Fiction
Related: About this forumMy long-postponed book report on "The Secret Place", by Tana French.
First, I will unequivocally state that Tana French is one of most favorite authors - I rank her right there up at the top of my list with Arnaldur Indriðason. As anyone who has followed my posts in this group probably knows by now, my main reading material these days is crime fiction, particularly by northern European authors, and more particularly by Scandinavian authors.
Tana French, however, is an Irish author, and she is damn good.
The Secret Place is the fifth book in her "Dublin Murder Squad" series. As a series, this one is somewhat unusual in that each book of the series features a different member of the Murder Squad in the leading role, so that a character who was somewhat peripheral in one book becomes the main protagonist in the next book.
The story in The Secret Place concerns the murder of a teenage boy whose body was found on the grounds of a private girl's school. He was a student at a nearby private boy's school. Both schools accomodate both boarding students and day students. As the story opens, we first meet four girls who are longtime friends, two of whom have been boarding at the school for several years, and two of whom are about to become boarders for their final four years of schooling. (The Irish school system is different from the U.S. system, in that post-elementary schooling is divided by first year, second year, third year, etc. - going up to sixth year - pre-college - when the students are about 18 years old - the story takes place when the girls are going through their third and fourth years, loosely equivalent to being freshman and sophomores in American high school.)
When the detectives come into the story, a year has already passed since the discovery of the body and the initial investigation, which was completely unsuccessful in finding the murderer. One of the detectives was part of the initial investigation, who takes on a new partner when one of the girls brings him a new piece of evidence that impels her to open up a new investigation into the year old crime.
It's a bit tricky to read, in that every other chapter focuses on the girls, beginning with the start of their "third year" in the fall. The murder has taken place in the spring of that year, and the new investigation of the murder takes place in the spring of the following year. The girls' story weaves a long spiral that eventually winds its way into the present day part of the story. It's a fascinating and skillful piece of writing, and I have to say that the denouement was pretty much a complete surprise.
The book ends with the action taken by one of girls that sets off the new investigation. So, you get to the end, when the murder has been solved, and there you are back at the starting point again. For myself, all I could do was plunge right back into the beginning of the book, and read the whole thing again, straightaway.
TexasProgresive
(12,275 posts)scarletwoman
(31,893 posts)So, no, neither of the investigating detectives went to either school. In fact, both of them grew up sort of on the "wrong side of the tracks", in socio-economic circumstances that were a far cry from the posh world of the private schools. This class disparity creates a certain amount of emotional tension in their approach to the investigation - although the two of them each handle it quite differently.
In The Secret Place the conflict has to do with the fact that the girl, Holly Mackey, who shows up with a new piece of evidence a year after the murder, happens to be the daughter of Frank Mackey, the head of the Dublin Police Undercover Unit. Frank was the lead protagonist in Faithful Place (still my favorite of the lot). It's Holly's mother who's a graduate of the girl's school.
I can't really say much more, because I don't want to write any spoilers.
Enthusiast
(50,983 posts)I have yet to read Broken Harbour or The Secret Place. Mrs. Enthusiast is thoroughly engrossed in Broken Harbour.
scarletwoman
(31,893 posts)I'm anxious to re-read it again, since I remember so little about it for some reason. But it will be the last of the four Tana French books I have on hand, since I want to read them in order.
Lydia Leftcoast
(48,217 posts)Looking forward to it.
scarletwoman
(31,893 posts)I thought it was beautifully written and amazing complex. And as a former teenage girl (a million years ago) it was downright spooky how the book could plunge me right back into all the emotional angst of those years.