Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

KatK

(222 posts)
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 09:56 AM Monday

Drop AARP now - they are a shill for UnitedHealthcare

One easy action: Drop your AARP membership and let them know why on their Facebook page (leave comment on a post), Instagram, or (if you still use it) X,

Why?

"UnitedHealthcare has the worst record among all large insurers in denying necessary medical care to its subscribers.The data confirm what far too many patients experience. In 2023, UnitedHealth’s denial rate of claims was 32 percent, compared to an industry average of 16 percent. Nonprofits had a far better record than for-profits.

...

Why on earth would consumers buy such a flawed insurance product? It helps if they are captive customers, steered to UnitedHealth by a trusted source.

That would be AARP.

AARP has just under 38 million members. But AARP is basically an insurance marketing scheme masquerading as an advocacy group for the elderly.

For 27 years, UnitedHealth has been the co-branded choice of AARP. If you are looking for a supplemental policy to conventional Medicare, or a Medicare Advantage product, or a Medicare drug insurance policy, AARP will steer you to UnitedHealth. And only to UnitedHealth."


Read Robert Kuttner's Dec 11 article How AARP Shills for UnitedHealthcare

41 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Drop AARP now - they are a shill for UnitedHealthcare (Original Post) KatK Monday OP
No thank-you. I am NOT on their advantage care plans, and have absolutely no issues with them. Why would I cut my JohnSJ Monday #1
UHC, though, is the worst offender by a large margin. Scrivener7 Monday #3
Not if you are on a Medicare Supplemental Plan. If Medicare approves a procedure or visit, they MUST cover it. It is JohnSJ Monday #6
Yep Yonnie3 Monday #17
Mutual of Omaha Henry203 Monday #28
However the denial stats for UHC under moniss Monday #19
That may be, but Advantage Plans in general are where the problem is, and going after one insurer will NOT fix the JohnSJ Monday #36
However the issue is not just the insurer moniss Monday #41
Almost half of seniors DownriverDem Monday #30
Can't drop what I never picked up. Voltaire2 Monday #2
AARP has th best denatl Henry203 Monday #27
I sent them a SHAME letter about "The Donut Hole" young_at_heart Monday #4
What's a better supplemental plan? Ritabert Monday #5
Exactly. No supplemental plan can deny coverage if Medicare says it is covered. Advantage Plans allow the insurance JohnSJ Monday #7
Good point. Ritabert Monday #15
I have Physicians Mutual through Plan G QED Monday #8
Thanks. I'll look into it next October Ritabert Monday #13
Mutual of Omaha has the best price Henry203 Monday #25
Thanks I'll check it out. UHC isn't cheap. Ritabert Monday #40
USAA.com has a very good supplemental. erronis Monday #12
They are all the same Henry203 Monday #24
There are different plans, identified by letters. Plans with the same letters spooky3 Monday #31
I did the research Henry203 Monday #33
My point is that your posts that "the plans are all the same" spooky3 Monday #34
Mutual of Omaha Henry203 Monday #26
Supplemental plans are identical. It doesn't matter who you buy them from, Ms. Toad Monday #39
What Robert Kuttner should be talking about is the problem with Medicare Advantage Plans or HMO's, because JohnSJ Monday #9
And not only that! AKwannabe Monday #10
AARP does delta dfental Henry203 Monday #23
I had a sub... 2naSalit Monday #11
I have not had any problems whatsoever with United HealthCare. milestogo Monday #14
Don't have United Healthcare DownriverDem Monday #16
UnitedHealth has long been known for its cruel policies. summer_in_TX Monday #18
This is a known Figarosmom Monday #20
I dropped AARP Linda ladeewolf Monday #21
AARP also does delta dental Henry203 Monday #22
In both Ohio (two years ago, 15 years ago) and Nebraska (30 years ago) Ms. Toad Monday #38
United Health owns AARP Mblaze Monday #29
never joined. barbtries Monday #32
No thanks. We have both an AARP membership and a UHC health insurance plan through ACA. Happy kelly1mm Monday #35
In every jurisdiction I've checked, their Supplemental Plan is the best available Ms. Toad Monday #37

JohnSJ

(96,833 posts)
1. No thank-you. I am NOT on their advantage care plans, and have absolutely no issues with them. Why would I cut my
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 10:26 AM
Monday

nose off to spite my face?

As long as Medicare approves the procedure, it has to be covered under the supplemental plans. Not so with the Advantage Plans.

The problem per se isn't UHC but the Medicare Advantage plans that folks are on because I suspect many don't have the means to pay the premiums for the straight medi-gap plans.

This also applies to all insurance companies. Other insurer Advantage plans have the same problem, not just UHC.

This also may apply to HMO's under ANY insurance company, not just UHC, and many people may not have a choice. They need to select from what the company they work for has.

They can go for the ACA, but in most cases a company offered plan will have better premiums.

It is very unwise to make a blanket statement that some less informed people may make a decision that can adversely affect them on a public forum.

People need to make decisions on what is best for them.

I don't care what your suppossed stats show, the problem is with Advantage Plans and HMO's, not with Medicare Supplemental plans.

