General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThis message was self-deleted by its author
This message was self-deleted by its author (PeaceWave) on Sat Jul 5, 2025, 07:23 PM. When the original post in a discussion thread is self-deleted, the entire discussion thread is automatically locked so new replies cannot be posted.
Scrivener7
(58,277 posts)Prairie Gates
(7,175 posts)
The answer is no.
BannonsLiver
(20,259 posts)It's clear that there is absolutely nobody in the current Trump cabinet who possesses the necessary competency, and I have to assume the military leaders advising him are bottom-of-the-barrel incompetents as well, given that he or someone in the cabinet has selected them for that role. It's C teamers (or worse) across the board which is deeply concerning.
Delarage
(2,537 posts)Iran is an oppressive terrorist state that is helping Russia fight in Ukraine (by cranking out drones for them) and its subsidiaries regularly target American soldiers and sailors. So I'm on board with taking out their nuclear program. But the fact that Trump usually endorses only evil plans makes me worry.
Strelnikov_
(8,096 posts)Response to PeaceWave (Original post)
wcmagumba This message was self-deleted by its author.
ck4829
(37,421 posts)brush
(61,033 posts)in Gaza or the one that just got attacked...unprovoked...sorta like Putin did to Ukraine.
msongs
(73,076 posts)SSJVegeta
(2,278 posts)And Israel wouldnt be bombing them if they knew they had one.
Prairie Gates
(7,175 posts)This thread will never see the OP again!
crim son
(27,549 posts)that Iran has stated that, if they want to build nuclear weapons, they are going to build them. Someone upthread mentioned the instability in the region. I don't want Iran to have nukes but I admit, if I were in their position, I'd want to be able to defend myself.
Crunchy Frog
(28,214 posts)In spite of how messy it's likely to be.
choie
(6,602 posts)Crunchy Frog
(28,214 posts)whenever they respond to a post that's critical of russia. You don't happen to live in St. Petersburg do you? Anyway, well done!
choie
(6,602 posts)You are just like those who advocated invading Iraq in 2003, remaining comfy in their recliners while American forces were cannon fodder. Not to mention a million Iraqis murdered. Armchair warriors.
Response to choie (Reply #34)
Post removed
sarisataka
(22,216 posts)Obama, Sarkozy and Brown less so
From the second link-
Torchlight
(6,307 posts)jmowreader
(52,897 posts)The United States government has built several "fortified underground fortresses under mountains" that have nothing to do with nuclear weapons, like Command Post Tango in Korea.
I'll come right out and say it: I believe Iran is trying to become a nuclear-armed state, and since no one will sell them any they have to make their own.
Iran ALSO knows Donald Trump is president of the United States and he spends all the time he's not making speeches, writing tweets, eating hamberders, profiteering from his office or playing golf trying to develop a moderately-plausible casus belli for attacking Iran. As such, they need a contingency headquarters for the government that can't be taken out by Tomahawk missiles.
2naSalit
(99,979 posts)In the past have sought refuge underground from any number of threats. Perhaps they are making a place of refuge for their people.
EX500rider
(12,180 posts)Response to EX500rider (Reply #24)
PeaceWave This message was self-deleted by its author.
Straw Man
(6,928 posts)... ranks up there with the Easter Bunny.
AZProgressive
(29,848 posts)They were also in negotiations with the US before Israel attacked them like they were when they made a deal with Obama which Netanyahu was against at the time.
AloeVera
(3,991 posts)Bomb bomb bomb - bomb bomb Iran!
Sung by John McCain years ago.
Straw Man
(6,928 posts)"Close" is a subjective adjective. Of course it was in his interest to claim that, but how close is an open question.
