Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LibGranny

(711 posts)
Sat Jan 26, 2013, 03:40 PM Jan 2013

Anyone suffer from chronic leg cramps (Charlie Horses)? I've had this problem

for nearly 5 years and I've tried potassium supplements, calcium supplements, an OTC med called "Leg Cramps" (which worked for a while) and then talked to my doctor. He ordered a Doppler test on my legs (which revealed nothing) then said to continue with the Leg Cramps med as it contained quinine. I am about 10 lbs overweight and normally walk 3-5 miles a day (wearing good athletic shoes). I was awakened 2 days ago with the WORST leg cramp ever and my leg is still very sore and I'm at wits end.

I'd appreciate any advice from anyone who suffers the same problem!

47 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Anyone suffer from chronic leg cramps (Charlie Horses)? I've had this problem (Original Post) LibGranny Jan 2013 OP
Walk bare foot. The good athletic shoes turn out not to be so good for everyone Lionessa Jan 2013 #1
I used to use full strength quinine and it worked ProgressiveProfessor Jan 2013 #2
"quinine" left-of-center2012 Jan 2016 #21
my hubby is a pharmacist and said the herion thing isnt the reason but... samnsara Sep 2017 #34
Mine Comes From MS ProfessorGAC Feb 2013 #3
For some cramps, it's a deficiency of magnesium. Also, from your name, I get that you are maybe Nay Feb 2013 #4
same age group and thats what my dr said...that and drink samnsara Sep 2017 #36
Are you hydrating enough The empressof all Feb 2013 #5
I find I get them if I don't drink enough water. TDale313 Sep 2017 #35
Yes. I would start with dehydration. Good suggestion. Lilyhoney Sep 2017 #42
Magnesium and vitamin D ohheckyeah Feb 2013 #6
I second the Magnesium and Vitamin D hedgehog Feb 2014 #10
I too have found help with these. MuseRider Sep 2017 #33
Do you get enough to drink? Particularly in winter it is easy to get dehydrated. MADem Feb 2013 #7
actually i used to take water pills once in awhile and... samnsara Sep 2017 #37
Digging deep..... MADem Sep 2017 #43
Any problems with vertigo or dizziness ? If not arthritisR_US Nov 2013 #8
wrestless legs, toes, calf cramps.. Herself Feb 2014 #9
I also had this problem, which is now gone (?) b/c wordpix Feb 2014 #11
If you take a statin, it may be the cause. I had horrible leg cramps Nay Feb 2014 #12
Cuprum Metallicum made by Boiron... TeeYiYi Feb 2014 #13
The Internet can assist you in researching Answers oldwizard Apr 2014 #14
Canada still sells quinine and its OTC... samnsara Sep 2017 #38
I get them pretty often fadedrose May 2014 #15
I had killer cramps, including torso cramps Ineeda May 2014 #16
mine are never forgotten... the muscle in my leg stays sore for days after wards samnsara Sep 2017 #39
See my post #16 Ineeda May 2014 #17
Message auto-removed Name removed Nov 2015 #18
spray cramp area with magnesium oil and you cramp will ease immediately-spray into your palm and rub akamushi Dec 2015 #19
Yes! Mag oil directly on cramps takes them away in like 2 minutes! fierywoman Sep 2017 #29
Magnesium oil works great for me - usually in about 10 seconds. Patterson Jun 2021 #45
For quick relief Dalai_1 Jan 2016 #20
i have heard this too...didnt work for me...but the night i did it maybe samnsara Sep 2017 #40
I had been plagued with nighttime leg cramps for years. RebelOne Sep 2016 #22
I'm gonna try it and I'll report back. mackerel Nov 2016 #23
While out yesterday I picked up a bottle of Vit. E mackerel Nov 2016 #24
I used to get horrific charley horses oppressedproletarian Sep 2017 #25
Water, drink more. I have the exact same problem, exact same story Eliot Rosewater Sep 2017 #26
Two common causes are insufficient potassium (eat bananas and tomatoes) and dehydration. tblue37 Sep 2017 #27
Bananas. C_U_L8R Sep 2017 #28
Drink more water WhiteTara Sep 2017 #30
Make sure your potassium supplement is prescription strength. Jane Austin Sep 2017 #31
i have had these for years and nothing stops them.... samnsara Sep 2017 #32
also the one thing i have noticed from the posts is to do... samnsara Sep 2017 #41
Just a thought here PennyK Sep 2017 #44
Epsom's salt is magnesium. Patterson Jun 2021 #46
I suffered with foot and leg cramps for years. Even my doctor couldn't help me but after scouring Stardust Oct 2021 #47
 

