Her only offense is Talking While Muslim.

Please point to the text.

and can not be relied upon for a factual account of Israel’s founding.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benny_Morris

Care to explain?

Do you think the Jewish people have a right to live in their ancestral homeland?

Last edited Thu May 16, 2019, 03:30 PM - Edit history (1)

provided? The sources for those excerpted writings are linked to in the entry. I am not going to find each of them online separately when they are documented in the link I provided and you can yourself check them if you do not believe them to be Morris’s.
I do not think any people have the right to use force and theft to remove any indigenous people in order to occupy lands those people have lived on for thousands of years, in which they have been the dominant population.

I think I will defer to Miko Peled to discuss some of these issues. I do not think an ancestral link to original Hebrew tribes justifies the occupation, or can explain continuing apartheid:

You still haven't answered it.

to paraphrase him, the indirect or direct destruction of European Jews. He then details the “evidence.”

of Israel, but lacking in political finesse talking about that. She was disingenuous when she said it all gave her comfort. No way!

That is the point of Professor Morris.

relevant to Tlaib’s claims.

https://ifamericaknew.org/history/origin.html

It used to be banned at DU2.

Ask the host, Lithos if you need more information.

Whether you like Morris of not, the vast majority of his piece was simply stating facts.

to achieve a Jewish state. The wiki entry I linked to provides ample documentation of his extremist views, shocking positions, in fact. His theory blaming Palestinians for the holocaust, “directly and indirectly” is alone discrediting.
Is Miko Peled banned? Norman Finkelstein?
I could have provided other sources that establish that Palestinians were victims of ethnic cleansing, driven out of their lands and homes to become permanent refugees, and are an occupied people.
I, however, refuse to debate with anyone who subscribes to Morris’s beliefs.
If any source should be banned in a discussion of the conflict, it is a Bernie Morris.
Is the group Jewish Voice for Peace anti-Semitic?
What about the journal Mondoweiss online?
J Street?
End of.
I leave it to admin.
I certainly do not think Morris is a credible or sane source for any discussion.
Miko Peled, not a scholar, but an avid researcher, is featured in Youtube videos lectures about what he, the grandson of an Israeli state founder, son of a General during the six day war, former Israeli soldier, discovered about state founding myths.
It must be understood that any scholarship that counters the official story is not represented in mainstream American media. Norman Finkelstein could not get his most recent book about Gaza reviewed by the NYT and was labeled as pro-Palestinian for his challenges to the hard right wing in Israel and his writings about the plight of the Palestinian people. Dershowitz called him “not a real Jew,” despite the fact that both his parents are concentration camp survivors.
I leave it to admin.

J Street: No.
Jewish Voice For Peace: Maybe not.
Mondoweiss: Definitely.

He's citing to If American's Knew, which is citing to "The Origin of the Palestine-Israel Conflict." Essentially, he's citing to a hate site which is citing to a fraud. It's highly unlikely that Jews for Justice in the Middle East is a Jewish organization.

Alison weir (owner of IAK) is so bad JVP won't even work with her.

that Israel was created due to the Holocaust. It was already promised well before that after WW1. Jews were migrating there long before the Holocaust.