr 2025 #42
Useful Idiot Johnny2X2X Apr 2025 #45
Exactly, and... Martin Eden Apr 2025 #46
Fuck Bill Maher Prairie Gates Apr 2025 #43
Maher is not as bright as he thinks he is and was played by trump LetMyPeopleVote Apr 2025 #50
As bad as Fallon playing with his hair randr Apr 2025 #51
Maher is a practically talentless nobody. NoMoreRepugs Apr 2025 #52
You're cutting Maher way too much slack. Paladin Apr 2025 #53
Bill Who? doc03 Apr 2025 #55

Scrivener7

(58,151 posts)
1. Entirely too much press being given to a dinner between a has-been comedian and a has-been game show host.
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:00 PM
Apr 2025
 

Silent Type

(12,412 posts)
4. If one thinks Maher is a trumpster, watch the entire show including New Rules.
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:10 PM
Apr 2025

And like Maher said several times during his description, “Why can’t we — the people — have the trump I saw?”

ificandream

(11,653 posts)
6. But even then, though, there's still an evil man there.
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:13 PM
Apr 2025

Why would he want that? If that's his thinking, then he's been taken in, too.

misanthrope

(9,348 posts)
15. So what Maher described and said
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 09:01 PM
Apr 2025

Is the Trump has the capacity to be/act like a better person but just chooses not to for political expedience and power.

And how is that any better? In some ways, it is worse.

Yet Maher can't see that for himself. Either he is playing dumb or isn't as insightful as he thinks he is. Maybe a little of both.

misanthrope

(9,348 posts)
34. It was like when George C. Wallace
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 01:25 AM
Apr 2025

came out in the 1970s and apologized for his segregationist stances, then supported it by referencing a few things he did while he was an Alabama judge, where he treated Blacks with smidgen more respect than other judges. He thought that softened his image.

What it actually said was, "See I'm not really a racist, but I just took those stances for political expedience." He and his supporters never realized that was actually worse than really believing what he espoused.

Martin Eden

(15,315 posts)
37. If Maher is just paying dumb, then he deliberately helped to normalize Trump
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:14 AM
Apr 2025

I have no way of knowing, but my bet is that Maher is not nearly as smart as he thinks he is. Trump is a highly skilled con man, and saw an opportunity in this meeting.

Unfortunately I see nearly every episode of "Real Time" because my wife likes the show. I used to like it is well, but Maher is no match for creatures like Steve Bannon, who eat his lunch when he platforms them.

I'm done watching Maher, and she agrees with my assessment of his meeting with Trump. I hope he loses a lot of viewers over this.

skypilot

(9,097 posts)
58. I can imagine that...
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 08:12 PM
Apr 2025

...Bob Woodward asked himself a similar question during Covid when Trump acknowledged to him in private that Covid was a serious matter but downplayed it to the public. Who cares what Trump he "saw"? The Trump that matters is the one that the rest of us see and have to deal with.

tman

(1,250 posts)
5. He can't lose face so he'll be semi-defending trump till the end.
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:11 PM
Apr 2025

Also, this opens doors for him in the magasphere going forward. He has a new audience now.

Meowmee

(9,212 posts)
7. Time to understand the orange king is a psychopath / sociopath
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:16 PM
Apr 2025

Narcissist who already murdered millions, there is no other version of him. Bm is a narcissist who stirs shit to make money. Both are con artists.

harumph

(3,088 posts)
8. Bill Maher and Trump share an essential trait.
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:19 PM
Apr 2025

Neither of them care for anything other than their self aggrandizement. That and they're both transparent trolls and bullshitters.

Hassler

(4,741 posts)
9. I'm sorry Keith Olbermann didn't act
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:29 PM
Apr 2025

When he had the chance to pound Maher into the floor, but passed on it.

Abolishinist

(2,878 posts)
12. Would that be the same Keith Olbermann who made disgusting comments about those fundraising for childhood cancer?
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:47 PM
Apr 2025

Who was suspended for his controversial remarks about Penn State on Twitter?

