General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forums
Tadpole Raisin
(1,761 posts)kerry-is-my-prez
(9,866 posts)Angry black wonan!!!
Ilikepurple
(219 posts)I dont know what to make of the Jasmine Crockett comment, but she seems to be a fixation. I think a certain segment of the Democratic Party would rather use Trumps policies to silence the Democratic progressives than to unite against those policies.
Bengus81
(8,720 posts)and not in a good way to their Fuhrer. Otherwise they'd ignore her.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)
We must change the things that we cannot accept.
stillcool
(33,687 posts)mzmolly
(52,106 posts)Last edited Mon Apr 14, 2025, 10:16 PM - Edit history (2)
Im so tired of the notion that only Democrats should be defending our %$@ country.
Cirsium
(2,380 posts)That is like saying we shouldn't look to fire fighters because "what about the arsonists?"
That makes no sense whatsoever. Of course we look to our representatives, not theirs.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)official, who claims to care about the country.
Very good.
bsiebs
(826 posts)Yes, we need all elected Democratic members to step up and fight this at every level. However, NO elected official (that includes Independents and the Republicans) should be off the hook for this treason. Hold ALL of them to the fire... they all swore to uphold the constitution and protect it from all enemies, foreign and domestic.
Same goes for the press. Same goes for all US citizens, we all have a responsibility to fight this destruction of our country.
dchill
(42,139 posts)ALL the Dems in Congress could vote against anything - and it could still be the law. My choices are described for me.
kerry-is-my-prez
(9,866 posts)Thanks to Fox and the tons of RW media outlets.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)Each of the rest would prefer to be "The Dear Leader".
ShazzieB
(20,376 posts)Of course, the approval figures are less low for Republicans than for Dems or Independents, but they're nowhere near 80% from what I've seen.
kerry-is-my-prez
(9,866 posts)At least thats good news. I wonder if the number of people who identify as Republicans has gone down. You would think so.
InAbLuEsTaTe
(25,107 posts)Bengus81
(8,720 posts)MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)They will goose-step till they die.
Scrivener7
(55,506 posts)If we wait for repubiQans to defend the country, we will lose our country.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)Last edited Mon Apr 14, 2025, 06:34 PM - Edit history (1)
Constitution.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)The wholly fascist GOP doesn't give two shits about their oaths.
That ought to be fully self evident at this point.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)Got it!
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)What's the plan?
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)How about "If Any Elected Official Doesn't Speak Out ..."
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)May reason rule wherever you may dwell.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)be the only party responsible to uphold the constitution.
sheshe2
(91,556 posts)Especially the party that is not in power at this time.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)Fascists have no interest in defending our democracy.
The wholly fascist GOP fully intends to destroy our democracy and rule as fascist despots forevermore.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)have an interest in defending democracy?
InAbLuEsTaTe
(25,107 posts)mzmolly
(52,106 posts)given the OP.
crimycarny
(1,781 posts)Honestly, the silence of the Democratic Party is baffling to me. We know the GOP isn't going to say anything, that's a given, but for our Democrat leaders to remain so silent?
The world is looking at us as Trump burns up the Constitution. They are wondering why people aren't protesting in the streets. To do nothing, to say nothing, is to show an appalling lack of will to save our country.
Look at what is happening in Turkey. Massive protests against Erdogan. And those protestors are protesting at a great risk to their safety. We, as a nation, need to rise up and protest Trump on a massive scale similar to the Vietnam War protests. And our party leaders need to step up as well.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)to defend the country?
Yet the only party with a duty to act is the Democratic Party? Where are Libertarians? Where are Independents? Where are Republicans? Where is the Green Party?
WTF?
LuvLoogie
(7,982 posts)Bernie Sanders is Independent.
If Democrats are going to call out Republicans and Independents, it should be the leadership. But they don't, they can't, they won't because they would rather wait for the right circumstance. And Brown people being kidnapped and wrongfully imprisoned ain't it I suppose. Given this nation's history, is it any wonder?
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)member of the Congress and the Senate, accountable for what's happening. No one should get a pass.
crimycarny
(1,781 posts)Of course the GOP should be coming out against Trump, but what does that have to do with expecting my party to speak out against an innocent man being sent to an El Salvadoran prison?
I don't control whether the GOP speaks out or not. All I can control is what I do and what I ask my party leaders to do.