I agree that the Obama deal probably caused them to move their program to the proverbial back burner, but when that was shitcanned by Trump, why wouldn't they restart?
mopinko
(73,307 posts)someone i follow on fb says seismographs detected something that cd b an underground test. take it for what its worth. seems like a good source who often has contrary evidence to whats being peddled elsewhere.
i have no doubt they want them, r working on them, and wd love to lob them at israel. its their publicly stated goal to wipe out the jews. theyre major funders of hamas, as well as every terrorist group in the region.
i wouldnt wait around for them to do that.
beaglelover
(4,427 posts)Response to beaglelover (Reply #19)
PeaceWave This message was self-deleted by its author.
Blue Full Moon
(3,147 posts)NickB79
(20,241 posts)The IAEA has confirmed this as well. Weapons grade is around 90%.
Commercial nuclear reactors only require 5% enriched uranium. The only reason to enrich this far is for weapons production.
The only question is how close Iran is to a bomb, not whether or not they're trying to build one.
Response to NickB79 (Reply #22)
PeaceWave This message was self-deleted by its author.
LexVegas
(6,951 posts)meadowlander
(5,097 posts)and overthrowing their government is the way to get them to stop.
ILikePie92
(223 posts)....that in the last few days, Israel answered your question.
brush
(61,033 posts)sir pball
(5,250 posts)They have the fissile material, the enriched uranium and/or plutonium - once any reasonably industrial state has that, actually building a bomb is a relatively simple exercise that shouldn't take more than half a year. Nuclear weapons are no longer a dark art, the basic plans are available on Reddit
the only hard part is getting the fuel.
Iran doesn't have a bomb because they don't want to make one, not because they can't. Japan could also have one in six months but nobody is complaining about them
GaYellowDawg
(5,073 posts)Frankly, it's insulting to Japan to try to lump the two together.
0rganism
(25,470 posts)I mean, if i were an evil overlord running an authoritarian theocracy, or an authoritarian country of any kind, or even just me in 5th grade, I would definitely want a fortified underground fortress. Seriously. That's gotta be in the top 10 reasons to even be an evil overlord, or a generic Bond villain, in the first place. A lot of the evil stuff you have to do is repetitive and lame, but the underground fortress is where you get to be creative. Bonus points if you build it in an active volcano.
Seeking Serenity
(3,279 posts)We'll try to stay serene and calm
When Alabama gets the bomb!"
GaYellowDawg
(5,073 posts)1. Israel is a rogue state in the midst of genocide.
2. Iran is a terrorist state run by nihilistic religious fanatics who should never, never have nuclear weapons.
Both can be true.
I do not support the United States being directly involved in this war, or lending financial or logistical support to it. Let them fight it out. Maybe the last nation standing will be too weak to commit resources to genocide or supporting terror groups. I was going to say "will be peaceful" but the region will be blood-soaked as long as the Abrahamic religions exist.
That said, because fundamentalist Christianity is a death cult whose only use for Israel is as a tool to end the world, doesn't mean my opposition to them includes supporting Iran. If Israel can wipe them off the map on their own, I won't shed a tear.
Cerulean Southpaw
(46 posts)#1 is only true if you're using the HAMAS-inspired definition of the word "genocide". Israel has welcomed outsiders since Israel has existed, giving them voting-rights and even the right to hold positions in government. When anyone calls Israel "genocidal", it's the biggest :rolleyes moment ever.
On the other side of the coin, Iran has made it a mission-statement to destroy Israel and exterminate the jews.
Israel isn't always "the good guy", but it's sad how some people want to act like they're always "the bad guys", and then support anyone who opposes them. It's just hopping on a bandwagon of murderous hate.
Jit423
(1,568 posts)If your were indiscriminately being bombed with some of the most sophisticated weapons on earth, wouldn't you dig deep to protect valuables and perhaps prepare national shelters to protect your energy resources?
EX500rider
(12,180 posts)womanofthehills
(10,705 posts)The underground missile bases store their ballistic missiles, cruise missiles and launchers - according to Groc.
Iran also has underground air and naval bases.
EX500rider
(12,180 posts)I was responding to this quote:
"wouldn't you dig deep to protect valuables and perhaps prepare national shelters to protect your energy resources?"