Lionessa

(3,894 posts)
1. Walk bare foot. The good athletic shoes turn out not to be so good for everyone
Sat Jan 26, 2013, 04:02 PM
Jan 2013

and are sometimes the cause of the problem. The heavily reinforced shoes apparently can force your feet into positions not normal for certain folks' feet to ankle ratio.

Additionally vitamin E is a big help with leg cramps.

http://www.ehow.com/info_8099931_problems-athletic-shoes.html

ProgressiveProfessor

(22,144 posts)
2. I used to use full strength quinine and it worked
Sat Jan 26, 2013, 04:44 PM
Jan 2013

It is an off the book use of insurance will not pay for it and has some cardiac implications.

left-of-center2012

(34,195 posts)
21. "quinine"
Wed Jan 20, 2016, 09:56 AM
Jan 2016

My dad was given quinine when he served in the Marines in Haiti around 1930, as a preventive against malaria.
Somehow he got the idea it was a cure for bad colds or the flu and we kids grew up using it for that,
although apparently it didn't work.

As an adult, around 1990, when I had a bad cold I went to a pharmacy to get some quinine.
The pharmacist refused to sell me any, saying it's used to cut heroin.

samnsara

(18,281 posts)
34. my hubby is a pharmacist and said the herion thing isnt the reason but...
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 06:06 PM
Sep 2017

....its only indicated for Malaria and the FDA put a stop to it because ppl were over using it for various things....and there are some serious side effects if its misused. Only one company did the mandated safety research on it to maintain their interest and now they are the only ones selling it but the cost went up from $60 for 30 pills to 600$ for 30.

ProfessorGAC

(69,713 posts)
3. Mine Comes From MS
Wed Feb 6, 2013, 09:01 PM
Feb 2013

But, there are very muscle specific stretching things that help me a lot. Don't need to do them all the time, only when i'm feeling the spasms. They work great. Some are good for calves. Some for the feet, some for the things, and some for the hips and butt.

My root cause may be different though.

Nay

(12,051 posts)
4. For some cramps, it's a deficiency of magnesium. Also, from your name, I get that you are maybe
Thu Feb 7, 2013, 03:10 PM
Feb 2013

55-75 years old? I'm in that range and the doc told me that just getting older brings on cramps, and that stretching exercises every day might help.

The empressof all

(29,100 posts)
5. Are you hydrating enough
Thu Feb 14, 2013, 05:37 PM
Feb 2013

My SO gets cramping when he forgets to drink enough water. If the doctor has ruled out any thing serious...try to drink 8 oz of clear water 6 to 8 times a day.

TDale313

(7,820 posts)
35. I find I get them if I don't drink enough water.
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 06:06 PM
Sep 2017

Drinking more water's a simple thing to try with very little downside. I've found if I do wake up with one, drinking water helps relieve the symptoms. Works for me.

Lilyhoney

(1,987 posts)
42. Yes. I would start with dehydration. Good suggestion.
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 06:45 PM
Sep 2017

I'm not a doctor. I'm not dispensing medical advice. But my guess would be dehydration.

ohheckyeah

(9,314 posts)
6. Magnesium and vitamin D
Fri Feb 15, 2013, 11:56 PM
Feb 2013

helped my leg cramps. I have fibromyalgia and have rods and screws in my back so I have a lot of leg and back pain.

