Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
Fri Sep 8, 2017, 01:13 PM Sep 2017

Home well water systems

I'm pretty good with these things. But I want to diagnose correctly from the start, so I don't burn out the backup spare controller and switch.

A few days ago, I think it was Tuesday or Monday, the GFCI flipped while the toaster was running. Very unusual. Hasn't happened in 10 years. So I pushed it back in and all was fine.

Today, my well pump won't turn on. Totally separate circuit mind you, but I'm thinking a short in the well system could have pulled current and flipped the toaster GFCI?

Anyway, the well fuses are ok, though I do have spares and can replace them to be sure. The pressure tank reads 4 pounds, slightly more than when I turn off the system and drain it for sediment.

The oldest parts of the system are the wiring (41) and the bladder (18). Frankly the bladder is due or overdue. Could that be the problem? Would a ruptured or clogged bladder cause the switch not to turn on at 30 pounds?? yet still allow the water to run down to empty? I think unlikely.

So I'm going to examine visible parts of the wiring, including under the well cap, and see if anything. Test the switch, perhaps remove it and look for clogs.

I'm thinking the problem is in the controller or the pump. But the pump (very very light use) is only 6.5 years old and so is the controller and switch.

Thanks for any ideas. It's going to be a dry weekend here!

14 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Home well water systems (Original Post) bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 OP
You could look at the nykym Sep 2017 #1
Thanks, makes sense bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 #2
If you had a short nykym Sep 2017 #3
Wow! bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 #4
So after a weekend of work this is where it's at bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 #5
Is there an electrician in the house? bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 #6
You have issues for sure Wash. state Desk Jet Sep 2017 #7
Thanks bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 #8
Maybe you can get the well guy to come out and for a fair price trouble shoot the problem Wash. state Desk Jet Sep 2017 #9
You've hit my weak spot, it's evident to all isn't it bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 #10
You have positive attitude ! Wash. state Desk Jet Sep 2017 #11
Here's a YouTube video on what my well guy is talking about bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 #12
So I removed the large capacitor and ordered one from Amazon bucolic_frolic Sep 2017 #13
It's hard to believe the part is in such short supply locally. Wash. state Desk Jet Sep 2017 #14

nykym

(3,063 posts)
1. You could look at the
Fri Sep 8, 2017, 01:23 PM
Sep 2017

Pressure switch the little gray boxy thing near your bladder.
Sometimes the contact get pitted and worn out and the switch will or will not turn on.
Best to replace than try to clean up.
The other part to look at would be the unit that the pressure switch is wired to (i can't remember the name of it).
Mine is about 6=7" tall x 5" wide and about 3-4" deep, small gray box. front lifts off (there may be a screw or 2 holding it on.
There is a big capacitor in there so make sure you turn off the power and don't touch the bare contacts.
check to see if the spade terminals on the capacitor are corroded if so replace the unit. Costs about $60 to whatever.
Anyway that,s my 2 cents.

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
2. Thanks, makes sense
Fri Sep 8, 2017, 01:29 PM
Sep 2017

My pressure switch is mounted at the top of the system, the bladder is near the floor, but that's ok

The box is the controller. I have a spare. Just don't want to burn it out so looking for shorts first.

If there were a short, would the circuit breaker trip? Because that didn't happen.

nykym

(3,063 posts)
3. If you had a short
Fri Sep 8, 2017, 04:07 PM
Sep 2017

the breaker should trip.

I suggested those 2 things as we had a lighting strike across the street from my house and it took out the controller.
Surprising as it must have been at least 100' away.
Only evidence was a small (about 1/6th inch circle on the box near were the wires come into it.
It was myself and a local plumber - I pointed it out to him and sure enough that was the problem.
I have also had trouble with the pressure switch in the past as my utility room is rather damp.

If your bladder is shot it will start to leak, been there done that.

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
4. Wow!
Fri Sep 8, 2017, 04:13 PM
Sep 2017

I had a very close lightning strike about 2-3 weekends ago. I would say it was about 150-200 feet away. I could hear a little crinkling noise outside before it hit. Lost power overnight.

Off to diagnosis ... been reading all afternoon.

Will report back ... thanks again

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
5. So after a weekend of work this is where it's at
Sun Sep 10, 2017, 06:28 PM
Sep 2017

no wiring problems. Power does go to the switch, but the pump doesn't run and the switch doesn't switch.
When I separate the contacts on the switch with a screwdriver, they spark.

So I'm pretty sure it's the pump.

The well casing is steel, it flakes a lot, you can hear the flakes falling down into the water. In addition there
is iron/sulphur buildup in the well, and granulated particles come in with the water, the particles are dark brown
iron, and black.

Don't know if the lightning strike had something to do with it, though I do think so.

Get on the phone in the morning and see what some local well people think about it.

Not a fun repair bill!