Incidentally, if you are on a Medicare Advantage Plan, it is NOT a given thing that you can just transfer to a Medicare Supplemental Plan.


JohnSJ

(96,833 posts)
6. Not if you are on a Medicare Supplemental Plan. If Medicare approves a procedure or visit, they MUST cover it. It is
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:22 AM
Monday

only if you are on an advantage plan where you can be denied.

I will say it again the problem isn't UHC per se, but all insurance Advantage and HMO plans.

Aetna, Humana, Blue Cross, etc. have all denied coverage to people under questionable circumstances for those under an Advantage Plan.

Advantage Plans allow the insurer to dictate what is covered, not Medicare or a party that doesn't have a conflict of interest. THAT IS WHAT NEEDS TO BE CHANGED.

Yonnie3

(18,219 posts)
17. Yep
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:49 AM
Monday

This brings to mind the saying: "I'm not going to cut off my nose to spite my face."

My AARP branded UHC supplemental plan (F) has never been a problem.

Before I was on Medicare, I had numerous problems with Anthem and other insurance provided by my Employer and ACA Marketplace. The worst was that in the middle of cancer treatments, all of my treatment team were suddenly off network. The providers informed me of the upcoming change, but it was not possible to set up my weekly treatments with a new team in less than months and no way to get the team back on the network. This cost me much money and UHC wasn't the insurer.

Henry203

(196 posts)
28. Mutual of Omaha
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:20 PM
Monday

has the best price. All supplemental plans are the same. It is mandated by the government.

moniss

(6,189 posts)
19. However the denial stats for UHC under
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:54 AM
Monday
Advantage Plans is far worse than anybody else. Also you do not need AARP membership in order to have a supplemental plan. Those plans are in fact simply a matter of who you want to pay. The premiums and the coverages are regulated and any differences between the companies will be the customer service experience of paperwork processing etc. types of things. In other words the premium for Level X coverage is the same with Physicians Mutual as it is for UHC.

AARP, which I have been a member of for many years until now, has morphed from their original incarnation and is now more of a marketing and sales organization aimed at a market segment. Their advocacy and effectiveness has been more and more spotty. People are thankfully finally beginning to "vote" with their feet and their wallet. I understand and appreciate you making the distinction about Supplement versus Advantage but you need to recognize that people leaving AARP because of their cozy relationship with UHC is not a bad thing.

JohnSJ

(96,833 posts)
36. That may be, but Advantage Plans in general are where the problem is, and going after one insurer will NOT fix the
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 01:18 PM
Monday

problem.

They need t fix the Advantage Plans so insurers must cover a procedure if their physician warrants it necessary.

moniss

(6,189 posts)
41. However the issue is not just the insurer
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 06:23 PM
Monday

but also this huge organization that cuddles them.

DownriverDem

(6,690 posts)
30. Almost half of seniors
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:34 PM
Monday

are on a MA plan. If Dr. Oz gets his way so will you too. Besides many seniors can't afford a supplemental plan and drug plan. Too many folks don't get this.

young_at_heart

(3,865 posts)
4. I sent them a SHAME letter about "The Donut Hole"
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:06 AM
Monday

Every time I'd get a plea to join AARP during the Bush Jr. years I would "return to sender" with the word SHAME in large letters on the envelope because they supported Bush. I have never once joined AARP because of that!

Ritabert

(776 posts)
5. What's a better supplemental plan?
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:06 AM
Monday

I'm stuck with UHC until next October although I've never had trouble with their supplemental insurance (not an Advantage plan.)

JohnSJ

(96,833 posts)
7. Exactly. No supplemental plan can deny coverage if Medicare says it is covered. Advantage Plans allow the insurance
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:25 AM
Monday

companies to decide what they will or won' cover.

As long as it is an approved procedure or therapy, it will be covered under a supplemental plan.

The danger is if Oz takes over, along with the jerk RFK jr. That can adversely affect us all.

QED

(2,989 posts)
8. I have Physicians Mutual through Plan G
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:26 AM
Monday

No complaints, they've covered everything so far. But then, I haven't needed them much.

Ritabert

(776 posts)
13. Thanks. I'll look into it next October
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:48 AM
Monday

We've been through a gall bladder surgery and hospitalization for an ulcer (my husband) and wrist surgery for me.

Henry203

(196 posts)
33. I did the research
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:48 PM
Monday

and the prices for the same plans from UHC, Blue Cross were both about $50 more per month for the same plan from Mutual of Omaha. Blue was close to $175. UHC was $165 and Mutual of Omaha was $112.

spooky3

(36,466 posts)
34. My point is that your posts that "the plans are all the same"
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:51 PM
Monday

May be misleading to some people because you didn’t differentiate them by letters.

Henry203

(196 posts)
26. Mutual of Omaha
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:17 PM
Monday

has the best price. All supplemental plans are the same. It is manf dated by the government.

Ms. Toad

(35,682 posts)
39. Supplemental plans are identical. It doesn't matter who you buy them from,
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 01:55 PM
Monday

so you should buy the cheapest over time. (I plotted out cost through age 100, based on historical data - UHC was considerably cheaper than its lowest competitor).

