Atheists & Agnostics

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts) Thu Feb 18, 2016, 12:52 PM Feb 2016

Announcing! 2016 MARCH MEME MADNESS!!!

Last edited Fri Feb 19, 2016, 08:47 AM - Edit history (1)

Instead of the usual Meme of the Week/Month, for March 2016 I'll be running:
MARCH MEME MADNESS!!!

32 Memes have been selected and ranked for a head-to-head/one-on-one competitions each to be decided by DU Polls.

Many good and high quality memes have been left to the wayside due to being slightly out polled in the weekly and monthly polls.

March Meme Madness has been prepared to give a select set of 32 memes a 2nd chance to rise to the top.

Starting February 29th the first of 5-rounds of Polls/Games will be set-up for the DU community to participate in selecting the March Madness Winner.

Round #1 – All 32 (Polls will Run 2/29 to 3/6)
Round #2 – Sweet 16 (Polls will Run 3/7 to 3/13)
Round #3 – The Agnostic 8 (Polls will Run 3/14 to 3/20)
Round #4 – The Final Atheist 4 (Polls will Run 3/21 to 3/27)
Round #5 – March Meme Madness - The Final Word (Poll will Run 3/28 to 4/3)

Starting Bracket: Make Your Predictions Now!

A clean list of Round #1 Games and Assigned Memes will be posted later (the image file is hard to read as is).

The Meme Groups:

Group A
Meme #01 – Thinking the World is Wrong (2014 Meme of the Year)
Meme #05 – Divine Choices
Meme #09 – Choose Wisely
Meme #15 – Destroyed by the Truth
Meme #18 – That Awkward Moment
Meme #24 – Grayling – Religious Complaints
Meme #28 – Made God Commit Suicide
Meme #32 – Religious Infection

Group B
Meme #03 – Origins of Morality
Meme #07 – Needs Money
Meme #11 – Sociopathic
Meme #13 – Atheist Pig – BIBLE
Meme #20 – Absurdity
Meme #22 – Militant Fundamentalist Atheist
Meme #26 – Puddle Theology
Meme #30 – Kill the Amalekites

Group C
Meme #04 – Who Is Arrogant
Meme #08 – Batman or God
Meme #10 – Norwegian Beaver Cheese
Meme #14 – Persecution vs Contradiction
Meme #19 – Erroneous Assertion
Meme #23 – Choice of Sacrifice
Meme #25 – Perfect Ignorance
Meme #29 – Marking Their Territory

Group D
Meme #02 – Everything to Live For (2015 Meme of the Year)
Meme #06 – Respect is Earned
Meme #12 – Rampage
Meme #16 – Sober
Meme #17 – With Gott Anything is Possible
Meme #21 – Tasty and Filling
Meme #27 – Should Be Thankful
Meme #31 – Yule Tree

Notes:
Larger Images will be Available once the Game Round Original-Posts are Set-up
No Tie-Breakers. Ties will be decided by me at the end of each polling round.
The image files in this post will be updated periodically.

Have Fun Everyone! Start Filling out your Brackets!

(mods please pin this post)

17 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Announcing! 2016 MARCH MEME MADNESS!!! (Original Post) NeoGreen Feb 2016 OP

Kick. Lol. Warren Stupidity Feb 2016 #1

Holy shit. progressoid Feb 2016 #2

2016 MMM - Round #01 Schedule NeoGreen Feb 2016 #3

What fun! Curmudgeoness Feb 2016 #4

Uhhh... NeoGreen Feb 2016 #5

I think we could work on a signature badge. Goblinmonger Feb 2016 #6

Cool... NeoGreen Feb 2016 #7

I admit that I pay no attention to sports, Curmudgeoness Feb 2016 #8

How about a St. Christopher's medal with an engraving rurallib Feb 2016 #9

March Meme Madness! - Round #2 Sweet 16 Standings NeoGreen Mar 2016 #10

Thanks again for all the great memes and making choosing them even more fun! beam me up scottie Mar 2016 #11

March Meme Madness! - Round #3 - The Agnostic 8 NeoGreen Mar 2016 #12

Oh my gosh... SoapBox Mar 2016 #13

Apologies... NeoGreen Mar 2016 #14

WINNER: March Meme Madness! 2016 NeoGreen Apr 2016 #15

Quod erat demonstrandum, mea culpa... NeoGreen Nov 2017 #17

A tribute to the life warmfeet Mar 2017 #16

Warren Stupidity

(48,181 posts)

1. Kick. Lol.

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Thu Feb 18, 2016, 01:07 PM

Feb 2016

progressoid

(50,746 posts)

2. Holy shit.

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Thu Feb 18, 2016, 01:54 PM

Feb 2016

This is fantastic.

