Religion
Related: About this forumWhy do some people engage in Strawman nonsense?
Despite the great risk of getting an 18th commandment bullshit call, this is probably worth mentioning.
Quite often the link to the published definition of what the strawman fallacy is doesn't seem to be resonating with a few here, so it's probably worth describing what it is and how it's anything but clever as the authors of strawman rhetoric seem to think.
The term refers to building a strawman and then burning it down. In other words the only thing you accomplished is destroying something of your own making.
The fallacy contains 4 basic steps:
1) State an argument
2) Falsely attribute said argument to your opponent(s)
3) Refute said argument
4) Pretend you refuted your opponent(s) argument
When dealing with someone who employs strawman nonsense, the best approach is simply to point out why their tactic is a strawman fallacy. Engaging in the strawman simply further validates it, at least in the mind of the employer of such intellectual dishonesty.
guillaumeb
(42,649 posts)And, in an instance of unintentional irony, the post itself is a strawman.
Well done, in spite of yourself.
NeoGreen
(4,033 posts)marylandblue
(12,344 posts)You asked what about a post about whataboutism in response to a whataboutism accusing a post about strawmanism of being a strawman.
This must be the Mind Blowing Meta Fallacy. Consider my mind successfully blown.
Major Nikon
(36,900 posts)Post#1 in which NG replied to is self-contradictory
NeoGreen
(4,033 posts)...just starting.
BTW, thanks for noticing. You made my day.
Major Nikon
(36,900 posts)Just sayin
Voltaire2
(14,700 posts)emulatorloo
(45,561 posts)Sometimes it seems like the strawman fallacy and OTT hyperbole are the fuel DU runs on. Gets tiresome.
DavidDvorkin
(19,889 posts)Act_of_Reparation
(9,116 posts)...but performance art put on, we are to believe, for an audience too scared or too tombstoned to particapte here.
Major Nikon
(36,900 posts)Mariana
(15,094 posts)His adoring public send him numerous personal messages, asking him to continue doing what he is doing, and praising his efforts in this group.
Who would make up a story like that?