Walking around barefoot all the time made my leg cramps worse. What works best for me is cowboy boots. I know, it sounds weird, but they support my feet and thus my legs and back better than anything else. I spent over $100 on a pair of New Balance shoes that were custom fitted and I've worn them once. I switched to cowboy boots (remembering how I used to wear them years ago) and my leg and back pain has decreased significantly.

I also drink some tonic water at night sometimes (it has quinine).



MuseRider

(34,358 posts)
33. I too have found help with these.
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 06:02 PM
Sep 2017

Especially Magnesium for me. I buy Calm and mix it with water at night. It actually helps my CBD night dose taste better so .

It even works in the middle of the night if you wake up with cramps. You don't want to use too much so you have to be careful with that or you will be up in the bathroom all night instead of sleeping without leg cramps.

MADem

(135,425 posts)
7. Do you get enough to drink? Particularly in winter it is easy to get dehydrated.
Sun Feb 17, 2013, 11:11 AM
Feb 2013

Over-hydrate, if possible, and see if that helps you. Do you take a diuretic for any condition?

Here's a Q/A article that might help:

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/HEALTH/expert.q.a/05/25/leg.cramps.brawley/index.html

samnsara

(18,281 posts)
37. actually i used to take water pills once in awhile and...
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 06:11 PM
Sep 2017

..I would get leg cramps at night so I quit taking those pills.

arthritisR_US

(7,365 posts)
8. Any problems with vertigo or dizziness ? If not
Sun Nov 10, 2013, 10:13 PM
Nov 2013

then try MBT footwear (www.mbt.com). They work by strengthening the core muscles and by doing so they increase the circulation to the extremities. Work wonders on neuropathy in the hands & feet of diabetics so the oxygen increase to the limb muscles is wonderful in getting rid of the leg cramps. I suffered for years and a month into wearing MBT's they were almost gone. Within the next month, gone completely, no more being woken up with excruciating pain.
Sketchers makes rocker sole shoes too but I would absolutely NOT get those. They don't have a carbon fibre plate in them so one ends up overpronating to the point where the knees and hips start having major issues (serious issues). I knew a gal who ended up cracking both of her femeral necks, so please stay away from Sketchers.

Herself

(188 posts)
9. wrestless legs, toes, calf cramps..
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 06:42 PM
Feb 2014

I take magnesium/calcium/zinc.

Not all supplements are legit. Don't buy them at walmart.

Go to Vitamin Shoppe on line, etc.

Everyone is told to take potassium. If you are low in magnesium, your heart can't "relax after it's contraction part of "pump' operation. Same thing for leg muscles.

Have doctor check your blood levels.

Always get copies of your medical tests performed.

wordpix

(18,652 posts)
11. I also had this problem, which is now gone (?) b/c
Thu Feb 13, 2014, 02:27 PM
Feb 2014

recently I was diagnosed with cancer and I have done away with coffee, alcohol, most meat and dairy (unless a little free range/organic), and have very little sugar, except what's in fruit naturally. IOW, I am mostly now living on a vegan diet. Lo and behold, I have not had leg cramps since I started this diet in Dec.

The cancer is another story.

Nay

(12,051 posts)
12. If you take a statin, it may be the cause. I had horrible leg cramps
Fri Feb 14, 2014, 08:06 PM
Feb 2014

a few weeks after starting atorvastatin. I have taken other statins without having the problem.

One more possibility is that you are slightly dehydrated. I understand that will cause leg cramps. So drink your water even if you don't feel thirsty.

Finally, you may want to try leg stretches immediately after your walk. My physical therapist gave me three stretches that will lengthen/stretch your leg muscles, which contract after exercise. I have found these to be very, very helpful.

