Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(137,091 posts)
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 07:10 AM Jul 26

Vance argued for higher tax rate on childless Americans in 2021 interview

Source: ABC News

July 26, 2024, 5:05 AM


As former President Donald Trump's new running mate, JD Vance, faces renewed scrutiny over his previous comments criticizing childless individuals, an unearthed 2021 interview shows the Ohio senator advocating for higher taxes on Americans without children. The comments came in a 2021 episode of The Charlie Kirk Show podcast, where Kirk, the CEO of the conservative student organization Turning Point USA, was discussing how Republicans could shift public perception of certain conservative ideas from "unthinkable" to accepted policy.

"So JD ... what are you going to do to change this conversation? Everything we have to do should be about moving ideas from unthinkable, to sensible, to popular, to policy," said Kirk, according to a video of the interview obtained by ABC News.

In response, Vance, who at the time had not yet officially launched his 2022 Senate campaign, suggested that the country needed to "reward the things that we think are good" and "punish the things that we think are bad" -- before suggesting that individuals without children should be taxed at a higher rate than those with children.

"So, you talk about tax policy, let's tax the things that are bad and not tax the things that are good," Vance said in the interview, which is no longer public on Kirk's channel. "If you are making $100,000, $400,000 a year and you've got three kids, you should pay a different, lower tax rate than if you are making the same amount of money and you don't have any kids. It's that simple."

Read more: https://abcnews.go.com/US/vance-argued-higher-tax-rate-childless-americans-2021/story?id=112284318



Last I saw, there was a separate IRS "filing status" called "SINGLE" that has a higher tax rate than any other category.
31 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Vance argued for higher tax rate on childless Americans in 2021 interview (Original Post) BumRushDaShow Jul 26 OP
Does he not know that already exists? It is called the child tax credit tulipsandroses Jul 26 #1
" It is called the child tax credit" - But not just THAT BumRushDaShow Jul 26 #12
YES MotownPgh Jul 26 #28
People without children are not CRIMINALS Brenda Jul 26 #2
Because we have all that disposable income . . . . . no_hypocrisy Jul 26 #3
Idiots should be taxed at a higher rate. twodogsbarking Jul 26 #4
Shady Vance is an ignorant little devil... FailureToCommunicate Jul 26 #5
Just the type magats love mdbl Jul 26 #22
He doesn't know there are tax credits for dependents? IronLionZion Jul 26 #6
As a grandmother, I am grateful to all those who pay for things they'll never use, like public schools, quaint Jul 26 #7
What a complete ASSHAT!!! Devilsun Jul 26 #8
Some people KNOW... 2naSalit Jul 26 #9
I feel you belong here. I am grateful for you here. AllyCat Jul 26 #18
Hey 2naSalit Brenda Jul 26 #19
That's pretty much it. 2naSalit Jul 26 #21
Sorry you're not feeling well. Brenda Jul 26 #24
Thanks... 2naSalit Jul 26 #25
We are all just visitors here. quaint Jul 26 #23
You are not the only one. MotownPgh Jul 26 #29
You are not alone MotownPgh Jul 26 #30
How to say "I haven't read the tax code" without speaking those words jmowreader Jul 26 #10
He also argued that parents should get extra votes for each child they have. erodriguez Jul 26 #11
"JD Vance aka Captain Caveman" BumRushDaShow Jul 26 #14
School taxes. nt Hotler Jul 26 #13
The really frightening line is this: 70sEraVet Jul 26 #15
I think I saw that he wrote a forward to the Project 2025 document BumRushDaShow Jul 26 #17
Yes. So we know EXACTLY what he is, and why tRump picked him. 70sEraVet Jul 26 #20
This has been happening already. The MotownPgh Jul 26 #31
And tax credits for having kids. AllyCat Jul 26 #16
Don't we already? Hello, JD, what about child tax credits? Ocelot II Jul 26 #26
Vance wants Gilead Happy Hoosier Jul 26 #27

tulipsandroses

(5,763 posts)
1. Does he not know that already exists? It is called the child tax credit
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 07:15 AM
Jul 26

Good Grief
While not a higher rate, you will pay less if you have kids vs someone without.

BumRushDaShow

(137,091 posts)
12. " It is called the child tax credit" - But not just THAT
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 09:28 AM
Jul 26

If those children are DEPENDENTS (and there are OTHERS who qualify in the household as a "dependent" ), then that will also factor into further claims for deductions, and reduction of one's taxes, outside of that child tax credit.

Brenda

(1,285 posts)
2. People without children are not CRIMINALS
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 07:15 AM
Jul 26

who should be "punished" and forced to pay more taxes and not have the same voting rights as people with kids!

Kamala needs to bring this up in interviews. This insane, extremist idea will not even be popular with normal R's.

Clearly Chump didn't vet this guy very well.

