Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

gab13by13

(31,243 posts)
Sun May 11, 2025, 06:56 AM May 2025

Why Is It A Given That We Have To Give Billionaires A 7 Trillion Dollar Tax Cut

Why Do Billionaires Need More Money?

Why Does the money have to come from the poor and working class?

Why don't Democrats hold town halls only on this issue?

Sheldon Whitehouse is introducing a bill to shore up Social Society by raising the cap and adding a small tax to those making 400k and up. Is anyone aware that Whitehouse is doing this? Will his bill ever be passed and signed into law by Krasnov? Hell no but it is worth doing.

Hold a damn town hall and let Martin O'Malley and Whitehouse be moderators. Have members of the audience tell their stories about how they can't survive without the safety net. Have similar town halls for Medicare and Medicaid.

Democrats own the talking points on not gutting the safety net, Democrats own the talking points for not giving tax breaks to billionaires so I repeat my headline,

Why is it a given that we have to give a 7 trillion dollar tax cut to billionaires?

Do not dare and say that the MSM is to blame, I reject that excuse.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/politics/government/rigged-for-the-rich-dems-propose-a-different-kind-of-social-security-overhaul/ar-AA1EywQZ?ocid=BingNewsSerp

45 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why Is It A Given That We Have To Give Billionaires A 7 Trillion Dollar Tax Cut (Original Post) gab13by13 May 2025 OP
Why is it a given that we have to give a 7 trillion dollar tax cut to billionaires? sop May 2025 #1
Obsession with acquiring obscene amounts of wealth - werdna May 2025 #2
As is society's penchant for extoling their so-called virtues SheltieLover May 2025 #4
I think it's not a special form of illness Hieronymus Phact May 2025 #33
Yes. And Money is the gateway to Power addiction! n/t werdna May 2025 #39
Republicans believe the wealthy create jobs and Emile May 2025 #3
In the 1920's it was called Horse & Sparrow Economics gab13by13 May 2025 #10
What an absolute load of Horse Feathers IbogaProject May 2025 #21
Raw greed is core republiconism BoRaGard May 2025 #5
That's how we need to refer to them ... Delarage May 2025 #28
Because the billionaires have paid off all of the Republican senators and congress people, indusurb May 2025 #6
It really is the only solution. Get money out of politics. travelingthrulife May 2025 #14
Because of the galactic egos of a handful of farcially rich toddler ASSHOLES . . . hatrack May 2025 #7
This and the lack of progress against inflation would be precisely what we should be beating the GOP with. dutch777 May 2025 #8
RepubliQan Congress are co-dependent enablers of the billionaires' money hoarding mental illnesses. Scrivener7 May 2025 #9
Missing my point gab13by13 May 2025 #11
Ongoing. Just not reported except haele May 2025 #16
Some have. They have been holding town halls in red districts. hay rick May 2025 #20
Sean Casten is doing this in Illinois. murielm99 May 2025 #23
Yeah, the ole GOTV strategy, gab13by13 May 2025 #30
"Starve the beast" is a political strategy employed by American conservatives walkingman May 2025 #12
Past tense. Technofascists want to almost completely eliminate JCMach1 May 2025 #19
Good point - it does appear to be so. walkingman May 2025 #24
Read Yarvin, (or don't) read some summaries and critiques JCMach1 May 2025 #35
Because they bribed and lobbied enough GOP politicians IronLionZion May 2025 #13
Paying off the underaged ain't just peanuts, pal! Montauk6 May 2025 #15
Wow, lots of responses blaming republicans (easy), not so many addressing the OP's questions. n/t flvegan May 2025 #17
The point is that they don't care if you survive... Wounded Bear May 2025 #18
They really ought to be taxed out of existence. hunter May 2025 #22
It's a republican policy. BComplex May 2025 #25
Why? xuplate May 2025 #26
I've started having fun, pointing out to Trump voters ...... 70sEraVet May 2025 #27
Because our government now is not of, by and for the people FullySupportDems May 2025 #29
Two words... Mossfern May 2025 #31
Did anyone see the MSNBC town hall about fired federal workers? gab13by13 May 2025 #32
Because billionaires are the "truly entitled" Clouds Passing May 2025 #34
So far, I have not seen AI create anything original. Linda ladeewolf May 2025 #36
The billionaires want the end of times gab13by13 May 2025 #37
What could go right? dchill May 2025 #40
K&R c-rational May 2025 #38
"I reject that excuse" Ruby the Liberal May 2025 #41
Although it is dishonest, the Republicans are not calling it a tax cut karynnj May 2025 #42
Because we have an oligarchy making the rules, and they pick themselves GoodRaisin May 2025 #43
because THAT is who the greedy old pig party works for Skittles May 2025 #44
Take the cap off taxable wages and benefits in SS HereForTheParty May 2025 #45

sop

(17,439 posts)
1. Why is it a given that we have to give a 7 trillion dollar tax cut to billionaires?
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:03 AM
May 2025

Because they bought the government.

werdna

(1,196 posts)
2. Obsession with acquiring obscene amounts of wealth -
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:09 AM
May 2025

- is a form of sociopathic mental illness, currently unrecognized by any professional psychological association or governing body I know of.

