Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Lydiarose

(68 posts)
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 11:42 AM Feb 2022

Was my dad wrong?

My dad fought in the Navy in WWII in the Pacific. He lost a lot of buddies during the war. When my siblings and I were growing up, we were not allowed to buy anything made in Japan (and their products were as ubiquitous then as Chinese products are today). One time, while attending his annual Tin Can Sailors reunion in Seattle, he and a cohort of veterans stepped off the elevator when a group of Japanese visitors got on. Was he wrong? Today he'd be considered a racist or bigot. But given his experience, were his actions excusable?

27 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Was my dad wrong? (Original Post) Lydiarose Feb 2022 OP
I've always said that a war is never over until the last man that fought in it has died Walleye Feb 2022 #1
Well said JustAnotherGen Feb 2022 #6
Same attitude to Germans? ret5hd Feb 2022 #2
It is all in the eyes I reckon. nt DURHAM D Feb 2022 #4
See my post below JustAnotherGen Feb 2022 #7
My Pappaw had a German last name underpants Feb 2022 #13
He personally fought the Japanese Lydiarose Feb 2022 #14
it is all impossibly complicated. NewHendoLib Feb 2022 #3
I don't know JustAnotherGen Feb 2022 #5
Your dad's hatred of Russians Lydiarose Feb 2022 #25
Some vets have been able sarisataka Feb 2022 #8
People are a product of their times. Of course we tend to judge them all Chainfire Feb 2022 #24
Interesting take Lydiarose Feb 2022 #26
Given his experiences, whathehell Feb 2022 #9
I have been known Busterscruggs Feb 2022 #10
You don't see the difference? ret5hd Feb 2022 #16
I have stayed far Busterscruggs Feb 2022 #17
But the diff between what/how a person says, does, acts... ret5hd Feb 2022 #18
I guess Busterscruggs Feb 2022 #21
And that's the same as being "caught off guard" by someone being Asian? ret5hd Feb 2022 #22
and many who served got over stopdiggin Feb 2022 #11
War changes who people. Having said that, racism is racism. LakeArenal Feb 2022 #12
Yes Effete Snob Feb 2022 #15
There was a lot of anti-German and anti-Japanese propaganda produced during WWII No Vested Interest Feb 2022 #19
Some Native Americans today despise whites Kaleva Feb 2022 #20
He is not the only one, for sure. Chainfire Feb 2022 #23
You have had some good answers DashOneBravo Feb 2022 #27

JustAnotherGen

(33,327 posts)
7. See my post below
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 11:50 AM
Feb 2022

I have a distinct memory of an older german woman bending down to to pinch my cheek and saying I was adorable (mixed race little girl whose parents were stationed in Weisbaden in the 70's) and my Papa George - Great Grandfather, French Army Officer WW1 -

Slapping her hand.

He absolutely hated the Germans. Hated them. Didn't like the peace and that's why he immigrated to the USA in the early 1920's.

underpants

(186,377 posts)
13. My Pappaw had a German last name
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 12:25 PM
Feb 2022

He wasn’t my actual grandfather. He put up with a rash of shit and he fought in WWII. He spent two years recuperating from wounds at the Greenbrier which had become an Army hospital. He was a big Kahuna at the VFW too but people said horrible things to him all the time.

JustAnotherGen

(33,327 posts)
5. I don't know
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 11:48 AM
Feb 2022

My dad (Officer, Green Beret) had a tremendous amount of respect for the Koreans and Vietnamese.

But - he hated the Russians. HATED them.

My mom's dad (WW2 US Soldier), her mom's dad (my great grandfather - WW 1 french officer) and her step grandfather were absolutely HOSTILE to Germans when visiting us in Weisbaden in the 70's.

I think when I look at the three of them - it's the difference between knowing people LIKE the enemy (Montagnards - as an example - my dad lived with them and trained them) vs living in a trench for a few years, or entering a concentration camp at the end of the War. Or being at the Nuremberg trials as a Military Physician / Witness.

Familiarity does not breed contempt - it allows us to see the enemy as they are.

Funny though - my mom's dad didn't hold that 'hatred' for the Japanese. I think he thought they were noble - and his guilt for the H-Bomb might have been in play there.

Lydiarose

(68 posts)
25. Your dad's hatred of Russians
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 06:33 PM
Feb 2022

Look what's happening TODAY in the Ukraine!!! And what happened with Crimea! Makes you think. Of course, I don't blame the general populace. It's entirely on Putin!

sarisataka

(20,856 posts)
8. Some vets have been able
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 11:51 AM
Feb 2022

To put their experience behind them and even become close friends with former enemies.

For others their experience was too much and they cannot see some people except as enemies.

I try not to judge them too harshly.

 

Chainfire

(17,757 posts)
24. People are a product of their times. Of course we tend to judge them all
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 06:17 PM
Feb 2022

by the standards of today. (which may or may not be the standards of tomorrow) I don't know how that is to be avoided.

A lot of the issue with American Pacific Combat vets and a lasting hate of the Japanese comes from such a vast difference in the two cultures. The Japanese were seen a particularly brutal, by Western standards, of course. In fact, the Japanese were brutal, by our standards, with each other too. Sargents were brutal to corporals, corporals were brutal to privates, Lieutenants were brutal to Sargents, and so forth. In training in particular and in service in general, the Japanese beat the crap out of each other for minor breaches of conduct, or apparently, in some cases just for the hell of it.