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)

3. 2016 MMM - Round #01 Schedule

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Thu Feb 18, 2016, 02:36 PM

Feb 2016

Last edited Mon Feb 29, 2016, 08:21 AM - Edit history (1)

Round #01 – Game Schedule

Group A:
Game #01: Meme #01 vs Meme #32
Game #02: Meme #15 vs Meme #18
Game #03: Meme #09 vs Meme #24
Game #04: Meme #05 vs Meme #28

Group B:
Game #05: Meme #03 vs Meme #30
Game #06: Meme #13 vs Meme #20
Game #07: Meme #07 vs Meme #26
Game #08: Meme #11 vs Meme #22

Group C:
Game #09: Meme #04 vs Meme #29
Game #10: Meme #14 vs Meme #19
Game #11: Meme #10 vs Meme #23
Game #12: Meme #08 vs Meme #25

Group D:
Game #13: Meme #06 vs Meme #27
Game #14: Meme #12 vs Meme #21
Game #15: Meme #16 vs Meme #17
Game #16: Meme #02 vs Meme #31

Curmudgeoness

(18,219 posts)

4. What fun!

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Thu Feb 18, 2016, 08:24 PM

Feb 2016

So, what do we win if we pick the winner?

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)

5. Uhhh...

Reply to Curmudgeoness (Reply #4)

Fri Feb 19, 2016, 08:01 AM

Feb 2016

...Oops...hmmm...yeah...a prize...wow...didn't think of that.

Way to zero in on the flaw in my plan... ...(just kidding)...

Uhmmm...How About:

1) Bragging Rights...
2) The Undying Adulation and Adoration from your Fellow A&A'ers
3) A medal
4) A Hug
5) A Group Hug
5) Slow Clap

No?

Sorry, I got nothin'

Goblinmonger

(22,340 posts)

6. I think we could work on a signature badge.

Reply to NeoGreen (Reply #5)

Fri Feb 19, 2016, 11:09 AM

Feb 2016

Then you would have bragging rights wherever you posted on DU.

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)

7. Cool...

Reply to Goblinmonger (Reply #6)

Fri Feb 19, 2016, 11:22 AM

Feb 2016

...I like it.

But, I presume predicting the final winner will be fairly rare, and would require a non-editable declaration of which meme would win the "Final Word" round.

Any ideas for other badges that wouldn't require such a level of... precognition?

Curmudgeoness

(18,219 posts)

8. I admit that I pay no attention to sports,

Reply to NeoGreen (Reply #7)

Fri Feb 19, 2016, 06:50 PM

Feb 2016

so I may be wrong about this March Madness. But I do know that our local newspaper has a contest where everyone fills out their brackets, sends them in, and if you have predicted the winner, you win. I don't know what you win for that either.

Of course, it is next to impossible to predict the winner. But I think that is the point. But since there is no prize, it doesn't matter, does it?

:pout:

rurallib

(63,196 posts)

9. How about a St. Christopher's medal with an engraving

Reply to Goblinmonger (Reply #6)

Wed Feb 24, 2016, 11:10 AM

Feb 2016

something like:
"Not Believing Puts People Out Of Work"

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)

10. March Meme Madness! - Round #2 Sweet 16 Standings

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:25 AM

Mar 2016

Here are the remaining/surviving meme from Round #1

Round #2 - Polls/games to be created shortly

Final Scores – Round #1: 3/7/2016 – 8:30 AM (ish)

Group A:
Game #01: Meme #01 vs Meme #32 3/1/2016 - Score 25 / 3
Game #01: Meme #01 vs Meme #32 3/2/2016 - Score 29 / 3
Game #01: Meme #01 vs Meme #32 3/3/2016 - Score 30 / 3
Game #01: Meme #01 vs Meme #32 3/4/2016 - Score 31 / 3
Game #01: Meme #01 vs Meme #32 3/7/2016 - Score 32 / 3

Game #02: Meme #15 vs Meme #18 3/1/2016 - Score 18 / 10
Game #02: Meme #15 vs Meme #18 3/2/2016 - Score 20 / 12
Game #02: Meme #15 vs Meme #18 3/3/2016 - Score 21 / 12
Game #02: Meme #15 vs Meme #18 3/4/2016 - Score 22 / 12
Game #02: Meme #15 vs Meme #18 3/7/2016 - Score 23 / 12

