Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

rox63

(9,464 posts)
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 07:54 AM Mar 2012

Bariatric surgery

I don't see any topics on it here, so I don't know what the general opinion of it is around here. I have the vague feeling that it may be frowned upon within this group.

I am considering lap band surgery rather than gastric bypass. I'm not comfortable with all the re-routing of internal plumbing that goes with gastric bypass. And the side-effects (malabsorption of nutrients, 'dumping syndrome', etc.) also scare me. And it is really major surgery. Lap-band seems to have fewer risks and a shorter recovery time, although the weight loss tends to be slower. Slower sounds healthier to me. And it can be reversed in an emergency, whereas gastric bypass can not be reversed.

I have been heavy my entire life. Both of my parents and my only sibling were obese, and all developed type 2 diabetes in middle age. My Mom is also legally blind because of diabetes. My Dad died of a stroke at age 64. I already have hypertension and I had a mini-stroke last year. That scared the crap out of me. I'm currently 48 years old, and have back problems, knee problems, and very likely have sleep apnea as well. (being tested for that soon) I currently weigh about twice what would be considered a healthy weight for my height.

I've been on many diets and food plans. While I have lost weight on some of them, I always gain the weight back. My biggest weight-loss successes have been on prepared-meal plans like Nutrisystem and Jenny Craig. But eventually, it gets expensive to stay on those plans, and I quit. Then the weight gradually comes back on.

I'd like to hear people's opinions. I've only just started the evaluation process for this surgery, so it would be a few months before I go under the knife. It's a long process, and I will be evaluated by doctors in several different specialties before I can get approved.

So please discuss - I am interested to hear what people have to say on the subject.

78 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Bariatric surgery (Original Post) rox63 Mar 2012 OP
It's a hard decision. Pholus Mar 2012 #1
Thanks for your thoughtful answer rox63 Mar 2012 #2
That all sounds good so I think you picked a good one. Best of luck! nt Pholus Mar 2012 #3
While you are waiting for the surgery noamnety Mar 2012 #4
I'll take a look at these rox63 Mar 2012 #8
I think both of these books noamnety Mar 2012 #9
If reversal of diabetes is a concern, bypass is better MaineDem Mar 2012 #5
I am not yet considered diabetic rox63 Mar 2012 #7
I have had bariatric surgery. Biliopancreatic Diversion with a Duodenal Switch. auntAgonist Mar 2012 #6
wondering auntAgonist Mar 2012 #10
Thanks - I'm just 3 weeks into the program from my intake appointment rox63 Mar 2012 #11
Good for you!! You're having the lap band yes? auntAgonist Mar 2012 #12
I'm aiming towards the lap band, yes. rox63 Mar 2012 #13
I think, with all the prep you're doing auntAgonist Mar 2012 #14
I toyed with this, too Goblinmonger Mar 2012 #15
I have been to WW multiple times, with no lasting success rox63 Mar 2012 #16
I had a verticle sleeve gastrectomy on '09 annabanana Mar 2012 #17
Hey, I often wondered how you are doing! auntAgonist Mar 2012 #18
My insurance covers the sleeve gastrectomy rox63 Mar 2012 #19
Rox, I would highly recommend the sleeve! auntAgonist Mar 2012 #20
I thought you might be interested in this email from a bariatric surgery group I'm on .. auntAgonist Mar 2012 #21
Thanks for the information rox63 Mar 2012 #22
any updates on how you're doing, where you're at in the process? n/t auntAgonist May 2012 #23
I'm still in the process rox63 May 2012 #24
The waiting is actually good. MaineDem May 2012 #25
I've still got some work to do on a few things rox63 May 2012 #26
Good to hear that things are progressing well for you. Your Drs are being very thorough auntAgonist May 2012 #27
Will do! rox63 May 2012 #28
Importance of post- op jesspinto Feb 2013 #71
Clarification: I didn't write that post. I shared it because I thought it important. auntAgonist Feb 2013 #72
Hi Annabanana genxlib Sep 2018 #76
Mixed on results. annabanana Sep 2018 #77
Appreciate the response genxlib Sep 2018 #78
Met with the surgeon yesterday rox63 May 2012 #29
Good luck with the cardio Dr and all the sign offs!! auntAgonist May 2012 #30
Thanks! rox63 May 2012 #31
Yay! I know how exciting and scary it is. I couldn't believe my ears when my insurance company auntAgonist May 2012 #32
The surgeon says mine should be less than an hour rox63 May 2012 #33
An update rox63 May 2012 #34
Good Luck!!! I'll try and check in before auntAgonist May 2012 #35
Tentative surgery date is 6/18 rox63 May 2012 #36
Good luck to you!! nt K8-EEE May 2012 #37
Thanks! rox63 May 2012 #38
Good Luck!! Have you heard anything yet? n/t auntAgonist Jun 2012 #39
Still haven't gotten official insurance approval rox63 Jun 2012 #40
Update! Insurance company has approved! rox63 Jun 2012 #41
YAY!!! Congratulations. You'll be in my thoughts. What an amazing journey you are about to take. auntAgonist Jun 2012 #42
Thanks! rox63 Jun 2012 #43
Wow! With all the prep you're having to do I have no doubt auntAgonist Jun 2012 #44
Found out this morning that I've already lost a total of 30 pounds rox63 Jun 2012 #45
One week until my surgery date! rox63 Jun 2012 #46
omg I remember the "last supper syndrome" very well. I went out for Mexican Chimichangas auntAgonist Jun 2012 #47
Excited and nervous! rox63 Jun 2012 #48
I report to the hospital at 6:00 AM on Monday morning. rox63 Jun 2012 #49
Hope everything went well for you. I am watching closely because I madmom Jun 2012 #50
welcome to the group madmom! auntAgonist Jun 2012 #51
Thank you. I am still in the research stage and I'm waiting madmom Jun 2012 #52
Research this: little elvis Jun 2012 #53
little elvis has been blocked and tombstoned too! auntAgonist Jun 2012 #55
I'm home from the hospital rox63 Jun 2012 #54
You feeling okay? spinbaby Jun 2012 #56
I'm doing better than I expected rox63 Jun 2012 #57
I'll be watching you with interest spinbaby Jun 2012 #58
The adjustments are just until you find your "sweet spot" rox63 Jun 2012 #59
The way I figure it... spinbaby Jun 2012 #60
Cures diabetes? jambo101 Jan 2013 #61
Only if its obesity related jesspinto Jan 2013 #63
You are not too old at 65 The duodenal switch has been proven to cure diabetes. auntAgonist Feb 2013 #67
jambo where in Canada are you? Have you thought of going to the USA, I know that auntAgonist Feb 2013 #68
Thanks Auntagonist jambo101 Feb 2013 #69
The clinic is important jesspinto Jan 2013 #62
I had gastric band surgery back in June '12 rox63 Jan 2013 #64
How much total do you want to lose? spinbaby Jan 2013 #65
I want to lose a total of 120 lbs rox63 Jan 2013 #66
I hear you about the exercise spinbaby Feb 2013 #70
Jesspinto you seem to advocate going out of country for surgery. Every post includes auntAgonist Feb 2013 #73
I just now noticed where that link went spinbaby Feb 2013 #74
exactly spinbaby. If this person has experience with this clinic they'd like to share, I'm willing auntAgonist Feb 2013 #75

