Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(146,370 posts)
Mon Oct 7, 2024, 02:34 PM Oct 2024

U.S. Christians pushing back on Christian nationalism

Source: Axios

12 hours ago


A wide variety of American Christians from different denominations are speaking out against Christian nationalism, a once-fringe movement steadily gaining political power in the U.S.

Why it matters: The pushback comes as critics worry rising Christian nationalism is threatening the nation's multiracial democracy and as a record number of Americans identify as "religiously unaffiliated."

The big picture: From the Greek Orthodox Church to Roman Catholics to evangelical Christian leaders, several grassroots efforts — primarily led by individuals rather than any church hierarchy — have sprung up to issue warnings about Christian nationalism.

  • In some cases, they are protesting against former President Donald Trump and challenging fellow Christians who are calling for a rigid theocracy and anti-immigrant policies.
  • They say those ideas abandon the compassionate teaching of Jesus that focuses on the dignity of each person and love for their neighbors.


  • Catch up quick: Christian nationalism is a set of beliefs centered around white American Christianity's dominance in most aspects of life in the United States.

  • It seeks to establish a country governed by a fundamentalist interpretation of the Bible. Adherents and allies of the movement have aligned themselves with Donald Trump.


  • Read more: https://www.axios.com/2024/10/07/christian-nationalism-opponents-trump
    33 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
    Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
    U.S. Christians pushing back on Christian nationalism (Original Post) BumRushDaShow Oct 2024 OP
    This message was self-deleted by its author Chin music Oct 2024 #1
    Omg right??? LearnedHand Oct 2024 #3
    The Great Deception (R) BoRaGard Oct 2024 #2
    Don't believe the "pushback" angrychair Oct 2024 #4
    You might want to update and expand your understanding of wnylib Oct 2024 #18
    What an amazing post; very educational and puts things in proper perspective. Thank you. nt Frank D. Lincoln Oct 2024 #22
    That Is The Same Attitude That Is Used To Condemn Muslims, Jews, Etc. TomCADem Oct 2024 #20
    This is absolutely essential for them to do if we are to survive Hekate Oct 2024 #5
    It's OK. No real Christians will be harmed by damning the "christian nationalists" (AKA Nazis) erronis Oct 2024 #6
    (In Al Michaels' field goal voice) Kid Berwyn Oct 2024 #7
    This is WAY too little and WAY too late!! JoetheShow Oct 2024 #8
    +1 Hotler Oct 2024 #30
    ABOUT TIME 4catsmom Oct 2024 #9
    Didn't Jesus say, "Render to Cesar the things that are Cesar's, and to God the things that are God's"? patphil Oct 2024 #10
    This. nt Frank D. Lincoln Oct 2024 #23
    Ha Roy Rolling Oct 2024 #24
    All organized religion is 90% politics... dchill Oct 2024 #11
    For quite some time the MSM has lumped all practicing Christians in with the extremely conservative evangelicals led by Ford_Prefect Oct 2024 #12
    Regardless of the topic, slightlv Oct 2024 #16
    People, especially the young are pushing back on politicized religion, especially Christianity Warpy Oct 2024 #13
    I talked to a lifelong friend yesterday who lives in one of Chicago's western suburbs. Talitha Oct 2024 #14
    And right then and there, that priest slightlv Oct 2024 #17
    Using their rules Roy Rolling Oct 2024 #25
    Gee, you think maybe flirting with authoritarian dictatorships is a terrible idea? Initech Oct 2024 #15
    Christian Nationalism has been tried before. Marcuse Oct 2024 #19
    How one evangelical leader uses the Bible to expose the 'False White Gospel' TomCADem Oct 2024 #21
    My Mrs goes to a fairly liberal wing of the Lutherans.. yourout Oct 2024 #26
    I saw a "Evangelicals for Harris" ad somewhere. oldsoftie Oct 2024 #27
    Yup and the estate got mad and the video of the ad was pulled from youtube BumRushDaShow Oct 2024 #28
    Wasnt Graham quoting the Bible? Remake the ad without using him. oldsoftie Oct 2024 #29
    They may have re-done the ad and/or done additional ones BumRushDaShow Oct 2024 #31
    "Adherents and allies of the movement have aligned themselves with Donald Trump" -- Martin Eden Oct 2024 #32
    "...primarily led by individuals rather than any church hierarchy" maxsolomon Oct 2024 #33

    Response to BumRushDaShow (Original post)

    angrychair

    (10,048 posts)
    4. Don't believe the "pushback"
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 02:54 PM
    Oct 2024

    They just want it done on the down low. A core tenet of Christianity is "convert or die" and has been from the very beginning. I mean they didn't spend the last 2000 years invading countries and murdering millions of people for no reason.

    wnylib

    (25,183 posts)
    18. You might want to update and expand your understanding of
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 09:54 PM
    Oct 2024

    Last edited Tue Oct 8, 2024, 03:50 AM - Edit history (1)

    the Christian sects.