Game #03: Meme #09 vs Meme #24 3/1/2016 - Score 9 / 19
Game #03: Meme #09 vs Meme #24 3/2/2016 - Score 10 / 21
Game #03: Meme #09 vs Meme #24 3/3/2016 - Score 10 / 21
Game #03: Meme #09 vs Meme #24 3/4/2016 - Score 10 / 23
Game #03: Meme #09 vs Meme #24 3/7/2016 - Score 10 / 24

Game #04: Meme #05 vs Meme #28 3/1/2016 - Score 20 / 6
Game #04: Meme #05 vs Meme #28 3/2/2016 - Score 23 / 6
Game #04: Meme #05 vs Meme #28 3/3/2016 - Score 23 / 6
Game #04: Meme #05 vs Meme #28 3/4/2016 - Score 23 / 7
Game #04: Meme #05 vs Meme #28 3/7/2016 - Score 24 / 7

Group B:
Game #05: Meme #03 vs Meme #30 3/1/2016 - Score 22 / 3
Game #05: Meme #03 vs Meme #30 3/2/2016 - Score 26 / 4
Game #05: Meme #03 vs Meme #30 3/3/2016 - Score 27 / 4
Game #05: Meme #03 vs Meme #30 3/4/2016 - Score 28 / 4
Game #05: Meme #03 vs Meme #30 3/7/2016 - Score 29 / 4

Game #06: Meme #13 vs Meme #20 3/1/2016 - Score 3 / 22
Game #06: Meme #13 vs Meme #20 3/2/2016 - Score 3 / 25
Game #06: Meme #13 vs Meme #20 3/3/2016 - Score 3 / 25
Game #06: Meme #13 vs Meme #20 3/4/2016 - Score 4 / 26
Game #06: Meme #13 vs Meme #20 3/7/2016 - Score 5 / 26

Game #07: Meme #07 vs Meme #26 3/1/2016 - Score 20 / 8
Game #07: Meme #07 vs Meme #26 3/2/2016 - Score 21 / 10
Game #07: Meme #07 vs Meme #26 3/3/2016 - Score 22 / 10
Game #07: Meme #07 vs Meme #26 3/4/2016 - Score 22 / 11

Game #08: Meme #11 vs Meme #22 3/1/2016 - Score 13 / 13
Game #08: Meme #11 vs Meme #22 3/2/2016 - Score 13 / 16
Game #08: Meme #11 vs Meme #22 3/3/2016 - Score 14 / 16
Game #08: Meme #11 vs Meme #22 3/4/2016 - Score 14 / 17
Game #08: Meme #11 vs Meme #22 3/7/2016 - Score 15 / 17

Group C:
Game #09: Meme #04 vs Meme #29 3/1/2016 - Score 20 / 3
Game #09: Meme #04 vs Meme #29 3/2/2016 - Score 23 / 3
Game #09: Meme #04 vs Meme #29 3/3/2016 - Score 23 / 3
Game #09: Meme #04 vs Meme #29 3/4/2016 - Score 25 / 3
Game #09: Meme #04 vs Meme #29 3/7/2016 - Score 26 / 4

Game #10: Meme #14 vs Meme #19 3/1/2016 - Score 21 / 4
Game #10: Meme #14 vs Meme #19 3/2/2016 - Score 24 / 4
Game #10: Meme #14 vs Meme #19 3/3/2016 - Score 24 / 4
Game #10: Meme #14 vs Meme #19 3/4/2016 - Score 25 / 5
Game #10: Meme #14 vs Meme #19 3/7/2016 - Score 26 / 6

Game #11: Meme #10 vs Meme #23 3/1/2016 - Score 12 / 15
Game #11: Meme #10 vs Meme #23 3/2/2016 - Score 15 / 16
Game #11: Meme #10 vs Meme #23 3/3/2016 - Score 15 / 16
Game #11: Meme #10 vs Meme #23 3/4/2016 - Score 16 / 17
Game #11: Meme #10 vs Meme #23 3/7/2016 - Score 18 / 17

Game #12: Meme #08 vs Meme #25 3/1/2016 - Score 17 / 10
Game #12: Meme #08 vs Meme #25 3/2/2016 - Score 19 / 10
Game #12: Meme #08 vs Meme #25 3/3/2016 - Score 19 / 11
Game #12: Meme #08 vs Meme #25 3/4/2016 - Score 19 / 12
Game #12: Meme #08 vs Meme #25 3/7/2016 - Score 19 / 14