Pholus

(4,062 posts)
1. It's a hard decision.
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 10:15 AM
Mar 2012

I've been there with you but backed away a bit because I wanted to give it one more chance before doing something so drastic (not that THAT is working out so grandly mind you).

But then again you have the immediate health issues to consider and that is a big issue. So pursue your options. You have to do something...

If I had kept going I would have chosen the same as you for the same reasons. One of the criteria for surgery that I needed to satisfy was that I needed to have weight loss medically monitored for six months (weight watchers meetings count too). I was seeing some improvement from that so even that part of the process helps.

The one thing I'd add that I didn't see you mention is that the studies I've seen on the lap band seems to show that they lose effectiveness after two years or so. You have to go into it thinking it is a chance to give your health some breathing room and to more easily develop habits that will sustain you later because it is likely not a permanent solution.

We're in a hard place, one that not a lot of people understand, but it is good that you're on considering positive action -- best of luck!

rox63

(9,464 posts)
2. Thanks for your thoughtful answer
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 05:05 PM
Mar 2012

I hadn't heard about those studies about the lap band. I'll have to check further into that. My program requires at least 3 months of medical supervision, and has a very good reputation. I have to attend several classes and support group meetings, have to meet several times with a dietician. Also go through screening with psychologist, cardiologist, neurologist (because of the TIA I had last year), and a few other professionals. I also have to lose at least 5% of my body weight, and keep it off until the surgery date. There is a long list of criteria I have to meet. And I'm glad of that. I wouldn't want to be part of a program that would perform the surgery on anyone who wanted it.

 

noamnety

(20,234 posts)
4. While you are waiting for the surgery
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 10:22 PM
Mar 2012

I'd encourage you to read the 4 Hour Body or Wheat Belly if you get a chance. They both may shed some light on potential problems you've had with weight loss - the tie in with diabetes makes me think the solution isn't the overall restriction of calories, but the wheat and carbs.

I've known a few people who've had the surgery. They have all been glad they did it, they are gradually gaining weight back and have had some complications, so it's not a one time permanent solution, but it has overall improved their lives I think. The side effects from the surgery are less than the side effects of the weight they were carrying. I'd still encourage you to read one or both of those books though.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
8. I'll take a look at these
Fri Mar 2, 2012, 11:14 AM
Mar 2012

It's not so much the losing weight that I struggle with as much as keeping it off. I've probably lost hundreds of pounds on many different diets over the course of my life. But the weight always comes back. I went on my first diet when I was only 12 years old. I don't think of surgery as a cure, just as a powerful tool. But it's a tool that will require me to change the way I do things for the rest of my life.

 

noamnety

(20,234 posts)
9. I think both of these books
Fri Mar 2, 2012, 06:17 PM
Mar 2012

focus more on considering it a lifestyle change.

I did atkins before and lost a decent amount of weight, and then returned to eating "normally" - adding wheat and sugar and pasta right back into my diet, and gained it all back (and more). These are more about permanent changes not in the amount you eat, and in fact it's specifically NOT about calorie restriction, but getting a better understanding chemically of why it's better to cut out those types of foods 6 days a week - and (in the 3 hour body plan) why it's better to have a refeed on day 7, as part of a permanent plan to increase your metabolism and control insulin/insulin resistance, instead of a temporary plan to drop pounds. For me, mentally, knowing I can eat whatever I want once a week is the thing that makes it possible for me to stay on it. (I'm at 7 months right now, hoping to stay permanently on it.)

