Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

wnylib

(24,373 posts)
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:30 PM 6 hrs ago

Questions for people who attend Episcopal churches

I attended a few services at an Episcopal church and noticed two things that surprised me.

First, for communion, they used a common cup for everyone. Is that typical in Episcopalian churches? I passed on it, unable to share a cup with anyone, just on basic hygiene principles that I grew up with, not to mention the recent covid pandemic and increase in RSV infections.

Second, the priest urges people to practice one on one confession to him or his assistant priest, as in Roman Catholic churches. Is that also a common Episcopalian practice?

My own religious background is in two mainstream liberal Protestant denominations. Both of them have individual little glasses in trays for communion and run them through the church's dishwasher for cleaning and sanitizing later.

Both of them teach that there are various ways of confession. One is the common confession spoken by the congregation together in the service. Another is in the Lord's prayer, "Forgive us our sins/trespasses as we forgive those who sin/trespass against us." Or, people can privately, in prayer, confess specific sins directly to God. Another option is to speak to a pastor about specific sins, concerns, or troubling moral issues. Neither one of those churches urges or requires confession to clergy.





14 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

applegrove

(123,111 posts)
1. My sister had a boyfriend who was Anglican. He thought it so strange
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:34 PM
6 hrs ago

that a tray of little shot glasses filled with red wine was passed around, and a tray of little pieces of bread at our Presbyterian service. He said "cocktails, hors d'oevres, how nice". LOL! He was obviously not familiar with how us Presbyterians do communion.

wnylib

(24,373 posts)
3. My background is Lutheran and Presbyterian.
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:48 PM
6 hrs ago

So I know just what you mean. The Lutheran church uses wafers on a tray. The Presbyterians use bread.

The Presbyterians used to dip the bread in a cup (intinction), but decided that individual glasses were better.

applegrove

(123,111 posts)
5. I would not want to share a cup with others. Not an
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 10:09 PM
6 hrs ago

issue for me as I don't attend church. I'm glad I went as a kid but my life is too complex to attend. My god is nature and my ancestors. So I spent alot of time going on drives in leafy neighborhoods or the countryside or thinking about the lives of my ancestors.

AZSkiffyGeek

(12,598 posts)
2. My episcopal church doesn't practice like that
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:39 PM
6 hrs ago

I've run into common cup at other churches, but at my Episcopal church we lineup and kneel, they pass the bread, say the blessing and everyone eats, then they do the same thing w/ the little shot glasses.
As to confession, it's offered and there is a confessional in the back, but I've never seen anyone use it.
My experience was it was a combination of high Lutheran and Roman Catholic as far as the service, which is exactly what I was looking for because I crave the spectacle and ritual of high church, with plenty of social justice activism and no guilt.
And now, the fact that they're affirming is a big selling point as well.

SWBTATTReg

(24,085 posts)
4. I can't answer your questions, but the Episcopal churches are big in my area. Churches had a big time adapting when the
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 09:50 PM
6 hrs ago

Covid crisis hit, and so many of them had issues on being safe vs. their usual practices. A lot of them refused to be safe, stating that they would be fine regardless of not implementing common sense practices that would make things safer. As a result, I recall some congregations getting sick from Covid as a result.

To admit, I wasn't surprised that they chose to not be safe and as a result, expose their members to the potential of Covid (as well as other highly communicable diseases. And I suspect that some would continue this practice (exposing everyone).

This is one reason that I don't participate any longer in some churches, unless they have adopted different practices in abating the spread of disease.

It's a shame and the Episcopal church is not by far the only one that doesn't practice safety. A lot of 'Mom and Pop'/smaller churches do not practice procedures to ensure safety either (usually decided by the Pastor, committee or congregation on what they want to do).

So it's left to you mostly. Go to another church if need be. Your life may depend on it.

TommyT139

(697 posts)
6. Re covid practices
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 10:11 PM
6 hrs ago

Most parishes in my diocese still have hybrid services, and we're completely closed during the pandemic.

Usually for better, but sometimes worse, the diocesan bishops have a very strong influence on their parishes. This has permitted advances in LGBTQ issues, women in ministry, and so on. But I imagine a pandemic-minimizing bishop could lead in that way too.

wnylib

(24,373 posts)
8. I am not a member of the Episcopal church. I only attended a few services there.
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 10:21 PM
6 hrs ago

Because of the communion and confession practices there, I would never have joined.

surfered

(3,077 posts)
7. First , we attend the local Episcopal church because we respect the rector.
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 10:13 PM
6 hrs ago

We are not Episcopal, but come from several different Protestant backgrounds. In our communion, we are given a wafer to dip into the cup of wine. I have not seen anyone drinking from the cup.

Secondly, confession has never been discussed. I have never “confessed” nor witnessed it.

wnylib

(24,373 posts)
9. When I asked the priest about it, he told me that
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 10:31 PM
5 hrs ago

dipping the water into wine was more unsanitary because people's fingertips touch the wine in the process. I Iooked it up online and that was confirmed in the article that I read.

My church uses individual glasses in a tray. There are a nurse instructor and a doctor in the congregation. They initiated the change from dipping to individual glasses during the pandemic and it has remained in practice. Glasses on a tray was the practice in the church that I grew up in, too.

TommyT139

(697 posts)
10. In my experience
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 11:19 PM
5 hrs ago

In my experience, the common cup is standard practice, with intinction/dipping being a common variant -- especially if someone was raised Roman Catholic.

It is also very acceptable to decline the cup, which people do if they don't drink alcohol and there's no non-alcoholic wine available. Crossing one's arms over one's chest in an X signals that clearly, and the priest will give a quick blessing. Then extend hands for the bread. During the pandemic after vaccines (required in the parishes I attended), it was bread-only for a long time for everyone.

As far as confession, I've only gone to anglo-catholic parishes -- "smells and bells," high liturgy, often sung services. Individual confession was rare, maybe once a year or so, or perhaps on a retreat. Again, people who grew up Roman Catholic seemed more likely to include individual confession in their personal practices.

I was raised Methodist -- thimbles of grape juice and all! Joining the Episcopal Church as a grad student, even though I served on altar staff for a year, I never felt pressured to do something I wasn't comfortable with.

Long story short-ish: if you find most of the service meaningful, but sharing the chalice squicks you out; and individual confession is off-putting...you get to participate as you are comfortable. If clergy are judgy, that's them, not the Episcopal Church.

wnylib

(24,373 posts)
12. Your last sentence was the reason I asked about
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 11:25 PM
5 hrs ago

those questions in the OP. I wondered if what I encountered was typical Anglican practice or just the clergy at one church.

I was only visiting there. There are other reasons why I would not have joined. It just was not the right place for me.



wnylib

(24,373 posts)
14. True. But being in a church offers the opportunity of
Thu Nov 21, 2024, 12:34 AM
3 hrs ago

sharing the experience with others, of having a mutual support system, and of working with others in community service activities.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»Questions for people who ...