On Twitter, Olbermann got into it with students and fans over the school's annual pediatric cancer fundraiser called "Thon." The Penn State dance Marathon known as "Thon" began Friday night at the Bryce Jordan Center in State College and wound up at 4 p.m. Sunday. Hundreds took part in the annual dance marathon over the weekend which raised more than $13 million for pediatric cancer research and care.

The fund's mission is to conquer childhood cancer by assisting children treated at Penn State Hershey Children's Hospital. The fund ensures that all expenses a family incurs are covered, from medical bills to gas and food money and household living expenses.

A PSU alum sent Olbermann a tweet saying "We Are!" with a link to the news on the Thon.

That's when Olbermann responded "pitiful."

Wiz Imp

(8,755 posts)
25. I never knew Olbermann said that. He's the one that's pitiful for saying that
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 11:01 PM
Apr 2025

(Penn State's) THON is the largest student-run philanthropy in the world, raising funds and awareness for the fight against childhood cancer. Since 1977, THON has raised more than $219 million. Penn State Health Children's Hospital is the sole beneficiary of charity, Four Diamonds which started in 1972 to provide monetary support to childhood cancer patients at PSCH. Four Diamonds is the sole beneficiary of the annual Penn State IFC/Panhellenic Dance Marathon (THON) event at Penn State University's University Park campus.

Hassler

(4,741 posts)
33. I'm not defending KO, but why aren't you
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 12:40 AM
Apr 2025

Furious with the guy who is actually cutting cancer research, and ignoring the sycophant, Maher? Typical left, find one thing to be outraged about and ignore the tyrant's dismantling of an entire country -- and it's cancer research, which you seem so concerned about. Backatcha.

applegrove

(129,957 posts)
11. Trump is the person who is tearing apart American and trying to bully empathy
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 07:44 PM
Apr 2025

out of the people. Especially people who have empathy for other people they do not know. He's dangerous. Doesn't matter if he can clean up for a dinner. Trump is still the person who he is day in, day out. As they say with Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, the is no Dr. Jekyll. (Mr Hyde murdered multiple people in person, Trump not in person but millions will die). Trump is the person who repeatedly and intentionally goes after others to his own glee to carve out a win where someone else has to lose (he doesn't understand win win). Millions of AIDs patients in Africa will die and children will be orphaned. It costs 8 cents a day to stop that. He lies. He exploits. Doesn't matter if Trump is nice to Trump's own family or to Bill Maher. How is he to the young women who find themselves knocked up when they are no way ready to start a family? How about taking voting rights away from people? Trying to shake down Zelenskyy? This whole dinner was just an attempt to dial down the anger and fear in the center and the center left so Trump can keep breaking things. The Trump admin seem to break things and backtrack (Harriet Tubbman censored and then not, Medicaid pull apart, then not in February) if its cruelty overwhelmes the public and the public starts lashing out at Trump and his administration. It gets too hot. Dinner with Maher was just an attempt to normalize Trump and dial down the opposition's emotions in another way, particularly those in the who watch bill maher, so Trump can break things the next week (the world economy almost, many people's 401Ks). Again all so he can do stuff, like get rid of income tax and replace it with tariffs like Trump is already hinting at, so his rich friends will be richer and poor people poorer. That he is kind to people who he needs doesn't matter. Millions will die. Hundred's of millions lives will be bleaker.

Abolishinist

(2,878 posts)
13. Thanks for posting this! I didn't find much to disagree with either. He has a
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 08:10 PM
Apr 2025

different approach (and yes, he has his flaws, some of which I find to be off-putting). He votes for the Democrat every time, and there's a long list of damaging things he's said against frump. To me there are far more serious things going on to complain about.