What is happening is wrong. I want my party to be on the right side of history and do what is right regardless of what someone else does or doesn't do.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)of history. Democrats are NOT the problem.
crimycarny
(1,781 posts)No one is saying the Dems are the problem. You continue to conflate wanting the Dems to fight back harder/differently with saying Dems are the problem. Trump is the problem, the GOP enabling him is the problem, and I want my party fighting back harder.
AOC and Bernie have the right idea, and it's starting to resonate (30,000 showed up in Folsom, CA last night.) Cory Booker had the right idea with his marathon filibuster. Dem Representative Al Green, who stood up and protested at the SOTU, had the right idea. The House Dems who stood in silence while holding up bingo paddles had the wrong idea. AOC, Bernie, Cory Booker, and Al Green all protested from a position of active strength, not weak passive symbolism. It is our duty as Democrats to let the leaders we voted for hear our voices.
Complaining about how your party does or doesn't fight back against what another party is doing is not the same as saying your party is the problem.
travelingthrulife
(2,130 posts)I read about Democrats voicing their disagreement everywhere. I don't watch tv anymore but fully understand that Democrats are not given the same voice in media.
Why not complain about Republicans doing something about this madness? Why do the instigators get a pass? Have you called your reps? Especially if they are GOP.
Or is it easier to blame Democrats for the things Republicans do?
crimycarny
(1,781 posts)Last edited Tue Apr 15, 2025, 01:53 PM - Edit history (1)
You are conflating voicing my concerns to my party with "blaming" them for what is happening. No one is "blaming" the Democrats, but as a Democrat, I'm letting them know I want those speaking out to continue to do so, and those who aren't to start speaking out.
People urged their representatives to speak out against Jim Crow during the Civil Rights movement. They didn't waste time thinking "why do I have to go down to the South and protest? The people living in those states should be doing that!"
I will add that I am extremely angry and frustrated with the Republicans, as they are the ones who have the power right now to stop Trump, but they aren't. Worse, they are echoing his lies! But I've gotten to the point where that anger and frustration is making me feel helpless and exhausted, it's fruitless. This isn't about a "pass" or blame; history will judge that, this is about taking action and rising up.
Skittles
(163,656 posts)they are GOOSE-STEPPING to Trump
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)eom
Skittles
(163,656 posts)they start wars based on lies, they mismanage a pandemic, they crash the economy over and over
and what happens?
THE ENTIRE GOVERNMENT WAS HANDED TO THEM
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)now.
Bengus81
(8,720 posts)kacekwl
(8,228 posts)Lips firmly planted on trumps ass. Democrats need to win the mid terms big and this issue should be a golden goose for them along with about 2 dozen others.
thought crime
(174 posts)That's who he speaks to. There aren't a whole lot of Republicans watching Pod Save America.
progressoid
(51,317 posts)whopis01
(3,821 posts)about the Nazis not trying to stop Hitler in 1939.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)for everything. Never republicans. So tiresome.
Autumn
(47,727 posts)going on. Only a few elected Dems are blaming them but there are a lot of elected Democrats who are not blaming them. They need to all be speaking out about Republican compliance.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Autumn
(47,727 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)It's circular firing squad thinking.
Autumn
(47,727 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)and painfully naive
Autumn
(47,727 posts)
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)will appreciate your efforts
Autumn
(47,727 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)TheBadWolf
(49 posts)Sorry, but integrity matters, even if you don't think so.
thought crime
(174 posts)Integrity matters. There isn't much chance that someone with an R after their name has much integrity. It is now the party of bad faith and a whole bunch of hate.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Why drive more away?
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)to defend the country against all enemies - foreign and domestic? This is NOT a political issue.
Autumn
(47,727 posts)You must have missed where I posted that And yes it is a fucking political issue.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)what? By making it political, we're belittling what is happening.
JI7
(91,798 posts)So even when Republicans fuck things up it's seen as the fault of democrats for not preventing it.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)and when we have very little.
Autumn
(47,727 posts)
As long as we have politicians it is political. Everyone in this country should be screaming from the rooftops that includes Democrats and the very few republicans who complain to elected Democrats in private but keep their mouth shut in public. If they aren't raising hell about what's going on fuck them.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)Perhaps that's where we differ? I do NOT.
Yes, "fuck them Democrats" will help us all defeat fascism.
I expect every elected official who takes the oath of office to honor that oath, period.
