Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Old Crank

(4,653 posts)
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 02:52 PM Jan 2024

Vehicle size makes them more dangerous

No real surprise here. The long trend towards monster SUV and Pickups is killing people who aren't in the vehicles. Also more dangerous for people who decide to keep a small car. Deadly by design, and that doesn't coiunt the increased pollution from exhaust, brake dust and tire wear.

The original is in French. But my windows or google translater works well on it.

***
Vulnerable users and occupants of small cars risk paying the price

In recent years, cars have become heavier, taller and more powerful. While passengers on board are increasingly safer in the event of an accident, the same cannot be said for passengers in smaller vehicles and vulnerable users. Thus, in a collision between two cars, one of which weighs at least twice as much as the other, the occupants of the light vehicle are 3 times more likely to suffer serious injuries than when the two vehicles have a similar mass. Likewise, the risk of fatal injuries for a pedestrian or cyclist hit by a car whose hood is 10 cm higher than average increases by 30%. These are the conclusions of a new study by the Vias institute which examined all the accidents that occurred between 2017 and 2021.

Vehicle mass
Vehicle mass has both a protective and “aggressive” effect: occupants of heavier vehicles are less likely to be seriously or fatally injured, while their opponents are more likely to suffer serious or fatal injuries.

Let's take the example of a collision between a 1600 kg car and a lighter 1300 kg car. The risk of fatal injuries:

decreases by 50% for occupants of the heaviest car;
increases by almost 80% for occupants of the lighter car.

https://www.vias.be/fr/newsroom/des-voitures-plus-lourdes-plus-hautes-et-plus-puissantes-pour-une-securite-routiere-a-deux-vitesses-/

11 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Vehicle size makes them more dangerous (Original Post) Old Crank Jan 2024 OP
Moral of the story: buy a bigger car? ColinC Jan 2024 #1
PArt of the answer Old Crank Jan 2024 #5
Absolutely agree. My goal is to get an electric SUV when we can afford it, but ColinC Jan 2024 #8
This information is not new. Squaredeal Jan 2024 #2
I saw some numbers Old Crank Jan 2024 #7
I'm shocked MichMan Jan 2024 #3
In '66 or '67 I gave a college class speech on the issue sanatanadharma Jan 2024 #10
Given the extensive weights of most EV, it would make those the vehicles the ones most hazardous to others then MichMan Jan 2024 #4
However Old Crank Jan 2024 #6
My last reply to you I was thinking omly teslas were like that. ColinC Jan 2024 #9
Basic physics MichMan Jan 2024 #11

ColinC

(10,701 posts)
1. Moral of the story: buy a bigger car?
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 02:55 PM
Jan 2024


They are safer to be inside, more comfortable and get just as good gas mileage as small cars now. Also better for Wintry conditions and rougher terrain. The signs point towards more people getting larger cars.

That being said, I don’t think the answer should ever be “buy a smaller car.” But rather, don’t speed, drive like an asshole -or as if anybody else’s life doesn’t depend on how you drive. Unsafe driving puts everybody’s lives at risks regardless of the type of car you are in.

Old Crank

(4,653 posts)
5. PArt of the answer
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 03:57 PM
Jan 2024

is to make it so you can't speed. Cars can only go the speed limit monitored by your location. The cars I rent in Europe all know the speed limits, even in construction zones.

Another big issue is the front ends of these beasts. They are deadly when they hit people. Lower the hoodlines and slope them more intstead of a wall. Then work on visibility. More mirrors so you can see in front and down the sides.

Cars get better fuel economy. Quick look. Chevy Malibu 2023, 30 mpg. Chevy Tahoe, 16-17 mpg depending on gas engine. Diesel gets 22. But diesel costs a bunch more and are even more polluting.
The Silverado gets 24 if diesel. The gas engines get 20 for the 4 cyl. and as low as 13.

Bigger heavier vehicles burn more fuel.

ColinC

(10,701 posts)
8. Absolutely agree. My goal is to get an electric SUV when we can afford it, but
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 04:03 PM
Jan 2024

I think your response provides a lot for me to consider for safety. Interestingly enough, I feel like the Tesla SUVs meet a lot of the categories that you laid out. I don’t intend to buy a Tesla partly due to the horrible person that runs it, but I will be considering a lot of the points you laid out when we purchase our next vehicle.

Squaredeal

(536 posts)
2. This information is not new.
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 03:15 PM
Jan 2024

My younger MAGA brother, who one time drove a Chevy Suburban, said that he was going to buy such large-type vehicles for his two sons when they were old enough to drive. When I replied that new, young male drivers are more likely to cause car crashes and that maybe it wasn't such a good idea to give them such large, high-powered vehicles as novice 17-year-old drivers, his response was, “ My kids would survive the crash. That’s all I care about.”

Old Crank

(4,653 posts)
7. I saw some numbers
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 04:01 PM
Jan 2024

about deaths in big Pickups and SUV. Almost 50% of the deaths come when the driver aren't belted in . So the drivers aren't bothering with the safety features. His kids will probabgly be like that.

MichMan

(13,199 posts)
3. I'm shocked
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 03:24 PM
Jan 2024

This was an issue going back at least to the 60's when full size American cars like Chevrolet Caprice, Pontiac Bonneville, Oldsmobile 98, and Ford Galaxie were sharing the roads with VW Beetles and the like.

sanatanadharma

(4,074 posts)
10. In '66 or '67 I gave a college class speech on the issue
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 04:07 PM
Jan 2024

In '66 or '67 I gave a class speech on the issue at KU.
I argued the wisdom of reducing mass rather than adding armor.
Time shows that I was not listened to.

MichMan

(13,199 posts)
4. Given the extensive weights of most EV, it would make those the vehicles the ones most hazardous to others then
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 03:26 PM
Jan 2024

They are just as heavy as the trucks and SUV in many instances.

Old Crank

(4,653 posts)
6. However
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 03:59 PM
Jan 2024

Car type EVs are shped a lot different than the big SUV and pickups. the sloped fronts and lower hood lines aren't as dangerous upon impact as the rolling walls that the large ones have.

ColinC

(10,701 posts)
9. My last reply to you I was thinking omly teslas were like that.
Tue Jan 9, 2024, 04:06 PM
Jan 2024

I find it interesting most EVs have those features.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Automobile Enthusiasts»Vehicle size makes them m...