TeeYiYi

(8,028 posts)
13. Cuprum Metallicum made by Boiron...
Mon Feb 17, 2014, 10:20 PM
Feb 2014


My mother who has MS swears by it and has done for years. I've used it too and it stops a charley horse like nothing else will. I swear they're magic. I keep some close by at all times. Google it to find it online or buy it in your local grocery store health food department.

TYY

oldwizard

(2 posts)
14. The Internet can assist you in researching Answers
Mon Apr 14, 2014, 12:06 PM
Apr 2014

Dear LibGranny,

Research ALL advice on the internet, including your physician's.

1. Over hydration can KILL YOU. I know; by the time I was discovered unconscious and reached the ER, I was "within 2 to 3 hours of death", according to the ER physician who initially treated me .

I had taken the advice of drinking lots of water when working outdoors in high heat and humidity. What was not mentioned is that high intake of water can dilute your blood with a concomitant dilution of the electrolytes necessary in maintaining proper nerve function (heart), and not losing consciousness.

2. Electrolytes need to be in a balanced formula; read Wikipedia about both 'electrolytes' and then read about each of the electrolytes individually, i.e. enter "potassium", and read, etc. Having too much or too little (hyper and hypo) Potassium and Magnesium can cause serious medical problems. Too much calcium, in some individuals, can cause kidney stones, not life threatening, but painful (worse than childbirth, according to one woman who had had both a child and kidney stones).

After leaving the hospital, I went online to find a supplement that had all of the necessary electrolytes (and only electrolytes) in a BALANCED FORMULA OF SODIUM, POTASSIUM, MAGNESIUM, AND CALCIUM.

I found ONE such supplement. It's marketed to endurance athletes; the people who run 100 miles in the desert -- that sort of thing. I called their '800' number and explained I was not an endurance athlete but had terrible leg cramps after exercise and often leg cramps at night. The person told me about one of their customers (mid 60s) who had the same problem and after taking their balanced electrolytes the cramping stopped. I also greatly increase the dose of electrolytes when drinking large volumes of water to stay hydrated.

3. Proper hydration (NEVER, EVER, OVER-HYDRATION) with sufficient and balanced electrolyte intake is essential, particularly when it's cool and you don't think you need much in the way of fluid or electrolyte intake. You always need fluid and electrolyte intake, less when it's cool or even cold, but still critical.

4. Boiron"s "Cuprum Metallicum" (latin for copper metal), is a Homeopathic remedy, which means that it most likely won't harm you, since it contains virtually no copper at all, but most likely won't help you either. So take it if you want to, but only after water and electrolytes.

5. Quinine, Quinine Sulfate -- prescription tablet, probably cannot be obtained in the U.S. However, you might be able to obtain it from an online British pharmacy, where it is still prescribed for nighttime leg cramps at a dose of 300 mg. (see Wikipedia/quinine) The amount of quinine in quinine water is extremely small (see Wikipedia/quinine) and probably, but `not worth consuming.

6. I also STRONGLY RECOMMEND the website "Drugs.com". You can open an account, at no cost, where you can enter all the medications (both OTC and prescription) that you are taking, or are contemplating taking, and you will be given all of the interactions. The site also gives you access to information about similar medications and user reviews. You can also read both the manufacturer's and the FDA's information about any medication at either the consumer or 'professional' level (both OTC and prescription). If you open an account, or just go to the website, you can enter either "muscle cramps" or "hypertonicity", and you will get a list of prescription muscle relaxants.

7. If you see your physician and a blood test for electrolytes is ordered, it is extremely important, actually it's mandatory for determining the electrolyte levels that immediately precede your muscle cramps, to have exercised just as you normally would and without supplements, and then go to the lab as quickly as possible to have blood drawn to find out 'in real time' how your body reacts to exercise. If you don't, the results are more likely than not to show normal levels.