I don't know that a refeed of grains/carbs would work with bypass though - I'm not sure if there's a quantity of food you'd be limited by that would prevent the two plans from being compatible. I do know that both books gave me a better understanding of why things were making me gain weight even though I ate healthier than almost everyone I know, excepting some vegans.

MaineDem

(18,161 posts)
5. If reversal of diabetes is a concern, bypass is better
Thu Mar 1, 2012, 11:45 PM
Mar 2012

The surgery itself very often stops the disease. Not the same with lap band.

There should be a waiting process of all types of bariatric surgery. Many insurance companies require a six-month supervised weight loss program. Others just require a certain BMI. Most good surgeons - they should be Centers of Excellence - have a pre-op program that takes a few months. It's good because it allows patients to learn new habits. No soda, no drinking with meals, eating really slowly, chewing a LOT. And they should require a psychological screening.

Have you looked into the vertical sleeve gastrectomy? It's another option along with band and bypass. Basically it's the first part of the gastric bypass that reduces the stomach but it doesn't realign the intestines. So the malabsorbtion issue isn't there.

I personally know many people who have had weight loss surgery with successful results. I also know people who have had the lap band but find a way to defeat the process and end up having it removed and a revision to bypass done.

With all of these surgeries, taking vitamins and supplements will be a life-long thing. And dumping doesn't have to happen. People dump on sugar and fats. But not everyone experiences it the same way, or at all. But the negative reinforcement of dumping can be a good thing. It'll keep patients from eating things that will sabotage their efforts.

Good luck.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
7. I am not yet considered diabetic
Fri Mar 2, 2012, 11:00 AM
Mar 2012

But both of my parents and my only sibling developed type 2 diabetes in middle age. They were also all obese. Considering my weight and family history, it's suprising that I haven't developed it yet.

The hospital I am going through is a Center of Excellence. Their pre-op program is pretty extensive. I have just started the process. I went to the the introductory nutriton class earlier this week, and the food plan they prescribe includes everything you mentioned. They also do sleeve gastrectomies. But I am hoping to go with the least invasive procedure possible. I know people who've had both gastric bypass and lap band. The person that had the lap band done has struggled somewhat, partly because it does allow you more freedom and choice. But she has lost a significant amount of weight, and has kept it off 18 months after surgery. But she still has some more to go.

I don't want to never have another sweet treat for the rest of my life. I would just like to be able to eat like a reasonable person, and be able to stop at just one.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
6. I have had bariatric surgery. Biliopancreatic Diversion with a Duodenal Switch.
Fri Mar 2, 2012, 02:01 AM
Mar 2012

I researched for about 3 years before making a fully informed decision as to which surgery would be best for me.

*edited to add* I went from 302lbs to a maintained weight loss of 139lbs. I had surgery March 15th 2005.




As you well may know there are many types of surgery for weight loss.

Lap Band, least invasive of all surgeries but without the huge weightloss results. I have 2 friends who've had this and neither is happy with the results.

Roux en Y, Does not retain the pyloric valve therefore you lose the advantage of digestive juices and also RNY patients are prone to dumping syndrome. People who have the RNY have a pouch.

Sleeve Gastrectomy, the stomach is made smaller therefore your intake is restricted. this surgery is often done in preparation for the BPD/Ds on patients who are so obese that the entire surgery, the diversion with the switch could be life threatening. Stage two is often done after significant weight loss and health improvement.

Bileopancreatic Diversion with a duodenal switch is the most invasive of all the surgeries. The stomach is reduced in size to about 3-4 ounces (it will stretch a bit over time) and the intestines are re-routed. This is also the most successful of all the operations. Not only do you get the restrictive element but you get the malabsorption part too. IF you don't look after yourself properly, IE: take all of your vitamins and supplements, eat properly and stay hydrated the malabsorption can lead to serious problems.

I have found that most primary physicians are not well schooled in Bariatric Surgery. They seem to be of the opinion that they are all the same. You'll need a good Surgeon, a good Primary for follow up and probably an endocrinologist to monitor all your lab work/results.

When I was looking for a new Dr I prepared this for him.

*****************************************************


• I have had a combined restrictive-malabsorptive procedure in which the restrictive part will substantially resolve over time, but malabsorptive part is permanent.
• Because of this malabsorption, I need regular bloodwork to confirm I am absorbing enough protein, vitamins, and minerals. Please see the list that I have attached of blood tests that I need annually or more often if I am having a problem.
• I malabsorb DIFFERENT vitamins and micronutrients from gastric bypass patients, and I need you to NOT make assumptions based on what you may have read about regarding different procedures. In addition, time-release medications may not be appropriate for me.
• Fat-soluble vitamin and calcium malabsorption are primary concerns because of the duodenal bypass, and must be monitored closely -- and SPECIFIC tests that my surgeon recommends must be ordered routinely -- this is NOT negotiable. Calcium must be monitored via PTH and vitamin D3 -- perhaps not the usual tests you routinely order for non-DS patients, but none the less I will need this testing frequently and I will need your support in this matter. I may also ask you to provide me with or fax copies of my lab results to my DS surgeon, who has additional expertise in helping me manage my post-op long-term care. A copy of my annual lab requirement is attached.
• From time to time there may be specialized tests that my DS surgeon will request and I will need you to support and respect these requests.
• Other tests, such as albumin, liver function, etc., are also extremely important, as is a baseline and at least every other year I will need a DEXA scan.
I do not absorb 80% of the fat that I consume, so please do not get concerned that I am eating too much fat. I also malabsorb about 30-50% of the protein and complex carbohydrates I eat, so I must eat more protein than you might think appropriate.
• My primary challenges with living with the DS are, in no particular order:
o Eating 80-100 g of protein/day
o Taking my supplements
o Monitoring my labs to head off any problems as quickly as possible
o Dealing with the stool and gas issues, both volume and smell, which in most cases may be a direct result of my diet: complex carbohydrates, especially white flour, increase the smell and volume of both, and too much fat can cause diarrhea
o Sometimes, constipation is also an issue.