Hieronymus Phact

(722 posts)
33. I think it's not a special form of illness
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:46 AM
May 2025

It's classic addictive behavior we've seen over and over. I've come to realize that getting wads of money function on the brain like heroin or coke. You get a high and then want more, you want that high so bad you'll hurt people to get it.

Emile

(40,637 posts)
3. Republicans believe the wealthy create jobs and
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:18 AM
May 2025

by giving them tax cuts it will trickle back down. They been telling this lie for 100 years.

Demand create jobs. There will always be investors capitalizing on the demand.

gab13by13

(31,243 posts)
10. In the 1920's it was called Horse & Sparrow Economics
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:43 AM
May 2025

Feed the horse more oats and the sparrows will have plenty to eat. Reagan changed the name to trickle down.

IbogaProject

(5,620 posts)
21. What an absolute load of Horse Feathers
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:08 AM
May 2025

The income multiplier declines as income increases these schemes can't work.

BoRaGard

(7,591 posts)
5. Raw greed is core republiconism
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:33 AM
May 2025

They are happy to screw unto others, if it makes them mammon.

indusurb

(297 posts)
6. Because the billionaires have paid off all of the Republican senators and congress people,
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:41 AM
May 2025

Plus some of the Democrats as well. That kind of campaign contributions etc. buys billionaires a lot of tax cuts and deregulation. The only way to stop this is a Constitutional amendment for publicly funded elections, from dog catcher to president, along with banning professional lobbying. Get money out of our government.

travelingthrulife

(4,463 posts)
14. It really is the only solution. Get money out of politics.
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:52 AM
May 2025

I think the 24/7/365 campaigning is also what is helping to make people crazy. Limit the campaigning time to six weeks or something.

hatrack

(64,256 posts)
7. Because of the galactic egos of a handful of farcially rich toddler ASSHOLES . . .
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:18 AM
May 2025

This was one of FT's "Lunch with the FT" features, with this interview taking place at Altman's Napa Valley farm house, where he's spent much of his time since he and his husband welcomed their first child via surrogacy. Altman offered to cook lunch - a simple vegetarian meal - for the journalist instead of going to a restaurant where he'd be pestered by selfie seekers.

But he still reminded the journalist - FT editor Roula Khalaf - that as OpenAI CEO, he has the most important job in the world.

Not surprisingly, she writes that she found Altman "brimming with confidence" and "radiating ambition" and "convinced of his own destiny."

He's gone from thinking AI is as important as the Industrial Revolution to believing that the "explosion in creativity" from AI makes it more comparable to the Renaissance. (Note: Generative AI like OpenAI's is FAKE creativity via mashups possible only because OpenAI stole as much of the world's intellectual property as it could, and the theft continues, with OpenAI's bots scraping some websites as much as several hundred times a day.)

Altman, ever the company hypester,.tells her "people are saying" their most advanced models are "genius-level intelligence.". (People are saying otherwise, too.)

She asks Altman about recent questions on his company training AI on copyrighted intellectual property, including art from a Japanese anime studio whose founder has made his contempt for AI art clear. Altman tells her " compensation for artists may be required" (her words, not necessarily his) but he'd prefer to release the tools first and then "find answers to the questions that arise" (again, her words). And this is standard Silicon Valley "move fast, break things, steal things, pay the best lawyers whatever's necessary so you won't have to pay for what you broke and stole" business philosophy.

He compares AI art to the invention of the camera, a BS comparison. (Cameras capture reflected light from a real subject in front of them, and artistry and creativity are involved in choice of subject, lighting, angle, editing, etc. AI does a sort of shopping-with-keywords exploitation and mashup of stolen photos and artwork and their descriptions - often grotesque mashups - and the AI user and pretend artist can generate images of something with just a name, like a Latin species name, without having any idea what that object looks like, as long as the name and related image(s) were ripped off for the AI's training data.)

