Musicians
Related: About this forumHow hard is it to learn mandolin?
I've got a degree in music, play keyboards extensively, also play bass, a bit of guitar and used to play violin (I understand it's the same tuning).
We're starting up a band and they want me playing bass or mandolin when there's no keyboard part.
arcane1
(38,613 posts)And the tiny frets!
Though I suppose you could tune it to guitar format
TrogL
(32,825 posts)I'm more comfortable with bass than guitar. Bass has the same 4ths layout so it's just a matter of thinking up a 3rd.
Mandolin tablature appears way different than guitar so it's going to take a bit of getting used to.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)But if you're more used to runs, I found switching from bass (my first stringed instrument) to mandolin (my second) showed me exactly how lazy I was being with my hand positions. Do learn the lrighteft hand positions correctly and make yourself do them, if you want my advice, otherwise you'll pay for it down the road.
RevStPatrick
(2,208 posts)I was playing songs on it within a few minutes.
Compared to the months it took as a teenager learning guitar.
I say go for it!
johnp3907
(3,890 posts)I'm finding it easy to learn, hard to master.
theMark
(21 posts)Tuned like a violin, fretted like a guitar (only much tighter). Just work on your tremolo - those strings don't ring very long! From a trumpeter / pianist / guitarist / drummer / singer / and now (since Christmas!) a mandolinist.
TrogL
(32,825 posts)The electric's pickups hummed badly and another model wouldn't tune properly.
ProfessorGAC
(69,894 posts)Chording is somewhat, which is why so many mandolin parts involve drone strings. That way you're not trying to fret all four sets of strings.
I've got an Ovation mandolin. Really good looking and sounds great. I don't play it a lot, just once in a while.
Truth be told, i bought it because i had a space on the wall of my rec room that was too narrow for a guiar. Since i've got 12 of my 15 guitars handing on the wall, that empty space was bugging me.
So, basically bought it as an objet d'art, but ended up liking to play it.
Mine even has the built in piezo so i can plug it in. Pretty fun.
GAC
jeepnstein
(2,631 posts)If you've spent time on the fiddle you're already there. And the bonus is a mandolin has frets. I don't see why you can't be up to speed in a few months for the most part.
The fun part will be finding an instrument that's worth a darn. I strongly recommend you look at Eastman mandolins. Until you get into serious money for an instrument they are as good as it gets.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)Which is something a fiddle doesn't have: you can basically do all the stuff people do with a ukelele as well as play fiddle tunes.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)I love that the violin has the same tuning, so fiddle tunes work very well. Unfortunately most of the music online is in tablature form, which I have pedagogical objections to.
jeepnstein
(2,631 posts)It's the basic melodies in standard notation as well as guitar tab. I can't stand playing tab since I can't see where I'm going musically. That makes me a bit of an oddball in bluegrass circles because most of the really good flat pickers I know don't read a lick. They can do some pretty amazing things and know the fretboard inside-out, but put sheet music in front of them and they freeze like a deer in a spotlight.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)If so, it didn't show up!
jeepnstein
(2,631 posts)lordsummerisle
(4,652 posts)but here's a brilliant young bluegrass mandolin player:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=RDTyr_pK-D0-8&v=Tyr_pK-D0-8