Most of the people who had actual combat with the Japanese at least respected their ability as fighters, but they viewed them as treacherous, sneaky, heartless and a little crazy. They did not play the war game by the same rules as Americans. Suicide pilots, suicide charges, mass suicide rather than surrender just shook the American troops to their core. American troops never could wrap their heads around how a man could intentionally kill himself in order to strike the enemy, or to avoid capture. It just didn't grok...

As soon as the war ended and the fighting troops went home, and the occupation troops took over, that attitude changed abruptly. A lot of American post-war troops brought home Japanese wives. The big surprise for the American leaders and troops was how cooperative the defeated Japanese were with the victors. Senior American leadership expected a lot of post-war violence and it never materialized. Almost as soon as the surrender, American troops were safe in the streets of Japan.

Lydiarose

(68 posts)
26. Interesting take
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 06:40 PM
Feb 2022

I did not know that, but it's very interesting as well as seemingly contradictory. And Japan has made no war overtures since then. It's like they're a whole different country today.

 

Busterscruggs

(448 posts)
10. I have been known
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 11:55 AM
Feb 2022

To steer clear of Maga hats and open carry idiots. Disliking things and people comes in all stripes

 

Busterscruggs

(448 posts)
17. I have stayed far
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 01:46 PM
Feb 2022

Away from military service. Being that I have a serious phobia of guns and weapons of any kind, the Maga hats and open carry avoidance is the only life experience that is similar.

ret5hd

(21,320 posts)
18. But the diff between what/how a person says, does, acts...
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 02:28 PM
Feb 2022

Vs a trait they were born with is so vastly…uhh, man. Take me away Calgon.

 

Busterscruggs

(448 posts)
21. I guess
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 03:45 PM
Feb 2022

I dont understand what your point is? I've been caught off guard by a gun on a belt so bad before that I hurried out of the store to breath into a bag while sitting on the curb. The lady at goodwill gave me a hug when I came back though which was nice

stopdiggin

(12,694 posts)
11. and many who served got over
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 11:59 AM
Feb 2022

that bitterness (or at least modulated over time). IMO - perfectly understandable human behavior. (troops have come home from every conflict with some pretty ugly sentiment about their opponent - just no love lost) At the same time ... This is surely something that we do not want to encourage, embrace, or reinforce?

LakeArenal

(29,740 posts)
12. War changes who people. Having said that, racism is racism.
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 12:16 PM
Feb 2022

Not all abused children grow to be abusers.

Not all military become racists.

 

Effete Snob

(8,387 posts)
15. Yes
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 12:52 PM
Feb 2022

My dad had a lot of buddies killed by Germans (and Austrians), and ended up marrying one.

Those people on the elevator had nothing to do with what happened to your father or his friends.

To suggest it is "justified" is also to justify the common... "I was (beat up / robbed / victimized in some way) by a (insert racial, ethnic or religious group), so I don't like them."

No Vested Interest

(5,193 posts)
19. There was a lot of anti-German and anti-Japanese propaganda produced during WWII
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 02:58 PM
Feb 2022

that I remember and that we sometimes see in a historical context.
In addition to the interring of Japanese-US citizens and taking their property in many cases. they were blatantly referred to as "Japs" in headlines, etc; i.e., the discrimination was approved of and advanced by US government and institutions.
Germans were similarly demeaned. I recall the Disney short comic film, with the song "In the Fuhrer's face." - Funny, and we all laughed.
In WWI, streets with German names were renamed to more Anglo-sounding names or words.

Some of this was harmless and in support of our troops and war effort; some of it had deep problematic effects that have lasted until the present day.

 

Chainfire

(17,757 posts)
23. He is not the only one, for sure.
Mon Feb 21, 2022, 05:09 PM
Feb 2022

I had two uncles, both Marines, both seriously wounded, one on Okinawa, the other on Iwo Jima. Until their last breath, they hated anything to do with Japanese people or culture. Interestingly, both also harbored very bad feelings about the American Red Cross who they claimed, that while in long-term recovery in various hospitals, constantly shook them down for goods that were supposed to be free. Stuff like writing paper, cigarettes, treats. Neither of their children were ever allowed to participate in the RC donation drives that were common in the schools in the 50s-70s.

Were these people bigots. No question. As far as my uncles, it wasn't limited to the Japanese either. As far as that went, the whole country used racism as a weapon during the war against the Japanese. Japanese people were often shown as Monkeys, with buck teeth and Coke bottle glasses, on the propaganda posters. What the government did with innocent Japanese American citizens was heartbreaking, and based on race.

We know the National policy was racist, because neither the Germans nor the Italians were not depicted as sub-humans. Of course, they did make a lot of fun of the German leaders, but depicted them as tyrants and idiots instead of inferior human beings.

DashOneBravo

(2,679 posts)
27. You have had some good answers
Tue Feb 22, 2022, 12:50 AM
Feb 2022

It’s a product of combat. Which I was never in but my dad and a lot of my friends were.

I’m sure there are soldiers of different armies that feel that way about us. It’s their experiences that were up close and it happened to their friends.

One guy interviewed on tv talked about the North Koreans who found his loaded truck full of critically wounded lying in stretchers. They burned the truck with him in it. He escaped in a ditch. He still hates them.

Awful things happened and the Japanese were especially brutal. A Japanese sergeant or officer could beat and execute a Japanese soldier. They despised people who had surrendered. That’s why the treatment prisoners so badly.


My dad hated the North Koreans as well. It mostly stemmed from them recovering dozens of bodies of US troops who had been tied with their hands behind them and it looked like about 40 guys had used them for bayonet practice.

Hope that helps

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Veterans»Was my dad wrong?