LibGranny, if you, or anybody, would like information on where I get my electrolyte supplements, or on one of the best (I think) labs in the country (apart from Cleveland Clinic and Mayo Clinic) just ask. I'll monitor this thread every week or so.

fadedrose

(10,044 posts)
15. I get them pretty often
Sun May 4, 2014, 10:30 PM
May 2014

Usually from either bending or stretching leg muscles, and it happens when I'm standing as well as lying down. It helps if someone rubs the spot, but by the time I can call out to get help, the pain is gone just from keeping still for a few minutes, whether I can rub it or not.

Extremely painful, 10 on a scale of 10, but it's soon gone and forgotten. Very weird.

You must have twisted or overstretched your leg muscles while you were sleeping. I bet it won't happen again for a long time and you will never find the cause.

Ineeda

(3,626 posts)
16. I had killer cramps, including torso cramps
Mon May 19, 2014, 10:53 AM
May 2014

and tried many remedies --tonic water, supplements, electrolyte drinks, Endurolytes capsules (meant for runners, cyclists). My cramps were occasionally so bad that I told my neighbors not to call the cops if they heard screaming (and I am not normally a screamer.) I found this product via Google and was desperate enough to give it a shot.

http://www.stopslegcramps.com/?gclid=CNy94pCnuL4CFbTm7Aod7SMAqA

{Sorry, can't post an image.}
Anyway, I took one dose -- it was the most vile-tasting stuff ever, BUT it seems to have worked and I'd have taken cyanide to stop the pain!! It's about $15 for 8 oz. (with unconditional money-back guarantee.) You only need a capful and it doesn't 'expire'. All natural ingredients of vinegar, ginger, garlic and does not need refrigeration so you can keep it on your nightstand.

I suggest you go to their website and read about it. Good luck.

Response to LibGranny (Original post)

akamushi

(6 posts)
19. spray cramp area with magnesium oil and you cramp will ease immediately-spray into your palm and rub
Thu Dec 24, 2015, 05:14 PM
Dec 2015
http://www.healthextremist.com/how-to-make-magnesium-oil/
How To Make Magnesium Oil

-What You Need

-1/2 cup of Magnesium Flakes
-1/2 cup of Water
-Jar or Spray Bottle to Store the Mixture

-Magnesium Oil Directions

Heat up ½ cup of water (not to the point of boiling)
Pour the water over ½ cup of magnesium flakes
Stir the mixture until the magnesium flakes are dissolved.
Let the mixture cool and store in a spray bottle or jar
You can apply the mixture to your skin after it has cooled enough to a comfortable temperature. You can also store the magnesium oil for future use

i spray onto my palms and rub into the cramp

Patterson

(1,579 posts)
45. Magnesium oil works great for me - usually in about 10 seconds.
Mon Jun 28, 2021, 10:55 AM
Jun 2021

I keep tubes all over the house - especially by the bed.

Dalai_1

(1,301 posts)
20. For quick relief
Mon Jan 11, 2016, 09:28 PM
Jan 2016

Hold a bar of soap over the area cramping.Any bar of soap will work other than Dove.
Many keep a bar between top and bottom sheets on another health forum I belong to..
Apparently their is no scientific reason this works but it has for me.

samnsara

(18,281 posts)
40. i have heard this too...didnt work for me...but the night i did it maybe
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 06:19 PM
Sep 2017

...I wasn't going to get a cramp that night anyway.

RebelOne

(30,947 posts)
22. I had been plagued with nighttime leg cramps for years.
Fri Sep 9, 2016, 05:12 PM
Sep 2016

Last edited Sat Sep 10, 2016, 04:31 PM - Edit history (1)

Then I was advised by a poster on DU to take Vitamin E before going to bed. It worked and I very rarely have leg cramps at night. So try taking a 1000 IU capsule of Vitamin E every night. It works for me and I hope it works for you.

mackerel

(4,412 posts)
23. I'm gonna try it and I'll report back.
Fri Nov 25, 2016, 08:01 PM
Nov 2016

I get horrible legs pains and the last few days it's been so bad I can only get 2-3 hours sleep. I know hydration and stretching help too.

mackerel

(4,412 posts)
24. While out yesterday I picked up a bottle of Vit. E
Sat Nov 26, 2016, 12:41 PM
Nov 2016

and took 1200 IU only because I couldn't split the pills as they were in gel form. Anyway, last I had zero leg problems. Yeah!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I've been battling this problem off and on for the last year but it's gotten increasingly worse. I read somewhere that my symptoms are often associated with restless legs syndrome.

