Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

31st Street Bridge

(67 posts)
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 02:39 PM 3 hrs ago

Does the human race need a huge catharsis to straighten out its act?

Think of it: Only through cataclysm does mankind ever really solve anything.
It took a Revolution to make America free.
It took a Civil War to free enslaved people in the United States.
It took a crippling Great Depression for a real social safety net to develop.
It took 65 million deaths in World War II to stop Hitler and his fascists.

Must we have a blowout World War III now to really set us straight? If that's even possible?
Just asking.

21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Does the human race need a huge catharsis to straighten out its act? (Original Post) 31st Street Bridge 3 hrs ago OP
By the end of World War II we had nuclear weapons, relatively small nuclear weapons. Jim__ 2 hrs ago #1
Yes, and the cure for diabetes is a diet of only doughnuts and candy bucolic_frolic 2 hrs ago #2
and 1 azzwhole to reverse 250 years of progress rampartd 2 hrs ago #3
There are still selfish troglodytes. haele 2 hrs ago #4
This book is really sobering SamuelTheThird 2 hrs ago #5
I heard Taylor Swift is mentioned in Revelations. BannonsLiver 2 hrs ago #8
I apologize SamuelTheThird 2 hrs ago #9
No check that, I heard she's a prize in a Cracker Jack box. BannonsLiver 1 hr ago #14
I think most of us would settle for your not spreading RW BS from bot farms on DU Emrys 1 hr ago #15
Straw man argument SamuelTheThird 1 hr ago #17
Another attempt at dodging from you after your bravura performance yesterday. It'll fare as well. Emrys 44 min ago #19
What bs SamuelTheThird 32 min ago #20
The crisis, when it comes canetoad 2 hrs ago #6
That would only be a temporary solution. BannonsLiver 2 hrs ago #7
Can't supply cat-harsis, but here's... GJGCA 2 hrs ago #10
I'll take it. 3catwoman3 1 hr ago #16
Humanity will never "straighten out it's act". maxsolomon 1 hr ago #11
Sad but true... GJGCA 1 hr ago #13
Foundation Series OC375 1 hr ago #12
The doctor's orders in "Dracula: Dead and Loving It"... BH liberal 1 hr ago #18
A WWIII would be the end of humans with all the nukes flying Bayard 17 min ago #21

Jim__

(15,061 posts)
1. By the end of World War II we had nuclear weapons, relatively small nuclear weapons.
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 02:52 PM
2 hrs ago

We used some of those small nuclear weapons. We have large nuclear weapons now. If there is a World War III, what are the odds we use some of those large nuclear weapons. Do you think using those weapons will set us straight?

bucolic_frolic

(53,891 posts)
2. Yes, and the cure for diabetes is a diet of only doughnuts and candy
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 02:58 PM
2 hrs ago

It's the inoculation of disease principle applied to nutrition, same as you apply it to politics and nationhood.

rampartd

(3,687 posts)
3. and 1 azzwhole to reverse 250 years of progress
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 02:59 PM
2 hrs ago

the usa, and maybe 90% of us, are quite doomed however or whenever he and his cult are raptured.

haele

(15,051 posts)
4. There are still selfish troglodytes.
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 03:01 PM
2 hrs ago

The sociopathic baby-men (and women) who believe cooperation is a weakness. Unless it primarily benefits them.
Other people are competition to them; if they're not the center of attention, if they can't own the outcome, anything that's going on without their agreement or approval is an attack against them.

Those idiots have always been with us. They are never able to think beyond themselves.

SamuelTheThird

(586 posts)
9. I apologize
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 03:20 PM
2 hrs ago

I'll know my place as a peasant and not criticize the defenseless billionaire. I'm very contrite

Emrys

(8,922 posts)
15. I think most of us would settle for your not spreading RW BS from bot farms on DU
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 04:11 PM
1 hr ago

See here, as you still don't seem to realize you were, at best and on the most charitable interpretation, gullible, unlike many of those who responded to your infamous OPs:

Note: Though based on research about recent campaigns targeting Taylor Swift, the findings have wider relevance for potential political influence operations in future, as detailed in the last paragraph quoted below.

Taylor Swift's Last Album Sparked Bizarre Accusations of Nazism. It Was a Coordinated Attack

Data analysis of social media posts painting the singer as a Trump supporter or white supremacist revealed a network of inauthentic accounts

...
Soon, online discussion of the [The Life of a Showgirl] album turned extreme in ways that many found bewildering. There were social media posts accusing Swift of implicitly endorsing the MAGA movement, trad-wife gender norms, and even white supremacy with dogwhistle references. While the far-right have been known to claim the singer as an icon of “Aryan” greatness despite her record of championing Democrats and liberal values — and President Trump himself has blithely and disingenuously shared AI-generated imagery depicting her as a supporter — this was a noticeably divergent trend, an apparent attempt to cancel Swift for those presumed affiliations. The attacks largely focused on specific word choices (her use of the term “savage” on the song “Eldest Daughter” was interpreted as racist) and symbols (a necklace for sale on her website stirred up Nazi comparisons because its lightning bolt charms bore a passing resemblance to the bolt pattern worn by the SS).
...

Editor’s picks

What Swift’s defenders didn’t realize, however, was that they were pushing back against a false narrative that had been seeded and amplified by a small network of inauthentic social accounts. Worse, they were helping to disseminate those bad-faith allegations by earnestly engaging with them.