Autumn
(47,727 posts)post well... I won't bother.
Good luck.
You suggested again that Democrats better do something and a few Republicans should join them.
We have to take back the house and senate in 2026 and pissing on Democrats doesn't help that effort.
dem4decades
(12,693 posts)My God, if today's Democrats can't pick up the flag and bring it to the fight, get some that will.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Keep democrats divided, attacking each other so they keep winning elections.
dem4decades
(12,693 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)dem4decades
(12,693 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)helps Republicans
Response to SocialDemocrat61 (Reply #60)
Post removed
Oopsie Daisy
(5,623 posts)Correct as usual.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)There is doing.
There is not doing.
There is no such thing as trying.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)both houses of congress and the Supreme Court. But sure it's all the democrats fault. The Purity police is why democrats lose elections.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)Trump asked the El Salvadoran President to build 5 more facilities to imprison American Citizens of his choosing.
Did you miss that perchance?
The entire Democratic Party MUST stand against this.
That. Is. Their. Job.
Not speaking out would be an abject abdication of moral duty.
Reasons aside, the administration is ultimately making a shockingly authoritarian argument with few parallels in American history: that it can send anyone, from U.S. soil, to a foreign prison, and no court can ensure the person's return. Indeed, Trump mused again on Monday about sending American citizens -- "homegrown" criminals, as he put it -- to El Salvador.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)but apparently that's not good enough. It's just making the perfect the enemy of the good.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)Have a better one y'all.
Eat well, sleep well, stay well.
All my best to you and yours.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)mzmolly
(52,106 posts)MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)The GOP is wholly fascist.
They want to destroy our democracy, deport and imprison for life any that dare oppose their unbridled fascist depravity.
That. Is. What. The. GOP. Desires.
Any other questions y'all?
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)I am not a religious person, but that's the oath of office taken by Republicans, too.
electric_blue68
(21,072 posts)iemanja
(55,879 posts)Standing up to fascism, the issue of our time, is not minor or optional. You expect nothing, you get nothing.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)that's just unrealistic
iemanja
(55,879 posts)Sure, go along with concentration camps, sending Americans to El Salvador. It's unrealistic to expect decent human beings to speak out against such things. Say goodbye to America. it's unrealistic to expect the people we elect to serve our interests to actually stand up for us.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)But when you everyone only do it the way you want, isn't that fascist too.
iemanja
(55,879 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)But blaming democrats for not being perfect will only help Republicans
iemanja
(55,879 posts)Directly.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)But blaming democrats doesn't help
iemanja
(55,879 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)I said blaming democrats only helps republicans.
iemanja
(55,879 posts)You insisted we should accept anything any Democrat does, regardless of the consequences. What does being a Democrat mean to you? Youve already said standing up to fascism is unrealistic. What else is there that matters?
What you fail to understand, despite all evidence to the contrary, is that the path you demand is one that leads to perpetual electoral defeat.
I am a citizen of this country, not a vassal. I have every right to expect elected officials to represent me. I will not collaborate with fascism. There is nothing else that matters. We have no country left If we fail to stand up.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)that I never said. And the op sets a standard and attacks those that don't meet his standard. I've seen the same thing in the past and it always results in losing elections. Better to praise democrats like AOC and Booker and save attacks for Republicans.
Response to SocialDemocrat61 (Reply #173)
Post removed
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)You dont make the rules here.
My point is what it always was, attacking democrats helps republicans. Praise democrats like Warren and Murphy and Crockett and save attacks for republicans.
iemanja
(55,879 posts)If you have nothing to say, so be it.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Im not the one here demanding anything. Im just stating an opinion. Sorry if other opinions offend you.
Ilikepurple
(219 posts)I dont think purity police as a term even applies in this thread. OP reposted a tweet asking our Democratic elected representatives to either speak out on this or explain themselves. How is that fascism by any definition. It seems like you are bundling centrist frustrations concerning losing the last elections with a specific request. I keep hearing you and other say the republicans own the Presidency, House, Senate, and USSC, so they are powerless. They may be powerless to unilaterally change or block anything solely by their votes, but they, like us, are not powerless in their voices. Asking them to use those voices is neither fascism nor a test of purity.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)But blaming all democrats if they dont adhere to a certain level of purity will only help republicans.
