Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Behind the Aegis

(54,671 posts)
Sun Jul 21, 2024, 03:19 PM Jul 21

(Jewish Group) So, how did the West become antisemitic?

Before the present noxious morass of publicly expressed antisemitism, wry semi-humorous statements were fashionable, such as “Jews are just like everyone else, only more so,” variously attributed to the philosopher Isaiah Berlin or a British rabbi, Lionel Blue.

The implication was that Jewish people tend to provocatively cause a tzimmes and raise hackles. According to this thesis, a penchant for words and deeds likely to offend may have sparked the wrath of adversaries.

This belief is newly analyzed in How the West Became Antisemitic, an erudite overview by religious studies scholar Ivan Marcus.

Marcus concludes that there is “little hope that diaspora Jews will cease to be victims of some forms of antisemitism” as long as other groups reject an egalitarian, live and let live attitude. Even so, knowing the history of the often-vituperative slanging match that was inter-religious communication may be the first step for dialing down the internecine hatred.

more...

6 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
(Jewish Group) So, how did the West become antisemitic? (Original Post) Behind the Aegis Jul 21 OP
We are not.......................... Lovie777 Jul 21 #1
Yeah, that's the ticket. Behind the Aegis Jul 21 #2
It has always been so MyMission Jul 21 #3
I consider myself pro-Jewish. The way some people are Francophiles or Anglophiles, I'm a MaryMagdaline Jul 21 #4
This is very thoughtful essay with good points, positives and reflections. Thank you. appalachiablue Jul 21 #5
This message was self-deleted by its author Mosby Jul 22 #6

MyMission

(1,935 posts)
3. It has always been so
Sun Jul 21, 2024, 03:33 PM
Jul 21

1) The west has harbored antisemites and racists, and their ideologies have continued and infiltrated many parts of our society. Blaming the Jews is an old trope.

2) Throughout our history, Jews have been allowed or accepted someplace for a time, only to be expelled or displaced, attacked or exterminated eventually.

We are living in interesting times!

MaryMagdaline

(7,536 posts)
4. I consider myself pro-Jewish. The way some people are Francophiles or Anglophiles, I'm a
Sun Jul 21, 2024, 04:17 PM
Jul 21

Judeophile. What follows is some major generalizations, oversimplifications and some honest observations thrown in:

My friends have been disproportionately Jewish. I married Jewish. We met in Georgia, where I grew up. Half of my friends are Jewish. That’s hard to do when they are such a small population.
What attracts me to Jewish people and probably them to me is the willingness to discuss politics and morality. What do we owe society? Is a thought that was taught in Jewish homes. Should have been taught in all homes, but often was not.
I’ve ceased to be Catholic, barely believe in God, but was always overwhelmed by the Sermon on the Mount. Very blunt and very Jewish in its tone. Social Justice is a centuries old Jewish tradition.
I’ve had discussions with friends who are Jewish and atheist who mock the Hebrew Bible as useless mythology. I like to champion the Jewish Bible as follows: What poverty stricken, isolated people, contemplating why God has punished them so much arrive at the decision that it’s because they have mistreated widows and orphans? I mean they could have gone into major group think, built bigger temples, sacrificed more animals, kissed up to God through bribery, but they decided that GOD REQUIRES JUSTICE, NOT SACRIFICES. This was Jewish thought that has contributed to all of western civilization. Yes, others were there, too, but credit to Jews for putting their morality on paper and for writing and teaching it for generations.
To be around Jewish people, there is always a challenge to check one’s social standing, to think of the less fortunate, to test the powers that be. And a lot of blunt speech. See Freud.
Some people are not comfortable with that tradition and can be very offended by the questioning of authority.
The Jewish tradition to trust science is also threatening. Witness the anti-vaxxers. Imagine how much worse the hatred was during the plague because Jews washed their hands and didn’t die.
People are right to give Jewish people credit for socialism and civil rights - they pulled above their weight for centuries in Europe and America to bring about social equality. Their devotion to Justice doesn’t make them many friends.
I’m not trying to simplify this but since Jews in Europe were segregated, limited to certain trades, dressed differently and practiced their own religion, this was a set up for discrimination. Catholics and Protestants butchered each other over the meaning of the Eucharist. Jews and Muslims were never safe.
The fear that Jews were smarter (and worse!) chosen by God - can instill hatred and jealousy. I believe the Romans pushed that whole crucifixion thing onto Jews to counter the clear statement by God that Jews were the chosen people. (Just try telling a Catholic that crucify is a Latin word - crucifixare - and had no Hebrew or Aramaic word before Rome took over. ) For centuries, Europe had Passion plays during Easter week, acting out the killing of Jesus. And in the Fox News tradition of its time, the immigrant Jews were portrayed the ones who killed Jesus. (Never mind that Jesus was a socialist killed by the powerful people because he was too good at preaching social Justice).
Anti-Semitism is real. There are those of us westerners who lionize Jewish contributions (maybe the Chosen People thing got to us psychologically), but the contributions by Jews absolutely cannot be ignored. They introduced their Bible and with it, their conscience, to Western Civilization. Success, unfortunately, has made them targets of jealous hatred and violence.

Response to Behind the Aegis (Original post)

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Jewish Group»(Jewish Group) So, how di...