Trump Administration Demands Reddit Reveal Identity of User Who Criticized ICE
Source: MEDIAite
Apr 10th, 2026, 10:00 pm
The Trump administration has ordered Reddit to provide personal information on one of its users who criticized Immigration and Customs Enforcement, The Intercept reported on Friday. Reddit has until April 14 to provide the data. Attorneys for the user say their clients posts and their anonymity are clearly protected by the First Amendment.
On March 4, an ICE agent in Fairfax, Virginia sent a request to Reddit seeking information on the user, referred to as John Doe. To compel compliance, ICE slapped the social media behemoth with an administrative subpoena, which does not require approval from a judge.
Failure to comply with this summons will render you liable to proceedings in a U.S. District Court to enforce compliance with this summons as well as other sanctions, the request stated. You are requested not to disclose the existence of this summons for an indefinite period of time. Any such disclosure will impede the investigation and thereby interfere with the enforcement of federal law.
The request sought a months worth of data on the user, but it did not specify what the agency found potentially actionable. Reddit informed Doe about the request two days later, prompting the person who lives in the Pacific Northwest to retain attorneys from the Civil Liberties Defense Center in Oregon. The users attorneys say nothing in their clients posting history points to illegal activity.
Read more: https://www.mediaite.com/media/news/trump-administration-demands-reddit-reveal-identity-of-user-who-criticized-ice/
Here comes another "Pirro Special". Whatever happens with this case could impact DU and every other discussion site.
Walleye
(45,330 posts)MuchBetterThanThis
(83 posts)These blokes think they are the Mafia🤔
Walleye
(45,330 posts)Im encouraged to see that its not really working in any significant way. Im hoping Americans remember soon that they dont like being pushed around.
paleotn
(22,612 posts)Whether or not this would stand up in court is irrelevant.
COL Mustard
(8,344 posts)Pretty scary.
Irish_Dem
(82,150 posts)Even if it gets thrown out, it will scare people.
Like in China and Russia you cannot make comments against the dictators or you
get disappeared.
Walleye
(45,330 posts)Irish_Dem
(82,150 posts)Americans have become so strange.
They used to be a brave people.
Walleye
(45,330 posts)Soul_of_Wit
(133 posts)That is the point of the Donald administration's bluff. If there was a credible threat, then the DOJ could get a judge to issue a subpoena. Compliance in advance is their ask.
Pinback
(13,637 posts)One of the primary appeals of Reddit is user anonymity. Theyve already pissed off a lot of users by disallowing VPN-shielded logins. If they go so far as to cough up a users identity to the Pedo administration, they can watch the whole thing go down the drain.
ShazzieB
(22,821 posts)Last edited Mon Apr 13, 2026, 01:12 AM - Edit history (1)
I kniw a lot of people deride Reddit as being a cesspool, but that's a gross oversimplification, imo. There may be some garbage subreddits out there, but there are also many, many well run subreddits that are a pleasure to use. I would hate to see anything endanger that. Reddit is extremely diverse, and that's one of the best things about it afaic.
Pinback
(13,637 posts)Good moderators and less tolerance of abusive behavior overall have made a big difference. People sometimes like to criticize the old Reddit, or their impression of the current Reddit based on second-hand reports, without experiencing it in its current state for themselves.
Im by no means saying Reddit is perfect, or even as good as it should be. But as an occasional user, I find the experience overall helpful and positive.
My biggest complaint is that theres a fair amount of silliness that you have to filter out (although, to be honest, some of that is part of the fun sometimes). And I couldnt care less about some of the relationship advice threads and other personal drama reveals. I hide or block those most of the time. And, more and more, there are posts that seem to be bot-generated but the community tends to sniff those out and alert others to ignore them.
I also tend to stick to hobby groups most of the time, and when I do scan the political threads, most of them reflect a progressive viewpoint. (But I dont visit the conservative forums, and right-wingers usually dont get much traction in the mainstream news and politics subgroups.)
angrychair
(12,464 posts)The "justice" system exists to punish regular people and help the wealthy and powerful.
They believe that anyone that speaks out against them is a domestic terrorist.