Ilikepurple
(219 posts)I concede that you havent said enemy, I just made that inference from your simplistic youre either with us or against us GW level reasoning. If you wanted to engage my statement rather than just repeat yourself, you failed. There is no purity police issue here, I hope due process rights for US citizens is seen as foundational to the Democratic Party platform. I dont see how calling out silent democrats helps the republicans on this issue. The term purity police is generally used by those who would sacrifice the marginalized civil rights for a perceived better end. Im not even saying that the perfect isnt usually the element of the good. Trumps statements today touch all of our rights. I dont see the good in not holding our reps accountable in their reactions. Let the politicians defend themselves and let us share ideas.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)other than to help elect republicans. Maybe we should be celebrating those like Cory Booker, Chris Murphy, AOC, Jasmine Crockett and others who are speaking out, rather than demand a standard of perfection from everyone else and blaming those who dont meet it.
Ilikepurple
(219 posts)OP asked reps to speak out or explain their silence on an issue that affects US citizen due process rights. This is not a demanding perfection issue. Its a demanding representation issue. You are demanding a standard of perfection according to your beliefs from people who owe you no allegiance. Also, how is it wrong that we ask more democrats from non marginalized groups to speak out? I applaud those speaking out, but there needs to be more. Lets try to get more reps speaking out. You are so interested in courting the middle to win elections. How can that be done without cross demographic representation from our party?
I dont think asking an elected official to speak out on an issue you feel important is blaming them. Likewise, neither is asking them to explain why they are silent. Are we in grade school? Politicians are big people and if they cant argue for their position, maybe theyre in the wrong line of work. Politics is a feedback loop. They say and do stuff then we say and do stuff then they say and do stuff to respond to what we say?Are you saying that taking Democratic Party reps to task if silent about Trumps recent statement will get republicans elected, then make the argument. Saying things doesnt make it so. You do realize you are trying to protect democratic representatives silence at the expense of democratic individuals voices? Of course that might be your intent.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)It sets a standard for all democrats to meet. And criticizes any that don't meet that standard.
That will only help Republicans.
Better to cheer on democrats like Booker, Crockett and others and save the criticism for Republicans.
Ilikepurple
(219 posts)If you dont have any standards all democrats must meet, its hard to say what you stand for. Mass murderer? Ok! Baby puncher? Ok! Hate crime supporter? Ok! Fascist extrajudicial extradition and imprisonment? Ok! We might disagree on the basic standards we hold people, even democrats, to, but I think all non nihilists have some standards. I dont expect loved ones, let alone politicians, to meet all my standards, but I some I cling to a lot harder than others. In politics, my only power besides my vote is my voice. Hopefully, voices similar to mine are heard and considered along with others as politicians form their own opinions on issues. Its possible to have one goal with many voices.
It seems youre upset about something other than OPs post. Something that probably goes back to 2002 or 2004 or whatever you gestured at in other posts. Kerry lost cuz woke? I think its telling that you seem to be a lot more alarmed by we democrats not uniting behind the silent than you are about this administrations constitutional and legal transgressions. Having a difference of opinion on particular issues does not necessarily divide our party although you seem determined to create a division. Shoot, presidential hopefuls can criticize each other for a whole primary season and survive to run together. This bifurcation of cheering and criticizing seems to be a simplistic abstraction. We can obviously do both. Yay Booker. Boo Trump. Yay Crockett. Boo Vance. Yay due process rights. Boo those elected officials who wont explain why they dont support some of them.
That will only help Republicans? Youve repeated this often without a little thing called argument or at least a fleshed out narrative. Most of us have been alive long enough to remember when this or that happened. It doesnt make us experts. In this particular case, whats your argument? Dont vote for the democrats some democrats have problems with, vote for me, a republican, who almost all democrats have a problem with? It seems your real argument isnt that the criticism harms democrats directly, but that purity testsmoves the Party platform to the left which alienates too much of the center-right to remain viable in future elections.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Too many rather blame democrats than republicans. Attacking your allies instead of your enemies is always a bad strategy. Republicans win elections because they stick together and dont attack each other.
Why is it so hard support democrats and criticize republicans?
Celerity
(49,493 posts)
Talk about wilfully misusing the concepts of purity tests/purity policing.

SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)There are many good democrats speaking out. But to demand every single one speak out is demanding purity. Then will be this one didn't speak out strong enough or didn't say what I wanted. I've seen these purity tests before and they only help Republicans.
