Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Cartoonist

(7,507 posts)
Sun Jun 2, 2019, 04:12 PM Jun 2019

Who needed Judas?

What was his crime again? He fingered Jesus? As if Jesus was in hiding, or nobody knew who he was.

Wasn't he last seen standing on a Mount, or handing out fishes and loaves? Who picked up the tab at the Last Supper? I'll bet even the waiter knew who he was.

It was all just a bit of drama. Something a bad novelist would add to a work of fiction that needed a little intrigue. A hole in the plot.

13 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

Major Nikon

(36,899 posts)
1. If Jesus wasn't a criminal to begin with, what did he have to worry about?
Sun Jun 2, 2019, 04:28 PM
Jun 2019

It's also worth pointing out when they arrested Jesus, they caught him with a nude boy.

It could very well be that Jesus was really the bad guy here, but just had a better publicist.

Karadeniz

(23,343 posts)
4. There is a school of thought that the original movement consisted of different levels, from
Sun Jun 2, 2019, 05:52 PM
Jun 2019

"Children" ( beginners, newly committed) to the mature. The newbies are thought to have declared their commitment by undergoing a baptism by immersion. The Way they embarked upon renounced materialism, encouraged vegetarianism, pledged to behave with lovingkindness and attend learning sessions and group celebrations. Candidates for the highest level may have undergone an experience such as the mystery religions (notably the eleuthran mystery) provided, a psychic/spiritual event. As one ancient commentator post-Eleuthra said, one would never again fear death. Day 1 of the Eleuthran consisted of swimming in the sea with piglets...compare Jesus's casting demons into pigs and their jumping into the sea...quite reminiscent. And Paul said he practiced a mystery and he used different terms to describe his followers' different spiritual levels. Jesus insisted Lazarus wasn't dead and, sho nuff, he wasn't...just all dressed up for his death. The naked youth may have been naked beneath his cape in preparation for his psychic/spiritual initiation.

There are lots of ideas from cannibalism to homosexuality bandied about to explain the original communities. I think it was a type of mystery religion. The huge difference from it and the others is that this one dictated an earthly lifestyle, how to live, in addition to teaching the spiritual God System.

Ferrets are Cool

(21,859 posts)
3. Just another part of the fairy tale.
Sun Jun 2, 2019, 04:48 PM
Jun 2019

It's why you can't dig deep into that novel without finding 1000's of contradictions.

keithbvadu2

(39,862 posts)
5. Judas got 30 pieces of silver, but just once, for selling Christ.
Sun Jun 2, 2019, 05:53 PM
Jun 2019

Judas was an early modern day conservative disciple.

Judas got 30 pieces of silver, but just once, for selling Christ.

Pat Robertson, Jim Bakker and their ilk get millions of dollars repeatedly for selling Christ.

Judas was a fool for doing a one-time sale.
------------------------

MineralMan

(147,334 posts)
9. Well, it's story-telling, isn't it?
Mon Jun 3, 2019, 08:10 AM
Jun 2019

Judas is Jesus's Nemesis. His supposed betrayal is a key element in the overall story. The whole thing is a a story, finely honed, that evokes an emotional response in its audience.

The entire Bible comes from the ancient oral story-telling tradition. Over centuries the art of telling a story to trigger action or establish beliefs developed through experience in what moved the audience.

AtheistCrusader

(33,982 posts)
13. No judas, prophecy can't be fulfilled, and the whole Jesus narrative would have had to be
Fri Jun 7, 2019, 10:38 AM
Jun 2019

re-written.

Copy editors can only take so much.

Cuthbert Allgood

(5,166 posts)
11. If that's true, why do so many argue he is in hell?
Mon Jun 3, 2019, 08:33 AM
Jun 2019

Why is he a villain. He needed to do what he did in order for the Christ story to come about.

But, really, that's some pretty crappy storytelling. At least put some real barrier that Judas needs to overcome. All he did is say where he was going to be. The authorities could have figured that out.

Act_of_Reparation

(9,116 posts)
10. Sunt Leones
Mon Jun 3, 2019, 08:30 AM
Jun 2019
My point which up to this has been obscured
is that it was the lions who procured
By chewing up blood gristle flesh and bone
The martyrdoms on which the Church has grown.
I only write this poem because I thought it rather looked
As if the part the lions played was being overlooked.
By lions’ jaws great benefits and blessings were begotten
And so our debt to Lionhood must never be forgotten.


Stevie Smith, "SUNT LEONES" 1972

edhopper

(34,660 posts)
12. Another illustration of God being a dick
Mon Jun 3, 2019, 08:35 AM
Jun 2019

Judas has to betray Jesus for him to "die for our sins", so he sets Judas up as the fall guy and Jesus even tells him to do what he must.
Without Judas, we don't get all the torture porn that follows.
Did Judas have free will if his act was per-ordained?

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»Who needed Judas?