Group D:
Game #13: Meme #06 vs Meme #27 3/1/2016 - Score 12 / 11
Game #13: Meme #06 vs Meme #27 3/2/2016 - Score 13 / 14
Game #13: Meme #06 vs Meme #27 3/3/2016 - Score 13 / 15
Game #13: Meme #06 vs Meme #27 3/4/2016 - Score 13 / 16
Game #13: Meme #06 vs Meme #27 3/7/2016 - Score 15 / 16

Game #14: Meme #12 vs Meme #21 3/1/2016 - Score 1 / 21
Game #14: Meme #12 vs Meme #21 3/2/2016 - Score 2 / 24
Game #14: Meme #12 vs Meme #21 3/3/2016 - Score 2 / 25
Game #14: Meme #12 vs Meme #21 3/4/2016 - Score 2 / 26
Game #14: Meme #12 vs Meme #21 3/7/2016 - Score 2 / 28

Game #15: Meme #16 vs Meme #17 3/1/2016 - Score 11 / 12
Game #15: Meme #16 vs Meme #17 3/2/2016 - Score 14 / 12
Game #15: Meme #16 vs Meme #17 3/3/2016 - Score 14 / 13
Game #15: Meme #16 vs Meme #17 3/4/2016 - Score 15 / 13
Game #15: Meme #16 vs Meme #17 3/7/2016 - Score 17 / 13

Game #16: Meme #02 vs Meme #31 3/1/2016 - Score 22 / 3
Game #16: Meme #02 vs Meme #31 3/2/2016 - Score 24 / 5
Game #16: Meme #02 vs Meme #31 3/3/2016 - Score 25 / 5
Game #16: Meme #02 vs Meme #31 3/4/2016 - Score 25 / 5
Game #16: Meme #02 vs Meme #31 3/7/2016 - Score 27 / 5

beam me up scottie

(57,349 posts)

11. Thanks again for all the great memes and making choosing them even more fun!

Reply to NeoGreen (Reply #10)

Mon Mar 7, 2016, 04:50 PM

Mar 2016

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)

12. March Meme Madness! - Round #3 - The Agnostic 8

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Mon Mar 14, 2016, 09:03 AM

Mar 2016

We are now to The Agnostic 8!

It just keeps on getting more difficult to choose...

Round #3 – The Agnostic 8 (Polls will Run 3/14 to 3/21)
Round #4 – The Final Atheist 4 (Polls will Run 3/21 to 3/27)
Round #5 – March Meme Madness - The Final Word (Poll will Run 3/28 to 4/3)

SoapBox

(18,791 posts)

13. Oh my gosh...

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Mon Mar 21, 2016, 11:43 PM

Mar 2016

I just discovered this...it's great.

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)

14. Apologies...

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Mon Mar 28, 2016, 08:02 AM

Mar 2016

...there will be a delay of a few days before another poll is posted.
(on vacation and only have a small screen which is not conducive to clean posts)

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)

15. WINNER: March Meme Madness! 2016

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Fri Apr 8, 2016, 07:27 AM

Apr 2016

Winner of March Meme Madness FINAL WORD (Game #31) with 19 of 33 votes

Destroyed by Truth

Thanks everyone for participating!

And thanks to Mr. Blur for my spiffy new medal:

The Croix de Grrr and Bar

Very much appreciated

Note to Mods: I would say it is time to unpin the thread if deemed appropriate.

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)

17. Quod erat demonstrandum, mea culpa...

Reply to NeoGreen (Reply #15)

Mon Nov 13, 2017, 09:24 AM

Nov 2017

Hey all,

In the spirit of Scientific Method where past errors are presented and corrected when new information is discovered, I am making this post because it has come to my attention that our 2016 March Meme Madness Final Word, was a mis-attributed Carl Sagan quote that should be properly be attributed to Patricia "Pat" Christine Hodgell:

https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Carl_Sagan

"If it can be destroyed by the truth, it deserves to be destroyed by the truth."

"That which can be destroyed by the truth, should be." — P. C. Hodgell, in her 1994 novel Seeker's Mask.

I do not believe it detracts from our collective sentiments and intent or our the fun in selecting, but just wanted to set the record straight.

If anyone has the time and inclination and the skills to create a quality image, please post a new graphic with the corrected quote and attribution.

In Peace and Reality,
NG

warmfeet

(3,321 posts)

16. A tribute to the life

Reply to NeoGreen (Original post)

Mon Mar 6, 2017, 08:02 PM

Mar 2017

of Carl Sagan. A person I have always looked up to. He was always a personal hero to me.

Reply to this discussion