Celerity
(49,493 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)But I saw the same thing during the Bush administration 20 years ago and democrats lost the 02 midterms and the 04 election. Those who refuse to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
alarimer
(17,146 posts)All we are asking for is MAKE SOME NOISE. Plenty are, but some are not.
dem4decades
(12,693 posts)I'm not blaming Democrats for Trump, but I'll blame them for not speaking up.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)will thank you for it.
dem4decades
(12,693 posts)Maybe if Democrats stayed quiet and didn't make any waves the country would appreciate their cowardice and reward them with their trust to lead them forward.
Because everyone wants a coward to lead them.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)should be seen and heard.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)but attacking and blaming democrats only benefits Republicans
iemanja
(55,879 posts)and keep it up and you may get just that. That is what the implication of your argument is.
That you called standing up to fascism "the purity police" is outrageous.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)but I'm not going to set a high bar and accuse anyone who doesn't reach it of capitulation.
iemanja
(55,879 posts)You seem to think the Democrats are elected lords with no responsibility whatsoever. You seem happy with a party with 7% strong approval ratings.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)This is exactly the kind of purity tests I was referring to.
Bettie
(18,190 posts)prison that is known for its inhumane treatment of people isn't OK doesn't seem like a high bar.
To say that those US citizens deserve due process and imprisonment in the country they are citizens of, doesn't seem like a high bar either.
Seems pretty basic.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)So what is the problem?
betsuni
(27,816 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)But they are proving my point about purity tests.
betsuni
(27,816 posts)No such thing as just having a different strategy or opinion, you don't pass the purity test, you're evil. But it's so natural, like fish not knowing what water is.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)We should be celebrating democrats like Cory Booker and AOC and even Bernie Sanders who are speaking out instead of blaming democrats who dont to our level of satisfaction.
DiverDave
(5,085 posts)Supposed to cower in the corner?
Why WOULDN'T I want my Democratic elected officials to yell at the fucking republicans?
Being silent about all this horseshit is not the way to go about it.
Why are you advocating doing nothing?
Not speaking out is just what the fucking rpukes want.
Why do YOU?
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)But blaming democrats when they don't meet your expectations of perfection will only help Republicans
DiverDave
(5,085 posts)We need everyone to be beating them over the head with this.
Not sitting on our hands.
Telling them to do thier job is OUR job.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Like Cory Booker, Elizabeth Warren, Jasmine Crockett and AOC.
mzmolly
(52,106 posts)
DiverDave
(5,085 posts)Under the rest of them?
That takes US,all of us.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Booker and Warren is a better way to light a fire.
DiverDave
(5,085 posts)That's working out.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)How is attacking democrats working out? Has it ever worked in the past?
DiverDave
(5,085 posts)Do thier jobs is attacking them?
I'm done.
You do you.
I think holding them to doing their jobs is our job.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Republicans will appreciate your efforts.
stillcool
(33,687 posts)that represent you?
dem4decades
(12,693 posts)stillcool
(33,687 posts)I follow him on Bluesky https://bsky.app/profile/chrismurphyct.bsky.social. But what is required of other Democrats to avoid the whipping post? Does Senator Warren 'speak up'? Senator Markey? Do you have to hear them?
dem4decades
(12,693 posts)stillcool
(33,687 posts)iemanja
(55,879 posts)You may not care what they do, but I demand they stand up to fascism.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)or you could cheer for Dems like AOC and Cory Booker who are speaking out.
iemanja
(55,879 posts)And I expect the rest to do their jobs as well.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)"do their job" up to your standards?
iemanja
(55,879 posts)And civic responsibility. What are yours? What do you stand for?
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)the baseline of human decency? Was that a job you were elected to? Personally I don't remember that position on my ballot.
As far as what I stand for it's not dictating to every one else what standard of human decency they need to meet to make me happy.
iemanja
(55,879 posts)I exercise my right as a citizen. You have done nothing in this thread but dictate to others. You insist we accept anything, even collaboration with fascism.
You refuse to say what being a Democrat means to you. I can only therefore conclude that it means nothing.
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Im not demanding that democrats meet my personal standard for human decency or that anyone explain what being a democrat is.
Im saying what Ive said from the start. Attacking democrats only helps republicans. Praise the democrats speaking out and attack republicans. That should not be so controversial in a forum dedicated to supporting democrats.
