Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Marthe48

(23,044 posts)
Wed Dec 3, 2025, 01:02 PM Dec 2025

My yeast is a dud

I've had the yeast in the pantry and it's best buy date is 7/26. I finished the old jar for Thanksgiving rolls and added a little from the new jar. The rolls weren't my best this year, but I put it down to letting them raise once, not twice as usual.

I started a loaf of bread today. I did everything as usual, same ingredients, same timing, and used the yeast from the fresh jar. I make a starter and let it sit 1 hour. Then I add the rest of the flour, knead, shape and let it raise for an hour. Then bake. I noticed that the starter was kind of flat, but thought maybe I'd used more water than usual. I added flour and kneaded it. It felt okay, but not as elastic as usual. I shaped it and let it rise for an hour. When I checked, it hadn't raised. I brought it out and added a little more yeast and also heated the oven a little more. It is rising, but slowly. I proofed some of the yeast, and it is very slow. I'm going to try to return the jar.

I hope I can salvage the loaf. I read about slow rising bread, but it wasn't what I wanted to do today. Finding out your yeast isn't lively in the middle of baking is a bad experience, for sure.





9 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
My yeast is a dud (Original Post) Marthe48 Dec 2025 OP
😕 buzzycrumbhunger Dec 2025 #1
I've had 10 year old yeast that was still ferouciously active Warpy Dec 2025 #2
Yeast I use usually does ok Marthe48 Dec 2025 #3
Be sure to check the ezpiratioin date on the jar Warpy Dec 2025 #4
We had a new jar of yeast fail too. Callalily Dec 2025 #5
That's an idea! Marthe48 Dec 2025 #6
Sorry, Marthe48. HeartsCanHope Dec 2025 #7
I don't use a lot of yeast Old Crank Dec 2025 #8
It was a bust Marthe48 Dec 2025 #9

buzzycrumbhunger

(1,866 posts)
1. 😕
Wed Dec 3, 2025, 02:30 PM
Dec 2025

I always store mine in a tightly sealed jar in the fridge. Even when I buy a ton and it sits for months and months, I've never had it fail.

Wish I had a substitute handy but work is killing me today and my brain isn't working...

Warpy

(114,552 posts)
2. I've had 10 year old yeast that was still ferouciously active
Wed Dec 3, 2025, 03:43 PM
Dec 2025

It was commercial yeast sold in bulk at a health food store. It came in pellets instead of powder, and I think that had something to do with its remarkable longevity.

I know the only time I proof yeast in warm water and barley malt is when I know it's old yeast and I want to make sure it's still alive. Otherwise, I don't proof it before baking, I've killed it off that way too many times.

Marthe48

(23,044 posts)
3. Yeast I use usually does ok
Wed Dec 3, 2025, 07:06 PM
Dec 2025

I keep the open jar or package in the freezer. I kept the unopened jar in my cool, dark pantry.

I'd start the yeast on its own for years, then learned I was proofing it Never too old to learn.

I am trying to make a sourdough starter, and it doesn't look promising. I'll try to exchange this jar.



Warpy

(114,552 posts)
4. Be sure to check the ezpiratioin date on the jar
Wed Dec 3, 2025, 07:21 PM
Dec 2025

The last jar of yeast I bought had it stamped on the label. There might also be a lot or batch humber on it, you don't want a replacement jar from the same lot or batch, it would be dud yeast, also.

Hope the next one works out better. There's little worse for a bread baker than expecting bread and getting a brick.

Callalily

(15,362 posts)
5. We had a new jar of yeast fail too.
Thu Dec 4, 2025, 08:14 AM
Dec 2025

I wrote the company and they sent me coupons for two free jars!

HeartsCanHope

(1,641 posts)
7. Sorry, Marthe48.
Fri Dec 5, 2025, 11:25 AM
Dec 2025

Nothing better than fresh baked bread. I, too would try to return the jar. Very frustrating to do all the work for a poor result!

Old Crank

(6,914 posts)
8. I don't use a lot of yeast
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 12:39 PM
Dec 2025

So I buy individual packets.
Then proof them before adding flour.

The slow rise could give you a more complex flavor.
Good luck.

Marthe48

(23,044 posts)
9. It was a bust
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 01:57 PM
Dec 2025

I tried starting some sour dough, and even after 24 hours, no luck. I'll try to exchange it.

I always used the small packets, but one year, my daughter got me a large package of bulk yeast and I've been a fan every since. I kept it in the freezer and it lasted way past its expiration date.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Cooking & Baking»My yeast is a dud