Election Reform

Renew Deal

(82,932 posts) Mon Sep 9, 2013, 07:53 AM Sep 2013

NYC Elections Board Rings In the Old, as Lever Machines Replace Scanners

Dented, dinged and dated, New York’s battleship-gray lever voting machines have been hauled out of retirement because the city can’t seem to get the hang of electronic voting.

About 5,100 old machines, each weighing more than 800 pounds and made of 20,000 parts, have been lubricated, and the names of candidates from 2009 (Michael R. Bloomberg, anyone?) have been removed and replaced with those of this year’s contenders.
<snip>

But after long lines and chaotic polling scenes in 2012, as well as problems producing complete election results, the State Legislature this year authorized the return of the lever machines for the primary and any ensuing runoff, though it insisted that the city make the electronic machines work for the November general election.

“It’s the only solution,” said Michael J. Ryan, who was appointed executive director of the Board of Elections a month ago, after nearly three years in which the position sat empty.
<snip>

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/09/nyregion/lever-machines-briefly-replace-paper-ballots-and-optical-scanners.html

4 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

NYC Elections Board Rings In the Old, as Lever Machines Replace Scanners (Original Post) Renew Deal Sep 2013 OP

Jeez, I remember those things in the gym of my NYC elementary school MannyGoldstein Sep 2013 #1

They are still used for smaller elections in my area. Renew Deal Sep 2013 #2

K&R'd! snot Dec 2013 #3

It's Not the ONLY Solution - But It's an OK Solution stuartsdesk1 Dec 2013 #4

MannyGoldstein

(34,589 posts)

1. Jeez, I remember those things in the gym of my NYC elementary school

Reply to Renew Deal (Original post)

Mon Sep 9, 2013, 08:01 AM

Sep 2013

Sorry, MIC, they're much tougher to rig than the electronic versions.

Renew Deal

(82,932 posts)

2. They are still used for smaller elections in my area.

Reply to MannyGoldstein (Reply #1)

Mon Sep 9, 2013, 08:04 AM

Sep 2013

The electronic machines are broken out for the GE, but we still get levers for school budget votes, etc.

snot

(10,705 posts)

3. K&R'd!

Reply to Renew Deal (Original post)

Sun Dec 1, 2013, 11:37 PM

Dec 2013

stuartsdesk1

(85 posts)

4. It's Not the ONLY Solution - But It's an OK Solution

Reply to Renew Deal (Original post)

Sat Dec 7, 2013, 09:07 PM

Dec 2013

There are other ways. And those DON'T include going all electronic.

If there is no physical backup (as there is not with totally electronic machines) then
there is no guarantee against electronic fraud. A truly reliable recount is impossible.

In my hometown we use large white cards with open ovals next to the candidate's
names. The cards are presented to the voter by the election monitors after they check the voter's name and registration status.

The voter enters a small booth and blacks in the ovals using a felt tip or ball pen. Then the cards are
carried to a 2nd set of election monitors who recheck the voter.s registration status.

The cards are then inserted into an optical scanner which records and tallies the vote AND saves the cards.
Either side up, top or bottom first, the scanner works in all directions.

It's fast, very safe and actually easier for voters to understand than the lever machine. Certainly more
intuitive and easier to use than an electronic terminal.

And there is a physical record in case a truly reliable recount is needed.

Reply to this discussion