Environment & Energy
Related: About this forumCleantechnica: California's Hydrogen Infrastructure Collapse Proves What We've Known All Along
An interesting spin from the "renewables will save us" crowd at Cleantechnia.
I agree, we've known it all along.
Californias Hydrogen Infrastructure Collapse Proves What Weve Known All Along
According to fire department reports, the blast occurred while two technicians were working on a trailer that contained compressed hydrogen tanks. The explosion instantly engulfed the hydrogen trailer and a nearby passenger car. Firefighters had the blaze under control in about 20 minutes, but the human cost was severe. One man was killed at the scene, and the second technician suffered serious burns.
Pilot company, the trailers owner, immediately suspended its compressed hydrogen gas operations to cooperate with the ongoing investigation.
The Network Collapse
That localized tragedy instantly triggered a statewide logistical nightmare. Because safety protocols dictate that hydrogen trailers are typically withdrawn from service across operators while an incident is investigated, the gaseous supply chain in California completely froze.
Without those specialized trucks moving fuel, pumps across the state dried up. As of late March, more than 60 percent of Californias retail hydrogen stations are completely offline. Out of 52 stations, 32 have closed signs hanging. The Hydrogen Fuel Cell Partnership has warned drivers that the few remaining liquid hydrogen stations are experiencing heightened, abnormal demand and massive lines from people who normally went to other stations.
If you own a Toyota Mirai or Hyundai Nexo and do not live near one of those surviving stations, your car is currently a heavy, very expensive paperweight. Manufacturers are trying to help where they can with rentals during the shortage, but its really not enough...
The full article points out that the tailpipe emissions of hydrogen cars are used to obscure the fact that hydrogen is made from the dangerous mined gas methane, controlled by and large by the same companies that provide gasoline. The author claims they knew it wouldn't work, but didn't care.
Some "final thoughts:"
It is time to stop falling for the delay tactics and fully embrace the technology that actually gives us our independence back.
I don't believe electric cars are sustainable by the way, and disagree with the author that electric cars have something to do with "independence."
Of course, I don't think cars are sustainable in any form, but that's just me.
We have known, for decades, that consumer hydrogen is a bad idea, which has been demonstrated time and time again. The use of rhetoric about a putative "hydrogen economy" still remains however, where it serves to greenwash fossil fuels, from which hydrogen is overwhelmingly made.
Cirsium
(4,127 posts)"I don't think cars are sustainable in any form." Especially when they are "thrown away" every few years.
Caribbeans
(1,325 posts)is Michael Barnard, one of North America's "Can't Do It" authors bashing h2 for everything.
Example: around 1 year ago he (and ChatGPT) posted this:
Airbus Drops Hydrogen As Aviation Industry Admits It Wont Fly
https://cleantechnica.com/2025/02/10/airbus-drops-hydrogen-as-aviation-industry-admits-it-wont-fly/
The problem is, Airbus did NOT "drop" hydrogen and in fact posted a clarification a few days after Barnyard's lie
Airbus Reconfirms Commitment to Develop Hydrogen-Powered Aircraft
https://www.esgtoday.com/airbus-reconfirms-commitment-to-develop-hydrogen-powered-aircraft/
Did Barnyard correct is mistitlled article? Not when I checked it.
Barnyard will lie, cheat and steal to bash hydrogen. Maybe because he was a Tesla shareholder? It's interesting that almost all of North America's EV websites have HATED hydrogen for anything, just like the US Government. Hmmmmm...
For anyone interested in learning more about the liar Michael Barnard, this article may help explain
Exposing Anti-Hydrogen Media Bias Part 1: Michael Barnards Background and Journalism Style
Fuel Cells Works | October 27, 2025
https://fuelcellsworks.com/2025/10/27/h2/exposing-anti-hydrogen-media-bias-part-1-michael-barnard-s-background-and-journalism-style
He'll go down in history all right, as one of the people that helped China lead the world in Hydrogen. Good job Michael!