Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Diamond_Dog

(41,216 posts)
Sat May 30, 2026, 11:15 AM 12 hrs ago

Why Do Stores Throw Away So Many Perfectly Good Products? I Went Dumpster Diving to Find Out.

(Not me, Diamond_Dog, the author of the article).

********

Before I flew to Texas to fully immerse myself in the reality of dumpster diving, I spent hours online watching videos of people pulling scores of discarded products out of various stores’ trash bags. As I scrolled, I saw influencer after influencer yelping with excitement as they found all sorts of delightful stuff for free — a bicycle! makeup! candles! Lego sets! luxury leather handbags! — just by digging through the garbage.

Dumpster diving is a treasure hunt and a game of chance. What will you find next? A bounty of gold jewelry? Or … a pile of trash?

And all I have to do is peek (or dive) into a dumpster to find out? Count me in!

So over the past few months, I descended into the muck — following dumpster divers both online and in person — to get an intimate look at what’s hiding in our trash bins.

The experience made me uncomfortable, dirty, tired, and a little nauseated.

And I had an absolute blast.

https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/dumpster-diving-investigation/?campaign_id=190&emc=edit_ufn_20260530&instance_id=176410&nl=from-the-times&regi_id=74838209&segment_id=220702&user_id=a9aa4f5d6050c1b2fa535a7ed5551a5b

14 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why Do Stores Throw Away So Many Perfectly Good Products? I Went Dumpster Diving to Find Out. (Original Post) Diamond_Dog 12 hrs ago OP
Economy of scale and tax write-offs. marble falls 12 hrs ago #1
Not Really A Write-Off ProfessorGAC 11 hrs ago #2
Against inventory. Igel 6 hrs ago #9
;-{) WHO KNOWS WHAT........ Goonch 10 hrs ago #3
Is that a Bob Kennedy photo? displacedvermoter 10 hrs ago #6
Paywalled article. n/t Jacson6 10 hrs ago #4
I'm sorry, Jacson6. It came through for me. Diamond_Dog 9 hrs ago #7
Sounds very RFK Jr-ey lame54 10 hrs ago #5
All the dumpsters around here are locked up because they attract homeless people. hunter 9 hrs ago #8
The manufacturers make them do it for their brand's image BigmanPigman 4 hrs ago #10
Very interesting article, I read the whole thing! Jack Valentino 1 hr ago #11
Message auto-removed Name removed 1 hr ago #12
Obama had Iran and 7 countries agree to inspections of Iran's nuclear program including cameras of their activities. surfered 1 hr ago #13
Sorry to interrupt the thread, but the previous poster was a known troll and I couldn't resist. surfered 1 hr ago #14

ProfessorGAC

(77,377 posts)
2. Not Really A Write-Off
Sat May 30, 2026, 12:26 PM
11 hrs ago

The cost of goods at wholesale is already part of the expenses, so on a P&L statement, the expenses have no revenue offset. No taxes are paid anyway.
Now, if they gave away stuff past it's sell-by date, (but still suitable for consumption) to a food pantry, the lost margin IS a write-off. But, only the margins, not the retail value, as what the store paid is already non-taxable.
In our tax accounting class in MBA school, retail was a focus for about 40% of the term, and grocery was a case study for a quarter of that. Learned quite a lot in that class.

hunter

(40,892 posts)
8. All the dumpsters around here are locked up because they attract homeless people.
Sat May 30, 2026, 02:52 PM
9 hrs ago


On the other hand our local food bank is pretty good.

Life would be better if we simply provided homeless people with safe, secure, comfortable places to live. It wouldn't have to be anything fancy.

The "no free lunch" people who don't even want to feed hungry school children have trashed this nation. They want the homeless around to serve as a threat to any wage slave who might protest dangerous, inhumane, and soul-killing working conditions.

You don't want to be that guy...

I've been a dumpster diver at certain times in my life for various reasons, including homelessness.

When my wife started grad school we furnished our apartment with stuff that had been abandoned beside the dumpsters at the end of the school term.

At one of my kid's college the school had a formal system for redistributing all this stuff. It was astonishing what graduating classes left behind. There were microwave ovens, mini-fridges, any sort of furniture you might need, bicycles, clothing...

Maybe every community needs a place like that, but it would be a shame to deprive WalMart or Target of that business...

BigmanPigman

(55,633 posts)
10. The manufacturers make them do it for their brand's image
Sat May 30, 2026, 07:24 PM
4 hrs ago

I worked at Macy's in Visual/Display and I was going to call the local news since brand new leather belts were among tons of expensive items that were trashed into the dumpsters since the various manufacturers, like Calvin Klein, Bill Blass, etc would not let us even donate items to charities, thrift stores, and so on. They didn't want their products "cheapened".

When I became a teacher I lived a block away from the Ed Center and I saw brand new phonics books in the dumpster. I recognized the books since I had the same ones in my classroom at a different school. The local news said the books were "old and damaged" but they weren't, they were the district's new books purchased with our tax dollars. Each classroom had several hundred of them.

Jack Valentino

(5,264 posts)
11. Very interesting article, I read the whole thing!
Sat May 30, 2026, 10:19 PM
1 hr ago

"“There is this gap between what is usable for consumers and what is sellable for retailers"

I am an almost daily customer of a 'Dollar General' which is about 400 yards from my house---
now I'm wondering what might be found in THEIR dumpster, after-hours!

(Likely a lot of cardboard which I could use to cover my garden at the end of the season,
at the least!)

I'm an Ebay seller also, although I haven't done much of that recently---
but offering products which cost me nothing but physical energy to procure
would obviously be a big plus! HMMMMM...


Response to Diamond_Dog (Original post)

surfered

(14,535 posts)
13. Obama had Iran and 7 countries agree to inspections of Iran's nuclear program including cameras of their activities.
Sat May 30, 2026, 11:02 PM
1 hr ago

Trump said that was a bad deal. He tore that agreement up. Now he’s launched a war he cannot win and cannot end and we will be worse off and you’re talking bananas.

surfered

(14,535 posts)
14. Sorry to interrupt the thread, but the previous poster was a known troll and I couldn't resist.
Sat May 30, 2026, 11:12 PM
1 hr ago
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why Do Stores Throw Away ...