Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

wnylib

(26,968 posts)
Tue Jul 7, 2026, 04:16 PM 23 hrs ago

Regatding Platner and the party choosing his replacement.

Maine law calls for the party to choose a replacement when a candidate drops out.

I support many social programs of the DSA, but not all of them. But, since the voters in Maine chose a DSA candidate, it would seem fair for the replacement to be DSA.

However, is the DSA a separate party operating under the umbrella of the Democratic party, or are its members a faction within the party?

If they are a separate party, then why would the Dem party be obligated to choose another DSA candidate? If they are a Dem party faction, then there is no problem in choosing a DSA replacement.

However, whether they are separate or a Dem faction, if the party chooses an establishment candidate to replace Platner, the Maine voters who chose him could very well react by not voting at all and give Concerned Susie the election.

I am a NY resident, so I have no say in it. I am only trying to sort out what the issues and considerations are.




8 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Regatding Platner and the party choosing his replacement. (Original Post) wnylib 23 hrs ago OP
Right now there is talk about replacing him with an establishment candidate lapucelle 23 hrs ago #1
That suits me. QueerDuck 23 hrs ago #2
How will Maine voters react to an establishment candidate? wnylib 23 hrs ago #3
He couldn't win the primary for the office that Mills is holding for her second term lapucelle 23 hrs ago #4
I think the ME Dem party has options Torchlight 23 hrs ago #5
I think that we are going to see a Republican win this seat Bluestocking 22 hrs ago #6
the candidate ran in the Democratic primary eShirl 22 hrs ago #7
Maybe you missed the following part of the OP. wnylib 21 hrs ago #8

lapucelle

(21,356 posts)
1. Right now there is talk about replacing him with an establishment candidate
Tue Jul 7, 2026, 04:29 PM
23 hrs ago

who came in third in the June governor's primary. He was a DNC member and superdelegate until he was term-limited out in December 2024. Plus he's still youngish (mid-fifties).

Personally, I think that any politician who continued to endorse and campaign alongside Platner after the first NYT story broke might want to take a seat for a bit and think about how and why they messed this one up so badly despite all the red flags.





wnylib

(26,968 posts)
3. How will Maine voters react to an establishment candidate?
Tue Jul 7, 2026, 04:35 PM
23 hrs ago

Will they vote for him or sit out the general?

lapucelle

(21,356 posts)
4. He couldn't win the primary for the office that Mills is holding for her second term
Tue Jul 7, 2026, 04:43 PM
23 hrs ago

which doesn't bode well.

Torchlight

(7,383 posts)
5. I think the ME Dem party has options
Tue Jul 7, 2026, 04:46 PM
23 hrs ago

in that the party's state committee can decide whether to use a convention, state committee vote, caucus, or another method permitted by its bylaws. That's my understanding of it.

Bluestocking

(925 posts)
6. I think that we are going to see a Republican win this seat
Tue Jul 7, 2026, 05:04 PM
22 hrs ago

For another six years. Reminds me of what they did to Biden when they appointed Harris as the candidate. This may cost the Dems control of the Senate. Oh well, at least I got live in a Democracy for 60 years. It was nice but I am too old to relocate.

wnylib

(26,968 posts)
8. Maybe you missed the following part of the OP.
Tue Jul 7, 2026, 06:31 PM
21 hrs ago

When I asked about the DSA's identity, I asked if it was separate under the umbrella of the Democratic Party.

It is a legitimate question because it remains unclear whether the DSA identifies itself as a left wing within the party or considers itself a separate entity that needs to temporarily latch onto an existing party but only until it is strong enough to either be completely independent or to just remake the Dem party.

Sanders is both a DSA and an Independent. So he is not a Dem, but caucuses with Dems. He ran in the 2016 Dem presidential primaries, but identified himself as DSA.

The DSA has its own separate platform.

So the DSA does sound like a separate party that uses the structure and organization of the Dems to launch itself. If that's not the case, then maybe a spokesperson for the movement could clarify it for the general public because I know that I am not the only person who wants clarification.

Regarding Platner, the state party in Maine apparently allowed Platner to run as a Dem. The voters in Maine chose him. The party could choose another DSA In keeping with the voters' choice. If they choose an establishment Dem, they run the risk of losing all or most of Platner's followers.






Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Regatding Platner and the...