Looking for some feedback on something

Hi - looking for some feedback on something related to my store. If you look at http://thewitsend.aliboom.com/Military/cat3224002_2769335.aspx you'll see that on my "Liberal" tees, I have an individual item/page for each of the services. However, on my "Atheist" tees (which can be accessed directly at http://thewitsend.aliboom.com/Atheist_Servicemember_all_5_branches_tee/p3224001_14801227.aspx ) I have only one page, with a dropdown to let you select which branch you want.

My question is, do you believe that latter method is too complicated or confusing? I am curious about that, since there are five different dropdowns to allow you to make your selection; though some of them have defaults. Or that it doesn't have enough draw without mentioning a particular service directly?

I'm wondering because I'm in the process of adding the items that I have in my Etsy shop, which has some shirts with other variations (for example "Progressive&quot and for veterans and retired veterans. There are also some shirts related to acronyms, such as FIGMO,SUSFU, SAPFU, etc.

I'd prefer to do it in the style of the latter ("Atheist&quot shirt but if people dislike that method enough, I'll do individual pages for each branch.

Thanks!

Incidentally, since I'm talking about it, don't forget that there is a LIBERALMILITARY coupon code that will give you 20% on any store order, if you ever decide to do some shopping.