    The ABC branch of Baptists has a group endorsed by the church leadership that actively opposes Christian Nationalism.
    Their opposition to it is based on the core Baptist belief that faith cannot be forced or imposed from the outside. It must be freely chosen, which is why they baptize adults into membership and not infants. They strongly defend religious freedom AND the right to have no religion.

    Calvinist-based denominations (Presbyterian, Amish, Mennonites, Reformed Churches), even the ones that practiced state religion in the past, oppose government enforced religion in the US today. The Amish and some branches of Mennonites are apolitical. They do not get involved in politics and do not proselytize.

    The largest branch of Presbyterians (PCUSA) are theologically and socially liberal. They respect the right of people to follow their own beliefs or to have no belief. The same is true of the largest branch of Lutherans, the ELCA.

    Those churches and others operate immigration programs that provide sponsorship, free legal assistance, language interpretation, and adjustment programs for immigrants. They also operate missions at the southern border to provide food, clothing, and legal help for asylum seekers who are let into the US. They aid people of all backgrounds and religions and do not require joining the churches that help them. Bringing immigrants and asylum seekers into the US is counter to nationalism and especially to Christian Nationalism.

    During the Nazi era in Germany, when Nazis infiltrated church councils in order to influence the churches to embrace German nationalism under the name of the German Christian Church, large numbers of Reformed and Lutheran pastors broke away and formed the Confessing Church (meaning faith-based, not politically based) in opposition to the German nationalist church. Some of their members were involved in resistance groups. They helped people escape Nazism. They called Hitler and the German Christian Church blasphemous for their worshiplike veneration of Hitler.

    Lutheran Pastor Dietrich Bonhoeffer was executed in a concentration camp for his resistance activities. Lutheran Pastor Martin Niemoller survived several camps and lived to 1984. He is the author of "First they came for the Socialists.... "

    Swiss Reformed Pastor Karl Barth was responsible for writing a declaration that rejected the Nazi influence on German Churches, which became the founding document for the Confessing Church (opponents of the German nationalist church). He mailed the document to Hitler and was forced to resign from his teaching position in Germany and return to Switzerland.






    TomCADem

    (17,787 posts)
    20. That Is The Same Attitude That Is Used To Condemn Muslims, Jews, Etc.
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 11:43 PM
    Oct 2024

    To paint entire groups of people with a broad brush. Martin Luther King, Jr. was a pastor.

    erronis

    (17,549 posts)
    6. It's OK. No real Christians will be harmed by damning the "christian nationalists" (AKA Nazis)
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 03:11 PM
    Oct 2024

    Once again, this group of RW zealots usurped the name of another group to appear as if they are in cahoots. The Nazis of the Bannon ilk have no link to christianity, except when they can use the name for marketing porpoises.

    JoetheShow

    (97 posts)
    8. This is WAY too little and WAY too late!!
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 03:20 PM
    Oct 2024

    These guys have had decades to push back against the Christian Nationalist. They've let the Falwells set the tone and agenda and they just tagged along. And now that there is push back, now the the country knows what the crazies are up to, NOW they push back. And where is the church leadership in all this? Welcome to the party after it's almost over, PAL!

    patphil

    (7,304 posts)
    10. Didn't Jesus say, "Render to Cesar the things that are Cesar's, and to God the things that are God's"?
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 04:48 PM
    Oct 2024

    He was establishing a policy of separation of Church and State 2000 years ago.
    So, what's to interpret?

    Christian Nationalists simply aren't Christians at all.

    dchill

    (41,059 posts)
    11. All organized religion is 90% politics...
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 05:13 PM
    Oct 2024

    ...10% select picks from the well-stocked God myth buffet.

    Ford_Prefect

    (8,260 posts)
    12. For quite some time the MSM has lumped all practicing Christians in with the extremely conservative evangelicals led by
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 05:19 PM
    Oct 2024

    Robertson, Falwell et al. Even though many among the mainstream denominations have been actively supporting Civil Rights, Peace, Inclusion, and other progressive issues.
    It is true that the RW Xian Nationalists gave been loudly outspoken, but this does not excuse either lazy journalism or weak-ass polling efforts.

    slightlv

    (4,684 posts)
    16. Regardless of the topic,
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 09:37 PM
    Oct 2024

    the loudest, most screechy voices and most violent of groups is the one that gets the most attention. It's been that way since forever, as far as I can tell. We've got way too much testosterone in the ruling (RWM) class.

    Warpy

    (113,131 posts)
    13. People, especially the young are pushing back on politicized religion, especially Christianity
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 05:58 PM
    Oct 2024

    It's about time. First, Christianity got hijacked by the Republicans who preened and postured and pressed it into service against those godless commies. Then millennial fever took over and it got really, really silly. And now that the fever has broken, the KIlanners and their brethren have hijacked it. It's just a wonder it has lasted as the majority belief system this long as a tool of sanctimonious frauds with boundless ambition.