Abolishinist
(2,447 posts)Hint: they will ask if you were in the voting booth when he voted.
BigDemVoter
(4,618 posts)I guess I took it as we need to hold our political representatives to a higher standard. And for the record, I am not unhappy with the response so far. With the deluge of outrageous BS that just comes every day, I am sure it is difficult for our Dem politicians to even keep up!
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)By the corporate media, Green Party supporters, etc. Its why democrats lose elections because theyll never reach some peoples higher standard.
Orrex
(65,064 posts)Blame the democrats for everything? Absolutely no one is doing that.
Blame the Democrats for not doing the one thing that they can do? Why the fuck wouldn't we blame them for that?
In you estimation, how much Democratic hand-sitting and powder-drying will it take before Trump is defeated?
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Not much they can do. Many democrats in congress and across the country are speaking out but its all they can do right now. Why not celebrate them instead and blame republicans. Democrats blaming democrats doesnt win elections, has never worked in the past and wont work next year.
Orrex
(65,064 posts)Literally no one (and I do mean literally, not "literally" as in "It's literally raining cats and dogs) is demanding that Democrats do anything that they are objectively powerless to do.
We are frustrated that our duly elected representatives aren't speaking out constantly. This is the time. This is not the time for leaning on a podium and wearily peering over one's glasses at an adversarial press corps.
Why are you so dead-set on excusing Democrats for inaction?
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)Other than speaking out theres nothing much they can do. I accept the reality of that. And plenty of democrats are speaking out. Its just not enough for some people. Lets keep focus on blaming those who are responsible, republicans.
electric_blue68
(21,072 posts)a ?bashing tone: but a genuine why wouldn't you *say something against just a horrific current (the poor man who got erroneously jailed, and probably many, to most of the others), plus potental attacks against US citizens in the future?
3) Also condemning Replublicans for following a authoritarian-loving president, and his hideous policies. There used to be relatively reasonable Republicans.
We can chew gum, and walk at the same time.
*Once I finish reading the posts, I'll post something more about "saying something".
SocialDemocrat61
(4,279 posts)but the op came across as bashing. Lets not attack democrats because you dont think theyre doing enough or having the right message. Im a believer that positive reinforcement accomplishes more than negative.
electric_blue68
(21,072 posts)kerry-is-my-prez
(9,866 posts)This problem is much bigger than a Demicratic politician going out and screaming. They actually make fun of them on Fox - which is twice as popular as MSNBC and about 3-4 times as popular as CNN.
Nimble_Idea
(2,636 posts)EVERYONE WATCH OUT!!!
Autumn
(47,727 posts)



MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)There is doing.
There is not doing.
There is no such thing as trying.
Unity In Voice
(11 posts)I just keep hoping that the Democrats are working in secret in the background to end this GOP crap.
Autumn
(47,727 posts)CousinIT
(11,263 posts)The man ought to learn to use social media.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)I'm We Are Stardust We Are Golden over at Blue Sky...
Come and see me!
CousinIT
(11,263 posts)@cousinit.bsky.social
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)


Nimble_Idea
(2,636 posts)I going to be a good Dem and support 100%. No need to look for new options. Are primaries still something though?
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)I'm unclear about what you're saying.
Might you clarify further?
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)There ought to be a full delegation going to El Salvador.
Trump asked the El Salvadoran President to build 5 more Prisons specifically to deport and imprison for life all of those that dare oppose his unbridled fascist depravity.
The entire party must stand...
Or else...
There will be no party to stand...
We'll all be in a foreign prison for life.
sop
(13,848 posts)Elected Republicans must stand up to Trump, but more likely they'll defend him on this, just like Marco Rubio and others in his administration have.
dalton99a
(88,308 posts)LoisB
(10,199 posts)RandySF
(73,594 posts)I stopped listening to his pod after they invited Chris Christie on the show and allowed him to spew false corruption accusations against Biden.
JI7
(91,798 posts)Iamscrewed
(160 posts)Treason, emolluments, fraud, violations of oath of office, insider trading, violations of the Geneva convention, war crimes, violations of the rule of law and violations of the constitution. When, where and how does this shit exist or end?
betsuni
(27,816 posts)and "Why Didn't Democrats Stop All the Bad Things, Mommy?" shows.
