Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
24 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Carville on Platner: (Original Post) applegrove Jun 7 OP
I'm hoping Carville's right on this one. oasis Jun 7 #1
I'm really anxietied up over it. Does not feel good. applegrove Jun 7 #2
I believe Carville thinks a strong anti-Trump Dem oasis Jun 7 #5
Didn't we think we would get that with Fetterman? LisaL Jun 7 #6
How about this? Wiz Imp Jun 8 #20
That's the whole point of the organized smear campaign. Bluetus Jun 8 #13
Nope. I just don't know if he was aware he had a NAZI tatoo. applegrove Jun 8 #14
I don't deny he could turn out like Fetterman Bluetus Jun 8 #23
Its been a long time since he has been right about anything krawhitham Jun 8 #16
Here is an interesting take on what is going on Ars Longa Jun 7 #3
I can think of a few people LisaL Jun 7 #7
right?? Skittles Jun 7 #10
Morals are out, that's so 2016 (evils, lesser than; voting conscience) and 2024 ("genocide" one issue). betsuni Jun 7 #11
You must be a poet MorbidButterflyTat Jun 8 #18
I am ... um ... INSPIRED. betsuni Jun 8 #19
THIS Cosmocat Jun 8 #24
Now that's a ringing endorsement "Politics is not about picking good people." rogue emissary Jun 7 #4
yup Skittles Jun 7 #9
You don't have to be James Carville to rationalize the situation GoodRaisin Jun 7 #8
I don't much care for James Carville. Morbius Jun 7 #12
Exactly. When was the last time he was right about something? 1997? FSogol Jun 8 #17
I am so sick of AND DONE with Carville.. AZ8theist Jun 8 #21
The stakes have always been high Pris Jun 8 #15
He is the best chance we have to gain that senate seat questionseverything Jun 8 #22

oasis

(54,311 posts)
5. I believe Carville thinks a strong anti-Trump Dem
Sun Jun 7, 2026, 10:15 PM
Jun 7

will beat a wishy washy Republican like Collins.

LisaL

(48,014 posts)
6. Didn't we think we would get that with Fetterman?
Sun Jun 7, 2026, 10:30 PM
Jun 7

Can you point me to Platner's strong anti-Trump statements?

Wiz Imp

(10,802 posts)
20. How about this?
Mon Jun 8, 2026, 01:17 AM
Jun 8
https://www.newscentermaine.com/article/news/politics/elections/candidates/graham-platner-sabattus-maine-town-hall-senate-campaign/97-04091df7-0634-4fea-9282-9ef52e2194ed
Graham Platner vows 'investigation time' for Trump administration if Democrats regain control of US Senate
“We need to shut down the White House for the next two years," Platner said on Wednesday.

SABATTUS, Maine — Maine Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Graham Platner is promising a dramatic increase in oversight of the Trump administration should he help his party flip enough Republican seats for Democrats to regain a majority in the U.S. Senate.

Platner reiterated the goal—made previously at a Democratic Party forum two weeks ago—at his campaign’s 63rd town hall Wednesday night, when about 150 people filled the American Legion Post in the Androscoggin County town of Sabattus.

“If we get the majority, it is Senate committee investigation time," Platner said. "We need to shut down the White House for the next two years. Not only do we have so much crime and corruption to actually investigate, but it’s also a tool. If we haul everybody in the White House under subpoena in front of Senate committees over and over and over again, they won’t have time to be in the White House breaking more things. I also think not one Democratic Senator should vote to confirm a single nominee that come out of the Trump administration moving forward.”

“We got sold out by a political system that does not have our interests at heart—a political system that could not be a better example of than Susan Collins. Susan Collins is the epitome of the self-interested establishment politician who shows up for her donors and always leaves her constituents hanging," Platner said at the town hall. "Things have gotten worse down here in the 30 years that she's been in office. She brings in a little bit of money to the state to justify the fact that a lot more is getting sucked out of us by a system that was built to make sure that we all work harder and longer and for less. It needs to change.”