IronLionZion
(51,526 posts)displacedvermoter
(4,941 posts)that I have read on the Internet that Trump is syphilitic?
I believe it to be true!
FakeNoose
(42,240 posts)I'm not buying it because it doesn't make sense. He sees doctors regularly and it would have been treated long ago.
displacedvermoter
(4,941 posts)And the power of positive thinking. James Carville believes it to be true, and recommends we share the news. Only thing I agree with Carville on.
Tanuki
(16,494 posts)..."Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) in Neisseria gonorrhoeae (N. gonorrhoeae) appeared soon after the antimicrobial medicines started to be used. This has continued to expand over the past 80 years, affecting medicines such as tetracyclines, macrolides (including azithromycin), sulphonamides and trimethoprim combinations and, more recently, quinolones. In many countries, ciprofloxacin resistance is exceedingly high, azithromycin resistance is increasing and resistance or decreased susceptibility to cefixime and ceftriaxone continue to emerge.
The extensively drug-resistant gonorrhoea with high-level resistance to the current recommended treatment for gonorrhoea (ceftriaxone) but also including resistance to penicillin, sulphonamides, tetracycline, fluoroquinolones and macrolides (including azithromycin) are called gonorrhoea superbugs or super gonorrhoea."... (more)
SonOfNebanaube
(137 posts)ShazzieB
(22,821 posts)It's not a question of being able to diagnose him (a blood test is needed for that anyway). It's a matter of a few basic facts, all of which are readily available on the internet:
1. Syphilis is easily diagnosable with a simple blood test and has been 100% curable since the mid 1940s (basically Trump's entire life).
2. As a result of the above, tertiary syphilis (the final, most advanced stage of the disease) has become extremely rare in industrialized countries. At one time, it was deadly, but it is now virtually unheard of in people with ready access to half decent medical care.
3. A person has to go untreated for years, if not decades, for syphilis to reachan advanced stage. The possibility of this happening to someone in Schlump's position (i.e. wealthy and with good medical care at his fingertips) in this day and age seems wildly unlikely to me.
I don't understand why this rumor still persist. It needs to die once and for all. Trump almost certainly has frontotemporal dementia and congestive heart disease. There's no need to resort to something as exotic and unlikely as tertiary syphilis to explain his condition.
ShazzieB
(22,821 posts)That syphilis rumor is absolutely ridiculous. I
every time I see a mention of it. Fortunately that doesn't happen very often these days, but here we are.
displacedvermoter
(4,941 posts)I always chuckle, myself, and think positive thoughts.
ShazzieB
(22,821 posts)I think "Here we go again" and roll my eyes.
If I'm feeling ambitious enough, l may take the time to write a post outlining all the reasons I think the rumor makes zero sense, as I did in reply #63, above. Then I remind myself that it doesn't really matter because the frontotemporal dementia and congestive heart failure that I DO believe he has aren't going to need any extra help to finish him off!
paleotn
(22,612 posts)popsdenver
(2,559 posts)and I was not a reddit user.......
calimary
(90,616 posts)Linda ladeewolf
(1,142 posts)Did he just now notice?
Collimator
(2,135 posts)They want to take on Reddit? Why don't they just go into every middle school in the country and confront the Mean Girl cliques?
Thinking about it, I can see Trump squaring up against the Snarky Queen Bee type, since that is the essence of his personality. It would be a losing battle, of course, because he is on the downward slope in terms of looks, charisma and influence.
underpants
(197,049 posts)TommyT139
(2,431 posts)And the info on specific actions, eg against ICE locations, abductions, and even agents (crowd sourcing so sane people can learn who their neighbors are) is excellent.
That's apart from the thousands of niche interest groups, everything from hobbies to sexuality.
Of course, Reddit has money for lawyers, which would likely wipe out progressive boards hosted by individuals or small groups.
eShirl
(20,390 posts)IronLionZion
(51,526 posts)MAGA are like what a satire cartoonist would draw to make fun of fascists
Botany
(77,761 posts)
sites/computer servers are just about all based in foreign countries. Im willing to bet those
platforms such as MAGANationX not only have Musk but Russian backing. Just like Trumps
degree from Wharton it is phony.