"This idea about purity, and you're never compromised, and you're always POLITICALLY WOKE, and all that stuff, you should get over that quickly. The world is messy. There are ambiguities. People who do really good stuff have flaws." -Barack Obama

An interesting aside, a post was removed the other day (from a 1st time poster) noting the amount of hatred, bile, vitriol they found against Maher.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,662 posts)
17. How do you know
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 09:10 PM
Apr 2025

that he votes for the democrat every time? Do you get in to the voting booth in him and look over his shoulder? And does every time exclude 2000 when he publicly endorsed Nader?

SocialDemocrat61

(6,662 posts)
21. Why?
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 10:00 PM
Apr 2025

The ballot is secret. No one knows who any one votes for once they are in the privacy of the voting booth.

applegrove

(129,957 posts)
22. He gave a million to Democrats a few cycles back. Really why the attempt to alienate Bill Maher from Democrats.
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 10:27 PM
Apr 2025

He is a comedian. No problem if you don't like him. I find satisfaction in how Maher calls out the bullshit on the right. You don't find that anywhere else as the MSM anchors give equal time to Republican panelists and don't make fun of them for their lies. Maher and Michael Moore begged Ralph Nader not to run. Was he lying then? Do you think Michael Moore is stupid? Do you think Killer Mike is? What i don't find satisfaction is in how the right tries to make Maher isolated from the left online. For like 8 years. I've always said Republicans will steal our totems. Even Bill Maher admits the right wing keeps trying to enlist him in their American Carnage. He keeps saying they are too cray cray. Doesn't stop Republicans from getting online and hating on him hoping to convince lefties that they can't handle a centrist view and to cancel him. Just don't watch if you don't like him.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,662 posts)
24. So?
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 10:49 PM
Apr 2025

Trump donated to democrats for decades.Does that give him a pass too? Maher may call out BS on the right but he also attacks many on the left. Sure he once asked Nader not to run but 4 years earlier he supported Nader, not Gore. How did that turn out? He is also vocally anti-vax, bigoted and sexist. You can ignore his anti-woke rants and parroting of right wing talking points as well as his platforming of people like Ann Coulter and Milo Yiannopoulos with little and weak pushback on their bs. Now he’s having dinner with Trump and trying to normalize him. I’m not the one trying to alienate Maher from democrats. He’s doing that all by himself.
And I don’t watch his show. Haven’t for a long time. But it doesn’t mean I can’t criticize him either.

AZProgressive

(29,808 posts)
38. The poster probably had the post deleted for slamming DU on the way in
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:33 AM
Apr 2025

The post was much longer than that I didn't alert on it but I'm not surprised to learn that post was deleted. The poster seemed to think DU of all places was too far left mainly because they didn't like Maher.

Warren was actually #1 in the polls when Obama said that. She wasn't my first choice but I don't think she would have had to drop out after 1 term and could have prevented Trump from getting a second term. The goal of the 2020 primaries was to end Trump's career and Democrats have failed at that.

Blue Owl

(58,121 posts)
14. I foolishly thought Maher might surprise and Hold Dump's feet to the fire
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 08:15 PM
Apr 2025

True colors shown — no more Maher for me.


Martin Eden

(15,315 posts)
18. Maher got played into normalizing the orange monster
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 09:14 PM
Apr 2025

Last edited Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:00 AM - Edit history (1)

If Trump really is a normal person playing an evil megalomaniac on TV, that's even worse than a sociopath who can't control himself.

The last straw was his casual dismissal of Cory Booker's marathon speech in the Senate.

Straw Man

(6,925 posts)
20. Maher got played.
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 09:56 PM
Apr 2025

Not sure why he let that happen to him and didn't see through it. You'd think he knew better. Maybe he's scared.

 

Hornedfrog2000

(866 posts)
26. Maher probably has plenty of kompromat
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 11:08 PM
Apr 2025

That can or has been easily dug up. I would bet lots of skeletons in his closet. Easy to blackmail

Doodley

(11,573 posts)
29. The media message was "Trump can be a quite nice." All that does is confirm to MAGAs that they are right about Trump.
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 11:17 PM
Apr 2025

He ate on our dime, at a tax-payer funded dinner, and he could have asked questions on our behalf. I'm sure Putin can be very charming too, but that is no reason to generate positive headlines. He could have used the opportunity to ask Trump why childhood cancer research has been cut. Is that a price worth paying to help with tax cuts for the rich? Or he could have called Trump out over his lies and gaslighting. But no, it was shameful that all he could do was grovel and report what a charming guy Trump is.