• The intestinal bypass may result in imbalance in the bacterial flora and I may ask you to prescribe unusual antibiotics from time to time -- perhaps even prophylactically if I have difficulties with gas and diarrhea - I need to know if you have a problem with this. You may be interested in information I have access to about non-prescription probiotic replacement products that I would be happy to share with you, and which you might find useful with your "normal" patients with intestinal issues such as IBS as well.
• Because I have a normally functioning stomach, I should not have any particular problems with taking NSAIDs or anticoagulants, in contrast with RNY patients.
• NOT every problem I have will be DS-related, just as NOT every problem I had pre-op was obesity-related (an unpleasant and dangerous issue many morbidly obese patients have experienced). Nevertheless, my DS needs to be taken into consideration if problems

• arise, either as a source of the problem or as a consideration in how medication will be absorbed.
• As with any abdominal surgery patient, I have an increased risk of bowel obstructions, even years after my DS surgery. These can be because of bowel slipping into internal hernias, or holes in the mesentery, as well as into spaces that develop because I have lost abdominal fat. However, there is one very important issue that is particular to the differential diagnosis of bowel obstruction in DS patients (as well as, to a lesser extent, in RNY patients): we can have a complete intestinal obstruction and still be passing stool and gas, because the obstruction can be in the biliopancreatic limb (and thus the alimentary limb could still be fully patent). Thus, it may be necessary to order a CAT scan for me if I present with severe belly pain, even if I am still able to pass stool and gas.

************************************
REQUIRED LAB orders.

ANNUAL DUODENAL SWITCH LAB ORDERS
Dx: POST-SURGICAL MALABSORPTION, 579.3a
Please Draw the Following:
• CBC
• COMPREHENSIVE METABOLIC PANEL
• FASTING LIPID PANEL
• FERRITIN
• FOLATE
• IRON
• MMA (Methylmelonic Acid)
• PHOSPHORUS
• PTH, intact with Calcium
• TSH
• VITAMIN A
• VITAMIN B6
• VITAMIN B12
• VITAMIN D, 25 HYDROXY
• ZINC
Note:
VITAMIN A REQUIRES 2 ML FROZEN SERUM
VITAMIN B6 REQUIRES PLASMA - FOIL WRAPPED
*********************************************

I hope this helped And good luck to you !!

aA
kesha
edited to fix 130lbs to the correct 139lbs --darned fingers.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
11. Thanks - I'm just 3 weeks into the program from my intake appointment
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 03:58 PM
Mar 2012

So I've got a long ways to go. I still have to be screened by the neurologist, cardiologist, and psychologist. Still have the sleep study to go through, plus all of the medical tests you need before surgery. It will be at least June before I have surgery. I've already lost 10 lbs of the 13 lbs I need to lose before I can get approved. My problem has always been one of keeping weight off. I know I can lose weight when I put my mind to it. But it always eventually comes back.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
13. I'm aiming towards the lap band, yes.
Fri Mar 16, 2012, 08:43 AM
Mar 2012

I'm kind of scared of all the internal 'plumbing' changes associated with gastric bypass. And I'm ok with the slower weight loss associated with the lap band.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
14. I think, with all the prep you're doing
Fri Mar 16, 2012, 09:44 AM
Mar 2012

and (what sounds like)your determination you'll probably do very well with the lap band.

I don't know if you read my post above but I had the most invasive of the surgeries, the BPD/DS. I'm not in the least bit sorry that I did but I have had to deal with a LOT of differences in my life and a few health issues.

Even with the lap band you will have to be vigilant and listen to your body for any signs of anything that might be going wrong.

You're on a good path by the sound of it though.

aA
kesha

 

Goblinmonger

(22,340 posts)
15. I toyed with this, too
Mon Mar 19, 2012, 08:37 AM
Mar 2012

I was 360 at my highest. Something needed to be done. My Dr recommended the "sleeve" surgery. Honestly, if my insurance had paid for it, I might have had it done. They didn't and I went, instead, to Weight Watchers.

Best decision of my life. In hindsight, I would never consider the surgery again. Right now I'm down to 275 a year and (almost) a half later. It's a slow run, but I think that is best. I have learned a lot about why I eat and am learning the right way to control it.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
16. I have been to WW multiple times, with no lasting success
Mon Mar 19, 2012, 01:02 PM
Mar 2012

I've been on many different food plans and weight-loss plans. I know why I overeat. I can lose weight, but I just can't keep it off. Because of my family history of diabetes, stroke and heart disease, I have decided that I need to do something that will help me keep my weight off for the long term. If I were younger, perhaps I would think differently.

annabanana

(52,791 posts)
17. I had a verticle sleeve gastrectomy on '09
Sun Mar 25, 2012, 08:41 PM
Mar 2012

At my highest, I weighed 359 lbs. I am down to, and maintaining about 155 - 160. I was considered heavy enough for a Duodenal Switch, and a sleeve was often considered a "first step" to make the DS safer.