(and so forth . . . )

https://www.democraticunderground.com/100220304330

dutch777

(4,884 posts)
8. This and the lack of progress against inflation would be precisely what we should be beating the GOP with.
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:19 AM
May 2025

Our tendency as broad thinking Dems to is want to talk to and fix everything. We can't keep trying to win on 50 platform points, however worthy they may be. We win as the GOP did, on a few key issues that the voters care enough about to come out and vote for. But GOP is beholden to the donor base. Money into politics is the ultimate cause of erosion of our democracy.

Scrivener7

(58,350 posts)
9. RepubliQan Congress are co-dependent enablers of the billionaires' money hoarding mental illnesses.
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:35 AM
May 2025

gab13by13

(31,243 posts)
11. Missing my point
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:44 AM
May 2025

Why don't Congressional Democrats make Congressional Magats own giving 7 trillion dollars to billionaires?

Where is the debate about not giving the tax cuts?

haele

(15,083 posts)
16. Ongoing. Just not reported except
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:56 AM
May 2025

By those who actually follow CSPAN.
We as a society treat Congress as a joke anyway, yet complain they do nothing.
Have you contacted your congresscritter recently? Laz calls our senators and congressman every week talking about what's on the docket and how it affects our neighborhood and city -and their politics. Laz understands enough about history and economics to make his points.
They know where he stands. Because he talks to them and makes sound arguments.
And he calls them when he thinks they did something right.

hay rick

(9,357 posts)
20. Some have. They have been holding town halls in red districts.
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:08 AM
May 2025

Chris Murphy and Maxwell Frost are currently barnstorming Florida. Two things about that: 1) the Medicaid attack and tax cuts are front and center, but it's town halls- they talk about memecoins, the rule of law, and whatever else comes up; 2) cover your ears- the MSM has given their tour minimal attention- they give equal or greater coverage to Kash Patel in Vegas or Trump's latest word salad.

murielm99

(32,693 posts)
23. Sean Casten is doing this in Illinois.
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:11 AM
May 2025

Why don't the Dems do this? Why don't the Dems do that? Let's not forget that they are the minority in Congress. We can change that.

gab13by13

(31,243 posts)
30. Yeah, the ole GOTV strategy,
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:21 AM
May 2025

meanwhile our democracy disappears and the last election was stolen.

walkingman

(10,350 posts)
12. "Starve the beast" is a political strategy employed by American conservatives
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:48 AM
May 2025

to limit government spending[1][2][3] by cutting taxes, to deprive the federal government of revenue in a deliberate effort to force it to reduce spending.

“We tend to forget that Republicans were not always the party of tax cuts,” Prasad explained. “When President Ford wanted to cut taxes in the 1970s, it was conservative Republicans who were against. Within a few short years, what it meant to be a Republican completely changed.”

The Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981, the largest tax cut in U.S. history, from its inception in the mid-1970s to the passing of the law during Reagan’s first year in office marked the beginning of this philosophy.

Significant tax cuts are a distinctly American phenomenon. In contrast to other countries, the United States is unusual for maintaining a low level of tax revenue as a percentage of GDP, despite the rise of GDP over the last several decades.The U.S. can learn from a European-style tax policy that embeds progressive policies into a system that also promotes businesses and encourages economic growth. BUT NO, NO, NO that would help the average American citizen - that would be so Anti...America First.

JCMach1

(29,090 posts)
19. Past tense. Technofascists want to almost completely eliminate
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:01 AM
May 2025

Central governance.

Starve the beast is now a sweet old fashioned idea.

walkingman

(10,350 posts)
24. Good point - it does appear to be so.
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:16 AM
May 2025

Not sure who/what is driving this? The GOP Congressional leaders do not appear to be smart enough to plan this as a strategy and no doubt the GOP POTUS's are not - Reagan, Bush, Bush, Trump....no way.

JCMach1

(29,090 posts)
35. Read Yarvin, (or don't) read some summaries and critiques
Sun May 11, 2025, 10:37 AM
May 2025

Of his wankings.

I refuse to say writings.

JD Vance, Musk, Thiel and others are the ones driving the boat with this stuff. Trump is literally just the front man (think Squid Game).