Bluetus

(3,282 posts)
13. That's the whole point of the organized smear campaign.
Mon Jun 8, 2026, 12:00 AM
Jun 8

This is most likely coming from AIPAC, Republicans and Corporate Dems. They want you to freak out.

applegrove

(133,731 posts)
14. Nope. I just don't know if he was aware he had a NAZI tatoo.
Mon Jun 8, 2026, 12:03 AM
Jun 8

I don't like the charisma attached to a questionable character. I guess we have no choice. Well Maine has no choice if they want the Senate seat.

Bluetus

(3,282 posts)
23. I don't deny he could turn out like Fetterman
Mon Jun 8, 2026, 10:51 AM
Jun 8

But I am impressed with the clarity and consistency of what Platner has been saying during the entire campaign. I believe our only hope is candidates who will speak clearly, forcefully and consistently, clearly on the side of working Americans.

EVERY candidate can be smeared. They are smearing Talarico for being a Vegan.

My rationalization is that if Platner turns out to be another Fetterman, we are no worse off than with Collins. OTOH, if he is true to his word, we gain some real backbone in the Senate, and we can build on that.

Regarding the tattoo, I simply don't believe anybody who claims to have known this was a Nazi symbol. That's a very obscure reference and the skull & crossbones imagery has been used millions of times in other contexts that have nothing to do with Nazis. Moreover, that misses the big picture, which is that it is now Israel that is leading the genocides. What Netanyahu has done to destroy sympathies for what the Jewish people suffered under Hitler is unforgivable.

betsuni

(29,430 posts)
11. Morals are out, that's so 2016 (evils, lesser than; voting conscience) and 2024 ("genocide" one issue).
Sun Jun 7, 2026, 11:47 PM
Jun 7

No Democrat was given the benefit of the doubt, corrupt motivations assumed, alarm over all the terrible caving they would do if not constantly and loudly bashed every day.

Math was out then, too. Vote Blue No Matter Who considered a threat telling people what to do, mention of Supreme Court and judges and legislation only possible with majorities was mocked.

Pragmatism was out, that was establishment, status quo, centrist, "donor class" blah blah blah.

Pragmatism not moral righteousness, trust the candidate, math is real. Welcome back, status quo!

Cosmocat

(15,519 posts)
24. THIS
Mon Jun 8, 2026, 11:05 AM
Jun 8

Republicans have had this mindset for many decades now - going back to the early 90s.

And, Ds almost always "taken the high road" and N E V E R. Not even once, been given credit for it, and the Rs never are held to account for it.

It is LONG past time for Ds to stop trying to hold itself up to standards that this country no longer has.

Morbius

(1,213 posts)
12. I don't much care for James Carville.
Sun Jun 7, 2026, 11:50 PM
Jun 7

Never have. It's completely in character for him to use the noise surrounding Platner to aggrandize himself. We do not need Carville or his advice.

FSogol

(47,686 posts)
17. Exactly. When was the last time he was right about something? 1997?
Mon Jun 8, 2026, 12:44 AM
Jun 8

TV sure loves his corn pone act.

AZ8theist

(7,753 posts)
21. I am so sick of AND DONE with Carville..
Mon Jun 8, 2026, 01:43 AM
Jun 8

I get dozens of emails a day asking for money.

If Carville, in any way, is in the header, I IMMEDIATELY delete it.

I've even rached out to some of the campaigns I support that have used him and told them as much.
You want my money, get rid of that clown as a spokesman.

I don't know Carville is saying about Platner, AND I DON'T GIVE A SHIT.

But I do know, from everything I've read, that Platner is getting shafted from all directions. And he doesn't deserve it.
He has been, in fact, a staunch anti-Trumper, anti-fascist, pro-democracy veteran.

And he is far, FAR, FAR SUPERIOR to the useless bag of jellyfish intestines called Suzie Collins.
THAT we should all agree on.

And tell Carville to go fuck himself.

Pris

(176 posts)
15. The stakes have always been high
Mon Jun 8, 2026, 12:20 AM
Jun 8

Platner is a sexist and it's a terrible thing to do to women and girls.

It needed to end with the Nazi tattoo and the first sexist tweet,

But sexism lives and we've got the faux working class screw up.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Carville on Platner: