Education

TexasTowelie

(116,442 posts) Sat Jan 18, 2014, 06:34 PM Jan 2014

Truly learning math makes wise thinkers

[font color=green]The following article is an op-ed piece by Southwestern University President Dr. Edward Burger that appeared in the Austin American-Statesman on Dec. 27, 2013 and in the Houston Chronicle on Jan. 17, 2014. Dr. Burger is an award-winning professor in mathematics and has appeared in nearly 4,000 online video lessons.

For full disclosure purposes, I am an alumni of Southwestern University and a math major.[/font]

The question that educators and legislators in Texas should be discussing right now is not whether high school students should be required to take two years of algebra. This is an excellent example of investing time, money and effort to thoughtfully and carefully answer the wrong question.

The right questions for all of us are: What positive and profound lifelong habits of effective thinking are we offering within all of our math classes? And if the content of the algebra curriculum will be quickly forgotten after the last required exam (or even before), then why bother to offer any algebra?

Currently, too many of our math classes — as well as other classes — focus on mindless memorization and repetition that is designed to game a system focused on scores on standardized tests that measure the ability to perform a certain act — an act that requires neither deep understanding of the content nor the necessity to make meaning of the material. Like magic, the moment the final exam is over, poof, the material is forgotten and magically disappears. Think it’s a joke? Math educators know otherwise. The overlap in middle school algebra, Algebra I and Algebra II is conservatively around 60 percent, and more realistically around 75 percent. Our curriculum acknowledges its ineffectiveness at inviting students to make meaning of algebra: Those who study algebra in school are doomed to repeat it.

We need to replace our current math classes with meaningful mathematical experiences that teach students how to think through math rather than simply memorize formulas about math.

-snip-

When teachers give assignments, they should always be asking themselves “What permanent benefit — what habit of thinking — will students get out of this exercise?” Teachers should craft assignments that promote long-term goals such as understanding deeply, learning from mistakes, asking probing questions, and seeing the flow of ideas. In other words, instilling lifelong habits of effective thinking.

More at http://www.southwestern.edu/live/news/8830-making-math-meaningful-is-essential-but-missing .

Cross-posted in the Texas Group.

5 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Truly learning math makes wise thinkers (Original Post) TexasTowelie Jan 2014 OP

As stated, this is true when studying anything. pangaia Jan 2014 #1

an act that requires neither deep understanding of the content nor the necessity to make meaning of lunasun Jan 2014 #2

The op-ed written by Dr. Burger does mention other discipline fields besides mathematics. TexasTowelie Jan 2014 #3

Yes and checking out his online videos now too lunasun Jan 2014 #4

Understanding and comprehension are victims of the testing culture. Ka hrnt Jan 2014 #5

pangaia

(24,324 posts)

1. As stated, this is true when studying anything.

Reply to TexasTowelie (Original post)

Sat Jan 18, 2014, 07:11 PM

Jan 2014

When I was a freshman music student back in the 1960's at a rather prestigious music school, I was fortunate to have quite a few brilliant, creative, one-of-a-kind teachers.

My freshman music history teacher did not have us memorize this piece by this composer. No, he gave what he called 'drop the needle tests.' He would literally drop the needle on the record and we had to give the period, decade and which composer wrote the piece....AND WHY.

In a course on Mozart and Hayden, the focus was on learning the differences between the two composers, which, at that young age, was not easy for us. Part of the final exam was to sing an aria from a Mozart opera in front of the class, whether or not we were singers! I am not and never have been a singer.

I sang "Konstanze, Konstanze, dich wiederzusehen … O wie ängstlich" from Die Entführung aus dem Serail. I could sing it to this day, although you would NOT want to hear it.

I am in the debt of these and other fine teachers for encouraging me to think, ponder and question, and not just spit out memorized garbage.

lunasun

(21,646 posts)

2. an act that requires neither deep understanding of the content nor the necessity to make meaning of

Reply to TexasTowelie (Original post)

Sat Jan 18, 2014, 07:54 PM

Jan 2014

yep and not only math

TexasTowelie

(116,442 posts)

3. The op-ed written by Dr. Burger does mention other discipline fields besides mathematics.

Reply to lunasun (Reply #2)

Sat Jan 18, 2014, 08:11 PM

Jan 2014

I didn't know if you clicked on the link to read the entire article and the statements in the last paragraph of the excerpt do apply to other disciplines.

lunasun

(21,646 posts)

4. Yes and checking out his online videos now too

Reply to TexasTowelie (Reply #3)

Sat Jan 18, 2014, 08:19 PM

Jan 2014

Ka hrnt

(308 posts)

5. Understanding and comprehension are victims of the testing culture.

Reply to TexasTowelie (Original post)

Sun Jan 19, 2014, 05:25 PM

Jan 2014

I was shocked last year in my algebra II class how so many students could use "graphic organizers" to get answers--but had absolutely no idea what was going on "behind the scenes." The clearest example of this was in FOILing. Some of those poor kids could get the right answer, but given a simpler problem involving a distribution, were completely lost. Sometimes I feel some of their teachers are teaching them not math but how to solve math problems. But when all that matters to the school district (money) and when your job depends on test scores, showing kids how to pass the ****ed tests is all that will matter...

Reply to this discussion