IronLionZion

(50,821 posts)
13. Because they bribed and lobbied enough GOP politicians
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:50 AM
May 2025

Poor and working class don't bribe enough

flvegan

(65,777 posts)
17. Wow, lots of responses blaming republicans (easy), not so many addressing the OP's questions. n/t
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:57 AM
May 2025

Wounded Bear

(63,843 posts)
18. The point is that they don't care if you survive...
Sun May 11, 2025, 08:58 AM
May 2025

There is no empathy in them, just greed. They will always want more.

hunter

(40,375 posts)
22. They really ought to be taxed out of existence.
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:10 AM
May 2025

Some of them are dangerous and need to be in prison.

xuplate

(159 posts)
26. Why?
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:18 AM
May 2025

Because so many voters are sheep and want to be told how to think. The GOP is quick to always be the first to publicly define their version of the so called reality of a situation. In addition to beating the Dems to the megaphone, they also send out their shills to all the media outlets. In the world of influence its first come, first believed. By the time the Dems respond the mindset has become firmly planted and is hard to remove. It happens continuously over and over again. Mitch McConnell is the master of the technique. The fact that he has been absent of late, at least publicly, speaks volumes about his opinion of Trump.

There is a book called “Influence” by Robert Cialdini that explains how influence works and how easy it is to apply it to manipulate public opinion. A must read if you are really into politics or just want to understand human interaction.

70sEraVet

(5,233 posts)
27. I've started having fun, pointing out to Trump voters ......
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:19 AM
May 2025

that with all of this effort to save money, by firing masses of federal workers and slashing government agencies and programs, has there been ANY talk of using the money saved to pay down the National Debt? Remember the National Debt -- that enormous number that used to make Republican leaders so worried?
No, all of this pain is only so we can give tax cuts to Trump and his highest-paying donors!

FullySupportDems

(407 posts)
29. Because our government now is not of, by and for the people
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:21 AM
May 2025

Unfortunately too many elected officials, and voters, don't believe in consent of the governed. They think might makes right.

gab13by13

(31,243 posts)
32. Did anyone see the MSNBC town hall about fired federal workers?
Sun May 11, 2025, 09:31 AM
May 2025

It was riveting and used personal, individual examples.

Democrats need to do town halls similar to the one done for fired federal workers, town halls with one topic.

Example: SignalGate and NLRB gate is not getting enough attention so do a town hall about this relating to our national security.
Get Malcolm Nance to moderate it and get people who are or were involved in national security as guests, maybe pry General Milley off his couch. With the proper publicity the MSM will be all over this type of town hall.

Do a town hall on billionaire tax cuts vs gutting the social safety net. Have Martin O'Malley as a moderator and get people to attend whose lives are dependent on the social safety net. let ordinary people tell their stories.

If the DNC wants some ideas, PM me. Wasting time on a 3rd impeachment is the definition of insanity.

Linda ladeewolf

(1,106 posts)
36. So far, I have not seen AI create anything original.
Sun May 11, 2025, 10:58 AM
May 2025

Being a crafter, I see ai in many things. Crochet patterns with lovely images of what it’s “supposed“ to look like, but never does. Bright colorful books on subjects that the “writer” knows nothing about. Weaving, knitting, crochet. You name it. Some charlatan has gone to ChatGPT and had it write a book for him/her that looks beautiful but doesn’t make sense to a knowledgeable crafter. Then they use it to scam people out of money until it gets so many bad reviews no one will buy it. Ai does what it’s told but cannot create! Yet! We had all better hope it never learns to do more than efficiently take orders.

gab13by13

(31,243 posts)
37. The billionaires want the end of times
Sun May 11, 2025, 11:51 AM
May 2025

They can hole up in their fortified mansions and they plan on AI solving the earth's problems from climate change.

Ruby the Liberal

(26,601 posts)
41. "I reject that excuse"
Sun May 11, 2025, 04:19 PM
May 2025

I don't.

They manufactured a horserace and now they have what they wanted - a black mirror style reality show to air nonstop to a frightened nation.

karynnj

(60,783 posts)
42. Although it is dishonest, the Republicans are not calling it a tax cut
Sun May 11, 2025, 04:42 PM
May 2025

The reason is that the current rate was reduced by the Trump tax cuts that expire. They expire because when enacted they were unsustainable if permanent.

Now, they want to prevent a ,"tax increase" which is really the rate returning to the rate before the TEMPORARY tax cut. All the cuts etc already threatened are still not enough to offset making that tax break permanent.

GoodRaisin

(10,735 posts)
43. Because we have an oligarchy making the rules, and they pick themselves
Sun May 11, 2025, 04:57 PM
May 2025

to be the beneficiaries of the rules. They plan to scrape together every last cent we have to live off of and give it to themselves. There is no check and balance system on greed in an oligarchy..

 

HereForTheParty

(915 posts)
45. Take the cap off taxable wages and benefits in SS
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:15 PM
May 2025

It closes a little over half the shortfall.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why Is It A Given That We...