Cirsium

(3,302 posts)
30. We aren't the haters
Sun Apr 13, 2025, 11:21 PM
Apr 2025

These apologies for Maher just play into the "Trump derangement syndrome" nonsense, and it is utter nonsense. We are not the haters. We are rejecting the haters, and we are rejecting the pathetic attempts to normalize the haters. Shame on the people trying to normalize Maher's behavior, and shame on Maher for normalizing Trump.

We aren't the haters.

ificandream

(11,653 posts)
48. If you're referring to my OP as apologizing for Maher, I really wasn't.
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 03:34 PM
Apr 2025

Last edited Mon Apr 14, 2025, 04:53 PM - Edit history (1)

Maher saw what he saw. I think it probably surprised the hell out of him, which makes the idea he got played a little more likely. In fact, maybe a lot likely.

Again, we'll have to see what happens down the road with both Maher and Trump, though we can probably guess what Trump will do.

hatrack

(64,176 posts)
57. We already know what's down the road - multiple gigantic piles of shit . . .
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 07:59 PM
Apr 2025

Some will be on fire, some will be covered with murder hornet nests and patrolled by rabid pit bulls, and some will feature irregularly timed eruptions of pieces of broken glass covered with VX and smallpox virus.

And from time to time, private jets will circle low and slow so that We The People can provide amusement for their passengers - Thiel, Musk, Maher and generations of Trumps.

BH liberal

(92 posts)
40. It's good to see...
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:42 AM
Apr 2025

that so many of you who are responding in this thread have cut to the core of Maher getting it wrong. The "real" Trump IS the one we see on TV and at the rallies. The "made for Maher" Trump that Bill met at the White House proved once again that the obvious mental decline of The Donald has not yet eroded his skills as a functioning con artist.

RoeVWade

(767 posts)
41. I was charmed by Bill Cosby. So, was my daughter.
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:43 AM
Apr 2025

I'm just trying to make a point. Never had dinner with him.

Johnny2X2X

(23,670 posts)
45. Useful Idiot
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 07:14 AM
Apr 2025

Exactly what I came to post.

He came away from the White House saying exactly what they wanted him to say and he's too dumb or arrogant to know it.

They knew he would ease the minds of some people if Trump turned on the charm and turned off the dictator for a few hours. They got exactly what they wanted.

Maher never stopped to ask why he was invited. Why? The Oligarchy running Trump knows people are alarmed at what they are seeing, they identified Maher as someone easily pursuadable who will be able to carry the exact message they wanted back to people. It's a way to mask and accelerate the country's descent into fascism.

And yeah, Maher put it out there that he agrees with trump on so many things, so it makes even more sense.

LetMyPeopleVote

(174,354 posts)
50. Maher is not as bright as he thinks he is and was played by trump
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:13 PM
Apr 2025


An Apprentice producer weighs in on Maher getting used by Trump: “I assure you Trump is laughing and telling everyone around him how easy it was to manipulate Bill… Trump’s superpower is telling whoever he’s with what they want to hear…”

randr

(12,613 posts)
51. As bad as Fallon playing with his hair
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:20 PM
Apr 2025

Anything that normalizes a psychopath only encourages them and makes people think of them as sane.

Paladin

(32,208 posts)
53. You're cutting Maher way too much slack.
Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:53 PM
Apr 2025

He is in the process of enabling and encouraging the most evil and dangerous individual ever to occupy the White House. It would be different if Maher was just another Fox News pimp---but he insists on spreading this absolute fiction that he's Mr. Fair Middle-Roader---which is absolute bullshit, of course.

Hope I'm around, if and when you finally realize that there's no room for it...

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The whole Bill Maher thin...