That’s according to new research from GUDEA, a behavioral intelligence startup that tracks how such reputation-damaging claims emerge and go viral on the internet. In a white paper examining more than 24,000 posts and 18,000 accounts across 14 digital platforms between Oct. 4 (the day after The Life of a Showgirl came out) and Oct. 18, shared first with Rolling Stone, the firm concluded that just 3.77 percent of accounts drove 28 percent of the conversation around Swift and the album during that period. This cluster of evidently coordinated accounts pushed the most inflammatory Swift content, including conspiracy theories about her supposed Nazi allusions, callouts for her theoretical MAGA ties, and posts that framed her relationship with fiancé Travis Kelce as inherently conservative or “trad,” with all of this framed as leftist critique.

Once the provocations were injected into the Swift discourse — often they appeared in edgier online forums like 4chan or KiwiFarms before migrating to popular social apps — they were organically sustained by the people challenging them on mainstream platforms. This, in turn, algorithmically reinforced their visibility. “The false narrative that Taylor Swift was using Nazi symbolism did not remain confined to fringe conspiratorial spaces; it successfully pulled typical users into comparisons between Swift and Kanye West,” the researchers wrote. “This demonstrates how a strategically seeded falsehood can convert into widespread authentic discourse, reshaping public perception even when most users do not believe the origin.
...
The more recent, Swift-focused activity of these accounts may indicate the owner(s) dipping a toe in the water before pursuing other ends with this network in the future. After all, while [Blake] Lively has argued that [Justin] Baldoni is trying to sabotage her career with bot-driven commentary, it’s not immediately clear what anyone stands to gain from painting Swift as a closet MAGA voter.

“When we put our doomsday hat on, I think we can see that reality,” Paul says of the test-run scenario. It could be, she speculates, “that there might be other nefarious actors, not U.S.-based, who have reasons to see, ‘If I can move the fan base for Taylor Swift — an icon who is this political figure, in a way — does that mean I can do it in other places?’”

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/taylor-swifts-social-media-campaign-life-of-a-showgirl-1235480646/

SamuelTheThird

(586 posts)
17. Straw man argument
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 04:37 PM
1 hr ago

I typed nothing dealing with any of this-

'The attacks largely focused on specific word choices (her use of the term “savage” on the song “Eldest Daughter” was interpreted as racist) and symbols (a necklace for sale on her website stirred up Nazi comparisons because its lightning bolt charms bore a passing resemblance to the bolt pattern worn by the SS).'

I did accurately note she didnt criticize ICE for using her song, unlike other artists.

I also linked to her friendships with MAGA people and her praising MAGA podcasts

Subsequently I also mentioned her documented high emissions from her vanity private jet use.

So, nothing I said was sourced from right wing bot farms. You are mistaken

Emrys

(8,922 posts)
19. Another attempt at dodging from you after your bravura performance yesterday. It'll fare as well.
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 05:00 PM
44 min ago

Read the whole article, which I had to excerpt severely to try to comply with DU's fair use rules.

It covers quite a few bases you did scattergun touch on during your rants. You did source your first screed from Reddit. It's one of the sites used in the campaign analysed. It's certainly not hard to find haters on Reddit, so it's fertile ground for campaigns such as those described.

The point of the article is how these memes spread from the kernel planted by the botnets, often propagated by well-meaning dupes who've had the right buttons pressed. If the cap fits ...

And here, yet again you're regurgitating the same supposed slams - "her friendships with MAGA people", "her documented high emissions from her vanity private jet use" yadayada, all responded to and rebutted multiple times (in the case of the flights, ably refuted by accurately citing what the article you linked in your support actually said, not what you wished and claimed it said) by those who bothered to reply to you yesterday.

I think you have a handful of buyers here. Keep pumping if you must, but I think you'll find you're pumping mud.

SamuelTheThird

(586 posts)
20. What bs
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 05:12 PM
32 min ago

Her private jet CO2 emissions have never been refuted.

And the friendships and podcasts are facts. Go refute them right here specifically if you can.

This celeb worship is really bizarre to me

canetoad

(20,137 posts)
6. The crisis, when it comes
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 03:15 PM
2 hrs ago

Will likely be the trigger that wipes out the humans.

Carl Sagan said:
Extinction is the rule. Survival is the exception.

BannonsLiver

(20,218 posts)
7. That would only be a temporary solution.
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 03:17 PM
2 hrs ago

As long as social media consumption is at current levels the species is doomed. We could have an alien invasion and it would be politicized and fully tribal in a matter of hours. Probably even before we could be exterminated.

maxsolomon

(38,127 posts)
11. Humanity will never "straighten out it's act".
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 03:52 PM
1 hr ago

We've been following the same barbaric course for 10,000 years (that we know of).

GJGCA

(210 posts)
13. Sad but true...
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 04:00 PM
1 hr ago
Out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made.
--Immanuel Kant

OC375

(410 posts)
12. Foundation Series
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 03:55 PM
1 hr ago

In some ways it’s prophetic, until you realize it’s just retelling human history.

BH liberal

(104 posts)
18. The doctor's orders in "Dracula: Dead and Loving It"...
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 04:40 PM
1 hr ago

would be a good place to start:

"Give them all an enema!"

Bayard

(28,446 posts)
21. A WWIII would be the end of humans with all the nukes flying
Tue Dec 30, 2025, 05:27 PM
17 min ago

Unfortunately, we'll drag the rest of the planet down with us. We seem compelled to destroy ourselves.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Does the human race need ...