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
6. Is there an electrician in the house?
Mon Sep 11, 2017, 05:41 PM
Sep 2017

I talked with the well company today, who advised me to replace the control box (controller, capacitor) which hums for 5 seconds before cutting off, and see if the new controller starts the pump. Ok, will do.

Meanwhile though, the switch has stopped sparking when opened.

And my circuit breaker box, aka 'fuse box', which was humming ever so slightly, has stopped humming.

I am wondering: the well pump is setup at 230 volts, two 115 breakers. If one of those breakers is not supplying electric to the system, that would cause the pump to not start: not enough juice.

Is there a way to test to see if both 115 volt circuits are supplying power? I mean, I know there is, for an electrician with a meter, but how about an intuitive test without such equipment?

Wash. state Desk Jet

(3,426 posts)
7. You have issues for sure
Mon Sep 11, 2017, 07:29 PM
Sep 2017


The cartridge fuses could be a source of the problem .I assume you have removed the plug fuses to look for burn marks at the contacts.

Also you mentioned lightning and power surge. Some years ago a client kept calling during rain storms or just after with circuit breakers going off or loss of power in different areas in the house. This was tough one because the breaker box was maxed out big time. But, after the third call ,they didn,t know who else to call so the said,I got curious about the power feed from the poll. I got out my binoculars and fallowed the line from the poll to the house--, and where the line passed through a tree in an area where lightning struck and took out a branch, there was insulation burned off. That was the cause of the problems. The power company came out and fixed that and took out some more branch's as well,at no charge ! It's just a thought !



electrical testers ,very basic ,tells you there is or isn't power.





I've used the wiggie for years. That's the black one at the top. Red to power ,black to neutral- read instructional before you go into it.

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
8. Thanks
Mon Sep 11, 2017, 08:19 PM
Sep 2017

Yes I swapped in a replacement pair of fuses, but it made no difference, and no burn marks. There was some black/green corrosion on the power switch, one of these dual contact pull-down on/off fuse box switches. I'm thinking similar corrosion could go on with circuit breakers.

I don't think there are any cartridge fuses in the system, unless they are hidden in the circuit breaker box.

The well man said the pumps can get stuck. I'm reading online tonight that the pumps have been severely cheapened by the manufacturers. My previous pump lasted 24 years. This one is 6.6, and the average life of the new cheap pumps with bushings instead of ball bearings and plastic components is 7 years. This pump was $886. Now the same company (and it was bought out) will replace it for $495. Same pump. Plus installation of course. Maybe it's a jobs program.

The electric company? Their wires on the phone poles must be 1955.

My electric testers are 1950s too. Pair of leads, durable bulb in the center. If there's power, they light up!

The well guy told me 3 times to replace the controller first, so I'm off to Home Depot tomorrow. He seems to think the humming of both controllers I have is indicative of nothing. Maybe a new one with a new condensor will have more power? Who am I to question experience?

Wash. state Desk Jet

(3,426 posts)
9. Maybe you can get the well guy to come out and for a fair price trouble shoot the problem
Mon Sep 11, 2017, 08:33 PM
Sep 2017

At least knowing what yer up against can help you in decision making as to how to deal with the tolatlity of the problem.

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
10. You've hit my weak spot, it's evident to all isn't it
Mon Sep 11, 2017, 09:19 PM
Sep 2017

Micromanaging. Because being the youngest in my family I was never allowed to formulate big decisions, my role was to to follow up and troubleshoot all their errors because they were too lazy to pay attention to details.

The personality is formed in the first 5 to 10 years of life, after that it's all echoes.

Try to fix a pump and you must repair a personality.

Wash. state Desk Jet

(3,426 posts)
11. You have positive attitude !
Mon Sep 11, 2017, 10:35 PM
Sep 2017

Sticktoitiveness ,that's what you gotta have to work yer way through a problem area ! You got it,stick to it !

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
12. Here's a YouTube video on what my well guy is talking about
Tue Sep 12, 2017, 02:45 PM
Sep 2017

My capacitors don't look bad, they don't bulge, but on close inspection one has a slightly yellow dot as this vid mentions near the end, and the other has a barely yellow hue to it with a darkened corner. So it is possible they could be inadequate to start my pump.

Also, went to Lowes and HomeDepot. No Controllers, just one that was too large. So it's end of summer, parts are in short supply, think of the number of new controllers they'll need in Houston! No wonder my well guy sent me to the store, he probably has a short supply too.

Guess I'll be without running water for awhile.

bucolic_frolic

(46,995 posts)
13. So I removed the large capacitor and ordered one from Amazon
Thu Sep 14, 2017, 06:47 AM
Sep 2017

though it will take a week to get here from New South Wales

It will either start 'er right up, or indicate the pump is KAPUT!

But the rebuilt control box will be good for the new pump at that point.

I'm following up here so others can see the process ... this was all unknown to me a week ago

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»DIY & Home Improvement»Home well water systems