Iamscrewed
(160 posts)Treason, emolluments, fraud, violations of oath of office, insider trading, violations of the Geneva convention, war crimes, violations of the rule of law and violations of the constitution. When, where and how does this shit exist or end?
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)The presidential ascendancy is currently wholly fascist.
electric_blue68
(21,072 posts)It really might work against them!
Imho.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)We'll see how it all plays out.
Here's to reason's rule.
Evolve Dammit
(20,540 posts)MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)The GOP desires to deport and imprison any that dare oppose their unbridled fascist depravity.
It's time to change the things that we cannot accept.
Mtnmama
(16 posts)to the rule of law and the constitution and nothing is being done to stop him. I never understood "we have a democracy as long as we can keep it." I'm starting to understand now.
jalan48
(14,852 posts)If they dont Id say we now have a Vichy government.
SuzyandPuffpuff
(114 posts)Bam agreed
SuzyandPuffpuff
(114 posts)Agreed
Grim Chieftain
(96 posts)you are complicit. You are enabling the most evil, lawless, corrupt president ever to occupy the Oval Office. He is a convicted felon, a thirty-four time convicted felon. Where is the outrage? Holy freaking hell - stand up, speak out, do something!
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)I Agree
flamingdem
(40,377 posts)he doesn't get a meeting with Bukele to discuss repatriation.
Can we get another brave congressman? Please?!
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)
flamingdem
(40,377 posts)and that they get information about others there who are innocent.
InAbLuEsTaTe
(25,107 posts)doc03
(37,746 posts)kansasobama
(1,750 posts)Here is Trump just saying he cannot bring Garcia back and our Dems like Linken Riley Gallego is just fine. Schumer is fine. Have we heard anyone from Dem Party speak up? Student deportations are fine. Kidnappings are fine.
stillcool
(33,687 posts)dem4decades
(12,693 posts)stillcool
(33,687 posts)or maybe even know? Warren, Markey, and Auchincloss.
kansasobama
(1,750 posts)Leaves me with zero representations. I try writing to Dem Senators in other states and keep complaining to my GOP reps and Senators from Kansas
Tetrachloride
(8,675 posts)stillcool
(33,687 posts)Mirrors are everywhere. Oh yeah, they aren't going to have a job, so you will be getting what you want, and what you probably continue to vote for.
LilElf70
(854 posts)Why do you have a job? Good question, eh?
Here's a thought. Become a "progressive democrat" Apparently they have no problem at all speaking up.
Doing nothing spells disaster. Staying the same spells a disaster. The same old, same old, will never do, again.
If there ever was a time to speak up, now is the time. Not tomorrow.
NOW!!!!!!
Liberty Belle
(9,660 posts)It is not limited to citizens.
Why isn't deporting ANYBODY to that hellhole torture facility in El Salvador being a violation of the 8th amendment?
They should be ordered to bring everyone back or if deportable, to find other countries to take them in.
No citizen should ever be deported to any foreign prison, of course.
But I want to see this stopped for every single person. Even a murder is entitled to humane treatment under our Constitution.
thought crime
(174 posts)lees1975
(6,435 posts)I'm sure someone has compiled something like that.
RandySF
(73,594 posts)Weve reached the point where were looking for reasons to get angry at Democrats.
betsuni
(27,816 posts)Universal health care, higher minimum wage and paid leave, increased taxes on wealthy and corporations, environmentalism and green energy, job creation, education, affordable housing, infrastructure, etc. are usual liberal Democratic issues so the emphasis must be on emotional polarization to get as many on the Left to hate Democrats as not progressive, same as Republicans, enemies. They give themselves away by all the angry personal attacks, not listening but assuming the other person is an enemy. Emotional polarization.
It only helps Trump kill democracy. If the majority of elected Democrats spent most of their time at rallies and on TV they'd be bashed for giving stern speeches and not doing anything, acting like celebrities, ignoring their jobs back in Washington,
Ilikepurple
(219 posts)Thank you for providing the list of what you believe are the key liberal Democratic issues. We are probably in agreement on all of these issues . It seems weird to damn me to the realm of emotional polarization if my opinion differs from yours on others. Im guessing these terms are used to highlight my unreasonable and confrontational nature. I assure you Im generally neither of these nor a. I helping Trump kill democracy. Im using myself as a placeholder for the subject of your rant to demonstrate your angry wide net attack on emotional progressives is not impersonal in its effects. It is so strange that some think attacking progressives as being too emotional and angry is the way to unite the party, but I think youve at least laid bare what I believe is the underlying disagreement has been in this thread. It hasnt really been about whether Dem reps speak out about due process.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)Perhaps you missed the part where Trump asked the El Salvadoran President to build 5 more Prisons so that Trump can deport any American citizen that dare oppose his unbridled fascist depravity and have them imprisoned for life.
