Jewish Group
Related: About this forum(Jewish Group) Superman was secretly a symbol of Jews standing up to Nazi bigotry
The literary narrative is a place where theory takes place, author Barbara Christian asserted. I would add that science-fiction provides the occasion to stretch the possibilities, to transcend the constitutive bounds and constraints by providing a context in which theory can function unencumbered.
I often think of the figure of Superman, that immigrant from a distant planet who came to Earth with powers far beyond those of moral humans.
Superman can be interpreted as a Jewish man passing as an Anglo Gentile on a number of levels. Two young Jewish high school friends from Cleveland, Ohio created the comic strip. Though Jerome Siegel (1914 1996) and Joseph Shuster (1914 1992) fashioned their superhero in 1934one year after Adolf Hitlers ascendancy to power in Germanythey would wait four long years until a comic book publisher, D.C. Comics would pick up the strip and introduce their super-powered man to the public.
Siegel wrote the text, and Shuster illustrated their creation. Both science-fiction fanatics, Siegel and Shuster graduated from Glenville High School in 1934, at a time in world history of extreme moral crisis, a time that signaled the beginning of the end of European Jewry as they had known it.
more...
quaint
(3,544 posts)Behind the Aegis
(54,852 posts)Then along comes non-Jews to "Christfy" Superman. Not uncommon for the dominant culture to co-opt, rebrand, of culturally appropriate, if you will, the works of a minority.
quaint
(3,544 posts)All that said, historians such as Martin Lund and Les Daniels argue that the evidence for Judaic influence in Siegel and Shuster's stories is merely circumstantial. Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster were not practicing Jews and never acknowledged the influence of Judaism in any memoir or interview.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superman#Religious_themes
Behind the Aegis
(54,852 posts)First, practicing or not (where was that "fact" pulled from), they were Jewish and experienced their lives as Jews. The themes are obvious to those who actually know what a Jew is and what the Jewish experience was at that time.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joe_Shuster
Elliot S. Maggin was Supermans principal writer from the 1970s to the mid-1980s. His Judaism and studies of kabbalah and Martin Buber heavily influenced his work, and he acknowledged ascribing effectively Jewish doctrine and ritual to the Kryptonian tradition. That Superman is Jewish, he said, is so self-evident that it may as well be canon.
https://forward.com/culture/504342/superman-10-jewish-things-siegel-shuster-samson-moses-golem/
willamette
(182 posts)This is my analysis as to the question of, "Is Judaism a religion, or a culture, or a race?" People who come/came from this area carry the mores and characteristics of that civilization. They may have different religions and taboos, but their commonality is their area of origin. People from the originally named Judea are not all Jews, nor are they all Arabs, Muslims, Christians, or Druze. In my opinion, one of the confusions is that people don't always get to define what group they belong to. One could identify as not a member of a religion or place of origin, but the decisions of who was/is killed based on group membership was/is not up to the people assigned to the different groups. Likewise, the religions and the different law structures passed/pass laws against supposed miscegenation. That reinforces a morphological similarity within groups. "Funny, you don't look Jewish."
I have been accustomed to saying that I am a secular Jew. Or, a Jewish atheist. Or, a Golda Meir Jew (she was also an atheist). I've been doing a lot of reading, and have been watching a lot of presentations and interviews by Middle Eastern scholars since the Hamas hordes overran the kibbutzim. I have come to the conclusion that I am Judean American, rather than a Jewish American. I carry the culture and the civilization, the mores and the ethics of the region, but not the religion. I do understand that there are Jewish congregations who are redefining the religion for their congregants (Reconstructionist) to get rid of the most egregious of the inequalities, taboos, and required performances. But for me, I am more comfortable in affirming the culture, and having ancestral roots in Judea.