25. I used to get horrific charley horses
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 05:10 PM
Sep 2017

I discovered that drinking tonic water (available at any grocery) upon awakening with agonizing pain really helped. Different brands of tonic water contain different amounts of quinine and there is no way to tell how much is in any given brand. They may contain only a small amount of quinine but this used to help me.

Eliot Rosewater

(32,530 posts)
26. Water, drink more. I have the exact same problem, exact same story
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 05:13 PM
Sep 2017

and on the nights that I drink 16 oz of water one hour or 2 before bedtime, i never have them.

tblue37

(66,035 posts)
27. Two common causes are insufficient potassium (eat bananas and tomatoes) and dehydration.
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 05:15 PM
Sep 2017

Since you have done the potassium thing, try increasing your water intake.

If you don't stay hydrated, your muscles will cramp up. I usually get my dehydration cramps in the arches of my feet, but I have a friend who gets them as Charley horses.

WhiteTara

(30,150 posts)
30. Drink more water
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 05:19 PM
Sep 2017

it's as simple as that. Start early in the day hydrating and continue until evening. But do drink more water. Your muscles can't work without it.

Jane Austin

(9,199 posts)
31. Make sure your potassium supplement is prescription strength.
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 05:23 PM
Sep 2017

The over-the-counter versions have hardly any potassium.

The prescription my doc gave me has been very effective.

samnsara

(18,281 posts)
32. i have had these for years and nothing stops them....
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 06:00 PM
Sep 2017

...but I don't know what starts them either!!

I tried different shoes, no shoes, exercise etc. I thought there would be a correlation with at least something.....but theres NO correlation to anything I do. Sometimes they happen after long flights or car rides sometimes not. Sometimes they are in exactly the same muscle in both legs.....sometimes in muscles I never knew I had! I tried leg cramp pills, potassium, bananas and my Dr said to drink tonic water (GAG!) I tried sugar free with lemon or lime and couldn't even gag the stuff down.

Now the one thing I do to at least help get back to sleep after being WIDE awake stomping, rubbing or messaging is a little pot.

samnsara

(18,281 posts)
41. also the one thing i have noticed from the posts is to do...
Mon Sep 18, 2017, 06:25 PM
Sep 2017

..something during the cramp that requires holding ones breath! Drinking water or taking pills. When I would wake up with a cramp I would sometimes take those otc leg cramp pills and then drink some water. In a cpl minutes (SOMETIMES) the cramps would stop.

PennyK

(2,312 posts)
44. Just a thought here
Sat Sep 23, 2017, 02:22 PM
Sep 2017

Epsom salt baths. My very athletic daughter told me to try it. It's a way to absorb magnesium through the skin without any annoying side effects (diarrhea).
I have SOMETHING going on with one hip and leg...might be arthritis or bursitis, I still don't know...but the bath really seems to help. Two cups in a nice warm bath, soak for twenty minutes, then shower it off to avoid dryness. I feel wonderful afterward and the whole next day. And the stuff is cheap...$2.99 for four pounds at my market.

Stardust

(3,894 posts)
47. I suffered with foot and leg cramps for years. Even my doctor couldn't help me but after scouring
Fri Oct 1, 2021, 07:07 PM
Oct 2021

the internet, I read about mixing a teaspoon of plain old salt with a gallon of water. I tried it and IT WORKS! I drink some throughout the day and I haven’t had cramps in years except very rarely. If I do get one, I drink the salt water, and the cramp magically goes away. Good luck!

Latest Discussions»Support Forums»Chronic Health Conditions Discussion and Support»Anyone suffer from chroni...