From NPR
A new feature rolled out on the social media platform X has set off waves of finger-pointing by suggesting that many account holders may not be physically located where users assume they are. Late last week, X, which is owned by Elon Musk, added more information to most accounts, including some that could provide clues on where the account user is located.
Seeming inconsistencies quickly surfaced. An account called @MAGANationX that describes itself as a "Patriot Voice for We The People" is labelled as "based in Eastern Europe (Non-EU)." The handle @American was "Based in Pakistan." An account used by a person who identifies as a journalist in Gaza now says it's "Based in" Poland and "Connected via" an app in the U.K. That may mean various things, including that the account was registered in the U.K. So far, X has not provided a definition of the terms.
Snip
Rage farming
It's possible that some of the accounts may indeed be people overseas pretending to be, or implying they are, Americans, said Renée DiResta, an associate research professor at Georgetown University who studies social media platforms. She said their motivation is largely financial.
"It's just a really easy way to generate rage - generate clicks in this case, generate direct monetization. That's something that we've seen on all different platforms for a very long time now. "
https://www.npr.org/2025/11/25/nx-s1-5619239/x-maga-influencers-location
IronLionZion
(51,526 posts)
paleotn
(22,612 posts)Attilatheblond
(9,184 posts)Oh... para-lawyers. I thought you meant pair o' lawyers.
Bengus81
(10,340 posts)for the first MILLION $$$ to roll in. An hour maybe........
IronLionZion
(51,526 posts)
paleotn
(22,612 posts)DeVito's character was a law school grad who failed the bar 6 times, thus calling himself a "para-lawyer."
Talitha
(8,131 posts)orangecrush
(30,980 posts)Go fuck yourself
Prairie_Seagull
(4,792 posts)Hey ICE
Go fuck yourself.
orangecrush
(30,980 posts)DBoon
(25,118 posts)ICE is a brutal police state agency whose only purpose is to enforce ethnic cleansing.
People who resist ICE in any fashion are heroes, just like the people who resisted the German Gestapo.
travelingthrulife
(5,510 posts)twodogsbarking
(19,251 posts)COL Mustard
(8,344 posts)nt
twodogsbarking
(19,251 posts)BumRushDaShow
(171,793 posts)(glad I didn't have a mouthful of tea when I saw your post
IronLionZion
(51,526 posts)Bayard
(30,163 posts)travelingthrulife
(5,510 posts)twodogsbarking
(19,251 posts)underpants
(197,049 posts)Thats understood by every who works in the public sector. Everything can be FOIAed.
Ziggysmom
(4,152 posts)I used to feel protected by the Constitution, not any more.
SunSeeker
(58,364 posts)Irish_Dem
(82,150 posts)Yep, designed to shut down groups like ours.
GreenWave
(12,769 posts)Exactly what Trump does every f-ing time.
SamuelAdams
(149 posts)The government is attacked for investigating real crimes hen controlled by Democrats. But those same people are fine with right-wing government trying to criminalize social media posts.
Joinfortmill
(21,577 posts)Each person needs to think long and hard about how they act/interact going forward, if they haven't already. This old girl doesn't have much to lose, so I'm all in. Fuck 'em!
ouija
(468 posts)snot
(11,848 posts)law enforcement agencies at various levels in the US routinely purchase or demand and get info from all the major social media platforms.
Given how reliant we've become on 'net-based communications from social media to email to cell phone calls, imho the Supreme Court made a grave error when it held that searched of those communications unlike those via the USPS and land line telephones would not require warrants.
kerouac2
(1,514 posts)I think they should tell them to go eff themselves, that is.
enigmania
(507 posts)bluestarone
(22,422 posts)That's the way it is. Nov 2026 won't change a fucking thing with this bunch of fuckers running our country. I just hope it can be stopped.
Bengus81
(10,340 posts)Grins
(9,508 posts)usonian
(26,423 posts)Sovereign Indignation Subpoena so delivered.
Seems only fair.
P.S. Ask Trump to spell subpoena.
AllyCat
(18,974 posts)How do they pick out just one?
vapor2
(4,840 posts)Can't hold on til the end of his freakin term