By the time I started researching, many people had been having good results with the sleeve alone, and some insurance companies have started covering it as a stand alone procedure.

It has some advantages. There is no foreign body left inside, no need for "fills" and nothing that can break down. The plumbing, if you will, is not rearranged so there aren't some of the absorption/dumping issues that other procedures have. While there is a need for vitamin and mineral supplements, there is no requirement for a regimen of any other kind of maintenance meds.

One disadvantage is that there is no going back. (not that I can imagine wanting to).

ANY kind of bariatric surgery can be sabotaged. I I were to go back to constant grazing & snacking, I could put significant weight back on.

My biggest regret is that I didn't get it done when I was younger.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
18. Hey, I often wondered how you are doing!
Mon Mar 26, 2012, 09:31 AM
Mar 2012

I'm glad to hear the sleeve worked out for you. I know a number of people who've gone that route and are very pleased with the results.

Good to hear from another person who's had bariatric surgery.

aA
kesha

rox63

(9,464 posts)
19. My insurance covers the sleeve gastrectomy
Mon Mar 26, 2012, 01:29 PM
Mar 2012

And the hospital that I'm working with offers it. I am glad it worked so well for you.

If I were to consider a surgery other than the band, that would be my next stop. The less cutting and stitching of internal organs I can get away with the better.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
20. Rox, I would highly recommend the sleeve!
Mon Mar 26, 2012, 10:35 PM
Mar 2012

I'd recommend it over the lap band to be honest. I think, and I've spoken to many who have had the lap band and have gone for revision surgery after not losing the weight they want to, that the sleeve has more chance for success and is much less invasive/intrusive than the Biliopancreatic diversion with the duodenal switch.

I realize the lapband is the least intrusive but for me, there are just too many ways to eat around it etc.

You know (I hope) that I wish you well in what ever you decide to do.

We'll be here to support you as you make the journey.

aA
kesha

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
21. I thought you might be interested in this email from a bariatric surgery group I'm on ..
Tue Mar 27, 2012, 12:08 AM
Mar 2012

Just an FYI, the experience of one person re the lapband. I'm not suggesting that this is a common issue but I think it's good to add it to your information bank.

kesha.

I live outside of Philadelphia, PA. In Jan 2009 I had lap-band surgery. It’s a long, frustrating story, but my surgeon’s staff just flat out didn’t believe me about anything. I lost 30 lbs in 6 weeks, then started feeling sick and stopped losing, but was constantly sick. They told me to “come back when I was ready to comply”. I was complying!

I tried for 18 months to find a bariatric surgeon who would take me on. Nobody would post-op. Until I found a fabulous surgeon at Abington Hospital. He found that the band had slipped to around my esophagus, and was starting to erode the esophagus. Emergency surgery to remove the band. It was growing into my stomach and esophagus. Lots of scar tissue now L

Then I had to wait until a year after that procedure! But now I am in the midst of pre-cert for ds in June, hopefully.

Hopefully, since I already did the clear liquid/full liquid/soft foods progression with the lap-band, I’ll at least be prepared for it this time. I already take tons of pills, and figure I will just be taking vitamins instead of prescriptions! I also know even better how important support will be.

Diane

From: duodenalswitch@yahoogroups.com [mailto:duodenalswitch@yahoogroups.com]

rox63

(9,464 posts)
22. Thanks for the information
Tue Mar 27, 2012, 09:52 AM
Mar 2012

One of the program "ambassadors" at the hospital's weight management center had a similar experience. He eventually had the band removed and had a gastric bypass. I realize that there are risks with every one of the procedures. But the program has a very good record, and has done thousands of bariatric surgeries.

I would likely go with either the sleeve or gastric bypass if I were significantly heavier than I am (My starting weight in the program was 261 - I am currently at 249), or if I were at more imminent risk of dire health consequences.

I know that it is easier to cheat with the band. I have watched a good friend struggle with that. But I know that I can lose weight. My biggest struggle is keeping it off permanently. Several years ago, I was able to lose 80 lbs, only to gain it all back over the following 3 years. What I really need is something that will make it difficult to fall back into those old patterns, and I think the band will do that for me. I know there will be a lot of hard work involved, whichever way I go.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
24. I'm still in the process
Tue May 1, 2012, 12:21 PM
May 2012

But don't have a surgery date yet. I expect it will be sometime over the summer. My insurance requires (among other things) at least 3 months of medically supervised weight loss before they will approve surgery. I've lost 21 pounds this way so far. I have so far been approved by the psychologist, the neurologist and the dietician, and just had a whole batch of mandatory tests at the hospital last week. (Upper GI, abdominal ultrasound, chest x-ray, echo-cardiograph, blood tests, etc.) I meet with the cardiologist and surgeon later this month, and will be tested for sleep apnea later this month as well.

This program is very thorough, and I'm glad about that. I'm still feeling good about going forward with the surgery.

Thanks for asking.

MaineDem

(18,161 posts)
25. The waiting is actually good.
Tue May 1, 2012, 12:57 PM
May 2012

Gives you time to wrap your head around the need to change eating habits, for example. I'm sorry if you've already said this but are there local support groups for you to attend?

Practicing how to eat S.L.O.W.L.Y is a big one. Chewing the heck out of everything. Putting the fork down between bites. Giving up carbonated soda and cutting back on caffeine.

And the waiting period also weeds out some who aren't willing to make the commitment.

Best of luck!

rox63

(9,464 posts)
26. I've still got some work to do on a few things
Tue May 1, 2012, 01:28 PM
May 2012

Like the eating more slowly and chewing more completely. There are support groups and educational classes available through the hospital's weight management center. I'm starting one later this week about the psychological and emotional triggers of overeating.

I have cut back on both carbonation and caffeine, but haven't given it up completely yet. I know the bubbles will have to go away forever. I'm told that I will be able to have a little caffeine after I recover from surgery, although it is discouraged. I know this is a huge committment, a forever committment. I'm glad that they make you wait. It's not something that should be done lightly.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
27. Good to hear that things are progressing well for you. Your Drs are being very thorough
Tue May 1, 2012, 11:30 PM
May 2012

and that bodes very well for them.

I'm glad you're still feeling good about your decision to have the surgery, it will go a long way towards your over all committment.

Congratulations on the 21 pound loss!!!

Do keep us posted please.


aA
kesha

rox63

(9,464 posts)
28. Will do!
Wed May 2, 2012, 03:40 PM
May 2012

I'll likely be so happy when I finally get my surgery date that I'll want to tell everyone.

jesspinto

(5 posts)
71. Importance of post- op
Tue Feb 5, 2013, 08:50 AM
Feb 2013

Very sorry about that. So you going in for another surgery now? Post- op checking is very very important. This is why they say a weight loss surgeon must be very friendly and open and must be good all in all.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
72. Clarification: I didn't write that post. I shared it because I thought it important.
Wed Feb 6, 2013, 01:54 AM
Feb 2013

My journey is documented elsewhere in this thread.

I've lost much more than I now weigh and I'm very happy with my success.

My surgery was done in Michigan in 2005. There are a LOT of excellent surgeons here in the USA that perform Bariatric surgery and it's important to do your research.


Are you considering surgery? Are you planning on going to India? You seem to advocate going out of the country and I wonder what your reasoning is?

thanks.

kesha.

genxlib

(5,691 posts)
76. Hi Annabanana
Mon Sep 17, 2018, 04:32 PM
Sep 2018

Looking through old OPs on Bariatric Surgery and found this.

I know you are still active and wanted to check in. Are you still pleased with your results?

I am well on my way towards a sleeve but not yet certain. Just curious about how it has been for you 6 years later.

annabanana

(52,791 posts)
77. Mixed on results.
Fri Sep 21, 2018, 03:26 PM
Sep 2018

Initially it's wonderful. I went from 360 to 155 over the course of about a year and 1/2. The thing is, the sleeve is only a tool. You still have to USE it properly to maintain results. While I can't eat very much at any meal (which is good). I am home most of the day, and I have always been a "snacker". Snacks can sabotage a sleeve easily.

I have regained a good chunk of what I lost, but am still in a much better place than I was. My weight HAS stabilized and I feel pretty good.

genxlib

(5,691 posts)
78. Appreciate the response
Fri Sep 21, 2018, 04:30 PM
Sep 2018

It is not an easy decision and I am seeking every scrap of information that I can find. I trust my DU community so I was hoping to find some heartfelt advice here.

I have heard a mixture on the long term efficacy of keeping the weight off. But if you kept at least part of it off, that is a plus.

I have never been much of a snacker. My problem is just eating too much at meal time. I can't be positive that I won't turn into a grazer but I have hopes that it could work for me.

Thank you so much for your answer and good luck in your continued journey.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
29. Met with the surgeon yesterday
Fri May 18, 2012, 12:27 PM
May 2012

It went well. Liked her a lot, and she thinks I'm a good candidate for the band. I still don't have a surgery date yet. Still need to get the sign-off from the cardiologist (appt is next week) and get tested for sleep apnea. (scheduled for 5/31) Once all the tests and doctor sign-offs are complete, the weight center will send everything out to the insurance company. If/when the insurance company approves, they'll be able to give me a surgery date. I'm hoping it doesn't take too long.

In the meantime, I've lost 25 pounds on my own in the last 3 months. I've always been pretty good at losing weight. But I totally suck at keeping it off for the long-term. The surgeon says that is one reason that I would be a good candidate for the band rather than the more drastic surgeries.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
30. Good luck with the cardio Dr and all the sign offs!!
Sat May 19, 2012, 05:03 PM
May 2012

I'm glad you're keeping us posted.

Good vibes coming your way for the insurance approval. I hope they cooperate and don't give you any hassle at all.




aA
kesha

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
32. Yay! I know how exciting and scary it is. I couldn't believe my ears when my insurance company
Tue May 22, 2012, 09:59 AM
May 2012

approved me! I was ecstatic and then, the nervousness hit !! LOL

You'll be fine. My surgery was about 5 hours long and so very involved. I wouldn't change a thing though.




kesha.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
33. The surgeon says mine should be less than an hour
Tue May 22, 2012, 12:36 PM
May 2012

And will only require an overnight stay in the hospital.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
34. An update
Wed May 23, 2012, 02:42 PM
May 2012

I just found out that my employer-sponsored insurance will be changing as of 7/1/12. Because we are very close to going for insurance approval, if the cardiologist approves me tomorrow, my surgery date will be either 6/11 or 6/18. Will know more after tomorrow's appt.

Kind of nervous, but in a good way.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
35. Good Luck!!! I'll try and check in before
Thu May 24, 2012, 01:25 AM
May 2012

tomorrow night. We're leaving for a long weekend vacation and I won't have internet. Please post as soon as you get clearance! (See, I know you're gonna get clearance)



kesha

rox63

(9,464 posts)
36. Tentative surgery date is 6/18
Thu May 24, 2012, 01:28 PM
May 2012

Unless my insurance turns it down, or a meteor strikes the hospital. Hoping neither of those happens.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
40. Still haven't gotten official insurance approval
Tue Jun 5, 2012, 02:08 PM
Jun 2012

Even though the surgery date of 6/18 is rapidly approaching. Had the pre-op appt at the hospital this morning, including meeting with the anesthesiologist. The Weight Center told me not to worry, but I worry anyway. This won't be happening without insurance authorization.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
42. YAY!!! Congratulations. You'll be in my thoughts. What an amazing journey you are about to take.
Thu Jun 7, 2012, 12:00 AM
Jun 2012

I am SO happy for you.

Sit back and relax now and you'll be on your way soon.



aA
kesha

rox63

(9,464 posts)
43. Thanks!
Thu Jun 7, 2012, 05:56 AM
Jun 2012

I have the mandatory pre-op 'band class' at the weight center this morning. Then I meet briefly with the surgeon again, then off to work. Another class at the weight center tonight after work (I told you they were thorough), part of a series of classes I've been attending about overcoming binge eating.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
44. Wow! With all the prep you're having to do I have no doubt
Thu Jun 7, 2012, 09:47 AM
Jun 2012

that you will be successful in your quest to lose unwanted pounds.

I look forward to following your journey and being supportive in any way I can.

You're going to feel wonderful!

aA
kesha

rox63

(9,464 posts)
45. Found out this morning that I've already lost a total of 30 pounds
Thu Jun 7, 2012, 12:29 PM
Jun 2012

since 2/22. As I've said before, I'm pretty good at losing weight. I just suck at keeping it off. I'm hoping that having this surgery will help me finally lose the weight and keep it off for good.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
46. One week until my surgery date!
Mon Jun 11, 2012, 08:01 AM
Jun 2012

And some of my friends are offering to take me out for meals that aren't all that healthy. This is what's known as "Last Supper Syndrome" by the folks at the Weight Center. Since I've lost significantly more weight than was required to qualify for surgery, there's no way I could gain back enough in one week to be disqualified. I did give in once so far, and let my best friend take me out for lunch for Mexican yesterday. (She had a 2-for-1 coupon for a local Mexican place) And while I enjoyed the enchiladas, I didn't feel all that good a few hours later. There is another friend offering to take me out for a meal this week. I will try to stick to healthier fare the next time.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
47. omg I remember the "last supper syndrome" very well. I went out for Mexican Chimichangas
Mon Jun 11, 2012, 10:49 AM
Jun 2012

and felt like hell afterwards!

I don't have many friends or relatives that live near me so I took myself out, hubby was working.

I bet you're getting excited!

kesha.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
48. Excited and nervous!
Mon Jun 11, 2012, 11:36 AM
Jun 2012

I've got a class at the Weight Center tomorrow called "Healing Faster", which deals with anxiety around the changes from the surgery, and teaches relaxation methods. Then a blood test on Saturday morning, because it has to be done within 48 hours of the surgery. And I'm due at the hospital at 6:00 AM Monday morning, with surgery scheduled for 7:30 AM.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
49. I report to the hospital at 6:00 AM on Monday morning.
Fri Jun 15, 2012, 01:29 PM
Jun 2012

Any positive, healing vibes you can spare would be welcome. If all goes well, I should be home mid-to-late afternoon on Tuesday.

madmom

(9,681 posts)
50. Hope everything went well for you. I am watching closely because I
Mon Jun 18, 2012, 03:24 PM
Jun 2012

have been researching the weight loss surgery and found this group. Again I hope everything is going well and all works out for you.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
51. welcome to the group madmom!
Tue Jun 19, 2012, 07:47 AM
Jun 2012

You're welcome to ask any questions you might have re weightloss surgery. I had the biliopancreatic diversion with a duodenal switch in 2005.

aA
kesha

madmom

(9,681 posts)
52. Thank you. I am still in the research stage and I'm waiting
Tue Jun 19, 2012, 12:46 PM
Jun 2012

for an appointment to talk with my GP about his recommendations. I will most certainly ask questions as they arise. Again thanks for the welcome.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
54. I'm home from the hospital
Wed Jun 20, 2012, 04:30 AM
Jun 2012

After having lap band surgery on Monday. Doing well so far. If you decide to go this route, make sure you get into a good program. There are some less-than-reputable ones out there.

spinbaby

(15,199 posts)
56. You feeling okay?
Wed Jun 20, 2012, 02:24 PM
Jun 2012

I totally agree with you about finding a good program. I did my research and went to a program that does over 1000 bypass surgeries a year with a 1% complication rate.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
57. I'm doing better than I expected
Wed Jun 20, 2012, 04:21 PM
Jun 2012