On edit: as previous poster said - a tax credit for kids exists, so childless people ALREADY pay more in taxes.

no_hypocrisy

(47,934 posts)
3. Because we have all that disposable income . . . . .
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 07:16 AM
Jul 26

Yeah, right.

We may not have children and have to spend our income on raising them, but unmarried individuals don't have the advantage of a combined income with a partner more times than not. We need to work longer to get a down payment and to qualify for mortgages, pay home insurance, property taxes, repair and maintenance of our homes.

We have no advantage over married-with-children folks.

quaint

(3,141 posts)
7. As a grandmother, I am grateful to all those who pay for things they'll never use, like public schools,
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 09:09 AM
Jul 26

kiddie parks, taxes to offset parental deductions for child care, private schools, etc.

2naSalit

(90,505 posts)
9. Some people KNOW...
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 09:25 AM
Jul 26

That having children would be a life of impoverished misery due to not having reliable partner or livable wages. That's why I have no children, I raised six who weren't mine by birth but I knew if I had any that they would have a shitty upbringing because I could not provide a reasonable lifestyle. It's been all I could do to take care of myself in this lopsided society. A few more years and I can fall off the planet, problem solved.

I have always felt that I don't belong here, anywhere, so I have resigned myself to looking forward to when I can finally go back to wherever I came from.

Brenda

(1,285 posts)
19. Hey 2naSalit
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 09:54 AM
Jul 26
I have always felt that I don't belong here, anywhere, so I have resigned myself to looking forward to when I can finally go back to wherever I came from.


I feel the same way! Remembering that helps me get through the anger, shock and depression regarding so many things in this world, especially with our beautiful planet being made uninhabitable for most life on it by beings who seem to be far worse than greedy selfish people but quite alien.

2naSalit

(90,505 posts)
21. That's pretty much it.
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 10:12 AM
Jul 26

Now that I'm officially old, approaching 70 in (For some reason the rest of my paragraph didn't load, weird)

So we can't get off the planet with our physical forms and that's all there is to it. If energy can only transform rather than dissipate, it's our physical forms that we will have to shed in order to carry on. I think that everyone who has been here, on this planet, was someone when they came here and when they departed, they are still in existence somewhere in a different form of energy.



I'm having a weird morning, got up at 2am and did some serious vomiting and have been recovering since. Not feeling all that bad, I must have eaten something that didn't agree with my stomach. This also happens when I mistakenly eat something that has some kind of mint in it that I can't immediately detect. I'm seriously allergic to mint. It feels like one of those events.

Brenda

(1,285 posts)
24. Sorry you're not feeling well.
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 10:48 AM
Jul 26

Never heard of a mint allergy but our bodies detect all kinds of "hidden" things I've discovered as I age.

Frankly, I have no idea what will happen to my energy/consciousness when I kick the bucket. All I know is that I'm going to be somewhere other than this fuckin' violent psycho planet.

Hope you feel better soon.

2naSalit

(90,505 posts)
25. Thanks...
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 10:52 AM
Jul 26

Now I'm just hungry and trying to decide what will go with my toast.

Too bad religion has everybody thinking that this is the only place and that leaving is bad, somehow.

MotownPgh

(246 posts)
29. You are not the only one.
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 11:19 AM
Jul 26

Great description. I was always fascinated by those redund checks for MORE than the recipient paid. It was child tax credits.
I have not once in my life, received a refund check.

MotownPgh

(246 posts)
30. You are not alone
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 11:20 AM
Jul 26

Great description. I was always fascinated by those refund checks for MORE than the recipient paid in. It was child tax credits.
I have not once in my life, received a refund check.

jmowreader

(51,083 posts)
10. How to say "I haven't read the tax code" without speaking those words
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 09:27 AM
Jul 26

Married Filing Jointly and Head of Household (single parents) filers have a bigger standard deduction than Single (childless unmarried people) filers do. Trump got rid of the personal deduction in his tax cut, but the Child Tax Credit, which requires you have kids, and the Earned Income Tax Credit, which essentially requires you to have kids, still exist. So...what Vance wants already exists, unless what he wants is to increase the number of tax brackets from seven to, say, ten, and say "if you have children your first taxable dollar will be taxed at 10 percent, but if you don't it will be taxed at 24 percent."

Which, naturally, would lead to the end of the Republican Party.

70sEraVet

(3,903 posts)
15. The really frightening line is this:
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 09:36 AM
Jul 26

"reward the things that we think are good" and "punish the things that we think are bad" (emphasis mine)

Using the IRS as a weapon to bring about your vision of an ideal society? Seems like Vance was the perfect, fascist pick (or 'prick').

Ocelot II

(119,038 posts)
26. Don't we already? Hello, JD, what about child tax credits?
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 10:56 AM
Jul 26

What about deductions for dependents? We sad, husbandless, childless cat ladies don't get any of those things, so we do pay an effectively higher tax rate. And we pay local taxes to support schools for the children we don't have.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Vance argued for higher t...