Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

irisblue

(34,084 posts)
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 11:08 AM Mar 2023

My water tank, which is of great age, is almost dead, I have no idea what to do next

I currently have a gas heated tank, I've read this article
https://www.thisoldhouse.com/plumbing/21015245/hot-water-heater-buying-guide


I did call city code & asked if the city inspectors come as who ever replaces the tank finishes the work to make sure the gas lines are properly connected, he tap danced around that but did tell me a permit was $75. I'm willing to pay that, I am not interested in having my house blow up ( happened to a neighbor when I was a kid, big memory).

I know I will get another 40 gallon tank again. I did look into getting a heat on demand syste, but the guy quoted a $5000 moving gas lines for a 50+yr old house, I'm not able to pay that.

Do I go to a big hardware store? Do I call a plumbing company?

Help me, I want a long hot shower again.
Thx

19 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
My water tank, which is of great age, is almost dead, I have no idea what to do next (Original Post) irisblue Mar 2023 OP
Lowes and Home Depot typically stock them ... Xoan Mar 2023 #1
Have you bought thru them? irisblue Mar 2023 #3
We've used Lowes a couple of times with success. CrispyQ Mar 2023 #9
I had mine replaced in 2020, $1600 parts and labor, AO Smith Tank commercial grade Shellback Squid Mar 2023 #2
Who did you use? A plumbing company? Hardware store guy? Private guy? irisblue Mar 2023 #4
Lowes, they arranged the contractor Shellback Squid Mar 2023 #5
Test WmChris Mar 2023 #6
Make sure the installer is a licensed plumber. sinkingfeeling Mar 2023 #7
I second this: a licensed plumber Auggie Mar 2023 #13
I third this. Plumbers do this routinely. Midnight Writer Mar 2023 #15
had mine replaced last year for $1300..Hot Water Tank company BlueWaveNeverEnd Mar 2023 #8
it isn't really a hard job Kali Mar 2023 #10
We did this last year MerryHolidays Mar 2023 #11
$5000 seems high for a tankless install... ret5hd Mar 2023 #12
In our case, the gas line was very far from the meter MerryHolidays Mar 2023 #14
Go tankless if you can. Much more energy efficient SheltieLover Mar 2023 #16
The folks who do our annual maintenance on the heating system... TygrBright Mar 2023 #17
I'm thinking about installing an electric hot water heater. OAITW r.2.0 Mar 2023 #18
We had a good experience with Water Heaters Plus in Worthington Ohio Ohiya Mar 2023 #19

CrispyQ

(38,050 posts)
9. We've used Lowes a couple of times with success.
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 11:28 AM
Mar 2023

But only windows & two outside doors, no plumbing or electrical. If you're on Nextdoor your neighbors might have referrals.

WmChris

(216 posts)
6. Test
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 11:19 AM
Mar 2023

Just make sure any fitting that was loosened and retightened or replaced is checked with soapy water for leaks. Any certified installers will do this as a matter of routine.

Kali

(55,687 posts)
10. it isn't really a hard job
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 11:32 AM
Mar 2023

flex line for the gas makes that part super easy. of course I am in the sticks where I really don't have much choice.

MerryHolidays

(7,715 posts)
11. We did this last year
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 11:52 AM
Mar 2023

Yes, Lowes and Home Depot can do it (usually same day).

We went through a water heater company which had the best price (and excellent reviews on multiple sources). Price shop, check reviews (making sure they are legit), and then go for it.

This is pretty standard, and the work can be done quickly.

We looked at a tankless water heater option too, but, like with you, it was going to be too expensive and not really worth it.

ret5hd

(21,314 posts)
12. $5000 seems high for a tankless install...
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 11:53 AM
Mar 2023

I’d get another quote or two (from licensed plumbers of course). Using flex lines makes that a simple job.

We have a gas tankless, and I wouldn’t go back.

The only downside is the number of simultaneous uses…we can’t

take a shower
wash a load of hot laundry
and run a hot load in the dishwasher

all at the same time.

But really…how often do you need to do all 3 at the same time?

MerryHolidays

(7,715 posts)
14. In our case, the gas line was very far from the meter
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 12:04 PM
Mar 2023

That would mean (according to the plumber) that the BTUs would fluctuate too much. Please you have to have electricity all the time. If the power goes out, I don't think the tankless heater works.

Our estimated cost was something over $7000.

For the right kind of install, yes, I think it's a great idea. But for us, it simply wouldn't work, and the cost was so much higher than an ordinary water heater.

SheltieLover

(59,358 posts)
16. Go tankless if you can. Much more energy efficient
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 02:02 PM
Mar 2023

Btw, you shouldnp't need a permit to replace an existing appliance! Call around to plumbers & ask!

TygrBright

(20,984 posts)
17. The folks who do our annual maintenance on the heating system...
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 02:29 PM
Mar 2023

...are a local "Plumbing and Heating" company. I will totally give them first crack at it when we replace.

If you know a similar company locally or can get recommendations from neighbors, you could start there.

helpfully,
Bright

OAITW r.2.0

(28,175 posts)
18. I'm thinking about installing an electric hot water heater.
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 02:55 PM
Mar 2023

The wrinkle here is that I want to tie the HW heater into my solar panel circuit so I can shut down my oil furnace for 6-8 months a year. I am guessing that I'd have to insert the the new unit to my furnace HW out line. In the winter, the furnace HW would flow into the electric HW heater and wouldn't require additional electricity to keep the water hot.

Ohiya

(2,407 posts)
19. We had a good experience with Water Heaters Plus in Worthington Ohio
Wed Mar 8, 2023, 11:11 PM
Mar 2023

6330 Proprietors Rd. Suite A Worthington OH 43085
waterheatersplus@aol.com

614-905-0195

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»DIY & Home Improvement»My water tank, which is o...