Not having much pain at all. Mostly I'm just tired. And I'm not really hungry. But I will be glad when I can eat solid food again. First post-op week is clear fluids. Second week goes to soft/pureed food. And if all goes well, I should be back on solid food by the third post-op week.

spinbaby

(15,199 posts)
58. I'll be watching you with interest
Wed Jun 20, 2012, 06:10 PM
Jun 2012

Lap band has the advantage of being reversible, but there all those band adjustments where they have to add and subtract fluid.

rox63

(9,464 posts)
59. The adjustments are just until you find your "sweet spot"
Thu Jun 21, 2012, 03:23 AM
Jun 2012

which is the fill level that works best for you.

Whichever program you get into will likely stress this as well - Remember that a band or a bypass is just a tool, not a cure-all. There is still a lot of hard work to be done after the surgery.

spinbaby

(15,199 posts)
60. The way I figure it...
Thu Jun 21, 2012, 06:50 AM
Jun 2012

...I'm already obsessively neurotic about what I eat; surgery will just let me get results from being obsessively neurotic.

jambo101

(797 posts)
61. Cures diabetes?
Thu Jan 31, 2013, 03:25 AM
Jan 2013

I've heard that Bariatric surgery cures diabetes, if so i'd certainly be up for the operation but my Endocrinologist says at 65 i'm too old to go under Canada's health plan and even if i did qualify it could be a several year waiting period, private clinics are numerous but they charge $20K+ for the procedure.

jesspinto

(5 posts)
63. Only if its obesity related
Thu Jan 31, 2013, 04:39 AM
Jan 2013

Well.......It is true that a bariatric surgery can cure diabetes. But this is true only if the cause of that diabetes is obesity. A bariatric surgery mainly helps reduce weight and in the process diabetes is cured. And yes....at 65 getting a bariatric surgery can be a little risky.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
68. jambo where in Canada are you? Have you thought of going to the USA, I know that
Fri Feb 1, 2013, 01:28 AM
Feb 2013

OHIP has sent many patients to Michigan.

My surgeon has looked after many Canadian patients.

I'm Canadian, living in the USA.

I had the Biliopancreatic Diversion with a duodenal switch.

I've gone from 302 to 136 at last weigh in on Monday past. My surgery was in March of 2005.

aA
kesha

jambo101

(797 posts)
69. Thanks Auntagonist
Fri Feb 1, 2013, 02:15 AM
Feb 2013

My endocrinologist hasnt recommended the USA option as yet, i might bring it up on the next visit,I assume when he says i'm too old he was referring to an age cap that the Quebec health system will pay 65 being the cut off point. While i'm sure an American clinic would be more than happy to perform the procedure i suspect having the operation done in the USA will not be covered by Quebec Health Insurance and will probably cost more in the USA than i can afford.

I envy your success..

jesspinto

(5 posts)
62. The clinic is important
Thu Jan 31, 2013, 04:21 AM
Jan 2013

I think the program into which you enroll is the most important. You clinic and surgeon etc etc must be good, supportive and have years of experience behind them. Having a bariatric surgery IS a big step. Which one have you decided on?

rox63

(9,464 posts)
64. I had gastric band surgery back in June '12
Thu Jan 31, 2013, 11:56 AM
Jan 2013

I've lost a total of 77 pounds in the last year, including the weight I lost during preparation for the surgery. The program I went with was very experienced and highly rated.

spinbaby

(15,199 posts)
65. How much total do you want to lose?
Thu Jan 31, 2013, 02:21 PM
Jan 2013

Do you find it more difficult as you get closer to goal weight?

rox63

(9,464 posts)
66. I want to lose a total of 120 lbs
Thu Jan 31, 2013, 04:12 PM
Jan 2013

My weight loss has slowed quite a lot lately. The more you lose, the harder you have to work to lose the rest of the weight. Since you are carrying around less weight, you burn fewer calories for the same amount of work. What I really need to do is ramp up the exercise. And it being winter right now is not helping this effort.

spinbaby

(15,199 posts)
70. I hear you about the exercise
Fri Feb 1, 2013, 12:53 PM
Feb 2013

It's so hard to get out there and do something in this weather. I'm still in the "honeymoon" phase of my bypass when weight just falls off but I worry about coping as I get nearer my goal weight and get hungrier.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
73. Jesspinto you seem to advocate going out of country for surgery. Every post includes
Wed Feb 6, 2013, 01:55 AM
Feb 2013

a hyperlink to a Bariatric Centre.

What is your experience?

aA
kesha

spinbaby

(15,199 posts)
74. I just now noticed where that link went
Thu Feb 7, 2013, 01:08 PM
Feb 2013

I might, given the right circumstances, go out of country for surgery. Some overseas centers are excellent. I would not, however, make that choice based on a random link spammed to an Internet message board.

auntAgonist

(17,257 posts)
75. exactly spinbaby. If this person has experience with this clinic they'd like to share, I'm willing
Fri Feb 8, 2013, 01:48 AM
Feb 2013

to take a look but as at now, it appears to be spam.

aA
kesha
just lookin' out for the folks here

Latest Discussions»Support Forums»Weight Loss/Maintenance»Bariatric surgery