Dr. Deborah Birx says she is "excited" for data-driven discussions in RFK Jr.'s confirmation hearings
Source: CBS News
November 17, 2024 / 3:27 PM EST
Dr. Deborah Birx, former White House Coronavirus response coordinator, said Sunday she is "excited" for the data on key health issues that will surface in Senate confirmation hearings for Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., President-elect Donald Trump's controversial pick for Health and Human secretary who has spread false information on vaccines and autism.
"I'm actually excited that in a Senate hearing he would bring forward his data and the questions that come from the senators would bring forth their data," Birx said on "Face the Nation with Margaret Brennan." "What I know for sure is he's a very smart man who can bring his data and his evidence base forward, and we can have a discussion that many Americans believe already is a problem."
President-elect Donald Trump announced Thursday in a social media post that he'll nominate Kennedy to oversee the Health and Human Services Department, which encompasses multiple agencies and has a $1 trillion budget. The position has to be approved by the Senate, which, come January, will be controlled by Republicans, which could make the nomination process easier but is not a guarantee.
"I am thrilled to announce Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as The United States Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS)," Trump wrote in a social media post last week. He said Americans have been "crushed by the industrial food complex and drug companies who have engaged in deception, misinformation, and disinformation" about public health, and Kennedy would "Make America Great and Healthy Again!" At an October rally, Trump promised to let Kennedy "go wild" on health issues.
Read more: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/deborah-birx-rfk-jr-confirmation-hearings-face-the-nation/
(I suppose she angling for a job in there again... the laugh for the night)
BOSSHOG
(39,836 posts)Figuring out her position based on that interview. Trump made her miserable with his nonsense. She almost sounds mocking of Kennedy. Bring your stuff and we can have a discussion? Many Americans already believe is a problem?
AloeVera
(1,941 posts)She went along with him far too much.
I don't think it's mocking she's doing here. She is already kow-towing to Kennedy. Or at least going-along-to-get-along. No surprise.
yardwork
(64,319 posts)Traildogbob
(9,958 posts)Skarfy McSkarfison?
CurtEastPoint
(19,178 posts)Traildogbob
(9,958 posts)Thats not so reassuring. We have seen how she will speak up while shit is being spewed. Who can forget that look when her boss was talking bleach and light insertion!
Klarkashton
(2,064 posts)He is a mentally ill piece of shit.
TexasBushwhacker
(20,667 posts)He's an attorney and a member of a legendary family. He has a right to his opinion, as we all do, but he is just as UNQUALIFIED as Trump's other picks.
rsdsharp
(10,115 posts)And she can give him advice on how to look like you want to disappear when the orange asshole starts talking about inoculations using bleach.
JohnSJ
(96,521 posts)substantiate his claims?
His autism link with vaccines was widely discredited, and his inane remarks about fluoride has been also.
He isnt a scientist, he is a conspiracy crack pop who wrote a hate filled book about Dr. Fauci that prompted death threats against Dr. Fauci and his family.
He is a low life scum, but there is no doubt the worthless excuse we call the media will give legitimacy to this kook.
Fortunately I dont participate as a spectator in the media circus.
reACTIONary
(6,008 posts).... he can substantiate his claims. She knows that if she just calls him an idiot, she will shut down those who might otherwise listen.
She is showing confidence in a fair fight, which is the right approach.
JohnSJ
(96,521 posts)Showing confidence in a "fair fight", won't cut it.
What it will end up doing is give legitimacy to anti-vaccine, conspiracy nuts, and anti-science purveyors.
They will gish gallop with uncredible data and sources, and I sure wouldn't count on much push back if there are congressional hearings, though the sociopath may try to get his appointments when Congress is on recess.
reACTIONary
(6,008 posts).... strategic. She was setting the expectation that there would, or should be, a hearing based on scientific facts. At this point, that is the best way forward. Maybe we can keep K from being confirmed, and maybe not. But denunciations and out-of-hand dismissals will not.
If we can't stop his appointment, at least we can set the stage for a good, solid "We told you so".
JohnSJ
(96,521 posts)dont think it will work in the republican controlled house, but we will see.
reACTIONary
(6,008 posts).... The repubs have a majority, but not a decisive majority. The senate is not as bat shit crazy as is the house. We would have to get something like five repubs to turn traitor.
No reason to be optimistic, but maybe reason enough to be hopeful.
JohnSJ
(96,521 posts)there are 5 Senate republicans who won't drink the kool aide, I am not so sure. Thune is more a "traditional" republican as opposed to MAGAs, but that was also how lindsey graham was viewed by some, before he became full MAGA.
That being said, I would like to think there is a chance that completely unhinged nominees would be rejected, but I also think there is a real chance the sociopath may try a backdoor recess appointments.
3catwoman3
(25,430 posts)...to her brain?
PortTack
(34,643 posts)Solly Mack
(92,756 posts)moniss
(5,711 posts)right there and allowed a madman to knowingly disseminate false information that endangered, caused illness and took the lives of people in the many thousands. A person of integrity would have spoken up, spoken out and as a last resort resigned rather than to stand there silently, as you did, which allowed people to use your silence as indication of endorsement of that false information. Dr. Birx I don't give a f**k what you look forward to, your opinion on anything or whether you think the American people should care about you or what you have to say in any way shape or form. Dear Dr. Birx at long last it would be the best thing you could do to just STFU and go away somewhere and try to live with the fact that when it came time that you were called upon to "do no harm" you were a complete and utter failure.
FarPoint
(13,617 posts)How does she retain an active medical license?
littlemissmartypants
(25,483 posts)Dr. Lights on, nobody's home.
Pototan
(2,015 posts)I cannot recommend this OP because it gives visibility to dangerous misinformation. I know this is an article from a reputable news agency. However, that's my point.
Grins
(7,883 posts)What the .?????
travelingthrulife
(685 posts)Vinca
(51,030 posts)reACTIONary
(6,008 posts).... She is presenting herself as being open minded and willing to listen - with the proviso that the discussion is based on facts, both what he presents, and what he is confronted with during questioning.
She KNOWS he won't win that discussion!
If she just called him a know-nothing idiot, she would have immediately cast her (and our) opposition as knee-jerk obstructionism. It would have turned off those who might be persuaded and predisposed them against listening at all.
She made a smart move.
PortTack
(34,643 posts)reACTIONary
(6,008 posts)... that in the current context, the approach that she has taken is the right approach to obtain the best possible outcomes. Denunciations and out-of-hand dismissals would be ineffective.
Telling people "fuck off" may be personally satisfying, but it won't move us in the right direction.
PortTack
(34,643 posts)So ya she can just go away..or FO!
hamsterjill
(15,507 posts)Shes a spineless submissive who went along with Trump before and will do so again if needed.
Lets not muddy the waters here. Keep your eye on the ball and lets keep it straight who the good guys are and who the bad guys are.
Shes not one of the good ones.