Religion
Related: About this forumWas the 'forbidden fruit' in the Garden of Eden really an apple?
What's the likely identity of the "forbidden fruit" described in the Bible's Garden of Eden, which Eve is said to have eaten and then shared with Adam? If your guess is "apple," you're probably wrong. The Hebrew Bible doesn't actually specify what type of fruit Adam and Eve ate. "We don't know what it was. There's no indication it was an apple," Rabbi Ari Zivotofsky, a professor of brain science at Israel's Bar-Ilan University, told Live Science.
Over the years, rabbis have written that the fruit could have been a fig, because in the Hebrew Bible, Adam and Eve realized they were naked after eating from the tree of knowledge, and then used fig leaves to cover themselves. Or maybe, some rabbis wrote, it was wheat, because the Hebrew word for wheat, "chitah," is similar to the word for sin, "cheit," Zivotofsky said. Grapes, or wine made from grapes, are another possibility. Finally, the rabbis wrote that it might have been a citron, or "etrog" in Hebrew a bittersweet, lemon-like fruit used during the Jewish fall festival of Sukkot, a harvest celebration in which Jews erect temporary dwellings.
Given all of these potential forbidden fruits, how did apples which aren't even from the Middle East, but from Kazakhstan in Central Asia become the predominant interpretation? Instead, the possible path from fruit to apple began in Rome in A.D. 382., when Pope Damasus I asked a scholar named Jerome to translate the Bible into Latin.
"The word ["malum"] in Latin translates into a word in English, apple, which also stood for any fruit ... with a core of seeds in the middle and flesh around it. But it was a generic term [for fruit] as well," Appelbaum told Live Science. Apple had this generic meaning until the 17th century, according to the Online Etymological Dictionary. Jerome likely chose the word "malum" to mean fruit, because the very same word can also mean evil, Appelbaum said. So it's a pun, referring to the fruit associated with humans' first big mistake with a word that also means essentially that.
https://www.livescience.com/what-was-forbidden-fruit-in-eden.html
Claire Oh Nette
(2,636 posts)Do apple trees grow in the Middle East?
Probably aren't many evergreens either, but that never stopped Christmas trees....
RainCaster
(11,485 posts)Christmas trees are a European tradition, if I remember correctly.
Clash City Rocker
(3,539 posts)Response to left-of-center2012 (Original post)
HUAJIAO This message was self-deleted by its author.
Beakybird
(3,389 posts)Fullduplexxx
(8,198 posts)Clash City Rocker
(3,539 posts)The likely location of the Garden of Eden, based on four rivers that are mentioned in Genesis as being nearby, is modern day Iraq. I doubt many apples grow near Iraq.
Id never heard an explanation for why people think it was an apple. Thats a nice theory.
ramblin_dave
(1,554 posts)Girard442
(6,384 posts)The serpent (metapborically speaking) might have been humankind's greatest benefactor.
pandr32
(12,104 posts)It underscores the mythological elements of the story.
5X
(3,987 posts)It was weed
Fullduplexxx
(8,198 posts)Midnight Writer
(22,930 posts)And the apple was an alien device that accelerated evolution and made people smart.
Karadeniz
(23,339 posts)Been the first people. Was Eden even on earth? I doubt it.