Aside from that, if you drop your supplemental plan, there is no guarantee you would ever be issued another one. You have one chance (in most states) to pick a supplemental plan. Unless you move or the company goes out of business, no other company is required to issue you a plan - and if they choose to, they can charge you based on your current state of health.

JohnSJ

(96,833 posts)
9. What Robert Kuttner should be talking about is the problem with Medicare Advantage Plans or HMO's, because
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:32 AM
Monday

that is the real problem with all insurance companies where the insurance company can play doctor.

Picking out one insurance company out of a group that practices the same thing is not a solution. Address the real solution, Advantage plans and HMOs.

AKwannabe

(6,439 posts)
10. And not only that!
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:37 AM
Monday

It is a Republican RAG! So many seniors have been duped into believing that AARP is for seniors. They are NOT. They are for money and have been making it hand over fist for decades! Fuck that rag.

Never will I ever be their member.

Henry203

(196 posts)
23. AARP does delta dfental
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:14 PM
Monday

It is the only dental plan that covers impalnts. If you go staright to Delta Dental they will not cober impalnts.

2naSalit

(93,701 posts)
11. I had a sub...
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:38 AM
Monday

For a year but discontinued because they really don't do anything for you and their scant advice is hardly worth it.

milestogo

(18,341 posts)
14. I have not had any problems whatsoever with United HealthCare.
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:48 AM
Monday

I do not use Facebook or Instagram.

This is not the time of year to make a change. The enrollment period had closed.

Sorry for not following your order.

DownriverDem

(6,690 posts)
16. Don't have United Healthcare
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:49 AM
Monday

I like AARP. I belong to The Ethel Group including the local group (The Ethel Gathering Group - Detroit & Suburbs) I have met some nice ladies going out to lunch with them.

summer_in_TX

(3,313 posts)
18. UnitedHealth has long been known for its cruel policies.
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 11:51 AM
Monday

I remember way back (maybe during the Reagan administration when homelessness soared to 4 million?), a news investigation revealed medical debt was a large driver even for those who had health insurance.

UnitedHealth was cited by the investigation for their aggressive “recissions,” terminating the insurance coverage for patients with life-threatening conditions when paying providers was going to bite into profits. They’d scour patients’ insurance paperwork for tiny mistakes to justify dropping them.

Desperately ill patients had to wait for care on appeals that often never resulted in the help they’d paid for in all good faith. And then they’d get dropped. Patients died and families were left destitute.

I suspect AARP was always mostly there to promote AARP and give them cover after the bad publicity. I never have nor ever will give them one dime because of the lives they’ve destroyed.

Linda ladeewolf

(500 posts)
21. I dropped AARP
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:07 PM
Monday

A long time ago. I dropped United H this fall, I hope my new provider is better.

Henry203

(196 posts)
22. AARP also does delta dental
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:12 PM
Monday

and it is the only dental plan that does implants. It is not AARP fault but it is ourselves as a consumer. If you do the research Mutual of Omaha has the best prices for the supllemental and it is exactly the same as AARP/UHC plan. The best vison is VSP. Don't blame AARP, it is your job to find out the most cost effective plan.

Ms. Toad

(35,682 posts)
38. In both Ohio (two years ago, 15 years ago) and Nebraska (30 years ago)
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 01:51 PM
Monday

Mutual of Omaha wasn't even close in cost to the UHC cost.

Humana dental covers at least some implants.

Cost, and what is covered, vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.

barbtries

(29,998 posts)
32. never joined.
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:42 PM
Monday

they sure tried though. like starting when I was 50? I'm 69 now and they leave me alone.

kelly1mm

(5,417 posts)
35. No thanks. We have both an AARP membership and a UHC health insurance plan through ACA. Happy
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 12:55 PM
Monday

with both (well, happy as one can be with any health insurance plan). Were previously on school board provided BC/BC plan for over 20 years and have similarly minor issues.

Ms. Toad

(35,682 posts)
37. In every jurisdiction I've checked, their Supplemental Plan is the best available
Mon Dec 30, 2024, 01:47 PM
Monday

Lowest initial cost, lowest increase over time, one of the smallest ranges over which age-related increases are taken.

Supplemental plans are identical (absent add-ons). Decide on the plan you want and by the one that is the cheapest over time. UHC was the cheapest when my parents bought their plans roughly 30 years ago, again when they had the opportunity to switch because they were moving out of state, and again when my spouse and I bought our plans 2 years ago.

My father's plan (at age 94) is around 200 a month. He pays the annual deductible (less than $300) and around $20 per office visit. My spouse and I have the deductible only plan. As of January 1, I pay $115/month. She pays $134 (she is older, so she is a couple of steps up the age-based increases). My mother is the only one not on UHC. She has 100% coverage and pays between 3 and 400 a month (to save the $300 deductible). My father wasn't able to convince her to switch when they had the chance (her mental faculties are declining).

Not a chance in the world I'm dropping my UHC plan.

Latest Discussions»Editorials & Other Articles»Drop AARP now - they are ...