In my book, silence is complicity.
We're currently under delusion's rule.
Which is why we see that our freedoms are ceasing to exist.
Our freedoms are reason based.
In reasons absence, delusion rules and our freedoms cease to exist.
Here' to reason ruling the day.
Sogo
(6,207 posts)must speak out also. This is un-Constitutional, and impeachment and removal should be front and center.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)As far as impeachment the line of succession is arguably worse than Trump.
If we're still able to vote in mid-terms...
If we're able to flip the House and install Jeffries as speaker...
Then we might be able to impeach Trump AND Vance.
Then either Jeffries or AOC would ascend to the Presidency.
As far as Republicans speaking out...
The only Republicans that might speak out are those that would like to smear lipstick on their pig face for better optics, so as to improve their chance to be "The Dear Leader".
The GOP fully supported Project 2025 which is what we now see happening in real time.
The GOP is an ongoing criminal enterprise intent upon the wholesale destruction of our democracy.
The GOP is intent upon establishing a fully fascist regime that rules for evermore.
The GOP is wholly fascist through and through.
No member of the GOP desires to stop this for they are wholly complicit.
In what world do those that supported and implemented such policy stand and rail against it?
I know of none.
electric_blue68
(21,072 posts)electric_blue68
(21,072 posts)🤬🤬🤬
flvegan
(64,919 posts)MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)
Ilikepurple
(219 posts)The arguments that imploring our elected Democratic Party representatives to take a stand on this issue is divisive are strange. They seem to be implying that asking for perfection or setting up a purity test seem to be either put forward to try to silence the left or, even more strangely, be offered by those who have more love for the institution of the Democratic Party or its personalities than its principles. There is a battle going on for the direction of the Democratic Party and it seems some just want those they disagree with to sit on their hands lest they create division. When cross referencing other discussions here, I cant but help these sorts of arguments are being used to quiet the socially progressive wing of the party and get back to focusing on the average American. I put the term in quotes because I dont know what it means, but Im sure the users know how theyre using it, and Im sure it excludes some of us.
MayReasonRule
(3,197 posts)I agree y'all.
Celerity
(49,493 posts)bee_peaceful
(77 posts)[snip]
Yesterday, Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) requested a meeting with Bukele today to discuss the illegal detention of my constituent, Kilmar Abrego Garcia. He said that he would travel to El Salvador this week if Abrego Garcia is not home by midweek.
Judge Xinis has set the next hearing in Abrego Garcias case for tomorrow, April 15, at 4:00 p.m.
https://heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/p/april-14-2025?utm_source=post-banner&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=posts-open-in-app&triedRedirect=true
Snark Twain
(83 posts)we've already lost. the threshold should have been kilmar - you let it pass without a fight they've already shown they can ignore orders from the SC
Orrex
(65,064 posts)Prairie_Seagull
(4,108 posts)prior to it being done/enacted (rather in the majority or not) is the minorities super power. They can garner the coverage to make this point clearly to the American people. Is the reason they haven't due to shock, research, shock. haha. It's time, get to it your honerablenesses.
republianmushroom
(19,598 posts)Publicity not many.
electric_blue68
(21,072 posts)and at least one or more other posters did, too.
(first, had to go through all the posts!)
58. Fear. Shapiro/ Pelosi attacks? But yeah, this is no time to be silent as fascism gains traction.
I think this might be true. Shapiro, Pelosi.
J6!
Especially after drumphf's return, and how [Rachel, said it's been a month, already for Garcia!] exceedingly worse he's been getting! Jail US citizens elsewhere, as well! (not that the others isn't bad enough!)
Do you really think that "defending The Constitution" meant physical danger, or worse was included on their bingo cards when they stated out as Reps, or Senators?
I don't think so!
Still I think every Dem should at least make a basic statement that what happened to Garcia, and threatening future American Citizens is wrong.
A basic simple statement.
And ultra safety to Chris Van Hollen if he and whomever goes with him to El Salvador! Yikes!