Baseball

Diamond_Dog

(34,413 posts) Sun Jul 24, 2022, 09:54 AM Jul 2022

Buy or sell? 8 MLB Teams on the bubble have some tough decisions to make.

With six postseason spots in each league this season, identifying buyers and sellers has become trickier than ever. Some executives might choose to do a little bit of both, dealing away prospects or expiring contracts for big league players with control beyond 2022. Others might simply stand pat, believing that their teams are one winning streak away from being a postseason threat.

Here’s a look at the eight teams currently on the bubble and whether they might emerge as buyers, sellers or both (listed in order of first-half record).

https://www.mlb.com/news/buyers-or-sellers-for-mlb-2022-second-half?partnerId=zh-20220724-659081-mlb-1-B&qid=1026&utm_id=zh-20220724-659081-mlb-1-B&bt_ee=cdZVWDueNrzKZSaX89w6PcB0gOjjUgHaAZIOVnBbxrCu%2BQJKNh%2BHgexeVMM34p5d&bt_ts=1658673287162

4 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Buy or sell? 8 MLB Teams on the bubble have some tough decisions to make. (Original Post) Diamond_Dog Jul 2022 OP

Giants should sell. Guardians should stand pat. Auggie Jul 2022 #1

So who will be on the market for the Giants come October, Auggie? Diamond_Dog Jul 2022 #2

I'd keep Rosario for 2022 ... Auggie Jul 2022 #3

My bad Diamond_Dog Jul 2022 #4

Auggie

(31,764 posts)

1. Giants should sell. Guardians should stand pat.

Reply to Diamond_Dog (Original post)

Sun Jul 24, 2022, 10:48 AM

Jul 2022

IMO

San Francisco has tons of money in reserve and a lot coming off the books in October: in other words, money to burn. Sell what's valuable now and load up in free agency.

Best bet for Cleveland is to work the trade market off-season and hope to sign a free agent or two who sees a 2023 playoff team like Orel Hershiser did in 1995.

Diamond_Dog

(34,413 posts)

2. So who will be on the market for the Giants come October, Auggie?

Reply to Auggie (Reply #1)

Sun Jul 24, 2022, 11:10 AM

Jul 2022

Is it likely they will trade Bumgardner before the deadline? How’s he doing this year?

Guardians‘ Amed Rosario is arbitration eligible next winter but I think the front office would be making a huge mistake dealing him away. You mentioned Straw before who might be more expendable for the Guards and I agree, even though i like him a lot.

Auggie

(31,764 posts)

3. I'd keep Rosario for 2022 ...

Reply to Diamond_Dog (Reply #2)

Sun Jul 24, 2022, 11:55 AM

Jul 2022

and trade him off season (unless there's a great offer now). Maybe keep Straw as bench reserve when speed is needed and late-inning defense. Plus he's been looking better as a #9 batter though he would be very valuable as trade bait. And Cleveland needs pitching.

Gonzales, Kwan, Jones is a formidable outfield.

Bumgarner pitches for Arizona. His best years are behind him, unfortunately. Lot of talk about targeting Soto but I think Giants will go after Judge instead (Soto would cost a lot). Judge grew up a few hours east of San Francisco and would probably love to come home. I think the Giants should trade Rodon now and hold onto prospects Marco Luciano and Kyle Harrison.

Giants need to go into rebuilding mode. Could have started in 2021 but too many players had career years and they won 107 games. Not the case in 2022.

Diamond_Dog

(34,413 posts)

4. My bad

Reply to Diamond_Dog (Original post)

Sun Jul 24, 2022, 12:42 PM

Jul 2022

Arg. I thought Bumgardner was still a Giant.

You think the Giants could go after Judge? That’s intriguing. That would upset many Yankee fans, for sure! I didn’t realize he was from the SF area.

Reply to this discussion