    The "Nones" are just rejecting exactly the same people Jesus did. I hope it turns out better for them.

    Talitha

    (7,500 posts)
    14. I talked to a lifelong friend yesterday who lives in one of Chicago's western suburbs.
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 07:05 PM
    Oct 2024

    We're both in our early 70s and went to the same Catholic schools, K-12. She was in church (Catholic) on Sunday and after the sermon, the priest made a comment about the upcoming election. He advised the congregation to "Vote pro-life, NOT pro-choice."

    slightlv

    (4,684 posts)
    17. And right then and there, that priest
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 09:40 PM
    Oct 2024

    should have seen his tax-free existence taxed to the maximum level. They really want it both ways -- to be political advocates, while claiming to be religious-only, non partisan, preachers. Oh, for Christ to come back and throw THESE moneychangers from their pulpits!

    Roy Rolling

    (7,246 posts)
    25. Using their rules
    Tue Oct 8, 2024, 03:54 AM
    Oct 2024

    Jesus wouldn’t support a priest preaching what he knows about politics and its material-World political elections.

    The pushback would be (under those rules) humble Christians who think Christ is to be believed about keeping politics and religion separate will reject that church and priest.

    He’s shown himself to be a rascal, and a smaller congregation is the result.

    Initech

    (103,184 posts)
    15. Gee, you think maybe flirting with authoritarian dictatorships is a terrible idea?
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 08:06 PM
    Oct 2024

    In a dictatorship, nobody is safe. Nobody.

    TomCADem

    (17,787 posts)
    21. How one evangelical leader uses the Bible to expose the 'False White Gospel'
    Mon Oct 7, 2024, 11:47 PM
    Oct 2024

    Jim Wallis who was spiritual advisor to President Obama and teaches at Georgetown University has done a great job of exposing how White Christian Nationalists take tremendous liberties in pushing hate while ignoring the bulk of the bible that address such topics as providing aid to the poor.

    https://www.cnn.com/2024/04/28/us/evangelical-christianity-false-white-gospel-wallis-cec/index.html

    Jim Wallis was a long-haired student activist in the early 1970s who read Marx, marched against the Vietnam War and had little use for evangelical Christianity. But one day he conducted an unusual theological experiment that would change his life.

    Wallis and several friends wanted to know how many scriptures in the Bible dealt with issues such as poverty, oppression and justice. So they took a pair of scissors and cut out every biblical verse mentioning the poor.

    “When we were done, all of those verses had fallen to the floor — about two thousand verses in total,” Wallis recalled. “We were left with a Bible full of holes.”

    Wallis would devote his life to championing those discarded scriptures. He is now one of the most eloquent defenders of a brand of evangelical Christianity that insists that faith is not entirely a private matter — that the church should address racism and public policy issues that affect the poor.

    yourout

    (8,218 posts)
    26. My Mrs goes to a fairly liberal wing of the Lutherans..
    Tue Oct 8, 2024, 04:26 AM
    Oct 2024

    And they welcome me the ex Catholic, atheist, agnostic on the few occasions I go with her.

    They have a female pastor and are probably as close to the actual teachings of Christ as anyone.

    While I don't think I will ever be a believer if I did change my mind that is were I would probably go.

     

    oldsoftie

    (13,538 posts)
    27. I saw a "Evangelicals for Harris" ad somewhere.
    Tue Oct 8, 2024, 05:29 AM
    Oct 2024

    It showed clips of Billy Graham telling us warnings from the Bible; interspersed with clips of trump. fitting each warning.

     

    oldsoftie

    (13,538 posts)
    29. Wasnt Graham quoting the Bible? Remake the ad without using him.
    Tue Oct 8, 2024, 07:22 AM
    Oct 2024

    Have someone else; preferably a well know evangelical, recite those warnings & make the same ad.
    Cant believe Graham isnt considered "public domain"

    BumRushDaShow

    (146,370 posts)
    31. They may have re-done the ad and/or done additional ones
    Tue Oct 8, 2024, 09:24 AM
    Oct 2024

    but it's hard to keep track of the dozens and dozens of groups who are doing ads and then try to get them posted here on DU.

    I try but I can't get them all.

    Martin Eden

    (13,731 posts)
    32. "Adherents and allies of the movement have aligned themselves with Donald Trump" --
    Tue Oct 8, 2024, 11:39 AM
    Oct 2024

    -- the most sinful, corrupt, immoral, irreligious POtuS ever to poison American politics.

    maxsolomon

    (35,625 posts)
    33. "...primarily led by individuals rather than any church hierarchy"
    Tue Oct 8, 2024, 11:44 AM
    Oct 2024

    So, the denominations themselves are silent. Quelle suprise.

    The RCC has been preaching anti-abortion absolutism in Mass for DECADES, essentially aligning the Church with the Republican Party.

    Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»U.S. Christians pushing b...